Law Should Be Influenced By Religion

3145 words - 13 pages

The purpose of this essay is to discuss whether religion should ever impact criminal law. The question of if it is desirable for religion to impact criminal law is endemic. Advocates of a strict application of the separation between church and state may eschew any notion of this being desirable. However, it is submitted that religion impacts criminal law and vice versa. To deny this would be erroneous.
In a religious plurality, the law has a fastidious task of treating religious groups equally – the State must not give a preferential treatment to one particular religion. But how feasible is this? If one accepts that religion should ever impact criminal law, which religion or religions should have an impact?
There have been calls for a Parliamentary inquiry into scale of Sharia law in the UK after the Law Society was ‘accused’ of promoting Islamic law. Although the particular areas of Sharia law currently being reviewed relate to private law (wills), imagine if the Sharia penal code were incorporated into English law? Wouldn’t other religions want to be accommodated in such an arrangement?
The idea of equality before the law is redolent of the Rule of Law doctrine. Dicey predicated:
“No man is above the law; every man and woman, whatever be his or her rank or condition, is subject to the ordinary law of the realm and amenable to the jurisdiction of the ordinary tribunals”.
While generally used to refer to government according to the law, it is submitted that this principle is germane to religious establishments.
In Wilkinson , the owner of a bed and breakfast had discriminated against a gay couple because of their sexual orientation under the Equality Act (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2007 by refusing them accommodation. The limitation imposed on the freedom to manifest her religious beliefs under Article 9 was justified, as it was prescribed by law, and necessary for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. While not a criminal case, it is contended that the Law be generally applicable. If a law prohibits a certain action, religious justifications should not necessarily circumvent it.
This contention may be buttressed using Andrews . The appellant, a Rastafarian appealed against his conviction – he had imported cannabis, contrary to the Customs and Excise Management Act 1979. He contended that the use of cannabis was part of his religious right and consequently s.170 (2) of the Act was incompatible with his Article 9 rights.
It was held that there was no incompatibility between s.170 (2) and his Article 9 rights, applying the principle of Taylor . Even if there had been interference with Article 9 (1), it would have been justified under Article 9 (2) for the protection of public health.
It is submitted that religion should impact on criminal law. The extent to which it should impact on criminal law is a separate issue.
Edge discusses some of the reasons why law is important to religion. He states “law may be seen as...

Find Another Essay On Law Should Be Influenced By Religion

Seat Belt Law Should Be Removed

1528 words - 7 pages ). The penalty from this law, depending on the states such as New York’s fine is 50 USD and 25 USD for Illinois states. Does the safety belt help save people’s life? Absolutely, using the safety belt is an option to save a driver and passengers life from any accidents but should it be a law? Should people obligate to pay fines if they don’t want to use a safety belt? According to Human rights, people should hold their freedom to choose, if they want

Should Affirmative Action Be Rescinded From Law?

799 words - 3 pages opportunities are heard threw family, friends and other social networks but because of racism segregation of communities occurs not allowing people of color to hear about the jobs. Federal law now makes employers advertise job openings so all people have a chance to compete. Preferential hiring pools were another argument. Black people should be considered first when going against other candidates even if their testing scores were slightly lower

Whyu The State Curfew Law Should Be Abolished

867 words - 3 pages level.So, what is it that makes the state curfew law so wrong? First, the government is setting a time for young citizens to be home no matter the reason they are out late for. Is America not the land of the free? The people who are influenced by curfew law are actually the ones who are not committing much crime. Seventy-eight point four one of the crimes in Indiana alone were committed by the very people the government allows to walk the street at night. Does it feel safe now knowing that criminals are being allowed to walk around in the middle of the night? The state curfew law should be abolished; young citizens have rights too.

Criminal Law: Should there be a crime of corporate manslaughter?

2580 words - 10 pages manslaughter.Current State of the Law.The current law in Australia is such that, although corporations are deemed legal persons, they cannot be convicted of an offence which is only punishable by imprisonment e.g. murder. In Australia, the acknowledgement of corporate responsibility for workplace killing is significantly inhibited by the Tesco principle, which holds that a corporation can only be charged with an offence where the persons who made the error of

Racial Profiling By Police Should Be Illegal

1729 words - 7 pages Department. The second act that was passed was The New York Police Department Oversight Act, passed by a margin 39-10, puts department oversight responsibility on the Commissioner of the Department of Investigation. These shows how the New York Police Department has been discriminating against people of race and color and, shows the New York Police Department is not following the law and make themselves look corrupt. On August 12, 2002 Judge

Euthanasia Should Be Performed By Medical Professionals

3049 words - 12 pages autonomy. Thus, similar to the reasons that suicide is prohibited, a patient should not be allowed to commit euthanasia. Garcia also argues that the three medical objectives mentioned above are paramount to any other medical duty. Therefore, a medical duty such as relieving pain cannot be used as evidence for euthanasia since relieving pain is a supplementary duty for a physician and is outweighed by their primary duty of lengthening life. Furthermore

Should Smoking be banned? By Asif

1267 words - 5 pages of people dying from cigarettes, the government should ban advertisements of cigarette ads, make cigarettes more expensive and introduce more smoke free roads by making smoke rooms everywhere, so that the people can smoke there instead of public places. There should be an improved package warning and health information in every pack of cigarette. If someone has to smoke, let him or her smoke ultra low tar cigarettes, they are harmful but not as

"Much Ado about nothing" - "Changing self" can be an internal process but is often influenced by external factors.

547 words - 2 pages and Benedick, although loving each other right from the beginning, needed external factor to push them together, Don Pedro, Claudio and Leonato talking loudly in the garden about how Beatrice was in love with him and Hero and Ursula doing the same thing to Beatrice shows how "Changing self" can be an internal process but is often influenced by external factors.

Should Aboriginals be using the Law to gain their Native rights?

2145 words - 9 pages in the past. Often times society thinks Aboriginals do not want to be 'Canadian'. To help themselves outside of the law Aboriginals need to band together and show the government that they will not abuse these newly proposed laws by abiding by the old ones too. Those arguing aboriginal rights should just want communally equal rights in the end.

Gun Control: Law Abiding Citizens Should be Permitted to Have Guns

1258 words - 5 pages Gun Control: Law Abiding Citizens Should be Permitted to Have Guns "Bleeding and weakened from the bullet wound in her chest, Susan Gonzalez aimed her husband's .22-caliber pistol, the one she hated, and emptied it into one of the robbers who had burst through the front door of her rural Jacksonville home"(Pinkham). This story shows that guns can be used to save lives. Americans have gun rights and privileges thanks to the Second Amendment

"The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" by Mark Twain: Should this book be banned for its controversy?

1957 words - 8 pages was common language. It did not have the same impact on a person back then as it does in today's society. Jim even uses the word nigger freely as if it does not have any meaning to it, and he is a black slave. When he's talking to Huck one day, he says, "I wouldn't 'low no nigger to call me dat."(77). Jim does not seem to be offended by the word because he uses the word himself. I think that African Americans at this time were so prone to hearing

Similar Essays

Religion, Politics And The Law Should Be Allowed To Mix

1264 words - 5 pages , resulting from a group's beliefs and practices. In summary, religion is a systematic theory that is esteemed worthy of respect or dedication by a congregated group of people.The topic 'Religion, law, and politics should they be allowed to mix' does not pose questions of the functionality of their union. According to the American Heritage Dictionary (2006), 'should' is used to "express probability or expectation." It is very probable that religion

Religion Should Be Taught In Public Schools

3344 words - 13 pages “If we ever forget that we are “One nation under God,” then we will be a nation gone under” -- Ronald Reagan (BrainyQuote). Ronald Reagan makes a great point. America was created as a place for religious freedom. Now that freedom is beginning to be stripped away from us. One of the biggest reasons is due to the argument concerning whether or not religion should be allowed in school. It is believed, by many, that allowing education and religion

Should Comparative Religion Be Taught In School

1193 words - 5 pages Whether religion should be part of the public school curriculum or not has been issue for debate in the USA for the past 60 years. Religion has always played a significant role in people’s lives. Archaeologists found that, even as early as 300,000 years ago, Paleolithic art was already based in religious theories (“Religious Beliefs”). In Egypt, ancient Greece, the Roman Empire as well as more recent civilizations, the influence of religion has

Should There Be A Law Against Paparazzi?

509 words - 2 pages How about creating a law against the use of telephoto lens and parabolic listening devices? How about creating a new crime—One that will penalize those persisting and persuading photographers, the Paparazzi also known to celebrities as stalkarazzi who follow the rich and famous for the thousand dollars snapshot that reveals some special, intimate moment or an embarrassing one. Should there be a law rebuking such act? Should there be strict laws