This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legal Case Study

1859 words - 7 pages

Legal Case Study This case is about the disagreement between Simpsons Ltd v Thowers
Ltd. The carrier’s liabilities will be discussed in three parts,
firstly to resolve the problem, I am going to give a short description
of the main components of the contract of carriage of goods by sea Act
1971, secondly I will decide which of the Hague Visby rules or the
Common law is applicable, and to finish I am going to apply the rules
in looking for the liabilities of the carrier by searching the duties
and the defences of the carrier for each good.

I) What is the contract “Carriage of Goods by Sea?”

Firstly, we have to check whether the case is governed by “the
carriage of goods by sea”, or not and Secondly, whether Simpsons and
Thowers satisfy all the conditions of Carriage of Goods by Sea. When
we are looking at the definition of the contract, the contract
stipulates that:

( JCT Chuah, 7-01, p201)

* The contract of carriage must be covered by a bill of lading or
any similar document of title.

* The carriage of goods is from a port in a contracting state.

In the case, we know that the contract was covered by two bills of
lading. They used one bill of lading for each product. The damage
happened during the carrying which means during the application of the
Act. As a consequence, the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971 does

In the second part, we will see if the Hague Visby rules apply in the
carriage of Goods by Sea.

II) Do Hague Visby rules apply as contained in the carriage of Goods
by Sea Act 1971?

A) Conditions of the application Hague Visby rules.

The Hague Visby rules do apply if :

Art 1 (Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971)

* The contract is based on a bill of lading or any other document of

* Carriage of Goods by Sea is between ports in two different states.

* The goods are not live animals

* If the contract of carriage stated as being carried on deck and is
so carried.

B) Effect of the exclusion clause

In the case, one clause could put in balance the use of the Hague
Visby rules. In fact it is on the first bill of lading “ five
containers containing engine parts, liberty to carry on deck”, we have
to check if the shipper could carry on deck or not.

The case Simpsons v Thowers complete the first three obligations if we
want Hague Visby rules apply. In fact, the contract is regulated by a
bill of lading, which has been signed in two parts from contracting
states and the goods capacity conform with the law (no live animals or
dangerous goods). There are engine parts and 1,000...

Find Another Essay On Legal Case Study

BWC Legal Case Study

2783 words - 12 pages to document them in the most appropriate technical manner. Furthermore, scope and works verification clauses can be added to ensure that BWC is continuously involved. 4- It is clear that BWC emphasizes the cost factor and requires a high degrees of cost certainty as well as price. DB modules can be beneficial in this case and can reduce the costs by substantial amounts, up to 10%, (Build LLC, 2010). However, to increase the cost certainty, it

Legal Issues in Nursing for BSN. Case study

1152 words - 5 pages Running head Case 1Legal Issues Case StudyCase 2Nursing Situation:Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13.Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore throat,wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough, shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear

ILAC case study - legal issues for managers - Griffith Business School

1132 words - 5 pages must not improperly use their position to “gain an advantage for themselves”. Under s191, a company director who has material personal interest, must inform other directors of any personal interests they may have. In the case of ASIC and Adler, Adler did not disclose information and used this for personal use (“Fact”). Likewise, Howard clearly held information for personal gain and acted in bad faith, breaching s180, s182 and s191 by holding

Case Study: Maple Leaf Shoes Ltd. - Legal Challenges - University of Regina - Introduction to Human Recourse Mgmt.

407 words - 2 pages Case Problem The significant issue in this case is the “sexual harassment” and the victim is Rosetta Maurizio. Internal and External Factors The first and main internal factor is equality of gender in working place. In the finishing section, there were only two women among twenty men. The second internal factor is a supervisor, it is Al’s responsibility to let their employees know what is sexual harassment? And what are the consequences

Ethical, Legal, and Professional Issues in Counseling - University of San Francisco - Case Study, Assignment

674 words - 3 pages Introduction The professional codes of ethics and standards of practice for licensed mental health professionals provides guidelines for therapists when faced with ethical issues that are difficult to resolve. Therapists are expected to engage in a careful review of ethical decision-making process and utilize available resources as needed. This paper provides summary of a journal article titled “When Good Enough isn’t” It identifies legal or

Legal Essay

1554 words - 7 pages ; rehabilitation also promotes acceptance and accountability for the behaviour which is shown by the defendant Perry with her sending a remorseful letter to the victim. The rehabilitation schemes have caused positive significant change for the offender as shown in the previously mentioned case, and have in this instance displayed remorse to the victim and the entire community and has resulted in a promise of not re-offending. Legal aid is an

Legal Process

889 words - 4 pages employee’s favor. A recommendation to John would be to first consult the human resources department about the discrimination issue. The human resources department’s investigation may be an alternative method that can save John and the employer from a long process of uncovering justice.ReferencesKrishna Regmi, Jennie Naidoo, & Sharada Regmi. (2009). Understanding the effect of discrimination in the workplace: A case study amongst Nepalese immigrants in the UK. Equal Opportunities International, 28(5), 398-414. Retrieved January 10, 2010, from ABI/INFORM GlobalU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, 2009,

Legal Process

1469 words - 6 pages case being appealed up to the inclusion of the U.S. Supreme Court, presuming the case substantiated such an elevated level of judicial review (Bennett-Alexander & Hartman, 2004).Bennett-Alexander and Hartman (2004) documented in their findings,"The EEOC's success rate is pretty high. An August 13, 2002, report on a five-year litigation study released by the EEOC (covering fiscal years 1997-2001) reported that approximately 91 percent of the

Legal and General Reward Management Study

2003 words - 8 pages 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARYANALYSIS OF THE LINK BETWEEN THE BUSINESS STRATEGY, HUMAN RESOURCE STRATEGY AND THE REWARD MANAGEMENT STRATEGYFrom the case study, the business strategy of Legal and General plc is "to increase its competitiveness by achieving lower administration costs, more effective sales distribution and maintaining an effective investment policy."The HR strategy aims at enabling the company to improve its competitiveness in the market

Paralegals: Legal Assistants

1451 words - 6 pages do other office tasks, such as office management as trainer of new hired paralegal, book keeping, and free lancing. NALA have available for paralegals the options of CLE (Continuing Legal Education). This program is live educational, online self-study programs, and publications which is overseen by the association’s Continuing Education Counsel. The council works with Headquarters staff, professional writers, and others in planning and

The Legal Atmosphere

1177 words - 5 pages than mere legal fencing between two opponents, it shows interactions between characters that are own to real society. Count Fosco has real claims under real law. And Mr. Dawson show himself as a real doctor with real worries. It is easy to appreciate the effects of Collins having study Law. Collins not only makes his characters speak for themselves as witnesses of a criminal trial, but gives them the proper vocabulary. This instantly provides

Similar Essays

Legal Case Study

2047 words - 8 pages Legal Case Study The American Automobile industry has historically been tied to the nations economic cycle in which three or four years were good followed by one or two poor years. In 1977 there were four major U.S. automakers including General Motors, Ford, Chrysler and American Motors. Imports were starting to make their presence in the market because they offered subcompact cars at reasonable prices. Ford

Legal Issues Case Study For Nursing

1069 words - 4 pages Legal Issues Case Study for Nursing Case 2 Nursing Situation: Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13. Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore throat, wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough, shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear

Legal Case Study: 62 Year Old Woman With Skin Cancer

1424 words - 6 pages Legal Case Study Following the review of a medical error about a 62-year-old woman with skin cancer who experienced wrong-site surgery I will summarize the legal and liability aspects of this case, as well as explore the legal and ethical implications of disclosing errors. In addition, I will discuss the pros and cons of having the provider disclose and empathize for the error to the patient. Finally, I will identify ways the nurse leaders can

The Murder Of Eden Delir Legal Studies Crime Case Study

3253 words - 14 pages bodily harm upon some person, or done in an attempt to commit, or during or immediately after the commission, by the accused, or some accomplice with him or her” [Crimes Act 1900. 2017]. It then goes on to give a sentence for someone charged with the crime, in this instance murder, which is suggested to be “a crime punishable by imprisonment for life or for 25 years” [Crimes Act 1900. 2017]. Such a sentence does not affect this case study however, as