Women In The Duchess Of Malfi And The Changeling

1853 words - 7 pages

Missing Works Cited
TWO WOMEN AND ONE FATE
The Duchess in John Webster’s tragic play, The Duchess of Malfi, and Beatrice Joanna in Thomas Middleton and William Rowley’s The Changeling, are both strong women living in a male-dominated society. The two women attempt to free themselves from this subordination by choosing to love that they desire. Both pay with their lives for this chance at freedom, but differ in their moral decisions about how they attempt it. Beatrice Joanna’s plan involves murder, whereas the widowed Duchess merely lives the life she chooses, then plots to leave Malfi. Both women are forced into their actions, but, whereas Beatrice Joanna is Machiavellian in her actions, the Duchess is morally superior.
Webster based his play on a real-life 16th Century scandal where a widowed Duchess remarried for love and did so beneath her class. The widowed Duchess had certain advantages and freedoms that the younger and unmarried Beatrice in The Changeling did not. The Duchess had significant wealth and independence, and she need not answer to a father or a husband. She no longer had the burden of protecting her virginity and the stigma attached if it was lost. Beatrice, on the other hand, had little sexual freedom, and she had to answer to her father and to the man to whom she was engaged. However a the Duchess, and Beatrice were doomed to subject to a patriarchal and male-dominated society. Upon her capture the Duchess declares: “I am Duchess of Malfi still” (4.2.141). She is a duchess only in name. In the end in both tragedies, it is the men –fathers, brothers, suitors, and the Church—who rule by physical force and by law.
Moreover, both women are driven by their passions and further choose to defy society by attempting to love whom they desire. Like Beatrice, the Duchess’s ambitions lead to her destruction. The Duchess, however, never resorts to murder and her plot to save herself and Antonio does not cause physical harm to anyone. It is her brothers, Ferdinand and the Cardinal, who are murderous and immoral in their plot to save the family reputation and inheritance. It is they who are consumed with aristocratic pride. It is their sibling jealousy and male pride that causes them to kill the Duchess.
From the onset of the play the Duchess is described as noble and virtuous. Antonio says:
Her days are practiced in such noble virtue
That sure her nights –nay, more, her very sleeps—
Are more in heaven than other ladies’ schrifts (1.1.201).

She is sexually confident and outgoing, and views marriage as a positive, loving venture. On the contrary, her brothers see marriage as a prison for women and a playhouse for men. The Cardinal believes “The marriage night/Is entrance into some prison” (1.1.326), and Ferdinand views it as the males’ time for sex when he says “And those joys,/Those...

Find Another Essay On Women in The Duchess of Malfi and The Changeling

A Comparison of Pride in King Lear and The Duchess of Malfi

1568 words - 6 pages The Sin of Pride Exposed in King Lear, and The Duchess of Malfi   In this brief monograph, we shall be hunting down and examining various creatures from the bestiary of Medieval/Renaissance thought. Among these are the fierce lion of imperious, egotistical power, a pair of fantastic peacocks, one of vanity, one of preening social status, and the docile lamb of humility. The lion and the peacocks are of the species known as pride, while

John Webster's Play The Duchess of Malfi

2660 words - 11 pages duchess does much to renew confidence in the audience that Malfi is indeed a fine and genuine place. Her description is certainly crafted by Webster as different from the corrupt Dukes. Her actions, derived from her "noble virtue" are offered as paragons for other women to copy by Antonio. The idea of "noble virtue" contrasts with the view the audience have been offered about the Duke and his brother, the Cardinal. She is "more in heaven" than

The Duchess of Malfi: A True Villain

1994 words - 8 pages According to Webster’s dictionary, the definition of ‘villain’ is “a character in a story, movie, etc., who does bad things” (Merriam-Webster). In John Webster’s play, The Duchess of Malfi, the plot line revolves around a duchess and her two brothers. The Duchess of Malfi is a very twisted and complicated story where the characters are not as they seem. One of the most significant parts of the story line is that the characters that appear to be

John Webster's "The Duchess of Malfi."

1234 words - 5 pages In Webster's, The Duchess of Malfi, one scene connects thematically, imagistically, linguistically, and dramatically with the rest of the play. This is Act III, scene ii. In this scene, the author's scrupulous attention to the flow of text as well as the location of each scene, which serve dramatic purposes, become apparent. He also makes obvious the use of metaphors that are continually part of the text. During this scene, one of the main

The princely powers of the Duchess of Malfi

1321 words - 6 pages killed by Bosola ). And Bosola had already killed Antonio confusing him for the Cardinal. In this play the Duchess is transformed from a tragic figure into a triumphal one, through imagery and signs that play a compelling role. With her character easy to recognise in a culture built on simulation and impressions, and the significance of gender playing a role. Although in part The Duchess of Malfi exaggerates what men can do to women, more

Othello and The Duchess of Malfi,’ Deconstruct and Challenge the Sexism of Jacobean Society?

2778 words - 11 pages portraying these women as individuals in their own right who are beginning to break away from male control. Similarly Webster’s ‘The Duchess of Malfi’ deconstructs Jacobean stereotypes of women by presenting the Duchess as a powerful Renaissance woman who has the qualities of both a man and a woman. In comparison Verdi’s Desdemona does not challenge sexism to the same extent because she presents the stereotypical 19th century woman who remains

The princely powers of the Duchess of Malfi

1077 words - 5 pages again after being widowed. Webster portrays her brother Ferdinand’s power as a corrupted duplicate of an ideal. An ideal that the Duchess reaches through the drag of patriarchy. However the play ends as a tragedy with the deaths of almost all the major characters in the play. The Duchess of Malfi contains a lot of stage violence and horror especially in the later scenes which attracted many visitors. However this is not the reason

The Duchess of Malfi: Themes of Blood, Lust, Violence and Intrigue

1826 words - 7 pages Nishtha Tewari25.09.2012The Duchess of Malfi: Themes of Blood, Lust, Violence and IntrigueSet within the Jacobean age, The Duchess of Malfi, is a revenge play that portrays the violence inherent in any society that functions on a blood nobility structure. The play focuses on both the physical and mental aspect of this violence. The structures existing within society and hierarchies important to the functioning of the dukedom lead to the

Duchess of Malfi: The most courageous character - Essay

768 words - 4 pages Who is the most courageous character in the play? Defend your choice. The most courageous character in the Duchess of Malfi is the Duchess as she defies the Jacobean expectations and ideologies of women being mentally and physically inferior. Webster presents The Duchess’ courageousness through her interactions with the male characters in the play, Webster also uses Cariola to emphasize and contrast the Duchess’ noble nature. Webster presents

Close Reading of The Changeling

1826 words - 8 pages women and how it impacts patriarchalism. Works Cited Eaton, Sara. “Beatrice-Joanna and the Rhetoric of Love in ‘The Changeling’.” Theatre Journal 36.3 (1984): 371-82. Accessed March 28, 2014. Harber, Judith. “‘I(t) Could Not Choose But Follow’: Erotic Logic in The Changeling.” Representations 81.1 (2003): 79-98. Accessed March 28, 2014. Kistner, A. L. and M. K. Kistner. “The Five Structures of ‘The Changeling’.” Modern Language Studies 11.2

Examine the character of Bosola in Webster's The Duchess of Malfi. To what extent is he typical of the malcontent in a revenge tragedy?

865 words - 3 pages The malcontent is a certain character type that emerges in Jacobean revenge tragedy. Examples include figures like Ford's Vasquez and Middleton and Rowley's De Flores. In 'The Duchess of Malfi', this is the character of Bosola. A malcontent can be identified by a number of traits. He is a discontented person; a rebel; disaffected, satirical and melancholic; bereaved or dispossessed and detached from an often corrupt society by his grievances; he

Similar Essays

William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night And John Webster's "The Duchess Of Malfi" Comparison Of The Role That Women Played

1539 words - 6 pages works portray women as sexual objects of male desire. In Webster's play, Ferdinand's incestuous longing for his sister, The Duchess of Malfi, is based on sick feelings of lust towards her. His sexual innuendos are evident throughout the play:Ferdinand: And women like the part, which, like the lamprey,Hath ne'er a bone in'tDuchess: Fie, sir!Ferdinand: Nay,I mean the tongue [Act 1, Scene ii](http://www.english-literature.org/essays/webster.html

The Theme Of Incest In The Duchess Of Malfi

922 words - 4 pages One can begin the discussion on the theme of incest in ‘The Duchess of Malfi’ by understanding the social conception of ‘incest’. Talcott Parsons says-“ it is not so much the prohibition of incest in its negative aspect(maintaining sexual relations) …(Instead) Incest is withdrawal from the obligation to contribute to the formation and maintenance of supra-familial bonds on which major economic, political and religious functions of the society

An Analysis Of Bosola In 'the Duchess Of Malfi'

1242 words - 5 pages suggest he is a convincing character, Bosola, at times, falls into set roles of the Jacobean Tragedy; malcontent, satirist and avenger. Webster uses Bosola to fulfill these conventions of the genre and to direct and drive the plot, especially after the Duchess' death. Even though Webster uses Bosola in this way, he is more than a mere tool as his character extends beyond the established roles of the genre, giving a more complete character

Consequences Of Ambition Exposed In Macbeth, The Maid's Tragedy, And The Duchess Of Malfi

3336 words - 13 pages Consequences of Ambition Exposed in Macbeth, The Maid's Tragedy, and The Duchess of Malfi       Twenty-first century America praises the ambitious. The American dream urges us to set lofty goals and then rely on the Protestant work ethic to achieve them-regardless of potential obstacles. Parents encourage their children to consider any and every career choice. Companies and schools stress goal-setting and celebrate productivity. Even