Legal And Ethical Analysis Of Ford Pinto

3714 words - 15 pages

FactsOn Tuesday August 9, 1977, Herbert L Misch, vice president of environmental and safety engineering at Ford Motor Company (Ford), read an unfavorable article entitled "Pinto Madness" published by Mother Jones magazine (1). This self-styled radical magazine had cited ford "secret documents' which, according to the author, proved the company had known for eight years that the Pinto was a "firetrap" (2).The article claimed that preproduction rear-end crash tests had revealed the dangerous nature of the design and placement of the car's fuel tank (3). The magazine article claimed that Ford was so anxious to get the car on the market that it decided design changes would not be made and would "take too much time and cost too much money" (4). The article further charge that Ford had used "some blatant lies" to delay enactment of a government safety standard that would have forced Ford to change the Pinto's "fire-prone" gas tank (5). The article concluded: "by conservative estimates, Pinto crashes have caused 500 burn deaths to people who would not have been seriously injured if the car had not burst into flames" (6).Nothing in Ford's records supported the contentions made in the article. Nevertheless, Misch knew that the overall effect of this Mother Jones' article, one that relied heavily on the testimony of a former Ford engineer, could be highly damaging to the company (7). It would also sharpen consumer criticism of the US auto industry in general and Ford in particular. Misch and his associates at Ford were angered by the allegations and are ready to denounce the article as "unfair and distorted" (8).The development of a large consumer movement, along with the enactment of the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966, had revolutionized the auto business in the US (9). According to the auto executives, the auto industry now had to answer to many more people than just auto buyers and the multitude of often conflicting regulations had placed unreasonable burdens on domestic automakers (10).Ford has had a checkered past with the government. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), a regulatory agency in the Department of Transpiration, had investigated Pinto's engine fires and fuel-line hose construction problems, which eventually led to a recall by Ford (11).In 1973 Ford was fined $7 million by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), a regulatory agency reporting directly to the US president, for unauthorized tempering of an emission test. In another incident, some Pintos were recalled due to a flaw in the car's air pollution control equipment (12).Finally, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), a regulatory agency reporting directly to the US Congress, had charged that the gas mileage claims made by Ford's Lincoln-Mercury division were inaccurate and exaggerated (13).Since Pinto was put into production in 1970, the subcompact had become one of the company's best selling cars and had allowed Ford to fight off some...

Find Another Essay On Legal and Ethical Analysis of Ford Pinto

The Legal and Ethical Environment of Business

601 words - 2 pages A recent situation has taken place where Americans of Middle Eastern decent have been targeted simply due to their national origin. Although security measures were tightened the situation has deteriorated. Threats have increased, employees have failed to report to work and customers have threatened to boycott our products. These circumstances are layered with legal and ethical issues that DWI must address. The case of Katzenbach v. McClung, 379

Ethical And Legal Obligations of Financial Reporting

1214 words - 5 pages The FASB, SEC, and PCAOB Ethical financial reporting is critical to ensure consumer confidence within an economy. Accounting entries record cash transactions in the form of financial reports. Financial reporting is used to interpret and analyze business activities for the purpose of investing and efficient management. Misrepresentations, whether intentional or accidental, can send the wrong signal to interested parties resulting in wrong

Legal and Ethical Analysis of Ashland Oil Inc. : Trouble At Floreffe

2698 words - 11 pages covers “new” construction only for Welded Steel Tanks for Oil Storage. API 653 covers the “reconstruction, repairs, and modification” of existing tanks (Reliability).Legal Issue 3Prior to AOI’s tank 1338 failure, API standard 653 did not cover the so called brittle fracture analysis (Reliability).Legal Issue 4Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 1973 issued the Oil Pollution Prevention Regulation (OPPR) to address the

Affirmative Action and College Admissions: A Legal and Ethical Analysis

3755 words - 15 pages Affirmative Action and College Admissions: A Legal and Ethical Analysis I. Introduction The institution of public education has been one of the most controversial establishments in the United States since its inception. More specifically, equality in the conditions and the opportunities it provides has been sought as one of its major goals. There is little doubt that minority ethnic groups have struggled to achieve educational equality

Ethical And Legal Obligations

1694 words - 7 pages Ethical and Legal Obligations Ethical and legal obligations apply to all members of society. As one in society, the obligation to act in an ethical, law abiding manner on a daily basis is vital to the integrity of daily life. Many professions have their own code of ethics. Financial reporting is not exempt from such ethical and legal standards. One’s lively hood depends on decisions made in the business world. Business transactions are

Ethical and Legal Preparations

583 words - 2 pages gain entry in order for it to be considered a burglary. Investigations must be ethical. An investigator must be professional and compliant when investigating these crimes. Ethical and Legal Preparations Ethics is a big part of investigating homicides and burglaries. Homicide is a horrible crime and should be treated as such. If an investigator is investigating a homicide that was committed by a homosexual lover

Legal and Ethical Responsibilities.

1426 words - 6 pages Legal and Ethical Responsibilities. Direct Discrimination :- something like putting in the job advertisement “women need not apply”. Indirect Discrimination :- saying there’s a height limit such as a 6’4”. This will limit who can apply for the job. Sex Discrimination Act 1975 The Sex Discrimination Act 1975 makes sex discrimination unlawful in employment, vocational training, education, the provision and sale of goods, facilities

Ethical and legal analysis of the Ann Hopkins v. Price Waterhouse discrimination law suit. Focuses on case law and ethics.

3145 words - 13 pages herself within a new firm at a partnership level (4 years pay)."ETHICAL ANALYSIS MODEL"1. IDENTIFICATION OF THE "CRITICAL OR RELEVANT FACTS" FROM THE CASE.See relevant facts from the case under step one of the legal analysis.2. WHAT ARE THE KEY "ISSUES"?The key ethical issues that I will address are as follows: Is it appropriate for a partnership to discriminate on the basis of sex regardless of legal issues; do they not have a duty to make

Legal, Ethical, and Regulatory Paper

1193 words - 5 pages IntroductionBusiness-to-consumer (B2C) and business-to-business (B2B) websites face legal, ethical, and regulatory concerns just as traditional brick-and-mortar establishments do. Although both B2C and B2B sites share similarities in web-based general ethical considerations and jurisdictional issues, each site has its own specific concerns due to the end-user relationship of the business versus consumer. Whether the end-user is a consumer or

International Legal and Ethical Issues.

769 words - 3 pages Upon completion of the University of Phoenix simulation "Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues," we as a team have outlined below several concerns that must be addressed prior to entering into any legally binding business contracts with international organizations.Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues.Prior to entering into international contractual business agreements it is important to take into consideration the rules

Ethical, Legal, and Regulatory Issues

1059 words - 4 pages Like the traditional brick and mortar companies, business to business (B2B) and business to consumers (B2C) models face ethical, legal, and regulatory concerns. According to Schneider (2004), "businesses that operate on the Web must comply with the same laws and regulations that govern the operation of all businesses. If they do not, they face the same set of penalties - fines, reparation payments, court-imposed dissolution, and even jail time

Similar Essays

Legal And Ethical Anlaysis Of The Ford Pinto

1234 words - 5 pages “Legal and Ethical Analysis of the Ford Pinto” For mankind communication has been a very important issue and with that transportation has also rose to prominence. Not so long ago we were aided by a new invention due to the innovation of a few workaholics and the automobile industry. Along with the Japanese rivals Ford is one of leading companies in the world and run by a family, which controls the major shares in the company. But the company’s

The Ford Pinto Case: Legal And Unethical

641 words - 3 pages . Taking an ethical approach to the Ford Pinto case makes it hard to accept the risk/benefit analysis used by the Ford Motor Company. In making what seems to be the correct decision based on numbers, Ford adopted a policy for allowing a certain number of people to die or be injured even though it could have been prevented. From a human rights perspective, this is a blatant disregard for human life. Ford legally chose not to make the design changes that

Disasters Of Ford Pinto Essay

2173 words - 9 pages therefore the changes for good business did not warrant the expense. At this time Ford held the patent on a safer gas tank, but they chose to use the faulty one since the production lines were already assembled. Ford understood the problems with the Pinto but they chose not to inform the public as to the safety hazards, and not to recall the vehicle at this time.The ethical issues which surround this case are breach of trust with the public. Ford has

The Ford Pinto: An Inexpensive And Compact Vehicle

1397 words - 6 pages safe and reliable product. Lastly, Ford neglected to inform the public about the flaw that its engineers had found. This brings about the idea that customers should be privy to all of the information regarding a product, especially when their well-being is at stake. Ethical Analysis The fact that Ford carried on with manufacturing of the Pinto despite its major flaw is considered to be unethical by many as a result of the cost-benefit analysis