Legal Case Study: 62 Year Old Woman With Skin Cancer

1424 words - 6 pages

Legal Case Study
Following the review of a medical error about a 62-year-old woman with skin cancer who experienced wrong-site surgery I will summarize the legal and liability aspects of this case, as well as explore the legal and ethical implications of disclosing errors. In addition, I will discuss the pros and cons of having the provider disclose and empathize for the error to the patient. Finally, I will identify ways the nurse leaders can learn from this situation, help prevent similar kinds of medical errors from happening, and assist the providers and organization to effectively disclose information to patients after such an error occurs.
Legal Aspects
The closest definition to medical error would be from the institute of medicine by stating “failure of a planned action to be completed as intended…” (Thomas, 2009, p. 671). In this case the error appears to be a system problem and not just one person (in this case the surgeon). A medical error did occur: wrong sited surgery. Bottom line the standard of care was not met. When referring to the legal ramifications about this case form the patient’s perspective, we would be speaking about the repercussions of the wrong sited surgery. These issues would be the time delay for corrective surgery (this procedure was for removal of cancerous tissue), pain the patient suffered (for undergoing two separate procedures), and wrongful disfigurement to the patient’s face as she has the potential to have an additional scar at the wrong sited surgery.
In order to encourage physicians to fully disclose to a patient after an adverse event, there are 35 states that have enacted laws that make expression of sympathy following an error inadmissible in court to prove liability. This is referred to as the “I’m sorry” Law. In the past decade, five of these states have gone a step beyond, by adding a mandatory notification requirement on hospitals to adopt policies of full disclosure (Bender, 2007). In addition to law it is the ethical responsibility of all healthcare providers to disclose information to the patient about adverse or potential adverse outcomes.
Assessment of Liability
After reviewing the case study, the liability falls with all parties involved with the patient’s care, not just the surgeon. In this situation it was a process problem. There was obviously a universal protocol process at the facility as the case study identified several safety check processes. Unfortunately, there were several breakdowns in the process. First, the person who marked the patient was not the consented surgeon who was performing the procedure. As the patient mentioned she never had the opportunity to speak with the person who mismarked the spot. Second, the patient was not involved in the site marking. The patient mentioned if she had the opportunity to use a mirror to verify the marking she would have noticed it was incorrect. Third, the patient remembered that a “time out” never actually happened in the procedure...

Find Another Essay On Legal Case Study: 62 year old woman with skin cancer

9 year old boy with testosterone disorder

1366 words - 5 pages A nine-year-old boy is brought into a clinic suspected of having a hypo- gonadism disorder. The physician ordered a test of the boys free testosterone after having considered this was the best option compared to testing the total testosterone. The test results came back at 25.0pg/ml reference range 0.1-3.2pg/ml flagged as high for the boy. Several months later a repeated test showed 28.0pg/ml reference range of 50-210pg/ml adult reference range

Legal Case Study

1859 words - 7 pages Legal Case Study This case is about the disagreement between Simpsons Ltd v Thowers Ltd. The carrier’s liabilities will be discussed in three parts, firstly to resolve the problem, I am going to give a short

Legal Case Study

2047 words - 8 pages Legal Case Study The American Automobile industry has historically been tied to the nations economic cycle in which three or four years were good followed by one or two poor years. In 1977 there were four major U.S. automakers including General Motors, Ford, Chrysler and American Motors. Imports were starting to make their presence in the market because they offered subcompact cars at reasonable prices. Ford

BWC Legal Case Study

2783 words - 12 pages contract or contractual obligations. In this case, BWC has extended the invitation to treat to three companies, with a specified “tender Closing Date”. Yet, it has awarded the contract to one of these three companies before the specified closing date and time. The Other unsuccessful bidders may raise claims that BWC has a contractual obligation towards considering their offers, which it has not done by selecting prior to a specified date. The basis on

Jill´s Case Study of Naspharyngeal Cancer

748 words - 3 pages There is a seventeen year old female who we will call Jill. She was born with nasopharyngeal cancer, and has been taken care of by her mother and father intensely since she was born. Jill was a surprise birth to her young parents, but they still love her no matter what they have to go thru due to the illness and expenses. The parents are both in good health, with no known medical problems. Jill was born and seemed to be a healthy child she

Moral Conflict with Ethical Principles and Laws - Suicidal Cancer Patient Tells Nurse Intentions - Ethics and Law of Health - Case Study

2568 words - 11 pages HLTH3000: Case Study Written Assessment A 57-year-old male patient is suffering from late stage prostate cancer and is currently in care of the oncology department at a general hospital in Brisbane, Queensland. He was diagnosed seven years ago by a urologist, but refused conventional medical intervention and chose to seek alternative treatment. Since this diagnosis, his current admission to the hospital was due to anemia and hypoproteinemia

Legal Issues Case Study For Nursing

1069 words - 4 pages Legal Issues Case Study for Nursing Case 2 Nursing Situation: Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13. Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore throat, wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough, shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear

Spiritual Care Needs for Cancer Patients: Case Study

952 words - 4 pages is frustrated and upset with Frank not being open to discuss about their future. A study found that “spirituality has to do with connectedness with the continuum of life and of energy in the universe” (Seccareccia & Brown, 2009, p. 807). With the use of spiritual care, it can be reassures the patient that his family still loves him no matter what and also ensures access and opportunities for clients and family to address their spiritual

A Treatment Plan for a 21 Year Old Male With Schizophrenia

3014 words - 13 pages Case Charles is a 21 year-old Caucasian single male currently residing with his mother and stepfather whom also is Charles’s uncle. Charles graduated high school and due to his illness he receives social security benefits. During a two year period Charles had nine visits to the emergency room resulting in admission to the psychiatric unit. On two admissions Charles left against medical advice, five admissions required a higher level of care

Jason Alexander Downie: Triple Murder Case by an 18 Year-Old

2169 words - 9 pages be equally burdensome, varying in death sentence (such as hanging, beheading and lethal injection) to what is more common at this modern era, a long-time to life-time imprisonment. This essay will discuss a murder crime occurred in Adelaide and will explain the crime causation along with the relevant theory. The criminal case covered in this essay involve a triple family murder done by an 18 year old student named Jason Alexander Downie. Jason

Legal Issues in Nursing for BSN. Case study

1152 words - 5 pages Running head Case 1Legal Issues Case StudyCase 2Nursing Situation:Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13.Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore throat,wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough, shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear

Similar Essays

Case Study On A Three Year Old With Bronchiolitis

2035 words - 9 pages Introduction: This paper will discuss a case study of Liam, a three-month-old boy who is transferred from the General Practitioner (GP) to paediatric ward with bronchiolitis. Initially, Liam’s chief health issues will be identified, following by nursing assessment and diagnoses of the child’s need. Focus will be made on the management of two major health problems: respiratory distress and dehydration, and summary and evaluation of the

Pediatrics Case Study Paper: The Case Of The 12 Year Old Boy Who Presented With A Head Trauma

3433 words - 14 pages A.B is a 12 year old, male who presented to the W.C.H.C E.R. department on August 24, 2005 via EMS for a head injury, that was caused by a collision with a car while he was riding his bicycle. He also had a neck appliance/brace, and a large area of bloody hair on the left side of his head, from a laceration he obtained from the accident.Disease Process.A head injury is any trauma that leads to injury of the scalp, skull, or brain. These injuries

Reflective Case Study Of 6 Year Old Boy

2262 words - 9 pages , as the child would need some sort of intervention i.e. a steristrip, glue or suture. When I found the little boy, Jamie, he was 6 year old and sitting quietly on his mother's knee. He looked frightened and his eyes were red as if he had been crying. I introduced myself as an experienced paramedic, but on placement to gain some extra experience in a controlled setting, with the aim to become an Emergency Care Practioner (ECP). I sought permission

Pancreatic Cancer Case Study

2988 words - 12 pages ensure the quality and safety improvement of the patients. A health care worker has an obligation and duty to satisfy every patient under their care (Richardson, 2010). Case Scenario In July of 2009, Mr Valdez, 68 yrs old, presented with abdominal pain, anorexia and started to lose weight rapidly and progressively. In September 2009, doctors finally had a diagnosis and it was pancreatic cancer with lung and liver metastasis. They were giving