Legitimacy Of Happiness To Evaluate Societies’ Performances: Hedonic Treadmill/ Adaptation Theory

2054 words - 8 pages

Happiness (Subjective Well-Being):
For centuries, the basis of philosophical, religious and scholarly debate has been happiness and what the nature of a good life is. In writings on happiness, a common theme is that happiness is relative; hence, the idea of Subjective Well-Being (SWB) came about. SWB refers to the fact that people subjectively feels and perceives or believes their lives are “desirable, pleasant, and good” (Diener, pg. 1). However, even this subjective definition of the good life varies amongst philosophers and scholars. To this, only in the last several decades have they turned to science for explanation.
Initially, one of the reasons sociologists and other behavioral scientists began this happiness research was to evaluate the performance of societies, assuming that happiness levels reveal whether a nation is meeting human needs (Diener, pg. 2). To this, conflicts arose as many anthropologists and sociologists doubted that happiness could reflect true human progress. In support to this objection was the theory that people will adapt to the circumstances of their societies such that all people will eventually be equivalent in terms of happiness (Diener, pg. 2). Additionally, the theory of subjective comparison, leading to the discussion of hedonic adaptation, suggests that happiness is both futile and evasive as it does not depend on objective good: hence, “futile” because a happy life may not necessarily equate to a good life and “evasive” because standards tend to rise with success, making the person as unhappy as before (Veenhoven, pg. 2). In other words, people will report similar levels of happiness despite conditions getting better or worse because humans are prone to adapting to external events and, thus, their needs will simply adjust with changes in their lives. Likewise, despite the wide assumption that material circumstances greatly affect people’s happiness, numerous studies suggest that they are hardly correlated at all. Hence, by this, promoting happiness made little sense at all to those who questioned the legitimacy of happiness in truly evaluating human progress.
Theories of Adaptation:
According to the adaptation level theory by Helson, people perceive objects in relative terms to a level established by previous experiences (Mochon, pg. 633). Thus, a positive event leads to short run increases in SWB. However, in the long run, people habituate to the new experience given by the positive event; hence, diminished the event’s positive effect (Mochon, pg. 634). Thus, adaptation to events refers to when events can initially produce happiness or unhappiness but, over time, those events lose their power to evoke affect (Diener, pg. 45). With this adaptation, good events no longer evoke happiness just as bad events no longer evoke unhappiness. In further support of this adaptation theory, Brickman and Campbell proposed, in 1971, that though current events are better than the standard (making the individual happy),...

Find Another Essay On Legitimacy of Happiness to Evaluate Societies’ Performances: Hedonic Treadmill/ Adaptation Theory

Review of Hutcheon's A Theory of Adaptation

695 words - 3 pages reason of the popularity of adaptations nowadays might be explained with financial facts. It is simply because if something made profit and was popular once, there is a high possibility of it will do the same once more, and even more sequels can be made, the risks would be minimal, the profits maximized. If we dwell deeper into the theory of adaptation, we might realize, that they have a “double nature”. Adapters do not only want to repeat or

Linda Hutcheon’s A Theory of Adaptation

1481 words - 6 pages , when the same story – or an element of the story - is used in various different media, it will inevitably spark debates on which one is superior. Adaptations often get frowned upon for appropriating and exploiting their adapted texts. There are many questions and doubts surrounding adaptation, such as what can be adapted and why are certain works easier to adapt. Linda Hutcheon’s book, A Theory of Adaptation examines these issues and attempts to

Critically evaluate of Internationalisation theory

671 words - 3 pages Critically evaluate of Internationalisation theoryOne of the prominent trends in the contemporary world is claimed to be globalisation. The term entails many different meanings and perspectives for global business. There are at least the four viewpoints concerning the business of internationalization: Transaction Cost Theory, Uppsala Module, Internationalisation from a Network Perspective and International Product Life Cycle Theory (IPLC

Evaluate the functionalist theory of the family

1393 words - 6 pages Evaluate the functionalist theory of the familyIn this essay, I intend to analyse some of the theories behind the functionalist perspective of the family, it is my intention to look at two main theorists in this field, Murdock and Parsons. I to analyse their theories and give objective argument for the pros and cons of the functionalist family. I intend to break this down by looking at the theorists separately and then looking at arguments

Evaluate Kuhn’s theory of scientific development

1541 words - 7 pages . Most importantly, Kuhn seek to find if were possibility for science to discover the truth. This essay will look at Thomas Kuhn’s theory of scientific development. It will begin with an explanation of the theory, and then will state some of its impact of science. It will then show and evaluate some weakness of Kuhn’s theory; assessing and mentioning the views of a number of scientists’ academics critical of Kuhn's concept of paradigms. Finally, it


1799 words - 8 pages birth to the philosophy of science (Okasha, 2002). Several perspectives of scientific theories have been postulated by many on the history and philosophy of science. One of such is the Kuhn theory of science development postulated by Thomas Kuhn. His theory brought about a new perspective where scientific theories are placed in an umbrella of a grand theory called the paradigm. Thomas Kuhn who was born in 1922 in Cincinnati, studied physics at

Two Nursing Theories: Theory on Human Caring and Theory of Adaptation

1051 words - 4 pages Nurse Theorist who developed the theory of adaptation. Roy’s theory views the client as an adaptive system an our goal as nurses is to help the patient adapt to the various changes related to health and illness including physiological needs, self-concept, role function and interdependence. If the client is unable to adapt to these changes then nurses must provide care to help them fulfill those needs (Potter & Perry, 2005, p. 69). “Serious

Evaluate social identity theory, making reference to relevant studies

1042 words - 5 pages Social identity theory, it is a person’s sense that is based around the group they are in, either by their personal identity or with different kinds of social identities. That is, people will try to improve their own image of themselves. The theory was proposed by Henri Tajfel. People can increase their self-esteem by both their own achievement and interaction with a successful group of people. This shows the importance of social belonging. This

Rousseau's arguments for "forcing one to be free" to ensure the legitimacy of civil commitments

757 words - 3 pages Jean-Jacques Rousseau claims that in order to ensure the legitimacy of civil commitments and to prevent them from becoming meaningless, tyrannical, and abusive, one can be "forced to be free." It is unclear, however, how forcing citizens to conform to the general will leads to a society which is any more reliable and capable of sustaining itself than the arbitrary rule of a few power-hungry individuals.When a society forms a social contract

5. In TEXT 3, Belinda McKeon refers to the tension between the everyday treadmill and the gilded promises of Grand Central Station. Write a person

1109 words - 5 pages everyday treadmill of life is a cycle. It’s a monotonous circle which seems to be never-ending but that, of course, is not true. It’s your daily routine; get up in the morning to the sound of a harsh alarm clock, taste the textured peanut-butter as you rush to swallow it before you must be gone, board a fuel-reeking bus, arrive at the school watching herds of identically-clad students milling by the door, and feel the hard plastic pen in your hand

What does the notion of legitimacy and social contract have to do with corporate disclosure policies?

2666 words - 11 pages corporation which are held by important groups within society. Furthermore, organisations might use the disclosures as a defend policy when the organisation's legitimacy is in threat (ibid).In this study, we will focus on the role of social contracts and organisation legitimacy, and how can these aspects influence managers' policies to corporate reporting. We will first examine the underlying literature of legitimacy theory and social contracts

Similar Essays

Legitimacy Of Happiness To Evaluate Societies’ Performances: Hedonic Treadmill/ Adaptation Theory

1412 words - 6 pages to remain longer and induce even further happiness. Hence, in this way, gains in happiness can be sustained over time without be slowed by the adaptation process. Similar to Sheldon and Lyubomirsky, Fredrickson and others suggest using the Loving-Kindness Meditation (LKM), which lies within the framework of the broaden-and-build theory, to resolve the limitations of the hedonic treadmill. According to Fredrickson’s broaden-and-build theory of

Roy's Theory Of Adaptation Essay

1670 words - 7 pages has continued to refine her theory of adaptation, addressing its limitations and expanding upon philosophical insights (Roy, 2009). Today, Roy’s theory is one of the most commonly used frameworks in nursing, guiding research, education, and clinical practice (Shosha & Al kalaldeh, 2012). Hence, the purpose of this essay is to provide an in-depth review of Sister Callista Roy’s adaptation model and discuss its contributions to nursing research and

Hedonic Eating: The Pleasures Of Eating And How It Causes Happiness

938 words - 4 pages Hedonic Eating is a term that refers eating for the sake of pleasure. Current research shows that the act of eating for pleasure is fairly common. Many factors contribute to why an individual may gain pleasure from eating including, brain activity caused by eating, environmental conditions, differences in what a person finds pleasurable, social influence and whether or not it has become an addiction for them. The common consensus of all the

Applying Ralf Dahrendorf's Conflict Theory To Pusuit Of Happiness

1550 words - 6 pages Conflict theory is a perspective that emphasizes the social, political, or material inequality of a particular social group. Conflict theory attempts to highlight the ideological aspects inherent in traditional thought, and while these different perspectives hold parallels, conflict theory does not have a unified school of thought on these theories. Conflict theorists see where groups fight for power, and the control of conflict means that one