This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Langdon Winner's Article: Upon Opening The Black Box And Finding It Empty: Social Constructivism And The Philosophy Of Technology

1666 words - 7 pages

Langdon Winner (1993): Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding It Empty: Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Technology

The Social Construction of Technology, or Social Constructivism, is a theory introduced by Wiebe Bijker and Trevor Pinch. The theory proposes that the development of technology is an interactive sociotechnical process within relevant social groups (e.g users, producers). As a methodology, social constructivism analyses artefacts in the context of society and explores the dynamics of technological change. According to Pinch and Bijker (1987), social constructivism is “fundamentally a sociological approach towards technology”. This school of research attempts to understand the mechanisms behind different social groups’ interpretations of technological artefacts.

In his article titled “Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding It Empty: Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Technology”, Langdon Winner (1993) presented a critique of social constructivism; noting that while there are definitely positive facets of social constructivism, there are also significant complications with the methodology. The aspects of social constructivism that he finds valuable include its conceptual rigor, its concern for specifics and its attempts to provide empirical models of technological change that better reveal the actual course of events (Winner, 1993). Despite this, Winner is adamant about the narrow confines of the social constructivist perspective. In his article, Winner (1993, p. 368) explores four specific limitations of social constructivism:
A disregard for social consequences: Social constructivist writing explains how technologies come to be, however it ignores the consequences of technologies and the impact it has on wider contexts.
A favoured conception of social process: Social constructivists only examine social groups that contribute to their model and ignores those who are “irrelevant” even though they are affected by technological processes.
A disregard for the possibilities of broader technological change, such as any cultural, intellectual or economic origins of social choices in regards to technology.
A lack of moral or evaluative stance on alternative interpretations of technology. Due to the rate at which technology advances, this indifference to other interpretations is a vain and unhelpful position.

Three articles that influenced Langdon Winner’s article

Steven Woolgar (1991) - The Turn to Technology in Social Studies of Science
In his article, Winner (1993) addresses an article by Steven Woolgar (1991) in order to present an example of how the social constructivist model “seeks to sidestep questions that require moral and political argument”. Woolgar’s article references Winner at a point, making light of Winner’s claims that expressway bridges were deliberately built low to the ground to prevent the passing of buses. Winner proposes that this was an expression of the architect's desire to separate...

Find Another Essay On Langdon Winner's Article: Upon Opening the Black Box and Finding it Empty: Social Constructivism and the Philosophy of Technology

The Winner's Tale Essay

1066 words - 5 pages controversial criteria of the tales is whether they are morally sound, and which is more morally sound. As said before, The Pardoner’s Tale was morally sound, it was The Pardoner himself that was not. Perhaps, an opposing audience would find the tale itself not morally sound because of the reason it was told. However if another teller, whom intended no gain but the enjoyment of this entertaining tale, were to tell the tale would the tale not then become

The Downside of Social Media and Technology

1332 words - 5 pages over the past generations. Imagination is slowly being snuffed out by technology. With the advancements in modern technology, such as social media, people have become more self-absorbed and the pace of life has increased. Not only does this technology spike affect the adult and teen world, but it can cause huge problems in the development of children. The digital world is one of creation and ingenuity; however, this is only partially true

The Future of Technology and Social Networking

1747 words - 7 pages , the media references social networking to enhance their stories creditability. Whether someone wrote on their blog, tweeted, or posted a status update on Facebook, the media grabs ahold of the information and uses it as a source. In a world driven by the latest technology, it becomes only natural for people to question what will happen to their blog or webpage when they pass away. For the occasion of the speech, Ostrow illustrates the human

Is Constructivism the Best Philosophy for Education?

932 words - 4 pages matter. The society has to also be able to adapt to the change. For such a pedagogy to be implemented it would need the support of parents and other stakeholders.State your opinion on the issue:The goal of instruction is not to ensure that students memorize specific facts, but rather that students elaborate on and interpret the information presented to them. The focus of constructivism is on creating cognitive tools which reflect the world in which

Constructivism and The Civil War in Sirya

962 words - 4 pages the absence of shared norms of sovereignty; and provide a solution from constructivism perspective which is diplomacy negotiation and limitation to it. Based on the constructivist view, the Civil War in Syria is initiated by the identity conflict between two groups which are the Assad’s regime and the rebel. Assad’s regime originates from minority Alawite, who made up 12 percent of the Syria population and also dominates most of the position in

The Social and Economic Impacts of The Black Plague

1810 words - 7 pages The Black Death is considered to be "the most severe epidemic in human history" that decimated Europe from 1347 to 1351 (Witowski). Not only did the Black Death depopulate Europe, but it also had long lasting social and economic effects as well. The social effects consisting of culture, morals, values, and social norms. The economic effects consisting of labor, payment, and the foundation of feudalism. However one would call it, the Bubonic

The Economic, Political, and Social Effects of the Black Death

1265 words - 5 pages East Asia to as far west as Greenland were catastrophic. All facets of society, from peasant to king were affected; no one was safe. All of society was affected; nothing would ever be the same. Thus, there were many economic, social, and political effects of the Black Death.Before one can understand the effects of the Black Death, one must understand precisely what is and what it did. The Black Death was the common name for what is now known today

Black Death and the devestation it caused. A look at the effects it had on the political, economical and social structures of medieval Europe

1716 words - 7 pages There have been many diseases reported historically such as small pox, measles and typhoid but none were as horrendous as Black death. In order to understand the devastation of this disease we must look at the effects it had on the political, economical and social structures of medieval Europe. The Black Death first appeared in Europe in 1347 when a boat filled with dead and dying people docked at Messina harbor, north east of Sicily. This boat

This is an article analysis of Jack in the Box

721 words - 3 pages The article I have chosen to summarize highlights the accounting practices of a San Diego--based company, Jack in the Box, Inc. (NYSE: JBX). In addition to summarizing the article, I will discuss how the concepts of the article relate to my organization The Platinum Company Inc., including, making recommendations for improvement for my organization based on the article. Lastly, explain the importance of ethics in accounting and financial

Philosophy of Aristotle and How It Relates to the Classroom

737 words - 3 pages aware of this. Hence, it becomes the teacher’s responsibility until the child learns to make choices on his own. Influence on educational practices today Aristotle, though he had formed his ideas thousands of years ago, his philosophy has a great impact on the education we receive today. The main idea of Aristotle was that through education and learning, children become good and virtuous individuals in society. His belief is followed through in

Social and Economic Effects of the Black Plague

1724 words - 7 pages streptomycin and gentamicin, tetracyclines, and the fluoroquinolone ciprofloxacin. However, those infected would need to be treated within 24 hours. Since there was basically no system for record keeping, historians and scientists have found it difficult to determine the true number of people that died of the Black Death. In Europe alone it has been known to kill at least twenty million people, or one-third of Europe’s population. The populations

Similar Essays

Summary Of The Whale And The Reactor By Langdon Winner

3277 words - 13 pages Summary of The Whale and the Reactor by Langdon Winner (pp. ix-39, 99-200). Winner states implicitly that he wishes to add his book to a surprisingly short list of works that can be characterized as "philosophy of technology" (which includes Marx and Heidegger). His book will deal primarily with the political and social aspects of this philosophy, pertinent since as he notes the world is changing because of tech., no longer comprised

Constructivism: Al Qaeda’s Terrorism And The Response To It

1609 words - 7 pages it hasn’t adequately discussed what constructivism perspectives say about terrorism by Al Qaeda either. This essay aims to apply constructivism theory to explain terrorism by Al Qaeda and the government responses to it. In doing so, firstly, this essay begins with an introduction to constructivism. Secondly, it discusses the application of constructivism around Al Qaeda’s terrorist attacks on the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. The discussion of the

Crack And The Box Essay

1171 words - 5 pages One is Crack and the Other is the Box Almost a century has passed since two revolutionaries have been born to change the world: television and drugs. It is clear that both drugs and television made their way to society at the same time, but it doesn't seem that obvious what is that made them escalate together. Some studious people say that it may have to do with the presence of drugs in the media, but it remains a mystery. In 'Crack and the

The Success Of The Opening To The Empty House In Engaging The Reader In The Story

2987 words - 12 pages now, do not possess that enthusiasm for work themselves. The settings used are effective in engaging the reader in the stories. In 'The Man With The Twisted Lip', the social context of the opening is drug abuse. In the period in which the story was written, drugs were very much an upper class hobby, whereas nowadays, it is frowned upon. This context would engage readers at the present time as they would be intrigued