This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Leadership Theories: Great Man Theory Essay

849 words - 4 pages

Chapter 1: Leadership theories
Leadership theories are attempts to answer some of the question people have about leadership. These theories range from simple “armchair philosophies” about the personal characteristics and effect relationship between leaders and followers and situations.
Great man theory
Thomas Carleyle, an influential Scottish historian, is given credit for the dictum: “the history of the world is but the biography of great men”. We can easily relate to Carleyle’s view since specific examples of men who seem to have changed the course of history come readily to mind de Gaulle, Hitler, Jesus Christ, Lincoln, Alexander the Great, Napoleon, Lenin, and Martin Luther King. ...view middle of the document...

Great men cannot be understood in isolation from the human and situational variables essential to leadership. Leadership results from the interaction behavior of leaders. Great man leaders owe, at least, some of their greatness to circumstances and followers.
Leadership trait theory
This theory is based on the premise that there are certain personality characteristics that are essential for a person to possess in order to be a leader. The main emphasis is on what the person is in terms of a constellation of personality traits. This theory searches for that set of universal leadership traits that will assure success. Numerous traits have been suggested: courage, integrity, loyalty, charisma, ambition, intelligence, honesty, clairvoyance, persistence, arrogance, health, political skill, confidence and vision.
The major problem with this theory is that no one has ever found a set of leadership traits that could be supported as truly universal an essential to successful leadership. Years of leadership research have not led to the conclusion that there is any consistent pattern of personality traits that characterize leaders.
Many factors have contributed to the failure to discover the leadership trait: difficulty and measuring and describing personality traits; problem in establishing cause and effect relations (due traits cause leadership or does leadership cause traits?); and disagreements on the meaning of terms, such as loyalty and courage and even leadership
However, the primary factors that accounts for the failure to establish a definite link between personality traits and leadership is the same factor that limits the value of great...

Find Another Essay On Leadership Theories: Great Man Theory

Leadership and women Essay

1145 words - 5 pages helping others to accomplish the goals of the organisation. The Great Man theory of leadership assumed that personal attributes of a great man determined the course of history (Denmark, 1993). The great man was thought to have distinctive and exceptional features and traits that distinguished him from his followers (Bass, 1990). Only very few people were thought to have such abilities, which were believed to be inherent, in other words, leaders

Leadership Is a Way to Change the Minds of Others

930 words - 4 pages theories, contingency theories, and transformational theories. The most common leadership theories include: The Great Man Theory is where theorists continue to argue whether a leader has a natural ability to lead or if they are molded into leadership through extensive training and developmental procedures. I believe that individuals can be transformed into leaders’ however; this conversion does not guarantee good effective leadership. “Leaders

Leadership in Health Care

1035 words - 4 pages right for them to lead. This style is not very popular. 5. Behavioral theories these leaders are very sure that a person cannot be born into a leadership. Leadership qualities must come with experience. This theory is the opposite from the “Great Man” Theory. 6. Participative leadership theories, these leaders like to listen to others, to their comments. These leaders inspire other people to participate with the leadership route, to make the

Comparing and Contrasting Leadership Models

2167 words - 9 pages leadership. The paper concludes with a look at transformational leadership. Although these leadership theories or models could be considered contingency models, they are addressed separately because of the emphasis that they place on morality and follower development.Trait TheoryIn the early 1900s, leadership traits were studied to determine what made certain people great leaders. The theories that were developed were called, "great man" theories


1815 words - 8 pages nowadays generally have the characteristics of the “Big Five Factors”, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, Emotional Stable and Openness. Their analysis showed that overall correlation is 0.58, there are a quite strong positive relationship between Big Five Factors and Effective leadership. As stated by the Great Man theory, in the old society, people generally believe that all leaders and their abilities are born, people cannot be able

Comparing and Contrasting Four Leadership Models and Theories

2156 words - 9 pages transformational leadership. Although these leadership theories or models could be considered contingency models, they are addressed separately because of the emphasis that they place on morality and follower development.Trait TheoryIn the early 1900s, leadership traits were studied to determine what made certain people great leaders. The theories that were developed were called, "great man" theories because they focused on identifying the innate qualities and

With reference to selected management theories and drawing on specific examples, discuss why managers need to be aware of limitations and simplifications present in some of these theories

4063 words - 16 pages , but it is said that there is no conclusive evidence that proves either way. There are three theories concern to this topic: Great man theory, Trait Theory and the Behavioral Theory.Great Man Theory: The great man theory assumes that leadership is enherented, as great leaders are born, and not made, as I have explained earlier. In this theory, leaders are usually referred to as Heroic, mythic and destined to lead. The term "Great Man" was used

Leaders, Born or Made?

3372 words - 13 pages successful leader, researchers have written eight theories on the basis of either the relationship between the leader and the follower, aswell as how leaders become leaders. The eight models/theories are:1- Great Man Theory: The great man theory is a theory that explains leadership by studying history, when it was thought that leadership is a male quality, since in the time of crisis, a man always rises to save the situation. Talking about either

Use of Transactional Theories in Management

1156 words - 5 pages to work independently was found. There are various types of leadership theories, and classified into eight major types, • Great Man Theories • Trait Theories • Contingency Theories • Situational Theories • Behavioural Theories • Participative Theories • Management Theories • Relationship Theories The theories I am going to relate with the quote are Management Theories, also called as Transactional Theories. The theories here focus

Leadership and Team Building

2187 words - 9 pages explain leadership development: trait theories, behavioral theories, and relationship theories. Trait theorists believe that leaders are born that way and leadership is part of an individuals DNA. In the 19th century, Thomas Carlyle, a historian proposed “The Great Man Theory” based on his research of many great men such as Gandhi, Lincoln, and Alexander the Great. He believed that these men were destined to become great leaders. According to

Leadership Theories

2107 words - 8 pages in an organization, trait theory targets only the man or woman in charge. Essentially, trait theory suggests that potential leaders and great leaders who have already demonstrated success are best analyzed in a vacuum. While trait theory may have fallen in an out of favor over the past century, it does have certain advantages that are especially pertinent to those in the military. Before treading any further into its occupational applicability

Similar Essays

Leadership Theories: Main Trait Theory Essay

1114 words - 5 pages , the research done on this topic is indicating that specific characteristics or traits are inherent in leaders and as cited in Murphy (2005) is can’t be develop thought educations or personal skills. The Great Main Trait Theory indicated that leaders were born and not made and the trait theory is pointing out that certain traits are necessary for a leader to succeed. The studies conducted on leadership styles, didn’t started until the 1930s, as

The "Great Man" Theory Of History

1503 words - 6 pages Two famous writers have presented us with opposite theories about the influence of leaders. Thomas Carlyle wrote most passionately: "Universal History, the history of what man has accomplished in this world, is at bottom the History of the Great Men who have worked here." Heroes teach us right and wrong, he said; heroes give us great inventions and discoveries. It is the great few who transform society; the multitude follows them. Modern

Post Paper

1588 words - 7 pages . Commensurable in certain ways to Great Man theories, trait theories, postulate that people inherit certain talents and traits enables them to be more effective and more preponderant suited to leadership. Trait theories frequently recognize specific personality or behavioral characteristics that may be shared with leaders/managers. () The trait model of leadership is predicated on the characteristics of many leaders/managers both prosperous and

A Theoretical Philosophy Of Leadership Essay

2259 words - 9 pages the nucleus of the leadership cell influencing the activities of the remainder of the cell through a variety of activities relating to action or inaction activities designed to inspire action. The core leadership theories making up Bass’ theory have inherent weaknesses, however, blending the theories together compensates and provides strength where the underlying theories are weak. An example of this is Bass’s exposure of the limitedness of