Legislative Proposal For New Indecency Language In Telecom Bill

2870 words - 11 pages

Legislative Proposal for New Indecency Language in Telecom Bill.I. SummaryAlthough the October 16, 1995 legislative proposal purports to regulate "computer pornography", the proposal contains fatal flaws which render the proposal at best counterproductive and at worst devastating to on-line communications. First, it prohibits, but fails to define, "indecent" speech to minors -- a dangerously vague, medium-specific, and, after decades of litigation, still undefined concept, which may include mere profanity. This may tie up successful prosecution of the law in courts for years to come, while courts wrestle to divine a constitutional definition of "indecent" -- and while companies are left with uncertain liability.Second, the October 16 proposal may actually hold systems liable for communications over which they have no specific knowledge or control. The proposal purports to target those who "knowingly" send prohibited communications -- itself a relatively low standard of liability that may not even require actual intent or willfulness. Nevertheless, because the proposal i) defines the elements of criminal liability in vague and contradictory terms, and ii) eliminates safeharbors in the Senate bill that would define a clear standard of care, it might hold systems liable for actions that don't reach even a "knowingly" standard of liability. As a result, access providers, system managers and operators, and employers may potentially be liable for actions of users over which they have no specific knowledge, intent, or control.For any company that communicates by computer, the proposal:1) Creates liability for, but never defines, "indecent" speech, a dangerously vague standard that could leave companies criminally liable for use of mere profanity;2) Establishes vague and contradictory standards of liability that could leave innocent companies vicariously liable for communications over which they have no control;3) Strips workable affirmative defenses from the Senate bill, eliminating a clear standard of care for companies.Not only does the proposal endanger companies, it fails to protect children. The indecency standard guarantees that enforcement will be tied up in the courts for years to come. Companies will be particularly reticent to identify and eradicate prohibited communications when they are incapable of discerning which communications are "indecent" and when the company's consequent knowledge of the communications may actually make them liable. At worst, the proposal will either shut down systems entirely or will shut down any attempts to constructively monitor and screen systems, as providers take a know-nothing stance to avoid prosecution for purported knowledge.II. The "Indecency" Standard and Uncertain and Conflicting Standards of Culpability Implicate Innocent Companies But Fail To Protect Children.A. The undefined "indecency" standard is possibly unenforceable and certainly counterproductive.Although the October 16 proposal purports to...

Find Another Essay On Legislative proposal for new indecency language in telecom bill

Proposal for a Skate Park in Nacogdoches

1332 words - 5 pages of skating something; somewhere, get broke. There has never been any attempt, whatsoever to get a skate park here in Nacogdoches. This is the reason why there are so many skaters out at night skateboarding on the public sidewalks. This is also presents a problem for the police because there are many places that are great for skating, but are restricted by city ordinances. However, there is always some zealous skater who will brave it and

Research Proposal: Depression in Children & Adolescence - A Cause for Concern?

3290 words - 13 pages unhappiness with the new child centered permissive culture being a godsend to consumer capitalism. He suggests that there may be a genuine increase in the amount of unhappiness experienced by children as a result of growing up in a cultural context that has seen huge changes in child rearing practices, family structures, lifestyles and education. Changes in Western economies, working practice in competitive global markets and capitalism's need for never

Business Memo for A proposal to Jiffy Lube to purchase a new piece of shop equipment for fuel system service.

1357 words - 5 pages audience for my proposal based upon the nature of the service they provide, which is limited to a preventative maintenance level only and not actually providing repair services. In order for Jiffy Lube to continue to provide valued service to its customers, it is important that actions be taken to counter the effects of fuel system deposits in customers' vehicles.SubjectPurposeI would like to recommend the purchase and implementation of a new

Project Proposal for a new computer system at a bank...Customer Assist and how the company will improve.

1190 words - 5 pages associates. Computer Banking Programs of America bid and completion cost to create and train employees on the new program came with in the allotted 25 to 30 thousand dollar budget. This included creation of the program, training for employees, installing software and technical support for the next two years. This does not include purchasing of hardware, which will be purchased from a separate budget.Management will receive 40 hours of training and

Language, Action and Time in Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot

2218 words - 9 pages Language, Action and Time in Waiting for Godot Twenty-two hundred years before the emergence of the Theater of the Absurd, the Greek philosopher Artistotle stumbled upon one of the themes developed in Samuel Beckett's play Waiting for Godot; that is, that Thought (Dianoia) is expressed through Diction and that Thought (Theoria) is in itself a form of Action (Energeia). Intellectual action is thus measured equally in comparison to physical

In Animal Farm, how is language important for gaining power.

1197 words - 5 pages Language is a very powerful tool that can be manipulated to become an instrument of control. Put differently, it can become a resource for accumulating great amounts of power, but if abused, can eventually lead to huge adversities. A quintessential example of this is the novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell. In this novel, a pig, which is the leader of animals on a farm, sets out his Utopian ideals of what might become of the future of Animal

Technology and Language in Education: The Effect of New Technology on Teaching Languages

1604 words - 6 pages Technology and Language in Education: The Effect of New Technology on Teaching Languages Annie Moore, a 15-year-old girl from Ireland arrived at Ellis Island in New York City on January 1, 1892. She was the first immigrant to come to that United States immigration station, but she was certainly not the last. According to the U.S. Census Bureau (2000), 28.4 million of the 285.2 million US residents in 2000 were foreign-born. With such a

Proposal for AaNew Health Care System Identify Your Vision, List Advantages and Disadvantaged and any New Problems Your Proposed System Would Create.

1052 words - 4 pages provider in the country. It would also reduce the need for patients to seek care in emergency rooms. Americans would benefit from the electronic access to their health care workers. In addition, the benefits of the single billing structure would reduce patient and insurance company financial obligations therefore, reducing the cost of health care. These are current challenges I believe would be resolved with my new proposal. Disadvantages would however

A New Role for Women in The Great Gatsby

1890 words - 8 pages . Due to the growing popularity of department stores, many jobs arose for women in retail. Many women also took up jobs as phone operators. The website went on to describe that women also experienced a lot of new freedom during the 1920s because they had just been given the right to vote (“Flappers”). The Clash of Cultures website described how women had more control over the money they earned during the 1920s. Since parents had less supervision

Utilising Ginseng in a New Skin-Care Product for China

2032 words - 8 pages preferences of the consumers in China. Incorporating the use of ginseng, a natural Chinese herb that has anti-ageing properties, in a new anti-ageing skin cream product will appeal to Chinese consumers and entice them to buy the product. Explanations on how my strategy will help reduce our reliance on the European economies for revenue will be given in the following sections. 2. Trends in China’s Skin-Care Market The market for anti-ageing products

The Motivations for Criminal Behavior in Post Katrina New Orleans.

1833 words - 7 pages helping each other out.E. Conclusion.In conclusion, I am not suggesting that no violent crimes occurred in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. "New Orleans was not crime-free in Katrina's aftermath. People were seen on television taking things from stores. Some were items to eat, drink or wear--what the police call "essential items," for which people were not being arrested because the situation was so dire. Others took television sets, jewelry

Similar Essays

Use Of Humor And Language Techniques In Monbiot's Article "Modest Proposal For Youth Scourge"

553 words - 2 pages In the article “Modest Proposal for Youth Scourge”, we see George Monbiot expressing his opinion about young people. Monbiot is making fun of those in society who want to go to extreme methods to keep youth out of public places - by using emotive and figurative language, tone and humour. At the beginning of the article, particularly in the first paragraph, you believe that Monbiot is serious about the topic. But by the end of the second

Proposal For A New University Admissions System

2597 words - 10 pages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.0         Main Elements of New System . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1         Reasoning for using Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.0         Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.0         Introduction In designing a new system there are a number of issues that need to be addressed. Firstly we need to know the purpose of the system; what it will be used for, how

Proposal For Entertainment Venues In Waldorf, Maryland

972 words - 4 pages these activities, but the rate at which they occur would drop. Waldorf is neglecting to notice the profit and social growth that would result from issuing a stipend of just $12,000 to jumpstart new entertainment facilities. Obviously the current businesses in place are not enough to put our city on the map, or to interest its youth. I urge our community to step forward, and our city officials to regard this with care. My proposal is best for the

Policy Proposal For Economic Reform In Russia

2761 words - 11 pages Policy Proposal for Economic Reform in Russia Despite making a recovery after the 1998 market crash, Russia remains weighted with numerous holdovers from the Communist era that keep its economy from taking advantage of free-market reforms. In short, Russia has not prospered under capitalism because it has not yet discovered it. In order to do so, the Russian government must engage in extensive reform in several key areas: improving the rule