Leadership: Transactional Versus Transformational Essay

1026 words - 5 pages

Weber (1920/1947, p. 358-359) described charisma, as a personality characteristic possessed by extraordinary, god-like exemplars. Robbins and Langton (2003, p. 395) asserted that the two most popular approaches to leadership are contingency models and the study of charisma. Burns (1978, p. 4) who built upon the work of Weber categorized two types of leaders, transactional and transformational. Kuhnert and Lewis (1987, p. 650) argued that constructive/development theory can be utilized to uniquely identify the different levels of transactional leadership by ferreting out the key personality characteristics associated with each level. Transactional leaders induce their followers to carry ...view middle of the document...

If, you were in prison for 25 years and you were set free would you refuse? Well, Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela the South African freedom fighter did, he refused the terms set by the government of the day, and negotiated his own terms. Mandela faced a complex, wicked, nefarious system known a apartheid. Mandela’s view on leadership was revolutionary and captivating and is encapsulated these words: in celebratory moments, lead from the back; and in perilous times frontline leadership is your ultimate responsibility (BrainyQuote, 2014). Nelson Mandela through a vision of positive social change and non-violent resistance transformed South Africa from an isolated territory into a new era of peace and prosperity.
Juxtaposing Transactional and Transformational Leadership
According to Bennis and Nanus (1985, p. 60), positive self-regard in a transforming leader results in high expectations in followers. Kouzes and Pozner (2006, p. 288) contended that transformational leaders possessed exceptional characteristics that motivated their followers towards superior levels of performance through a shared vision. The extant literature has not provided conclusive evidence of the causal relationship between transformational leaders and transformation in followers’ organizational behaviors (Northouse, 2013, p. 203). The demands on the energy and time of transactional leaders are greater than transformational leaders because transactional leaders must continuously provide valuable exchanges to pacify their followers (Kuhnert & Lewis, 1987, p. 649).
According to Kuhnert and Lewis (1987, p. 653) stage 3 transactional leaders exhibit an essential characteristic of transformational leaders, in that they use values, beliefs and relationships to motivate followers instead of bartering. Nikezić, Purić, and Purić (2012, p. 287) deduced that transactional leadership is inflexible and difficult to change as it is trait-based. Consequently, transactional leadership is best suited to simple, deterministic problems. In contrast, transformational leadership is best suited to poorly defined, complex problems. However, a major challenge to the transformational approach is not enough time to accomplish all the necessary transitional steps in implementing a successful change (Nikezić et al., 2012, p. 289). In addition, Eisenbeiß and Boerner (2013, p. 63) found that an attendant negative side effect of transformational leadership was...

Find Another Essay On Leadership: Transactional versus Transformational

Changing Hats: Incorporating Transactional, Transformational and Complexivist Leadership Styles into 21st Century Classrooms

2970 words - 12 pages nature of our society. This needs to be reflected in the classroom. In my essay, I will argue that as teachers we need to draw from both transactional and transformational theories of leadership as they can help us understand how to effectively manage our learning environments but that we also need to begin to consider the complexity of an emerging society, promoting both creative and critical thinking. This requires us to move beyond these

Transactional Versus Servant Leadership focusing on the leadership style and the difference in leadership methods

3992 words - 16 pages charismatic leadership.The article "Transformational versus servant leadership: a difference in leader focus by (A.G.Stone; R.F.Russell; K.Patterson)" states that there are vast similarities between transformational and servant leadership but the main focus is towards the leader and his balance towards both leadership style. It is that very focus of the leader that determines the very difference in servant and transformational leadership. Also he states

Servant Leadership versus Transformational Leadership

1157 words - 5 pages Servant Leadership as it compares to Transformational Leadership Transformational and servant leadership are rooted in the study of charismatic leadership. An early conceptual model of "charismatic leadership" has been closely linked with the work of Max Weber, who described the leader as a charismatic person who exercised power through followers' identification with and belief in the leader's personality. Both transformational and servant

Characteristics of a Leader and Two Types of Leadership

1001 words - 5 pages . 2014. . 4. "Transformational Leadership Vs. Transactional Leadership Definition." Small Business. Web. 13 Mar. 2014. . 5. "Transactional Versus Transformational Leaders." Boundless. Web. 13 Mar. 2014.

Leadership Models and Communication

1117 words - 4 pages premise of this "full range" leadership model (Avolio & Bass, 1989, p. 163) is that transformational leadership is not viewed as opposite ends of a continuum. The same leader can display each of the full range of behaviors or styles (i.e. transactional, transformational and even laissez-faire). Thus, transformational leadership does not replace transactional leadership but adds to it by encouraging followers and colleagues to put in the extra

Leadership ASS1 Part 2 - Assignment

604 words - 3 pages ://smallbusiness.chron.com/transformational-leadership-important-10423.html. Retrieved 9 11, 2017, from Small Business. Solar, A. (2017, 8 7). https://getbambu.com/blog/employee-empowerment-examples/. Retrieved 9 12, 2017, from BAMBU. Spahr, P. (2015, 9 16). Retrieved 9 10, 2017 Spahr, P. (2015, 9 16). sT. Retrieved 9 10, 2017, from http://online.stu.edu/transactional-leadership/.

The Study of Leadership and the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire

1817 words - 7 pages approach was only after the work of the political sociologist James McGregor. In his book Leadership(1978), he attempted to link the roles of leadership and followership. He also distinguished leadership into transformational leadership and transactional leadership. According to Burns(1978), transactional leaders are those who work on the exchange principle and transforming leaders are those who engage with the followers and raise their motivation and

Leadership and complex adaptive systems

1710 words - 7 pages Although current leadership theory emphasizes the distinction between transactional and transformational leadership, in fact, most leaders have a mixed profile of the full range of leadership styles. The best form of leadership is not only transformational or only transactional, but rather a combination of the two. However, in order to better understand each style's pros and cons, they have to be discussed in terms of similarities and

How important of leadership in business - RMIT - Short essay

813 words - 4 pages leadership, transactional leadership and servant leadership. Transformational leadership aims to build a connection between leaders and followers, in which the both parties “help each other to advance to a higher level of morale and motivation” (Burn, 1978, p.9). Transformational leadership can become especially useful in organization where still runs outdated structure and requires urgent change as it helps people to get more motivated and redefine

The Immersion of Transformational Leadership

3730 words - 15 pages leadership theory, to which he called transactional leadership, to one of a more influential and dynamic form of leadership known as transformational leadership (Johnson, 2012, p. 190). Burns suggested that the transactional leader provided only the most basic of needs, such as food, shelter, and acceptance. This was achieved through the exchange of monetary funds and benefits through which the followers could achieve such needs. Acceptance was

Transformational leadership for change

703 words - 3 pages Transformational leadership is an important contemporary theory of leadership. Its one leadership style consistent with successful organizational change management.Burns argued that all leadership behavior is either transactional or transformational. Transactional behaviors are "largely oriented toward accomplishing the tasks at hand and at maintaining good relations with those working with the leader [exchanging promises of rewards for

Similar Essays

Transformational Versus Transactional Leadership Essay

740 words - 3 pages the satisfaction of consumers (Aarons, 2006, p. 1163). It is evident that there is a difference between transformational and transactional leadership. The two forms of leaderships are seen to have a diverse relation to cultural and organizational boundaries studied in a number of research cases (Aarons, 2006, p. 1163). There are cases where leaders use both forms of leadership to enhance the output of their commitment to the organizations. This

Transformational & Transactional Leadership Essay

925 words - 4 pages Introduction Over the past twenty years, an abundant body of researches have been done to review transformational leadership and transactional leadership. Burn (1978) was the first person to introduce and conceptualize the concept of transformational leadership and transactional leadership. Bass (1985) based on Burn’s concept and deepen his notion with modifications, which stated that one of the best frameworks of leadership is

Transformational Vs. Transactional Leadership Essay

1947 words - 8 pages Introduction Over the past twenty years, an abundant body of researches have been done to review transformational leadership and transactional leadership. Burn (1978) was the first person to introduce and conceptualize the concept of transformational leadership and transactional leadership. Bass (1985) based on Burn’s concept and deepened his notion with modifications, which stated that one of the best frameworks of leadership is

Transactional Vs. Transformational Leadership Essay

3160 words - 13 pages Article Summary http://johnsardelli.wordpress.com/2013/05/07/howard-shultz-starbucks-and-maslow/ In the above article it discusses the transformational leadership style of Howard Schultz and it’s a effectiveness, we also see a comparison between transactional leadership and transformational leadership. Howard Schultz’s leadership style forces him to be more of a motivation towards his employee’s and also makes him take up a more proactive