Legal Development Of Abortion Essay

1335 words - 5 pages

Legal Development of Abortion

    This essay traces the development of abortion law in English and American society up to the time of Roe v. Wade in 1973. Beginning with Biblical citations, the essay researches the Early Church Fathers on the issue; the American colonies; developments of the 1800's which caused change, and so on.


Up to the time of the Protestant Reformation, the English society inherited its traditional anti-abortion law from the Church practice of 1500 years standing; which belief began even before Christianity as part of the Old Testament Jewish belief. The Old Testament tells us: "Death was not God's doing, he takes no pleasure in the extinction of the living" (Wis. 1:13). What is willed is life, and in the visible universe everything has been made for man, who is the image of God and the world's crowning glory (Gen. 1:26-28). In the Christian tradition, the Early Church Fathers taught in The Didache, perhaps the first Christian catechism from 70-90AD, the following in chapter 2, verses 1-2: "The second commandment of the teaching: You shall not murder. You shall not commit adultery. You shall not seduce boys. You shall not commit fornication. You shall not steal. You shall not practice magic. You shall not use potions. You shall not procure [an] abortion, nor destroy a newborn child." (Jurgens vol.1,p.2)


The colonies inherited English Common Law and largely operated under it until well into the 19th century. English Common Law forbade abortion. Abortion prior to quickening was a misdemeanor. Abortion after quickening (feeling life) was a felony. This bifid punishment, inherited from earlier ecclesiastic law, stemmed from earlier "knowledge" regarding human reproduction.


In the early 1800s it was discovered that human life did not begin when she "felt life," but rather at fertilization. As a direct result of this, the British Parliament in 1869 passed the "Offenses Against the Persons Act," eliminating the above bifid punishment and dropping the felony punishment back to fertilization. One by one, across the middle years of the 19th century, every then-present state passed its own law against abortion. By 1860, 85% of the population lived in states which had prohibited abortion with new laws. These laws, preceding and following the British example, moved the felony punishment from quickening back to conception. (Dellapenna) Abortionists, if convicted, were sent to jail for varying lengths of time. There is no record of any having been executed.


The definitive study of the question of whether women were punished contradicts Planned Parenthood's ads which have claimed: "If you had a miscarriage you could be prosecuted for murder." (Wash) Studying two hundred years of legal history, the American Center for Bioethics concluded: "No evidence was found to support the proposition that women were prosecuted for undergoing or soliciting abortions. The charge that spontaneous miscarriages...

Find Another Essay On Legal Development of Abortion

Legal Abortion=Freedom of Choice Whenever a society attempts to outlaw abortions, it ignores the same urgent reasons for safe, legal abortions that have always existed.

787 words - 3 pages Legal abortions are essential in a free society that values women and their rights. Abortion is never an easy decision, but women have been making that decision for thousands of years. Whenever a society attempts to outlaw abortions, it ignores the same urgent reasons for safe, legal abortions that have always existed.Choice is good for families. There are many programs such as family planning, sex education, and contraception which diminish the

Abortion should NOT be illegal. This is a persuasive essay that shows the good that could come out of an abortion and why it should continue to be legal for women to CHOOSE to have an abortion

985 words - 4 pages they are legal or not. The problem is that these "back-alley" abortions are extremely unsafe. In past years, thousands of women have died from illegal abortions. The women who died were simply trying to practice their right to self-determination.The cultural and religious views of abortion continue to be an extremely heated debate. The Roman Catholic Church, Hinduism, and Buddhism teach that the soul enters the body at or before conception

Abortion Should Be Llegal

2310 words - 9 pages debate between anti-abortion and the opponents is increasing heated (BEYOND CHOICE P19).Woman tend to choose illegal abortion when it is unavailable for legal abortion, even it is unsafe with poor conditions and unqualified provider (Berer, M., 2000). Traditionally, laws and medical ethics against abortion for mainly two reasons: first of all, it seems like killing a developing human being as fetus should have a moral and legal right to life

Women's rights in the US

2364 words - 9 pages abortion? There are several anti-abortion laws that have made abortion illegal in the United States since 1900. It was illegal in 30 states and only legal under special circumstances (rape, incest). After the Roe v. Wade case, laws have been established to legalize abortion and to set guidelines for the abortion process. Since this case, the amount of new laws regarding abortion has grown significantly. The legalization of abortion comes with its


964 words - 4 pages conception ( Abortion). Both sides have a liable reason as to why abortion should or shouldn’t be legal. It isn’t right that others can just jump in and give an opinion on what a mother to be can or can’t do with a fetus that has yet to grow into a life with the ability to survive without the aid of its’ mother. Even though abortion is the considered the killing of an unborn life, abortion should be legal because it prevents the birth of a

Abortion Should Remain Legal

2323 words - 9 pages , pro-choice (legal abortion) advocates argue that; it is women’s rights to control their own bodies without any interference; abortion does not kill a baby, but just ends a pregnancy; modern abortion is safe because it is performed by professions in a safe setting; women who choose abortion do not have ability to raise children. These two sides over the issue are strained since long time ago. However, again, viewing abortion in terms of medical

Abortion: From The Beginning To The Present.

1723 words - 7 pages panics because she isn't ready for a child. She has heard about abortion but knows there are mixed feelings about it amongst society. She doesn't know what to do...Abortion is one of the most controversial and important subjects of this generation. Its controversy has stirred up a lot of different opinions and protests around the world in hopes to keep it legal or make it illegal. According to, one in four of our generation is

Abortion: Two Sides Of The Story

1760 words - 7 pages blastocyst in the endometrium and before the fetus has obtained viability (Henshaw, 1990, p. 76). Pro-life groups say that human life begins at conception while supporters of choice do not accept the notion that a fetus at all stages of development is a meaningful human life (Flanders, 1991). These two groups set the terms for discussion on abortion.According to Hurley (2001), the pro-choice philosophy maintains that abortion is moral and legal

Adoption, NOT Abortion

940 words - 4 pages Nowadays, abortion has become a controversial issue because people are becoming more aware of the issue that abortion brings to society and the individual who is going through the abortion .In recent years, however, society has become very open-minded, and as a result pro-life and pro-choice groups have been able to sway the American public’s view of abortion. Abortion became legal in 1973 when Roe vs. Wade declared that a woman has the right to

Should Abortion be Legal?

958 words - 4 pages stages of pregnancy or at birth? If the woman has the right to choose then what about the babies right to live? Is the baby not living even as it starts its development as a fetus? What about people who believe abortion should be illegal just because of religious beliefs and that god is the only one to decide to take a life? I believe that abortion should be a legal choice for women. I?m not saying that women should use abortion as a form of birth

Abortion Rights or WRONGS?

3916 words - 16 pages ruling in Roe v. Wade."The justices upheld the ruling by a vote of 5 to 4. The court also ruled that states might require women seeking an abortion to first receive counseling by a doctor about fetal development and abortion risks. The court also decided that states might require women to wait 24 hours between the counseling and the abortion. " (World book online, 4)The Case of National Organization for Women v. Scheidler (1994) was a legal response

Similar Essays

Abortion Fetal Tissue Research Is The Process Of Using Fetal Tissue, Derived From Legal Abortions, For Scientific Research Into Fundamental Biological Processes And Human Development.

746 words - 3 pages Every year in Canada, over 100 000 murders never reach thecourtroom.1 They never reach the courtroom because they are completelylegal. Abortion continues to grow across the world, hurting and killingchildren, as well as their mothers. Abortion is immoral, harmful, and actions must be taken to stop it.When a woman aborts, she is not only killing her child but is alsoharming herself. Legal abortion is the fifth leading cause of maternaldeath.2 Ten

Mary Anne Warren's On The Moral And Legal Status Of Abortion

1751 words - 7 pages Mary Anne Warren’s “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion” describes her justification that abortion is not a fundamentally wrong action for a mother to undertake. By forming a distinction between being genetically human and being a fully developed “person” and member of the “moral community” that encompasses humanity, Warren argues that it must be proven that fetuses are human beings in the morally relevant sense in order for their

Abortion Should Not Be Legal In The United States Of America

2954 words - 12 pages Abortion Should Not be Legal in The United States of America In Roman times, abortion and the destruction of unwanted children was permissible, but as our civilization has aged, it seems that such acts are no longer acceptable by rational human beings. In 1948, Canada along with most other nations in the world signed a declaration of the United Nations promising every human being the right to life. The World Medical Association meeting in

Analysis Of Warren's Book, On The Moral And Legal Status Of Abortion, Questions Of Life And Death

869 words - 3 pages abortion is dependent on the fetus’s own violation of the mothers’ freedom such that as soon as the fetus is no longer violating the mothers’ rights, the mother herself has no right in violating the fetus/infants existence. Thus Warren’s argument doesn’t support infanticide and she can safely refute the objection that her defense of abortion permits infanticide. Warren, M. (1982). On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Questions of Life and Death, 397-403