Lawrence Stone, The Family, Sex And Marriage In England 1600 1800

2482 words - 10 pages

Lawrence Stone’s book ‘The family sex and marriage in England 1600-1800’ is one of controversy and contrasting opinions about marriage in the medieval era. As a medievalist historian, Stone puts forward a conflicting perspective when it comes to the medieval family unit in providing a new interpretation of the medieval family unit. In producing such a notorious argument, Stone provided the beginnings of the debate that has now surrounded the medieval family. His work, has had a mixed reception in the history community sporting conflicting ideas about his distant view on marriage. Lawrence's book challenges the aspects of the making of marriage and the patterns of family relationships that have never before explored so closely.

The main subject matter of the book, argues there were multiple reasons why relations between men and women changed in Medieval England. In his anthology, Stone opens himself to counter attack from other medievalist historian when he states that there was hardly any love in English marriages before the eighteenth century, famously taking a ‘hard line’ when it comes to the view of medieval marriages. Throughout his book he questions the factor of love present in matrimony and has came to the idea that marriage was seen more of a pack with mutual rights and individual tasks. Stone also demonstrates the modern relevance of these radical changes when he states that there are three key features of the modern family that can be clearly seen in the medieval family unit.1

According to Alan Macfarlane, Stone’s ‘book provides an interesting example of the way in which a set of assumptions shapes the historian's evidence.’2 Stone sets major themes throughout his book while examining social attitudes and how they influenced family relationships, successfully displaying this when he uses an amalgamation of public and personal documents. One review concludes that ‘Stone's book helps to confirm and add depth to the current paradigm of the development of the first industrial nation.’3 Although Stone has been criticised for using select information to frame his argument, he has self confessed his own mistake.4

One of Stone’s prominent views, was his interest to studying the mentality of society in the medieval era when he states that the most important change in ‘mentalite is to have occurred in the early modern period.’5 In accepting the Annales School’s view in which there was a larger stress on the social rather than the political or environmental themes Stone presented a new way to look at history. Although rejecting the creation of ‘laws’ of history in the manner of Karl Marx, Stone’s argues that the most anyone can conclude is a generalization about a particular century. In focusing on the social theme, Stone combines the ideas of sociology and anthropology in his book.

Individualism is a key theme in the book, Stone argues that it was in the sixteenth century that distinct roles formed in marriage that caused...

Find Another Essay On Lawrence Stone, The family, sex and marriage in England 1600-1800

Same Sex Marriage and the Law in Canada

1687 words - 7 pages Marriage is a fundamental institution in Canadian society today, and has been the topic of much controversy in recent years. The issue of same-sex marriage has caused debates between many groups in society. Not just in Canada, but around the world, individuals and governments have debated whether marriage has a continuing value to society, and if so whether and how the state should recognize married relationships in law. Many groups are opposed

Same Sex Marriage and Politics in the U.S.

816 words - 3 pages Recently, Same Sex Marriage has become a major issue in the United States. There are variations in opinions concerning the topic. The main concern is should same sex marriage be allowed or declared unconstitutional. Plenty of conservatives are completely against gay marriage and many of liberals are fighting for equal treatment. Many controversies and arguments have developed from this issue. There are many reasons why gay marriage should be

"Pride and Prejudice": Exploring the Chasm Between Love and Marriage in Georgian England

1575 words - 6 pages “Pride and Prejudice”, is a novel which explores the huge chasm between love and marriage in Georgian England. Jane Austen’s presentation of passion and matrimony reiterates the fact that marriage is a “business arrangement”. Austen uses irony to make fun of polite society in this satire and Austen also emphasizes the point that social hierarchy dictates whom you can marry. The pressures of men and women in Georgian England are revealed through

Family, Marriage, and Gender Roles in America

714 words - 3 pages husband, wife, and children is a thing of the past. Recently an alarming number of unfavorable situations have arisen. These situations range from one-parent families to the inexplicable situation of two partners of the same sex. What happens to a society where the nuclear family is no longer the dominant configuration? Only time will tell.Being brought up in a traditional environment, I have very conservative views on the concept of a family

Marriage and Family in Updike's Stories

659 words - 3 pages family relationships, marriage, and divorce. This topic appears clearly in his three short stores Son, Still of Some Use, and The Lovely Troubled Women of our Old Crowd.One of the main causes of family problems, resulting in divorces, is the disability of parents to compromise. Most of the time, parents disagree on something and the problem grows until dislike is created, resulting in a divorce. The parents usually divorce without thinking about

Sex Education and the American Family

1707 words - 7 pages discuss sex with their children, and does this lack of communication between child and parent affect the child’s future. This lack of communication has been proven through studies to be harmful to the lifestyles and well-being of members of society. The importance of family involvement and communication in sex education should be emphasized to reduce the future risks of sexually transmitted infections, prolonged psychological trauma, or confusion

False Picture of Marriage in The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence

1207 words - 5 pages impression of the other. Modern literature demonstrates that a marriage built upon illusion will falter when exposed to reality. In order to understand the effects of illusion on marriages in modern literature, we will explore two pieces: The Dead by James Joyce and Odour of Chrysanthemums by D.H. Lawrence. Both stories have central characters who have created, and lived with, a false picture of their spouse and their marriage. Firstly, I will

Gay Marriage and Family

584 words - 2 pages decision, family is the union by a first and a second applicant. There are no more bride and groom spaces in marriage applications. Now it is a space for first applicant and another for the second applicant.It has been established that children do best emotionally, academically, and physically in husband - wife households. Now, there are times when a mom or dad is absent because of divorce or death, but that is not an intentional attempt to deny

Marriage and Family Counseling

987 words - 4 pages the establishment in 1989 of the International Association of Marriage and Family Counseling (IAMFC), which is a division of the American Counseling Association. Requirements for marriage and family counselors typically include a master’s degree in counseling, two years or three thousand hours of supervised clinical experience, and state-recognized exams. Marriage and family counselors can work in mental health centers, clinics, hospitals

"The Stonhenge" This is about the stone hege in England and how long it took to build this structure and different stagesit went through.

856 words - 3 pages away from this monument. This circle of sarsen surrounds a horseshoe -shaped setting of five sarsen trilithons. Over a period of time some of the bluestones were reerected in an oval structure within the center of the sarsen horseshoe. Around the time of 1900 or 1800 BC, Stonehenge was almost complete to what we now see in present day. The altar stone is considered the focal point between two circles of sarsen and bluestone and two horseshoes of

Life in London in the 1600's

1467 words - 6 pages religion. The official established religion of England in the 1600's is the Church of England. Puritanism isn't a separate religion but a branch off of the Church of England. You were allowed to be a Puritan. If you were a Roman Catholic, however, you would be fined for not going to the Protestant services, which is the same as the Church of England services. It's illegal to be a Catholic priest in England, and very illegal to be a Jesuit. You are

Similar Essays

Trends In Family Formation: A Look At Same Sex Marriage

2367 words - 9 pages Introduction Family and marriage are social and divine institutions that are facing constant challenges due to the rapidly changing trends in society. In the past, the problems that families and marriages experienced were polygamy, early marriages, and family planning, but the current society experiences extra problems such as high rates of divorce, delayed marriages, single parenthood, cohabitation, and emergence of same sex marriages among

Trends In Family Formation Supporting Same Sex Marriage

1235 words - 5 pages the same sex thinking that those are the kind of people who cannot hurt them as opposed to the opposite sex. Marriage has become a private, expressive and emotional relationship and some people have found fulfillment of these qualities through same sex marriages due to the numerous failures of heterosexual relationships (Stanton & Maier, 2004). In some family set ups, the presence of children only created additional problems for the married

Living In The 1600 And 1700s

696 words - 3 pages ’ only medicine was from plants, the chances of dying or being scarred for life were high. If living the 1600s and 1700s could be described in one word, it would be tiresome. After all, diseases were as common as air, everyday was spent working or at least being productive in some way, and if there was time for a respite, it would be on the Sabbath, a day dedicated to God. Diseases were common and widespread in the colonies. Countless times

Marriage And Love In Elizabethan England

982 words - 4 pages Marriage and Love in Elizabethan England The movie, Shakespeare in Love, provides insight into the world of Elizabethan England. Through the character of Viola De Lessups the audience is shown how marriage was an institution entered into not for love, but as a strategic maneuver designed to enhance the lives of those who would benefit from a union, whether or not the beneficiaries were the people actually exchanging vows