This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Language And The Human Essay

1118 words - 5 pages

If we were time travelers, would we be able to understand our ancestors? Would we even be speaking the same language? Important questions about the definition of a language arise when temporal shifts come into play. Where is the line between a new language, and simply a dialect? Were Shakespeare and Chaucer writing in different languages? Does Barack Obama use a different dialect than George Washington did? The deciding factor of whether a language has evolved past the point of dialectical variation is mutual intelligibility, which can apply to linguistic changes based on geography, ethnicity, and, although it is less concrete, time. But this begs an important question: how can we test ...view middle of the document...

Eventually, the speakers in one place could not understand those in another. At that point, their system was no longer a dialect of Proto-Indo-European, but rather a language in itself. If two dialects of a language change enough–because of the combination of geographic distance and time–so that the dialect from one region is not understandable by the people using the other dialect, then the two are no longer dialects of one language. Instead, they have become two entirely different languages. Although it is, for the most part, impossible to isolate geography from time, it is possible to isolate time from geography. The rule of mutual intelligibility still applies: when a language changes to the point where its modern users cannot understand its traditional texts, then the traditional language and the modern one can be considered two separate languages.
Mutual unintelligibility is not the case with the English used today as compared to the English used in the late 1770s. For example, Barack Obama and George Washington, although there may have been small discrepancies, undoubtedly would have been able to understand each other’s writing and speech. We, as students at the University of Chicago, frequently read texts written in the 1770s and before, and are able to comprehend them even if they are unabridged. English has not changed enough in the last two hundred years to constitute two separate languages.
However, when it comes to Shakespeare and Chaucer, it is difficult to say whether they would have been able to understand each other. Although the time gap between them was roughly the same as the one between Obama and Washington, there was one vital difference: the Great Vowel Shift. This vowel shift would have made it much more difficult for Shakespeare to comprehend texts written in Chaucer’s Middle English, because the words would look completely different (Goldsmith, 2014)! Modern English speakers have notable trouble reading and comprehending Chaucer’s original texts, and it is doubtful that Chaucer would have been able to understand modern English. This mutual unintelligibility is what defines Chaucer’s Middle English as a different language from modern English.
However, this brings up an important flaw in the determination. With geographic differences, it is possible to have two different dialects simultaneously, and test whether each speaker understands the other. Temporal differentiation, however, is more difficult to...

Find Another Essay On Language and the Human

Comparing the Learnedness and Flexibility Found in Human Language to Horse Communication

1705 words - 7 pages imitate the sound. Foals need other horses to teach them social behaviors and some communicative sounds. Evidence shows that if they are separated from other horses or weaned off their mother too abruptly or too young they result in adult horses that lack appropriate behaviors for interacting with other horses (Proops et al, 2009). Through analyzing horse communication and the flexibility and learnedness found in human language separately we can see the complexities of both. The research conducted into horse communication reveals that they are more complex than some might think.

Summary/Analysis: Is Language the Key to Human Intelligence?

627 words - 3 pages The article Is Language the Key to Human Intelligence? , Written by David Premack a professor of psychology at the University of Pennsylvania, explains how humans have displayed their intelligence through language, unlike animals whose language, (any) hasn’t evolved at all. Premack uses examples such as grammar and syntax of the human language and explains the uniqueness and evolution of language over time. He claims humans have humans have six

The Dynamics and Intricacies of Human Relationships in House of Sand of Fog - Haidian Foreign Language Shiyan School - Essay

735 words - 3 pages The Dynamics and Intricacies of Human Relationships in House of Sand of Fog Topic: Andre Dubus III explores the disastrous repercussions of the relationship between three characters revolves the ownership of a house in House of Sand and Fog. Bare Thesis: The whole tragedy originated by a remediable mistake made by the county——— they evicted Kathy from her house which and sell it to Behrani immediately with a price a quarter of the value of

Development of Human Language, Neurolinguistics and Psycholinguistics: Exmaining Studies on Feral and Isolated Children

1824 words - 7 pages Most people take it for granted that children will develop cognition, language and communication skills when they reach a certain stage in their life. In fact, various studies have been conducted regarding these aspects of human development. A common topic for debate is the issue of nature versus nurture, wherein some groups support the idea that language and cognitive development is as natural as breathing while other groups contend that

How an Interdisciplinary Approach Has Assisted in the Understanding of Human Language

1922 words - 8 pages How an Interdisciplinary Approach Has Assisted in the Understanding of Human Language All perspectives provide a guide and include more than one distinct theory but within an approach they share certain basic principles and assumptions which give them a distinct ‘flavour’ or identity, The Behaviourist approach studied observable behaviour, and rejected introspection for being to subjective John Watson changed psychology

To what extent has DNA technology helped our understanding of human colonisation and the spread of agriculture in Europe over the past 10 000 years? How is this supported by language evidence?

1741 words - 7 pages Although the focus of this essay is to discuss how DNA technology helped our understanding of human colonisation and the spread of agriculture in Europe over the past 10 000 years, it will first look at the recent African origin theory as it is relevant to show how modern humans arrived in Europe in the first place. As later discussed it will also have a bearing on the development of agriculture.The two main hypotheses agree that Homo erectus

Politics and the English Language

1272 words - 5 pages George Orwell’s essay, Politics and the English Language, first published in 1946, talks about some “bad habits”, which have driven the English language in the wrong direction, that is, away from communicating ideas. In his essay he quotes five passages, each from a different author, which embody the faults he is talking about. He lists dying metaphors, operators, pretentious diction, and meaningless words as things to look out for in your own

Language and the Culture: Language learning through the culture of the target language

1931 words - 8 pages Language and the Culture : Language learning through the culture of the target language Teaching English as a Foreign Language, Winter spring 2010 Language and the Culture : Language learning through the culture of the target language As language and culture are interrelated, so that language cannot be taught without culture (Maria, 2002). How many people learn a culture of the target

The Internet and the Future of Language

789 words - 4 pages Throughout the history of civilization, a new medium of linguistic communication has always brought significant changes in our way of communication as well. Such media are printing in the fifteen century, telegraph and telephone in the nineteen century, and finally television and the internet in the twentieth century. However, the sheer scale and the significance of the Internet have in sociolinguistic and stylistic complexity of the language is

The Relation Between Identity and Language

1834 words - 7 pages and Religion: A Journey Into the Human Mind. The Edinburg Building, Cambrige CB2 8RU, UK: Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from http://books.google.com/books?id=y4LqTZ2bq8QC Edwards, J. (2009). Language and identity: an introduction. The Edinburg Building, Cambrige CB2 8RU, UK: Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from http://books.google.com/books?id=wwvOjiqyU-EC Hoff, E. (2005). Language development (3rd ed.). 10 Davis Drive, Belmont

Education Of The Language And Literature

2282 words - 10 pages , in the continuous development of the information society at the same time, China's science and education and also the rapid development of economy and culture, which are gradually changing people's traditional concepts of education and human resources strategy concepts, but also the traditional humanities majors enormous impact. As long history of one of the traditional specialty Chinese language and literature, as early as in the 'May Fourth

Similar Essays

Study On The Falsities Of Language And Human Interaction

3889 words - 16 pages Study on the Falsities of Language and Human Interaction This essay is an attempt to study the natural tendency of language to lie, and what it does to human interaction. I believe that we "colour" the "truth" in every occasion. One of the reasons for this is the referred natural tendency of language, others are social and psychological. In a way it is very human, it is something that our vigorous imagination forces us to do. One thing must

Human Agency And Language, By Charles Taylor

5191 words - 21 pages dominant approach, and leads to a holistic conception of language and meaning. Subsequent progression down this path leads to intriguing accounts of human nature and the source of our ancient notion of God. The Failure of the Dominant Approach In extracting Taylor’s argument for expressivism, it will serve us well to begin with a discussion of his critique of modernity. Taylor is critical of several mainstream disciplines

The Power Of Beastly, Human, And Godly Language In Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex

700 words - 3 pages Language serves as a means of communication between the human race and according upon the interpretation of the message delivered, can serve as a force of creation, destruction, or eradication of a powerful civilization amongst human society. The language used in Oedipus Rex, although hard to decode, parallels to the communication by ritual and oracle between man and God (Bloom 127). The evaluation of the language used by the Sphinx, Teiresias

How Psychology Helps Us Understand The Concept Of Language And Intelligence As Related To Human Beings

1549 words - 6 pages How Psychology Helps Us Understand the Concept of Language and Intelligence as Related to Human Beings Psychology, the study of behaviour and mental processes concerns itself with the reasons organisms do what they do and how they behave in a particular way, For example why acquired skills are not lost when learnt ; Why do children rebel against parents and, why humans speak, love and fight each other. These examples of learning and