Leadership Vs Management Essay

1679 words - 7 pages

Numerous Job vacancies begin by seeking the services of a Manager and then follow it up with the statement that the manager must have leadership skills. By implication, one can assume that leadership is second in command to management; and yet in the present turbulent environment, leadership is much more needed as it is the only thing that can make firms achieve competitive advantage. The most logical thing for organizations is to develop a job placement with a title-leader- thereby clearly stating that a firm is seeking a leader than that of a manager. This paper presents a review and critical evaluation of a key leadership and management issue facing organisations today. First of all, the paper will focus on a review of a key management issue, secondly, it will review a key leadership issue; and, finally, it will present a critical evaluation of both management and leadership.

Emphasis on Structure, Order and Consistency-A key issue of Management
The history of management is about the creation of structure; order and consistency as per the classical management approach. It should be noted that the classical view approach to managing an organisation ended up developing managers than leaders. Burnes (2000 pp.33) support this claim through his statement that classical approach is characterised by the proposition that organisations are rational entities, they are designed based on scientific principles, and that people are economic being and are only motivated by money. As a result, jobs are designed to maximise management control and minimise individual’s skill and discretion. Large Corporation, for example, a financial institution is a good case in point. Operations of a commercial bank is often hierarchically structured, calls for order and consistency. Procedures, moreover, regulate employee behaviour in order to achieve order. Therefore, managers spend all their time ensuring that routine but rigid operations are implemented. The aim is to maintain the status quo.

Management issues have its roots in classical approaches to management. This implies that shortfalls such as risk averse, rigidity, and short term focus can be directly linked to the classical roots. Of course, classical theorist may not entirely be blamed for creating a management based system which emphasises on order, predictability and consistency. Although its relevance today may be question, the theorist developed models to suit their operating environment. That is, the early 1900. For instance Henry Fayol’s 14 principles of management were developed to provide sanity in the troubled France coupled with industrial unrest among the railway worker, miners and civil servants. This was complimented by Fredrick Taylor’s in the United States America with his principles of scientific management, and Max Weber’s bureaucratic ideologies. At the end, classical led to the proposition that efficiency was achieved from the organisation level (Henry Fayol) and...

Find Another Essay On Leadership vs Management

Leadership vs Management Essay

938 words - 4 pages Management and leadership are two terms that should be used together, but often times are not. Management can be defined as "Organization, supervision, or direction; the application of skill or care in the manipulation, use, treatment, or control (of a thing or person), or in the conduct of something." (Oxford English Dictionary, UOP library). Alternately, leadership is defined as "the action or influence necessary for the direction or

Management vs Leadership Essay

1082 words - 4 pages Now more than ever, with today's challenging business world, the workplace demands faster results and fewer people. In order to stay competitive, organizations need to be able to rapidly translate new information into knowledge. Leadership and management are two ideas that are often used interchangeably, but there is a vast difference between a manager and a leader. However, these two words actually depict two different concepts in the workplace

Management vs. leadership

750 words - 3 pages Management and leadership are two of the most important positions to have for anyone in an organization. Both of these positions come with a great deal of responsibilities; however, they both serve two different purposes and responsibilities in an organization, along with a different sent of guidelines.LeadershipLeadership is a wonderful quality for anyone to have because not everyone possesses leadership qualities and skills; however, a person


3538 words - 14 pages Management Update, November Vol. 4(11). Kotler, P. (1999). The Marketing of Leadership, Leader to Leader, Winter (11), 22-27. Manz, C. (1990). How To Become a SuperLeader, Executive Excellence, June. Nibley, H. (1985). Management vs. Leadership, Executive Excellence, December. Senge, P. (1998). Rethinking Leadership, Executive Excellence, May. Straus, D. (1990). Facilitative Leadership, Executive Excellence, April. Treece, J. B. (2000). 2000 Industry


3579 words - 14 pages Full Range Leadership Model Vs. Models of Organizational Behavior: Cross comparison of military leadership models and civilian models of Organizational BehaviorXXXXXXX1MGT 6671Executive SummaryIn light of recent force management measures implemented by the Department of Defense, military personnel are being forced into an unfamiliar battleground, the civilian world. Military members have been accustomed to a specific lifestyle. Members endure


1977 words - 8 pages consistency. The way leaders and managers are developed are different, they have different experiences and approaches. Also, managers have "hard skill of management" and the leaders seem to have "soft stuff". (Leadership vs. Management; www.pslnet.org)Suggestions for an Effective and Efficient Team ProcessAn effective and efficient team process starts with a common purpose. The common purpose is broader than specific goals. Effective and efficient teams

Leadership - 1361 words

1361 words - 5 pages 28, 2006, from Max's Project Management Wisdom Web site: http://www.maxwideman.com/papers/leader/leadermanager.htmFarr, Dr. J.N Leadership vs. management: Do you know the difference?. Retrieved June 28, 2006, from Business leader online Web site: http://www.businessleader.com/bl/sep97/leadrshp.html

Leadership - 7460 words

7460 words - 30 pages . Envision to command, dominate, and rule personally. Ultimate authority and extended downwardPracticed Totalitarianism, absolute power rested on himselfCommunistDistrust followers but followers willingly obey his demandsHitler was, first and foremost, determined to command personally. He is hundred percent opposite of Gandhi. In other words, we can describe their leadership styles as the good vs. evil.According to his so-called Leader principle

Leadership and Management

696 words - 3 pages behaviors and characteristics like: confidence; service mentality; good coaching skills; reliability; expertise; responsibility; good listening skills; being visionary; realistic; good sense of priorities; honesty; willingness to share; strong self-esteem; technical or contextual, and recognition (Bennis and Nanus, 1997). Management vs. Leadership Leadership and management overlap, but they are not the same (Kotterman, 2006). Both leadership and

Management and Leadership

778 words - 3 pages Rules Breaks RulesConflict Avoids Conflict Uses ConflictDirection Existing Roads New RoadsBlame Blames Others Takes BlameReferences:Kotelnikov, V. Leadership versus Management. Retrieved on June 12, 2005 from http://www.1000ventures.com/business_guide/crosscuttings/leadership_vs_mgmt.htmlPascale, R. 'Managing on the Edge', Penguin Book, pg 65, 1990Anderson, D. Managers vs. Leaders. Retrieved on June 12, 2005 from http://www.bss-gn.com/nl/aug2000/art003.htm

Leadership and Management

2493 words - 10 pages . Because there are instances where management will have to utilize a combination of leadership styles are necessary to reach a common objective and goal. Leadership style is the manner and approach of providing direction, implementing plans, and motivating people. All the different styles--authoritarian or autocratic; participative or democratic; and delegative or free reign have the applicability. Like for instance, using an authoritarian style on

Similar Essays

Leadership Vs. Management Essay

976 words - 4 pages Leadership vs. Management Much has been written about the difference between management and leadership. In the past, competent management staffs ran effective companies. In light of our ever-changing world, however, most companies have come to realize that it is much more important to lead than to manage. In today's world the old ways of management no longer work. One reason is that the degree of environmental and competitive change we are

Management Vs Leadership Essay

841 words - 3 pages skills to accomplish the mission. But leadership and management work hand in hand with each other. The management sets the stage and the leadership makes it happen. Leadership is a human relationship process. Leadership is based on human factors and no two humans are the same. Managers are not only interested in status quo, but also production, expansion and growth. To be a good manager one must look at views from different perspectives. As

Management Vs. Leadership Essay

1119 words - 4 pages IntroductionManagement is not leadership just as leadership is not management. In order to differentiate between the two we must ask ourselves which we relate to more, or rather, which we consider ourselves to be by asking the question which am I? Am I a Manager or can I consider myself a Leader? What type of person makes a good manager? What type of personality is best for leaders?ManagementManagement is defined as "The people who administer a

Leadership Vs. Management Essay

1034 words - 5 pages Our current era of business development has created a somewhat gray area when it comes to our understanding of the words leadership and management. That is because most business leaders tend to now wear two hads in the business arena that allow to both lead and manage the various functions of their business undertaking. Historically however, leadership and management have always been two seperate entities as two business positions held by