This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legal Issues In Healhthcare Essay

1129 words - 5 pages

In the case of Michael T. Vandall, M.D., Plaintiff and Appellant v. Trinity Hospitals, a corporation, and Margaret C. Nordell, M.D., the issue is about retaliatory discharge. It deals with problems with Trinity Hospital in North Dakota, Dr. Margaret Nordell and Dr. Michael Vandall, both physicians working in the OB-GYN department.
Dr. Vandall was hired in 1996 by Trinity Hospital under the Physician Services Agreement. The Physicians Services Act, or PSA is a contract that establishes terms of engagement, such as responsibilities, scheduling, salary and insurance. PSAs are a form of alignment between hospitals and physicians that falls just short of full employment. Hospital contracts ...view middle of the document...

In October of 2001, the hospital informed the doctor that his PSA contract would not be renewed and his employment there would end.
In January 2003, Dr. Vandall sued the hospital and Dr. Nordell, stating that while he worked there, the hospital took a series of retaliatory actions against him, because he had reported Dr. Nordell's unethical medical practices. He said their actions "constituted intentional infliction of emotional distress." The trial court dismissed the claims and awarded the attorney's fees to the hospital.
Dr. Vandall's complaint and arguments were based on a common law claim for retaliatory discharge, not a statutory claim. The case discusses in great detail common law which comes from judicial decisions that have evolved from court cases, statutory law which emanates from legislative bodies, and retaliation, when a worker sues their employer for a wrongdoing. Through much legal talk, the awarding of the attorney's fee ended up being reversed.
Although I'm not very familiar laws and court proceedings, I find it interesting to see the legal system in action. What I took from this briefing was that a person was trying to do the right thing by reporting unethical behavior at his workplace and ended up in a long, complicated, legal battle. There seemed to be a misinterpretation of the the codes and laws, and how and what he was filing a claim for, but in the end it did seem to get corrected in the doctor's favor. Although the wording was difficult to understand at times, it did appear to be very precise. From what I read, the doctor wasn't looking for any kind of compensation or special attention. He was just trying to protect the patients at the hospital. According to the American Medical Association "Physicians have an ethical obligation to report impaired, incompetent, and/or unethical colleagues in accordance with the legal requirements in each state." This is based on the physician's obligation to protect their patients. Initially reports should be handled within the organization, but if that is unsuccessful, it can be brought to a higher authority. This was the case of Dr. Vandall as a Vice Chair at Trinity Hospital.
In my personal life, I have attended the District Attorney's Citizen's Academy. This is a series of weekly...

Find Another Essay On Legal Issues in Healhthcare

Legal and Ethical Issues in School Counseling

1735 words - 7 pages going into the school counseling profession. It is also a meaningful topic to me because life-changing decisions are made every day in reference to legal and ethical issues. Researching this topic has shed some light on the difficulty for school counselors to fulfill both legal and ethical requirements. The main reason for this is that laws and ethical codes may sometimes provide differing and contradictory messages regarding the same subject

Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce Simulation

1555 words - 6 pages Legal Issues PAGE 2 Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce SimulationUniversity of PhoenixLegal Issues in Reduction of WorkforceThe business world today demonstrates an increase of companies downsizing, restructuring or laying off personnel. Some factors that contribute to this are business stipulations, financial issues, organizational invention, continuing, and other miscellaneous items. "In the first quarter of 2007, there were 965 mass

Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce Simulation: Fast Serve Inc

2357 words - 9 pages Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce SimulationUniversity of PhoenixJuliet D. HollinJuly 24, 2007IntroductionFast Serve, Inc is a 25 million company, consisting of 350 employees, involved in direct marketing of branded sports apparel. The company has developed two websites that will allow them to increase in assets. Since, the online industry was not successful, Fast Serve, Inc, is to downsize. As a manager of Fast Serve, Inc. the viewer has

Informed consent or doctor knows best? Legal issues in Nursing

1082 words - 4 pages Informed consent or doctor knows best?In nowadays world, legal issues form an integral part of society when decisions need to be made. According to Johnstone (1995), the action role of legal support is done by reassuring the patients about their right and responsibility in making their own choices and also by reassuring them that they should not give themselves to pressure done by others in doing actions which are not wanted.Informed consent in

Legal Issues in Nursing for BSN. Case study

1152 words - 5 pages 11:08 p.m. observations. These indicated that the child's condition was not improving but was, in fact, deteriorating. Before processing the discharge order, the nurse should have communicated to the physician that the child had failed to improve with treatment and more aggressive therapy would have been followed, possibly including hospital admission.Conforming to legal standards and high quality care:Nursing malpractice exists because it is

Social, Ethical, and Legal Issues in Computer Graphics

1746 words - 7 pages being so large is that it used vacuum tubes to process data. It also broke down very the tune of once every fifteen minutes, and then it would take 15 minutes to locate the problem and fix it. This beast also used massive amount of power, and people used to joke that the lights would dim in the city of origin whenever the computer was used.Social, Ethical, and Legal Issues in Computer GraphicsRecognizing the importance of computer

Legal Issues in Estoppel: Promissory Estoppel in Relation to the Law of Contracts

1591 words - 7 pages It is commonly accepted that an estoppel is a legal doctrine which prevents a person from negating or claiming a fact due to that person’s prior conduct. The doctrine of estoppel has been applied for years and different forms of estoppel have been established. For the purpose of this essay, I will predominantly concentrate on promissory estoppel in relation to the law of contracts. This essay will be approached by discussing the issues of pre

Ethical, Legal, and Professional Issues in Counseling - University of San Francisco - Case Study, Assignment

674 words - 3 pages Introduction The professional codes of ethics and standards of practice for licensed mental health professionals provides guidelines for therapists when faced with ethical issues that are difficult to resolve. Therapists are expected to engage in a careful review of ethical decision-making process and utilize available resources as needed. This paper provides summary of a journal article titled “When Good Enough isn’t” It identifies legal or

Legal and Ethical Issues of Reporting Abuse in Both Children and the Elderly

779 words - 4 pages Reporting abuse has been a legal and ethical dilemma for years in the healthcare system. Some physicians, nurses, and other healthcare workers are quick to report abuse while others are more reluctant to report abuse in fear of overreacting to an occurrence. This leaves children and the elderly in unknown state of protection from their abusers. While these medical personnel are reluctant to report abuse, there are approximately 2,000

Legal and Ethical Issues encountered in Health and Social Care: Elderly People with Dementia in Residential Homes.

1569 words - 7 pages This assignment will identify and evaluate the legal and ethical issues within the health and social care for elderly people with dementia and living in residential homes. It will address the difference between the legal and ethical issues and the impact it has on the person suffering from the disease, their family and the role that the professionals have in decision making for the individual’s wellbeing. Dementia is a disease which causes

Legal Issues In The Workplace

1486 words - 6 pages people related business issues” (Noe et al., 2002, 59) which is the primary function of HR. “Once the strategy has been determined, HRM has a profound impact on the implementation of the plan by developing and aligning HRM practices that ensure that the company has motivated employees with the necessary skills” (Noe et al., 2002, 83). HR must enact its own strategies which can aid the organization in meeting its goals and mission. They are

Similar Essays

Legal Issues In Education Essay

1195 words - 5 pages in scope in comparison. As new cases are brought forth technology in schools will become more defined. Until such time, schools can protect themselves and the students by creating policies governing how students use technology in the classroom and what is expected outside the classroom.ReferencesWaters, Kevin Stewart, (May 7, 2008). The Internet, Schools, and the Constitution: AHistorical Analysis of Court Decisions. Retrieved from the ERIC database onAugust 18, 2009.Wenkart, Ronald D., & Darden, Edwin C. (1999). Legal Issues & Education Technology.National School Boards Association. Retrieved from the ERIC database onAugust 18, 2009.

Legal Issues In Emergency Management Essay

648 words - 3 pages not liable for their death because it was the person’s personal decision. An attorney can prove to be vital during emergency preparedness, during and after an incident. In emergency preparedness an attorney helps “… draft plans, evaluate training standards, and monitor exercises for potential legal issues, as well as assure that EOP revisions are sufficient from a legal standpoint…” (Nicholson & Esquire, pg. 421). During an emergency crisis

Technology: Legal Issues In Australia Essay

1092 words - 4 pages Advances in technology has brought many benefits but also problems. The use of new technology creates moral and ethical problems and conflicting attitudes in society. The complexity of the issues and the pace with which technology changes mean that legislators have difficulty making laws that can keep in control of these changes. Technology affects all areas of society, forcing changes in a range of laws. Advances in computer technology have

Ethical And Legal Issues In Ict

919 words - 4 pages Ethical and Legal issues in ICT • Introduction The consistent use of information and communication technology (ICT) in modern world enables us for countless opportunities for individuals, institutions, business organisations and scientists, but it also raises difficult ethical and legal problems. In particular, ICT helped to make societies more complex and thus even harder to understand. The use of ICT has led to changes in concepts: ownership