This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

968 words - 4 pages

[The criminal code of Canada states] “everyone who councils, aids, or abets someone to commit suicide whether or not suicide ensures , is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 14 years.” 1 It is this law which violates the human right to life as well as creates a widely spread controversy over whether or not euthanasia should become legalized in Canada. 2 Legalizing euthanasia would create many benefits for those who suffer from a terminal illness, giving them freedom and control over their own lives. Euthanasia should be legalized in Canada; this is because the euthanasia law is not consistently applied, it would create medical advances for Canada which would bring the country up to speed with other countries around the world, and legalizing euthanasia would benefit those who wish to die by preventing inhumane suicidal crimes from occurring. 3
The euthanasia law in Canada is not applied consistently in the Canadian justice system; therefore euthanasia should become legalized in Canada. 4 Cases of euthanasia in the past have proven to be significant to the current debate of euthanasia, because of the different outcomes that were decided. For instance, in 1993 42 year old Sue Rodriguez was suffering from a terminal illness referred to as lateral sclerosis. She made her appeal to the courts asking for permission to have a physician assist her with suicide. Rodriguez’s arguments were that “[she] had the constitutional right to doctor assisted suicide.” , and that section 241 of the criminal code violated her rights in the charter. Unfortunately her appeal was denied . Justice Sopinka, the judge on the Rodriguez case states “her[Rodriguez’s] choice...is death over life and as a result, life as a value is brought into play under section 7[of the charter].”5 This case is used to demonstrate how the law should properly be enforced if euthanasia continues to be illegal. Further, in comparison to the case of Gloria Taylor, the law was simply overlooked. Gloria Taylor was a women also suffering from lateral sclerosis and she made her court appeal in 2011 to be granted the right to voluntary euthanasia. Injustice struck when Gloria won her trail and was given that right. 6 The law shows to be very unjust when 2 women from very similar backgrounds wanted to be euthanized but only one of them was granted the right. Canada is not ready to apply a law with such flexibility; it is not consistent. This makes the law unfit to play a part the Canadian criminal justice system.
Canada needs the medical advance that euthanasia would bring. Giving qualified physicians this kind of power to help and aid the terminally ill will show to be a great stride for the Canadian medical field, letting others have the benefit of the doubt. 7 The worry that the government faces is that physicians will abuse their power,...

Find Another Essay On Legalizing Euthanasia

Legalizing Active Euthanasia Essay

1107 words - 5 pages we decline in legalizing it or not (Keown 114). The arguments based on legalizing active euthanasia include that people in the world should be leaving a life that is worthwhile. By legalizing it, there will be increment in the death rate and life will be cheap. When the number of people in the country is low, the economy will grow and this will raise the living standard. In most of the court rulings, there are principles that have been put

Argument For Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

2968 words - 12 pages patients, some have reported feelings of isolation because they fear patients and colleagues will judge them. Some have also reported the feeling of grief because they felt responsible for their death. This argument against euthanasia suggests that legalizing assisted suicide might pressure physicians into being involved in something they don’t want to do, and might also cause emotional trauma (Stevens). It might also decrease the number of people

Argumentative Paper: Legalizing Euthanasia

1736 words - 7 pages be surrounded by loved ones. Allowing someone to die does not promise the presence of family and friends. The law does not stop a person who is trying to end their life. The final concern I would like to discuss is the Slippery Slope Argument, which basically is the very real possibility of euthanasia being abused within society. Legalizing euthanasia could tempt the corrupt into carrying out unthinkable acts. Our society has plenty of

The Cons of Legalizing Euthanasia

1293 words - 6 pages you are good as if nothing ever happened. The crime rate of homicide will go rising up and maybe even physician will be accused of murder as well. How will the physician be able to testify that the person wanted the death? Yes with a contract but what if it doesn’t go as plan or maybe the person no longer wants this will it be irrevocable? We are pretty much legalizing murder if legalized euthanasia. Our mind control many things if we

Legalizing Euthanasia

879 words - 4 pages of health, and the mending of the broken body. What happens when the body is past mending? Is euthanasia the answer? What do I believe?      Through discussions with my uncle, David Hollett M.D., and first hand observation of the suffering of loved ones close to death, I have come to the conclusion that when the body is past mending, the current practice by physicians is to medicate and provide a pain management program

Whose life is it? Reasons for legalizing euthanasia

1976 words - 8 pages liberty and allowing someone to suffer a terminal illness can be considered "cruel and unusual punishment". However, this is overlooking the obvious. Euthanasia is considered morally wrong and because of the legal, ethical and social impact it has in our society, it should never be legalized.The law is there to protect citizens so legalizing euthanasia would defeat its purpose. Physician- assisted suicide is too close to murder and has so far been

The Slippery Slope of Euthanasia

1289 words - 5 pages are not required in Netherlands. This would result in involuntary euthanasia and some people regard it as the first step towards the Nazi-style genocide [4]. They fear that euthanasia would be practised on government opponents ultimately. In summary, legalizing euthanasia may lead to something presently unthinkable being permitted. Apart from the ‘slippery slope’ argument, practising euthanasia is against the will of God. Christians and

A Deadly Controversy

1054 words - 5 pages In the United States, the debate over euthanasia ultimately comes down to ethics. The common misconception people form from this debate is that you should be either for or against euthanasia, but this controversy is not as black and white as it seems is should be. People often look to the two extremes of the situation: legalizing all forms of euthanasia, or banning euthanasia completely, but neither of these choices should be the solution. The

Physician-Assisted Suicide

1548 words - 6 pages death” (Nargus). “Euthanasia” refers to the ending of a life. It is also known as “mercy killing” (Nargus). The ancients Greeks were generally tolerant of suicide, however great philosophers such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle argued against assisted suicide (Uhlmann 25-32). This most likely influenced many Western countries to refrain from legalizing and practicing euthanasia until the 1900s. A “euthanasia” program in Nazi Germany killed 200,000

Euthanasia a Controversial and of Risky Practice

1728 words - 7 pages to keep their patients alive as said by the Hippocratic Oath ("Euthanasia"). The Encyclopedia of American Law also puts euthanasia into a class of criminal homicide ("debate.org"). Some people believe that legalizing euthanasia will target poor and disabled people and create encouragement for insurance companies. These insurance companies could have the power to terminate lives in order to save their money ("Euthanasia"). Others say that the

Euthanasia Should Be Legal and Inexpensive

1164 words - 5 pages life while denying them the means, manner, or information necessary for them to give away this life (Should). Humans have a constitutional right to live; therefore, humans should have a right to die, so Americans should become involved in a movement towards legalizing euthanasia. In 1994, Oregon was the first state to grant the ability to a terminally ill patient to get a physician’s prescription to end their life in a humane and dignified manner

Similar Essays

Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

2128 words - 9 pages Legalizing Euthanasia Euthanasia is an arising moral contemporary issue. A brief definition of euthanasia would be the intentional termination of life by another at the explicit request of the person who dies" (Netherlands State Commission on Euthanasia). This may look like an only solution to many people whose lives are seemingly wasting away, or have been fully spent. Whether we should let such people die is an argument that is yet to

Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

1008 words - 4 pages Legalizing Euthanasia "Whose life is it, anyway?" A Plea stated by the late Sue Rodrigues. Rogrigues, a high-profile, terminally-ill resident of British Columbia, Canada, suffered from a terminally ill disease (Robinson, 2001). She was helped to commit suicide by a physician in violation of Canadian law. Many people, like Rodrigues, want to be in control of their final days. Terminally ill patients have a terminal disease and do not

Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

676 words - 3 pages Legalizing EuthanasiaImagine waking up and seeing yourself lying in an uncomfortable hospital bed with crying family members around you. You see that there is a long cord connected to your heart. You try really hard to move, but you are too weak to get up. Would you want one of your family members to decide for you to no longer live or do you want the decision to live? In situations like the one I just described is when euthanasia comes into

Legalizing Voluntary Euthanasia Essay

1038 words - 4 pages , not to give doctors the easy option of euthanasia. There have been organizations supporting the legalization of voluntary euthanasia in Britain and in the US for years now. They have had some public support but were unable to achieve the goal of legalizing voluntary euthanasia in either nation. In England a society, called “The Voluntary Euthanasia Society” was founded to make voluntary euthanasia legal for an adult that is suffering. The