Legal Accounting Essay

1846 words - 8 pages

This memorandum analyzes Dell, Inc.’s (“Dell”) alleged securities and accounting violations from fiscal years 2002-2006. During this time period, Dell failed to disclose exclusivity payments it obtained from Intel – a dominant manufacturer of CPUs for personal computers. These payments “amounted to “$61 million in the first quarter of 2003 (about 10% of operating income) and $720 million in the first quarter of 2007 (about 76% of operating income).” This memorandum will show that Dell’s failure to disclose Intel’s exclusivity payments was a violation of basic accounting principles. Additionally, it will address and disprove any potential defenses Dell may advance for its failure to disclose the Intel payments. Lastly, the memo will discuss the real motivation for Dell’s actions both while receiving the payments, and for coming forward when it did and will specifically discuss whether the $100 million settlement was excessive, a slap on the wrist, or just right.

I. Was Dell’s Actions Wrong?

Dell’s failure to disclose the exclusivity payments they were receiving from Intel was wrong and should be subject to punishment. The purpose of financial statement is to provide accurate information on a business’ revenues and expenses so that “shareholders, creditors, and anyone else who deals with the business,” can evaluate the company’s financial condition and performance. Furthermore, “the objective of accounting is to present relevant and reliable financial statements that are meaningful to users by providing a consistent basis for comparing the performance of an entity over time…” As the SEC press release explains, “accuracy and completeness are the touchstones of public company disclosures…” Taking into account the above statements, it becomes clear that Dell’s failure to disclose the exclusivity payments was contrary to these basic principles of accounting. Dell’s failures to disclose portrayed an inaccurate picture of Dell’s business and mislead investors. In fact, without the exclusivity payments Dell would have missed all EPS forecasts from 2002-2006. To make matters worse, during this time frame, Dell attributed their success to the superiority of their product, marketing strategy, operating efficiencies, and customer value proposition. This is problematic because not only did Dell fail to disclose, but they mislead investors by attributing their success and ability to meet Wall Street expectations to factors other than the exclusivity payments despite knowing that the only reason they were able to meet these expectations was because of the Intel payments.

With that being said, it can be argued that Dell’s actions were problematic not because of the payments themselves, but because Dell failed to disclose the payments in any of its financial statements. There is certainly nothing wrong with Dell vigorously negotiating for rebates to reduce its Cost of Goods Sold (“COGS”). This is especially so in this case because Dell was willing to use...

Find Another Essay On Legal Accounting

Legal Issues in Accounting-- duty of good faith

3144 words - 13 pages reference to honest men adds little.' --Johan SteynEnglish law generally involves 'adopting an external standard given life by using the concept of the reasonable man' . The commercial advantage of this approach as Johan Steyn seen is that it 'promotes certainty and predictability in the resolution of contractual disputes' . My paper is going to cite the case 'Waltons v Maher'(1988) to examine how this approach is actually in accordance with the legal

Principles and Assumptions Used in Preparing Accounting Statements

1660 words - 7 pages ] What assumptions used in accounting is generally predict solutions through experimentation of phenomena to upgrade them to the level of reality through the use of a combination of induction and deduction, and when the results to an acceptable degree of accuracy, it can be considered the evidentiary obligation accepted and valid, and perhaps the most important accounting hypotheses are: I. The imposition of a legal person: This

Managerial and Finanical Accounting Report

605 words - 2 pages There are two broad categories in accounting, financial accounting and managerial accounting. They differ in the type of user of the information presented. Financial accounting is concerned with preparing financial statements for external decision makers, such as stockholders and creditors. Managerial accounting presents information for internal decision making my managers.Financial accounting involves record keeping. A major objective is the

History Of Accounting

1195 words - 5 pages naturally thought that since income tax returns were legal documents, they would have exclusive rights to prepare them. Accountants replied that since that the bulk of the work in preparing a return involved accounting calculations, they were more properly accounting work. The substance of the tasks trumped legal argumentation. US law firms in the 1920¡¯s were slow to incorporate income tax preparations into their business skills. Public

The History and Role of Accounting in Business

1516 words - 6 pages Accounting can be defined in a number of ways, but I chose the book definition, which is; Accounting is an information system that provides reports to stakeholders about the economic activities and condition of business. The person in charge of accounting is called the accountant. The accountant is typically required to follow a set of rules and regulations. These rules and regulations are called the General Accepted Accounting Principles

Accounting Cycle

1139 words - 5 pages analysts, and editors, who are all directly reporting to the vice president. Other departments providing support include marketing, human resources, legal, information technology, accounting and audit. The marketing people are the ones who have direct contact with the subject. They collect and forward the primary documents and other requirements to the operations department through the report coordinators. The report coordinators will then input


842 words - 3 pages omission of goodwill amortisation consolidation - where companies have adopted merger accounting rather than acquisition accounting, even though by law should've been acquisition acounting government grantsProblems with TFV - open to interpretations, changes over time. It is subjective and vague.the true and fair view - recognition of economic substance rather than mere legal form - ruttermans Alexander - TFV is all

Financial and Managerial Accounting: What's The Difference?

2912 words - 12 pages Management accounting reports often are concerned with future events. Budgets and reports supporting decisions include forecasts and estimates of future costs and revenues, for example. Control and evaluation compare estimates made in the past with the actual outcomes of decisions and operations. Financial accounting reports are primarily historical in nature. In fact, there are legal disincentives for including predictions in annual reports. In

Accounting and Ethical Obligations

1553 words - 6 pages responsible for appointing seven full-time members to a FASB (Schneider et al). Found in 1973, the FASB has the primary responsibility for developing and issuing rules on accounting practice. This independent body issues Statements of Financial Accounting Standards (Marshall et al, 2004).Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is a US. Government agency that has the legal power to set and enforce accounting practices for entities whose securities are

Adapting International Accounting Standards

1430 words - 6 pages to the need for every country to have a system for regulating their financial reporting. Accounting regulations and standards are subsequently dependent on the legal system used within the country. Indeed, the author states that in some countries, accounting rules emerge from taxation law; they are known as code law countries. Accounting standards are thus embodied within the laws relating to trading entities. The government normally directs

Comparisons of usa, uk, and china accounting systems.

3599 words - 14 pages statements in China.Company Law and StandardsThe UK have developed and issued only a few number of accounting standards. The standards that have been introduced evolve around the set of forth-broad principles. The main current legal instrument used in the U.K to govern the accounting practices of limited liability companies is the Companies Act 1985 amended in 1989, introducing provision of the EC 7th directive. Reporting requirements in the U.K are

Similar Essays

Accounting: Ethics And Legal Obligation Essay

1097 words - 4 pages Accounting is used by management to record company activities, that is why it is referred to as the language of business. Accounting serves as an important tool for business executive and even inventor. Accounting is used to communicate economical information about an organization. It is used to identify measures and communicate activities within an entity so that investors, management and organizations can use this information to make informed

Ethical And Legal Obligations In Accounting

2104 words - 8 pages accounting principles as issued by the Federal Accounting Standards Board (FASB). The provider will also ensure that the company, if publicly traded, complies with requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the regulations of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCOAB). This paper briefly explains the principles of financial accounting and how the deviation from ethical and legal obligations led to greater government

Ethical And Legal Obligations In Accounting

982 words - 4 pages integrity of the securities markets (SEC, 2005). The SEC required public companies to disclose meaningful financial and other information to the public. This gives the public the knowledge to make informed financial decisions. The SEC takes legal action against companies and individuals who break securities laws. This includes insider trading, accounting fraud, and others.The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) is a private sector, non

The Ethical And Legal Obligations Of Accounting Reporting.

1089 words - 4 pages also adhere to the standers and legal obligations set forth by governmental and state agencies.The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) is an independent, private, non-Governmental authority that will be utilized to support the establishment of accounting principles in the United States. The mission of the Financial Accounting Standards Board is to establish and improve standards of financial accounting and reporting for the guidance and