This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Law And Morality. Speaks Of The Dilemma Of Making A Decision That Someone Must Die In Order For The Others To Survive. Explains And Justifies The Decision By Using Legal Tools Such As Law And Moralit

2117 words - 8 pages

It is not an everyday occurrence that someone must decide the fate of another's life. The dilemma of making a decision that someone must die in order for the others to survive, can obviously be troubling. The process in which the termination of one's life may be easy to make, but to justify that decision is the most difficult one. This paper is given a situation in which a decision of taking one's life is essential. The situation is that a nuclear war has occurred, which has destroyed most of the centres of civilization. There are five people that are that have escaped death by finding their way to a nuclear bunker. These five people consist of a pregnant woman; an old man, who is a retired judge; two teenagers - a fourteen-year-old boy and a sixteen-year-old girl; and a young and healthy woman who is a doctor. They all have been there for fifteen days and they must remain there for an additional fifteen days before they can be rescued. The problem is that although there are five of them in the bunker, there is only enough food for four people to survive for the remaining fifteen days. Rationing the food will not be of any use, because all will die with such a plan. The only way for most of the survivors to live for the next fifteen days is for one to die. Somehow they have contacted an outside source to advise them on the questions of 'Who shall die?', and 'How should the decision of choosing the person be carried out?' These are all very difficult questions to answer, but something must be done. It is unlikely that someone will voluntarily allow someone to kill them so that the others may live, that is why another form of decision making must be allowed. The best way to do so is probably by that outside aid to suggest that they try drawing lots. For example whoever pulls the shortest straw is the one who dies. With no time to procrastinate, this would seem the most time efficient and fairest way to choose who will die. Of course a reason must be provided to the person who had drawn the shortest straw, and that is the objective of this paper. This essay will explain how the decision will be made that will ultimately take one of the survivor's lives to save the remaining four people. From that explanation of the decision made, it will attempt to justify it. This paper proposes to explain and justify the decision by using legal tools such as Law and Morality, the Meta Rule, and The Doctrine of Necessity. The advice provided on how to carry out the unfortunate death of an innocent person may not be a 'right' one, but perhaps it will be legally and morally justified.Law and morality play a large role here, mainly because there is a legal issue and a moral issue associated with the predicament. The reason law has a part in the situation is that after the decision is made, it will be examined legally and must be accountable for its consequences. Morality has its place too, because many will find it morally wrong to take one's life despite any...

Find Another Essay On Law and Morality. Speaks of the dilemma of making a decision that someone must die in order for the others to survive. Explains and justifies the decision by using legal tools such as Law and Moralit

Financial Accounting: Tools for Business Decision Making Financial and Managerial Accounting: The Basis for Business Decisions

857 words - 3 pages Running head: TEXTBOOK ASSIGNMENT 1 TEXTBOOK ASSIGNMENT PAGE \* Arabic \* MERGEFORMAT 6 Textbook AssignmentnameACC/400: Accounting for Decision MakingMay 2010instructorTextbook AssignmentChapter 8 of Financial Accounting: Tools for Business Decision Making by Kimmel, Weygandt, and Kieso (2007) is Reporting and Analyzing Receivables. Receivables are "amounts due from individuals and companies that are expected to be collected in cash" (Kimmel

This essay describes a student nurse's experience of caring for someone in I.T.U. and the Law, Ethics and Therapeutic Use of Self issues related to this experience

1982 words - 8 pages does die he will leave a loving family that have loved him and will probably leave them devastated especially his wife, children and grand children.I was trying to determine what the best course of action might be, taking in to account the wishes of Mr. Jones and his family.I intervened by taking part in the care for Mr. Jones; I did so because I believed in the decisions that were made by the medical staff at the time.The actions of the hospital

Year 9 Health Response (Tobacco) Using the decision making model as a reference and guide address the following situation

1965 words - 8 pages Decision making model: You are with a group of close friends and they are trying to get you to try smoking tobacco, marijuana or drinking alcohol. They want to get together tomorrow and try it. In essay form, outline the process you would go through to make the decision as to whether you do or don't. Include all the facts and information you have accumulated in order to make an educated decision.In this situation, I am with a group of close

The Use of Polygraph Testing in Law Enforcement for Investigative and Hiring Tools

1643 words - 7 pages nervous that one who tells the truth. In the attempt to deceit the test through unconscious actions, many different behaviors have been associated with liars deception, including gazing aversion, the increase or decrease in movement, the amount of pauses or hesitations, slow of the speech rate, and speech errors. The polygraph became a valuable tools used by the different varieties of law enforcement agencies as either investigative information for

Racial stereotype and prejudice in judging others and decision making

1067 words - 5 pages decision-making is one such example of subtle prejudice, where seemingly objective decisions may be influenced by factors of which the decision maker is not even aware” (1988). Racial stereotype can also be seen in the medical services. Analyses of health care processes and outcomes repeatedly indicate that minority health care users, especially blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans are less likely than with health care users to receive high

The objectivity of judicial decision-making and interpretation

1638 words - 7 pages interpretation. American Legal Realism tends to lean strongly towards judges being purely subjective in their judicial activity (specifically in decision-making and interpretation) with the very few exceptions of basic situations being covered by the law, and this is evident in their rejection of formalism. Formalism is the act of judges using basic law as the basis for their decisions and interpretation. Any reasonable person would ask the

Decision-Making Tools for Mangers

1281 words - 5 pages will prevent this from happening and can also help a company save money in the long run. Another important tool discussed is the PMI model. Using PMI analysis is weighing the pros and cons on a scale to make sure that the pros always outweigh the cons (Mind Tools Ltd, 1995). By using a PMI model, decision makers can take their time making logical decisions that would benefit the company. Another useful technique when it comes to decision making

Using Cost of Production for Decision Making

2169 words - 9 pages Front cover CASE STUDY Using Cost of Production for Decision Making "The Vegetable Industry Development Program is funded by HAL using the vegetable levy and matched funds from the Australian Government". InnoVeg Horticulture Australia Limited Content Introduction 02 What is included in cost of production? 03 Calculating cost of production 04 Changing yield and costs 05 Using cost of production to make decisions 05 Should I harvest or cut my

The Process of Decision Making

1250 words - 5 pages as mentioned by Stroh, Northcraf and Neale (2002). An advantage of identify the problem can reduce the time if managers find the problem from a first stage particularly in lower quality of worker participation (Dubrin 2002). The second stage of decision making process is gathering and evaluating data. As stated by Prasad (2008), the managers should identify the different choices available in order to get most acceptable outcome of a decision


1148 words - 5 pages Introduction Decision making can be defined as "the act of choosing from among alternatives" (Naylor, 1998, p. 339). In the organization, decision making is quite important for the managers to choose the best choice for establishing their goals. Manager will make a rational and logical decision to overcome the issues. As Daft (2010) mentions, there are six important steps in the decision making process which are recognizing the problem

The Prefrontal Cortex and Decision-Making

1496 words - 6 pages learn from negative associated outcomes and the other projection is how people recognize the emotions of others. Learning from negative outcomes is known as social learning. The ability to recognize and consider other people’s emotions is known as emotional identification. Both social learning and emotional recognition are extremely important in the decision-making process. If a patient has a lesion in their Orbitofrontal Cortex they would suffer

Similar Essays

Management Abount Decision Making. As Managers And Entrepreneurs, We Should Have Confidence In Our Decisions, But Can We? Discuss With Regard To Your Ability As A Decision Maker And The Tools And...

2118 words - 8 pages A decision is means that make choice of two or more alternatives (Robbins, Bergman, Stagg & Coulter, 2006, p. 208). And it is the point at which a choice is made between alternative and usually competing- options (Fitzgerald, 2002, p. 8). Everyone would make any decision in their life time when they want to choose any ideas from alternatives, such as: to spend 3 dollars for coffee or 3.5 dollars for juice. Although it is very small things in

Decision Making Tools And Techniques Essay

1296 words - 6 pages outweigh possible losses" (Decision making skills and techniques, 2006). Dr. Hossein supposes there are two diverse types of models that can be used for decision-making: deterministic models and probabilistic models. Deterministic models evaluate a high-quality decision by results alone, whereas probabilistic models demonstrate trepidation for the results assessment as well as the total consequence involved in the decision-making. Because the makers of

Decision Making Tools And Techniques Essay

873 words - 3 pages One of the key roles of being a manager or potential manager is solving problems and making decisions. Do you do it alone? Do you involve others? Do you let others make the decisions? "Decision making is the study of identifying and choosing alternatives based on the values and preferences of the decision maker. Making a decision implies that there are alternative choices to be considered, and in such a case we want not only to identify as many

Knowledge Of Accounting System As Effective Tools In The Decision Making Of Micro Enterprises

1498 words - 6 pages that a massive part of the country may be put under risk if this sector starts to fail, enterprises’ vulnerability to economic pressures must not be neglected. This converse of how these businesses operate individually, with each business being able to display impressive performance and effective decisions. Options or tools must be provided for them in order to realize full growth and potential. Decision making marks the method of choosing