This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legal Profession And Legal Ethics Summative Assessment

1969 words - 8 pages

The legal profession has been historically linked with a moral and ethical behaviour on the part of its participants, and as such it is bound to necessitate careful scrutiny, in the same manner that the medical profession does. Solicitors are regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, and advocates by the Faculty of Advocates. Both bodies deal with a variety of matters, from establishing qualifications for admission to the profession to rules of professional conduct and disciplinary actions. They impose certain standards of service and behaviour on legal professionals.

Even though the legal profession is self-regulating, the Law Society exists only as a creature of statute. S.34 of the ...view middle of the document...

He noted that

“there are certain standards of conduct to be expected of competent and reputable solicitors. A departure from these standards which would be regarded by competent and reputable solicitors as serious and reprehensible may properly be categorized as professional misconduct”.

He goes on to complete that when assessing a solicitor’s conduct “it will be essential to consider the whole circumstances and the degree of culpability.”

It is reasonable to say that this test denotes much flexibility and leaves much room for interpretation. It is similar to the test for negligence established in Hunter v Hanley, where it was held that a professional is acting negligently is he does something “which no professional man of ordinary skill would have taken if he had been acting with ordinary care.” Negligence could also amount to misconduct if it is serious enough.
Delay, neglect and incompetence on the part of a solicitor are some of the most commonly invoked grounds for complaints in disciplinary hearings and cases, but they seldom lead to striking off, since that would be considered as an excessive measure-it would leave the solicitor unable to practice the law again.

These manners of holding solicitors to account for their professional misconduct might be considered as unfair for the public, because there are often very few other ways available for redress outside of this system. This clearly points to the fact that the legal profession is a separate and self-regulatory body, rarely able to be reprimanded outside of its own circle. The question might, therefore, be whether this independence is actually of a positive nature, or should be more carefully scrutinized. If a profession is regulated by its own participants (in our case, by solicitors themselves), is it necessarily thoroughly regulated? Independence is needed for the profession, but many might argue that solicitors are often unlikely to be held accountable for anything at all. Courts are expensive and people usually need a faster, more direct way in which to hold their solicitors accountable for any potential mishaps. Citizens partaking in legal proceedings are not necessarily pleased at the way in which disciplinary measures are employed, because lawyers assessing their lawyer peers might appear too indulgent in dealing with such matters. A simple google search leads to many instances where solicitors were seldom reprimanded for misbehaving and they often returned to their jobs once investigations were over.

It is true that lawyers making their own rules and judging their colleagues might appear unfair. But the law itself is in the hands of legal professionals. It is judges, lawyers and advocates who know the most about the system, about what should be demanded from them, and about punishments involved for professional misconduct or negligence. The system is indeed independent and sufficiently robust, and should remain this way. There is no reason why any other body...

Find Another Essay On Legal Profession and Legal Ethics Summative Assessment

Sustainability: Ethics, Legal, and Economic Aspects

1993 words - 8 pages . This paper will analyzing different ethical, legal, and economic issues relevant to sustainability as it pertains. Ethics and sustainability Organizations that are led by management who perform in a principled behavior are probable to be exemplified by an affirmative ethical civilization. Also, when their workforce is rewarded by doing what is right, helps cultivate the positive ethical image throughout the organization (Amos, 2012). When the

Legal and Ethics in Business Environment

903 words - 4 pages Legal and Ethics in Business Environment Name: Institution:   Legal and Ethics in Business Environment Introduction After working as an employee for Coca Cola Company for a period of 20 years, I accrued enough capital to establish my own company. The investment sector presents many challenges when one invests on a global scale. The main challenge comes when the country you invest in suffers from political instability. It usually happens

The Legal Profession: One Career, Many Avenues

1482 words - 6 pages The Legal Profession: One Career, Many Avenues Whether we are reading about the heroic small-town attorney Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mocking Bird, or watching in awe as Richard Gere portrays a smooth attorney in Primal Fear, it is apparent through culture and media that there is a power and prestige associated with the law in American society. This paper compares the training and education of such American lawyers with their English

Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility: The Regulatory and Legal Framework

1158 words - 5 pages rules are static but globalization is dynamic. Some argue that the introduction of prescriptive regulation with regard to CSR matters is unnecessary (Kercher, 2006) as CSR involves a voluntary business endeavor to address social and environmental issues beyond legal compliance, therefore, governments cannot impose hierarchical command-and-control policies to support it (David & Lipton, 2005).CSR and Ethics InternationallyHistorically

Legal Issues, Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility on Business Planning

931 words - 4 pages failures in many aspects of the daily operation of a business and the overall business plan of a corporation. The ongoing evaluation and analysis of the planning process is necessary to improve the overall process to keep the company in line with the latest changes in the industry. Therefore, this paper will discuss how legal issues, ethics and corporate social responsibility impact management planning at (My company).Legal IssuesBusiness plans

Comparing Three Websites: Ethics, Legal, and Regulatory Issues

1639 words - 7 pages the responsibility for personal information that is transmitted on these websites comes a whole bunch of legal, ethical, and regulatory values the privacy and security of its users. This value doesn't change when a consumer uses their auction site. Amazon also values the legal, ethical and regulatory issues that any website must address. To most consumers and website users, the legality and ethical side of a website is not

Analyzing Ethics in the US Legal System

1746 words - 7 pages In the legal system of the United States, there are many controversial topics and crises that have no one solution. Following suit, there is the question of ethics that exists within such an ideology. Some think that the current way of thinking is a sufficient way to run a country; others see changes that need to be executed immediately. The fact of the matter is as such, no one social institution is perfect. Therefore, the legal system is not

Legal, Regulatory, Ethics Issues & Trends Paper

935 words - 4 pages employee just as efficient in their own home as in their office 30 miles away.Internet Trade CommissionThe entire world depends and strives on some independent fruit of E-Business today. The success or failure of E-Business companies thrives in the technology market and there are new legal and ethical issues that derive everyday. One major aspect of E-Business that I can see changing or developing in the next five years is an E-Business or E

What evidence is there to show women in the legal profession suffer from discrimination?

1170 words - 5 pages find work in their area of choice. Women were disproportionately likely to miss out on training contracts according to the Law Society 1999, and this bias is reinforced at higher levels of the profession. There are very few women in the higher levels of the legal profession; women solicitors are generally in junior positions even though a third of practising solicitors are women. Even the most senior and successful women barristers were

Medical Ethics - The essay primarily discusses autonomy and legal issues as they relate to medical ethics issues

1071 words - 4 pages Medical Ethics and AutonomyThe term autonomy is derived from the Greek autos, which means self and from the term nomos meaning rule, governance or law. To be autonomous is to be self-determined and to be in control of one's life. In regards to medical care, being autonomous refers to one making a decision regarding personal medical care issues for his or her self.Autonomy focuses on respecting the ability of a person to make health care

Ethical and legal analysis of the Ann Hopkins v. Price Waterhouse discrimination law suit. Focuses on case law and ethics

3145 words - 13 pages for partnership.2. WHAT ARE THE KEY "ISSUES"?The key issues that I will address are as follows:-Is it legal to for a partnership to discriminate or are they immune from the protection of the Civil Rights Act?-Is it legal to have discriminatory motives, i.e. stereotyping, without taking discriminatory actions?-Is it legal to formally counsel an employee on their appearance and image with regards to their sex?3. WHAT ARE THE "LEGAL RULES" THAT

Similar Essays

Legal Assessment Essay

1331 words - 6 pages reliant on technology we as a society, need laws to reflect our fast paced world. Legal Issues In todays society in regard to legal issues with technology cyberbullying would be the most focused on issue as, 20% of kids that are cyberbullied think about suicide, and 1 in 10 attempt it. If there were to be a law protecting children, adolescents and even adults from cyberbullying this statistic would decrease dramatically. Right now there is no

Legal And Ethics Essay

1463 words - 6 pages contracts whose terms are beyond the power of the consumer to negotiate. The Concepcion ruling has several harmful implications for the consumer. Arbitration does not provide the right to a jury trial or the right to judicial review of legal errors and usually, the decision of an arbitrator is final (source). Consumers are at a disadvantage in arbitrating claims because businesses usually have a great deal of experience and knowledge in

Criminal Legal System And Ethics Essay

1308 words - 6 pages Policy Level Ethical Issues in Criminal Courts and the Legal System Ethics in policy making and application of ethics in criminal courts and legal system is a critical factor for systemic transparency. Policy makers are faced with the daunting task of creating an electoral system that reflects the will of the people. However, varied opinions make it hard to achieve this ideal. One ethical issue that policy makers and legal practitioners face is

Accounting: Ethics And Legal Obligation Essay

1097 words - 4 pages viewed has changed dramatically. There are various laws and rules governing how company revenues are reported. In the past, accounting was a self regulated profession, but all the various illegal activity has caused the government to start digging deep into company financial statements. This has also caused the government to implement tighter rules on organizations. As indicated in an article on Government Entities, there was a recent statement