This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Lanzmann Believes Schindler's List Was Not A Credible Movie

1831 words - 8 pages

Lanzmann believes that Schindler's List should never have been made for many reasons. Primarily, Lanzmann disagrees with Schindler's List because there were many technicalities and imprecise scenes which he dislikes. In his review, Lanzmann comments on how the Holocaust is trivialised and transgressed in Schindler's List, and often compares Schindler's List to his own motion picture, Shoah. Shoah and Schindler's List have many critical differences, and take different approaches. In Shoah we see survivors telling impersonal stories, like a 'spokesman' for the dead. On the contrary, Schindler's List is an individual story about survival. Lanzmann also believes that the Holocaust was transcendent, and that one could not re-experience, or accurately portray the events, with the same atmosphere, feeling and emotion that the Holocaust had, and that Schindler's List is an 'Impossible story'.
One of the reasons that Lanzmann believes that Schindler's List should never have been made is due to the common inaccuracies. Lanzmann said that the film is 'swarming with ambiguous and dangerous scenes', one of which shows Schindler bargaining with traditionally dressed orthodox Jews who take out handfuls of money and give them to Schindler. This illustrates the stereotype of Jews with money. In his review, Lanzmann criticises this scene, and the inaccuracies within it, because he believes 'one should instead, have worked with a pair of tweezers'. In addition, although the scene was not intended to be comical, the stereotypes introduced a humorous aspect to the film. Another light-hearted and amusing scene is where women are trying for the job of Schindler's secretary. During this scene jolly violin music is played and there is constant chatter and laughing. Lanzmann thinks that scenes like that were inappropriate and potentially made other aspects of the film unimportant.
Another aspect of the scene explaining why Lanzmann believes that Schindler's List should never have been made is the depiction of the emptying of mass graves, add experiences inside concentration camps. He disagrees with the depiction of such horrific moments because he believes that Spielberg could not do justice to what he was trying to portray because he could not 'tell the story of Schindler without also telling what the Holocaust has been'. In the review, Lanzmann goes on to say that there is a similar, but significantly different, scene in Shoah about the emptying of the mass graves, The fundamental difference between the two films is that the scene in Shoah is described, however in Schindler's List, it is displayed. In Shoah there is a survivor who tells of how he had to open the mass graves. When watching him describe how he recognised his mother and his three sisters and their children lying dead in the graves, one witnesses the suffering on his face as he explains the horrifying moment. Lanzmann said: 'Suddenly I realise that Spielberg shows everything that I left out in Shoah'.

Find Another Essay On Lanzmann Believes Schindler's List Was Not a Credible Movie

Was the Second Bombing on Nagasaki Necessary? List three reasons why or why not. I Said it wasn't and then listed three reasons

844 words - 3 pages Japanese? The first question was whether or not to drop a bomb. The effects of atomic warfare had not been known and studied, but it was apparent that it would be a good tool in ending the war. The first bomb did appear necessary to ending the war. It would put Japan in check to bring a quick finish to the fighting, saving many lives, as well as prevent the Russians from joining the Pacific War. The second on Nagasaki, however, was obviously not. It

A Critical Analysis of Thomas Keneally's Schindler's List

1279 words - 5 pages Czechoslovakia his plan continues in that he tricks the Germans into thinking that they were going to produce quality ammunition, but instead not one good shell was ever produced to help the German army. Gratefully, within a few months Hitler was dead and the Germans were defeated. Unfortunately, Oskar Schindler was now penniless for he had given everything in order to save as many Jews as possible.Thomas Keneally wrote Schindler's List to be more

A Critical Analysis of Thomas Keneally's Schindler's List

1298 words - 5 pages Schindler's list came to be. 1100 Jewish names that had in some way touched his life were put on a list and bought. His plan was to send the 1100 Jews to his newly created ammunitions factory in his native Czechoslovakia. However, Schindler's plan does not go smoothly for an entire train load of his women were accidentally shipped to Auchwitz instead of to his factory. Schindler then uses more of his diminishing financial recourses to try to get his

Marcus Antonius was Not a Great Man

1115 words - 4 pages relations, particularly that with Caesar. Marc Antony's mother Julia was the cousin of Julius Caesar, making him the second cousin. In a time when blood relations and family lineage were so important, this obviously meant Antony was destined from birth to be in a position of power. He did not rise up through the ranks and earn his complete status, but rather was granted most of it by Caesar, as Plutarch wrote in his book Antony: And the influence

The New Deal Was Not A Success

1056 words - 4 pages The Great Depression was one of the most terrible catastrophes in U.S. history, and resulted in the need for government help to pull the nation out of the depression. The New Deal refers to the programs and acts that came about as a response to the Great Depression. However, the New Deal was not successful in removing the country, either economically or socially, out of the Depression. The Agricultural Adjustment Act only resulted in waste of

My Great-Grandmother was not a Person

631 words - 3 pages My Great-Grandmother was not a Person My Great-Grandmother was not a person. Neither was yours. Up until about 67 years ago no females were. We were supposed to be pregnant and barefoot in the kitchen. At least that's the perception that the laws enforced. (For ex: The Election Act of the Dominion of Canada and The Common Law of England) As part of the British Commonwealth many of our laws were the same as England's and enforced by British

Schindler's List by Thomas Keneally: Character identity conflict/How does this book provide inspiration for hope in modern times? (Also recieved an A in an 11th grade AP Lit. and Comp. class.)

564 words - 2 pages In the book, 'Schindler's List,' identity conflict is central to the story of the main character, Oscar Schindler.Oscar Schindler is a member of the Nazi Party, a war profiteer. At the beginning of the book, Schindler seems cool and slick; he is a womanizer, he drinks, but seems to never get drunk, and has a plethera of friends in high places.Because of the war, Schindler has moved to the city to try his hand at business once again. He decides

Why Star Wars was such a Ground Breaking Movie

2207 words - 9 pages Why Star Wars was such a Ground Breaking Movie There are many reason for ‘Star Wars’ being such a ground breaking movie. ‘Star Wars’ is a science fiction film, a science fiction includes new world and civilisations that are discovered and aliens are featured in a lot of science fiction films, the setting of the films are usually set in the future and where the world is in danger. There are some characters that are

"Some like it hot", a movie should not be missed

937 words - 4 pages Some Like It HotHave people ever thought or talked about the movies made over forty years ago? Yes. One of them is "Some Like It Hot," the movie that was made in 1959 by MGM, a black and white movie that leave audiences much feeling.The film has aged but it is still very fresh and more alive than most comedies today. I know a lot of people (usually of the younger persuasion) today hate watching old films, for example, Some Like It Hot because of

“Jackson was not a noteworthy female poet, but simply a

1080 words - 4 pages "Jackson was not a noteworthy female poet, but simply a noteworthy poet." Ralph Waldo Emerson Jackson is one of the most interesting persons of her time. Born in 1831 she led a very interesting, yet equally sad life. Jackson's father, a stern congregational minister /author/ professor, died just three years after his wife Debrah. Debra's writing skills seemed to be passed down to her daughter even though Helen claimed, "I inherited

Essay on "Les Miserables" by Victor Hugo and whether or not it should be included on a summer reading list

1204 words - 5 pages historical context without taking on the tone of a textbook. The only concern with the novel is its size, approximately 1500 pages unabridged. The abridged versions lose much of the detail and history while condensing the novel to about 300 pages (yeah, I read both).Bibliography:This was done a couple of years ago. It's sort of a persuasive writing projects on your opinion of a book of your choice and whether or not it should be included on a summer reading list for some AP english class or another. I think I used sparknotes and wikipedia as well as the novel itself as sources.

Similar Essays

Movie Review Of "Schindler's List"

1293 words - 5 pages Schindler's List, directed by Steven Spielberg, stars Liam Neason, Ben Kingsley, Ralph Fiennes, and a host of wonderful co-stars, is the story of Oskar Schindler. Oskar Schindler was a Nazi businessman who saved hundreds of Jews from certain death during World War Two by employing them in his factory. This documentary like film begins with Oskar Schindler getting ready to make the deal of a life time by getting in good with the Nazi

The Holocaust: As Depicted Through The Movie Schindler's List. How Schindler Risked His Own Life, How Was A Hero, And How He Protected The Lives Of The Innocent

1043 words - 4 pages owned enameled-goods factory. There he employed Jewish workers from which he bought from the Germans - Jewish workers who's lives he saved. These were all actions that were against the law and an easy way of being murdered. Schindler also betrayed the Nazi party in which he was an active member; consequently, having to flee the country. Thus, it is evident that Oscar Schindler is a hero. He had no reason to save over 1,100 people; he was not

A Description Of The Movie "Schindler's List" As Well As Character Analysis And Theme Of The Movie

1436 words - 6 pages Schindler was interviewing secretaries for his factory and then he picked all of the pretty women for the job. He then hosts a party for all of the Nazi officials at his own expense and sends them gift baskets with all of the best wine, cheeses, etc... Schindler's mistress comes to the door and his wife answers, she is angry with him. He takes his mistress out to dinner where he sees his "girlfriend". They go home and Schindler's mistress says the

Movie "Lantana" : Valerie Believes That "Home Should Be A Sanctuary, Not A Battleground". Why Does Her Relationship With John Break Down?

545 words - 2 pages herself that home should be a sanctuary, this is not evidenced in the home life she is experiencing at the moment with John. With the mysterious late nights of her husband John, and the challenging therapy sessions she is engaging in with Patrick, Valeries capacity to trust is diminishing taking with it her "sanctuary" and leading inevitably to her death.Valerie and John's Daughter, Eleanor, was murdered a couple of years before the time of the movie