This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Le Bron James And Michael Jordan Essay

2119 words - 8 pages

Comparing LeBron James and Michael Jordan is like comparing apples and oranges. It just isn’t a fair comparison. There are too many differences. There are too many variables. There are too many fallacies that are involved to make a fair assessment to determine who the greatest basketball player of all time is. Unfortunately the comparison is being made seemingly every day, and the article by Mr. Mathis is full of fallacious material. His extreme uses of exaggeration and card stacking, along with many harsh examples of hasty generalizations, makes a claim that Michael Jordan is and always will be the greatest player to play basketball. An opinion is simply and opinion and anyone is entitled to their opinion, but using fallacies to formulate his response to the issue makes it too finite and too biased in favor of Michael Jordan.
There are so many clear and dramatic exaggerations throughout the article. Michael Jordan is described as being “the most unstoppable assassin of all-time, the smartest marketer of all-time” and then sarcastically mentioned as “the savviest shoe salesman of all-time” (Mathis, par. 2). He then goes on to describe how Michael “floated through the air and levitated to the rim” as the city of Chicago “lauded the former Bulls megastar as a messiah” (pars. 3-4). How much more exaggeration could a person use to describe Michael Jordan? I didn’t realize people could levitate and float. And when did Jordan become a “messiah?” He isn’t a God that can do impossible things like it is implied he could do by being called “messiah.” The things he did were impressive to watch, but LeBron has undeniable impressive moments as well. The point is that Michael Jordan was a terrific player, but exaggeration isn’t necessary to make that claim. He also fails to mention how dominant LeBron is on the court with his vicious slam dunks and amazing blocks that demonstrate his athletic ability as well. It also mentions how Jordan “wore down bodies, beat his opponents” and “broke ankles” on the court (Mathis, par. 28). It is just another example of exaggeration; another failure to mention LeBron’s performances on the court that have proven to be impressive as well. The exaggerations mentioned also give evidence to card stacking to add to the fallacies throughout the article.
Anne McClintock defines Card Stacking being when “one side may suppress or distort evidence, tell half-truths, oversimplify the facts, or set up a ‘straw man’” (308). There have already been some examples of card stacking by only mentioning Michael Jordan dunking and changing the franchise of the Chicago Bulls. Even with the example of Jordan being called a “messiah,” it fails to mention LeBron having the nickname “King James.” That is a nice parallel that could have been mentioned, but instead it is one sided and points towards the greatness of Michael Jordan. It even mentions how Jordan “won titles with a less talented supporting cast” while James won with “two NBA stars who...

Find Another Essay On LeBron James and Michael Jordan

Michael Jordan and Len Bias: Rulers of The Game

1038 words - 4 pages Michael Jordan, believed to be the best basketball player of all time, was drafted in 1984 by the Chicago Bulls. He was picked third overall in the 1984 National Basketball Association draft. He was a standout at the University of North Carolina, and a two time Atlantic Coast Conference player of the year (Boars 33).Two years later a sophomore from the University of Maryland, Leonard Kevin Bias, was drafted second overall by the Boston Celtics

My essay talks about the comparsion and contrast of michael jordan and larry bird

616 words - 2 pages Name Keron Munroe Title - Michael Jordan and Larry Bird The National Basketball Association league has been in existence for almost half a century. This league produces a large number of basketball stars and fans every year. Throughout their respective careers, basketball fans have compared the achievement, athletic style and popularity of two of the most recognizable basketball players careers of the 80's and the 90's: Michael Jordan and

The Legendary Lebron James

2096 words - 9 pages The chosen one, the hometown hero, the traitor, the king, the greatest of all time, or also known as Lebron James has been through what most kids can’t even imagine. Lebron grew up without a father and moved from house to house, but now he is one of the most successful men in the world. On April 4, 2014 Lebron is the youngest player ever to reach 23,000 career points in the National Basketball Association (NBA), beating Michael, Kareem, and

The Great LeBron

952 words - 4 pages back to back; the same thing he has done with the Miami Heat. The end of his junior year, LeBron was such a unique player he thought about going pro. “Sportswriters were comparing him to such legendary basketball stars as Michael Jordan.” He decided to finish his senior year and led the team to a third title and a top ranking. In all he scored two thousand six hundred fifty-seven points during his career at St Vincent- St Mary high. Next LeBron

MJ, LeBron, Kobe: You Decide

1880 words - 8 pages skipped the collegiate level to head straight to the NBA for true superstardom. The young phenom’s name was LeBron James. Drafted 1st overall by the Cleveland Cavaliers, LeBron was probably the most anticipated rookie to ever come into the NBA. As his career has gone on to this day he’s established himself as one of the greatest to ever play along with the legends including Jordan and Kobe (soon to be legend). Michael Jordan, although an all-around

“His Airness”

1012 words - 5 pages Throughout all the years I have been involved with sports, I’ve learned Michael Jordan is one of the most prolific athletes of his time. We define success as achieving wealth, respect, or fame, and Jordan has accomplished more than most men will even attempt in their lifetime. Some try and compare today’s superstar athletes such as LeBron James, and Kobe Bryant with the great Michael Jordan, but I am here to tell you that is impossible. Jordan

Is it Necessary to Imitate others?

955 words - 4 pages order to become successful, original, and creative. Athletes are an everyday example of imitation. Take Miami Heat’s superstar small forward LeBron James as an example. While growing up, LeBron was aspired to one day perform at the level Michael Jordan was at. Michael Jordan was, and still is, considered the greatest basketball player of all time. LeBron James and Michael Jordan are now usually argued about in sports conversations over who is the

Sports: LeBron James

1229 words - 5 pages was already on the path to greatness. Lebron was named the Rookie of the Year, finishing with averages of 20.9 points, 5.5 rebounds, and 5.9 assists per game. James became the first Cavalier to receive the honor, as well as joining Michael Jordan and Oscar Robertson as the only players in NBA history to average at least 20 points, 5 rebounds, and 5 assists per game in their rookie year. James recorded his first career triple-double on

The NBA now and then

831 words - 4 pages think that for those who love the game, you can appreciate what both eras bring to the table. While it may have been entertaining to see Dr Jay and Michael Jordan in action, it’s also important to realize the potential in today’s rising stars such as LeBron James, and KD. One thing that remains unchanged is that basketball has, and will always be an outstanding and fun sport to watch. Works Cited

Artifact Speech Kyle Katz

1021 words - 5 pages The number 23 has been worn by many great players. The two great players who have worn this number are Don Mattingly and Lebron James, but when you think of the number 23 you don’t think about them. You think about the great, the champion, and the best player to ever play basketball. This guy’s name is Michael Jordan. Michael Jordan has inspired many others to achieve their goals too. Jordan was born on February 17, 1963 in Brooklyn, New York

Kevin Durant Vs LeBron James

848 words - 4 pages Kevin Durant was right up in LeBron James’ face, guarding him the best he could. Ten seconds left now as LeBron starts to drive. Kevin stays right on him and forces an off balance shot and snacthed the rebound. Five seconds left as Durant pounds the ball up the court with LeBron hot on his tail. Three seconds left now as Durant starts to pull up for a mid-range jumper. One second left and Kevin Durant is at the highest point of his jump. He

Similar Essays

Michael Jordan Vs. Lebron James Essay

1494 words - 6 pages During the time of Michael Jordan and the now present Lebron James American culture has changed a lot. Both of these two superstars show how American society love and appreciate their superstars. The society loves them both, they are both amazingly talented and have supporting fans that will always be by their side no matter what happens, through the peaks and valleys. These two allstars are beyond incredible and show their talent in a

The Dreams Of Lebron James And Martin Luther King

913 words - 4 pages Lebron James grew up wanting to be a football player while he was in college he had a dream to be NFL star. This dream slowly faded when later on in college he found a new interest and love for basketball. He practiced everyday without fail. Wherever he got the chance he would be outside shooting hoops and practicing drills. It was at this time that a new dream arose. That dream was to be the best basketball player, and that dream came true. To

Michael Jordan And His Legacy In The Nba

1211 words - 5 pages Michael Jordan is not only a name; he is a legend and an inspiration. If you ask people in the developed world who this man is, it is likely they will know. Most are aware of Jordan's greatness and skill, and may believe he was born great, but he was not. Only through hard work, triumph, and adversity did this man made himself what he is today, a basketball legend.Mike's parents, James and Deloris Jordan, grew up in Wallace, North Carolina, and

Describes Marketing Scheme Of Nike And Michael Jordan

2483 words - 10 pages the serious athlete. Fortunately for Nike, in 1985 their star was brought to light. A rookie basketball player with amazing talent and a nice smile fell into their lap, his name is Michael Jordan. (story/chrono, 2)Michael JordanAs soon as Nike signed Michael Jordan they began to market a new line of shoes and apparel with the name AIR JORDAN. This was the beginning of the JORDAN Brand and Jordan's Jumpman23 products. Featured prominently on each