This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legality And Morality Essay

1093 words - 5 pages

1 Introduction

The aim of this essay is to differentiate between law and morality, and to discuss whether there is an overlap between the two concepts. I will be making reference to theorists of both positive law and natural law, namely H. L. A Hart and Lon L. Fuller respectively and compare the two views on the above question. For the purpose of understanding, I will apply the two theories to the legal system in Nazi Germany.

2 Law and Morality

H. L. A. Hart

As a positivist, Hart believes that there should be a firm distinction between ‘law as it is’ and ‘law as it ought to be’, specifically law and morality. According to positivists, whether a law is valid or not is not dependant on the justification of said law, but rather that it is recognized as enforceable by tests that are enforced by an efficacious legal system. To better understand this theory, one must look at Hart’s definition of a legal system and the separation of primary and secondary rules. The former refers to rules that are socially acceptable in a society and regulate the behaviour of persons in a society by creating obligations and therefore creating social pressure to follow these obligations. It is, however, insufficient for a legal system to contain only primary rules and because of this secondary rules come into play. Secondary rules enforce primary obligations in the form of law.

The rule of recognition can be used to explain this more clearly. Hart stands firm that the fulfilment of moral criteria is not needed in order for a law to be valid and denies the fact that there is a connection between law and morality. He states that in order for a norm to be legally valid, it has to observe ‘fundamental rules specifying the essential law-making procedures’ , i.e. secondary rules. A secondary rule comes down to being a higher-order rule. In saying that a rule is legally valid means that this rule has acquired legal status according to an accepted rule of recognition. In light of this, one might think that because secondary rules regulate primary rules, there is an intersection between law and morality. One could even go so far as to say that a rule must first pass a moral standard before it can be considered as legally valid. However, Hart maintains that there is no connection between law and morality, and that a law does not cease to be a law if it is in contradiction with moral standards. Hart does, however, admit that certain provisions for a legal system do, in fact, overlap with moral principles.

Hart maintains that the acceptance of the rule of law is solely based upon non-moral thoughts and may even be accepted when an individual finds the rule as morally objectionable. The rule of recognition is already accepted as the ultimate rule and therefore cannot be classified as either valid or invalid. The acceptance of the rule of law may be due to moral standards but this is not solely the case. Legal validity is not subject to morality and ‘law as it is’...

Find Another Essay On Legality and Morality

Title of Paper

992 words - 4 pages . “Stage 4” expands “Stage 3” by incorporating social rules: rules instituted by authority are immutable standards of morality, and behaviour becomes judged based on its legality (Kohlberg, 1981). The final stage, subdivided into stages 5 and 6 is the post-conventional stage, which is considered to be the most sophisticated level attainable. “Stage 5” bases morality on a social contract: society dictates what is good or bad; because society creates

Riggs V. Palmer Critaically Evalute The Legal Case Of Riggs V. Palmer

950 words - 4 pages which is moral but is not a law, particularly in this case. It is clear that Mr. Palmer receiving the money is not moral. The mere presence of morality, no matter how evident it may seem, does not create a law, therefore, a lacking of morality does not abolish a law. If one were to take the stance that, all things moral are laws, then it would be up to judges to determine morality not legality, and the written law would have no purpose.It is also

Morality in the Judicial Process

2221 words - 9 pages Justices must by necessity implicitly or explicitly consider questions of wisdom, justice, social harm and morality when deciding if a statute is unconstitutional. They should ensure that all these considerations are rooted in constitutional principles and constitutional questions. Society should not imagine these considerations are not present in judicial reasoning, nor should justices be ruled by them. The questions justices properly ask when

Dying with Dignity

588 words - 3 pages life, some patients wish to end their lives before they succumb to the disease. A physician aiding a terminally ill patient in their death is commonly referred to as physician assisted suicide, or PAS. The legality and morality of this highly contentious issue are hotly debated across the globe, and the practice has already been legalized in multiple countries and four US states. (Need another sentence) Although all life is intrinsically

Positive and Natural Law Theories

1644 words - 7 pages compatible with morality), Dworkin in his debate with Hart constantly underlined and revolved around the idea that legality cannot be explained by the social phenomena (practice, institutions, facts) alone, but has to consider morality as well (for instance justifiability of law, or what is the ground for subjects to obey). I would say, I hold the position of legal positivism, as it helps to establish a more stable, proper, working legal system, and

Thomas Aquinas: Justifiable War and Killing

689 words - 3 pages Among some of the subjects that Aquinas tackles in On Law, Morality, and Politics is the dilemma of War and Killing. Aquinas sums up the legality of war through three criteria: that the war waged is done by a legitimate authority, that the war is just because the enemy has done something grossly wrong, and the intention of the war is to solely right the wrong. Also we see Aquinas say that the killing of an innocent person is justified if God

Critically evaluate the main principles of legal positivism and natural law

3538 words - 14 pages human law conflicts with natural law according to Aquinas it is not lawful and may be disobeyed.Natural law jurists argue there is an intrinsic link between law and morality. However, positivists argue it is flawed because it is based on prejudice and value judgments. Homosexuality in some societies is considered unnatural so is immoral. Similarly it is morally wrong to kill yet in certain circumstances there are exceptions, e.g. wars. The

Legal versus Ethical Dilemmas impacting the Healthcare System

730 words - 3 pages to differentiate between the legality issues at hand opposed to justifying a case based on moral rules. According to Pozgar (2012), an ethical dilemma arises in situations where a choice must be made between unpleasant alternative. It can occur whenever a choice involves giving up something good and suffering something bad, no matter what course of action is taken (p. 367). In this paper, I will discuss cases that arose in the healthcare

Philosophy and Religion in Education

4093 words - 16 pages society such as the legality and morality of abortion, the death penalty, homosexuality, and pornographic material. Promotes college-level skills, especially writing and analytical reading.

Death with Dignity or Sanctity of Life: Who Gets to Choose?

1042 words - 4 pages Starks, PhD, MPH, Nicole White, MD, MA (2009) ETHICS IN MEDICINE. Retrieved from: Martin Levin (2002) Physician Assisted Suicide: Legality and Morality, Levin Papantonio, retrieved from:

Illegal Music Downloads

1200 words - 5 pages affects the artist and the Production Company?a. What type of economic impact does downloading illegal music has on production companies?b. What economic impact downloading illegal music has on the Artist?4. How do this practice affect society?a. It this a morality issue?b. What demographics are more prompt to download illegal music?c. What recourse society has to start early education?Is Illegal downloading music off the Internet morally

Similar Essays

Morality And Legality Of Abortion Essay

507 words - 2 pages Morality and legality of abortionSomewhere amidst the abortion debates of the last quarter century, the real issuehas been lost. The focus has become too religious for a country that has separated churchand state. Therefore, I won't argue the religious rights and wrongs of abortion. Noanswers can be derived until we focus on what the law and our citizens do value, becausethis is how laws are changed. American laws hold sacred the value of human

Integrating Business Values: The Legality, Morality, And Social Responsibility Of A Woman Who Uses Ru 486 To Terminate Pregnancy

7325 words - 30 pages days. It was like food poisoning. I couldn't keep anything down.""I went in on Friday and took the second dose of medication. After 15 minutes there was a tiny bit of cramping, but less than menstrual cramps. After two hours the cramps got stronger, and I started using a heating pad on my belly. I went to the restroom. When I started to stand up, it was like a faucet turned on. There was a steady stream of blood. I passed a golf-size blood clot

Texas Gambling: The Morality Vs Legality Of Casino Gambling

1807 words - 7 pages For years casino gambling was portrayed in the media and Hollywood as being associated with criminal activities and the mafia. Now with proper scrutiny and government regulations casino gambling has become a lucrative business, with casinos stock even trading on Wall Street. Casino gambling is an ever increasingly popular and legal activity in many states throughout the United States. “The term gambling or ‘gaming’ as the industry calls it

Pilgrim's Progress: The Theology Of Justification By Faith

937 words - 4 pages , and the role, or lack thereof, of works in acquiring salvation (Perry, Peden, Von Laue, pgs. 18-19). The concept of justification by faith and the zero sum value of works as taught by Luther is the central theme of the novel The Pilgrim's Progress and the basic position concerning Christianity that Bunyan conveys to the reader. Three examples of this position contained within the novel include Christian's opinion of morality and legality as a