Lgbt Equal Rights: It's Time To Legalize Sodomy

2595 words - 10 pages

      "The only part of the conduct of anyone, for which he is amenable to society, is that which concerns others. In the part which merely concerns himself, his independence is, of right, absolute... The principle requires liberty of taste and pursuit; of framing the plan of our life to suit our own character; doing as we like, subject to such consequences as may follow; without impediment from our fellow creatures, so long as what we do does not harm them, even though they should think our conduct foolish, perverse or wrong." This quote from John Stuart Mill's On Liberty, lays out the philosophical groundwork for the right to privacy. Although the United States Constitution does not explicitly guarantee this right, the Supreme Court through landmark cases such as Roe v Wade, Griswold v. Connecticut, and Eisenstadt v. Baird have judicially established privacy rights under limited zones relating to marriage, procreation, contraception, family relationships, childrearing, and education.

 

The Supreme Court has resolved, by a vote of five to four that the "Constitution provided no fundamental right to engage in homosexual sodomy." (Bowers v. Hardwick) This paper will show that the analysis behind the Bowers v. Hardwick decision was flawed and limited in scope. I believe that the government does not have the right to prohibit homosexual or heterosexual consensual sodomy. Anti-sodomy laws violate the right to privacy, equal protection, and provide no reasonable compelling state interest for these violations.

 

On August 3, 1982, Michael Hardwick was arrested in Atlanta for the crime of sodomy with a consenting adult male in the privacy of his own bedroom. (Cain, 1612) The Georgia statute provides that "a person commits the offense of sodomy when he performs or submits to any sexual act involving the sex organ of one person and the mouth or anus of another." (Cain 1613) Currently, 24 states and the district of Columbia provide criminal sanctions against individuals who commit acts of consensual sodomy in the privacy of their own bedroom. (Halley, 1750) Hardwick petitioned the court on the grounds that Georgia's anti-sodomy act was unconstitutional. The Hardwick case was decided by the Supreme Court in June of 1986. Although the Court formed an opinion regarding homosexual sodomy, "it did not comment on whether laws prohibiting heterosexual sodomy violate the right to privacy of heterosexuals." (Catania, 296)

 

The Supreme Court believed that the right to commit acts of sodomy are not entitled to constitutional protection because the right in question must be either "implicit in the concept of ordered liberty" or "deeply rooted in this nation's history and tradition." (Laveno, 1032) When writing the majority opinion, Justice White stated that laws against sodomy have ancient roots. These acts were forbidden by common law and in the laws of all 13 original states. According to the court the right to engage in acts of sodomy have...

Find Another Essay On LGBT Equal Rights: It's Time to Legalize Sodomy

It’s Time to Legalize Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1776 words - 7 pages It’s Time to Legalize Embryonic Stem Cell Research In the United States of America, people have many rights and freedoms that are respected by the Federal Government. As stated in Civil Disobedience by Henry David Thoreau: “There will never be a truly free and enlightened state until the state comes to recognize the individual as a higher and independent power” (225). In the goal to make America a truly free and enlightened state, laws have

America, It's Time to STOP World Policing

1114 words - 4 pages The United States was founded on the principals that every person was due equality, liberty and freedom as per the nations Constitution. The Constitution declared these principals not only for the citizens of the United States, but in principal expressed these rights to the people of the world. It was the expression of these rights that has led the United States to stand on the World Stage and work to insure that those who cant peruse or

It's Time to End Poverty in America

1043 words - 4 pages For those who live an impoverished life, it is difficult to participate in society. They are left behind in our cultural movement because they lack the necessities to be on an equal level with the rest of society. Because the poor cannot get their basic needs for life, they cannot improve their well-being; therefore, our society as a whole cannot efficiently move in new directions. As Jo Goodwill Parker states in "What is Poverty," she

It's Time to Stop Child Trafficking

2003 words - 8 pages child trafficking by we are known. Nowadays, most countries have better laws to protect their own citizens. Moreover, as time goes by, people are receiving a higher quality education and are more protected by the state and government, so it would make sense that there would be fewer criminals involved in human trafficking. However, the UNICEF website shows that “Every year, thousands of Beninese children and 1.2 million young people across the

It's Time to Allow Medical Marijuana

509 words - 2 pages It's Time to Allow Medical Marijuana Think of the word cannabis. What immediately comes into your mind? Druggies out on the streets, totally out of it and swaggering around like drunks? Many people are under these false images. Cannabis users are classed as the lowest of the low, drug abusers and criminals. Well, here is the truth about Cannabis. It is also known as Marijuana, Dope, Grass, Ganja, Weed, Puff, Gear, and Hash, is a

It's Time to Move Beyond Fossil Fuels

883 words - 4 pages It's Time to Move Beyond Fossil Fuels to Environmentally Friendly Energy Sources Fossil fuels, the main fuel for firing power stations for electricity, heating homes, and providing fuel for transport, have been used for many years. Despite their relative inexpensiveness, fossil fuels have major drawbacks. They introduce a myriad of negative implications including environmental degradation, global warming, acid rain, health

It's Time to Stop Global Warming

1296 words - 5 pages It's Time to Stop Global Warming (Minor Formatting Problem) Global warming is cused by the "greenhouse effect". The importance of the greenhouse effect was just conceived in the mid-twentieth century. 'For billions of years, cosmic forces shaped Earth, and land and air coevolved at an almost inconceivably slow pace to create a climate in which human beings and other creatures could flourish.' (Franscesca Lyman). Now, for the first time

It's Time to End the Drug War

2727 words - 11 pages It's Time to End the Drug War Uhh, uhhh B.I.G., P-O, P-P-A No info, for the, DEA Federal agents mad cause I'm flagrant Tap my cell, and the phone in the basement -Notorious B.I.G. lyrics from “Mo’ Money, Mo’ Problems” In Christopher Wallace’s (a.k.a. Notorious BIG) “Mo’ Money, Mo’ Problems”, the late rapper from Brooklyn mentions his run in with the police earlier in his life. Christopher Wallace came to be known as arguably the

It's Time to Put An End To Sex Trafficking

2051 words - 8 pages a woman she should have equal rights as the men and the people of higher castes do. Meena is a valiant fighter that should be looked upon as a hero to hopeless young girls in brothels worldwide.(Half the Sky, pgs 3-16) By now I hope that it is clear that sex trafficking is an unacceptable reality that has to be stopped. So how do we eradicate it? Raising awareness always helps with donations for companies that help force raids of brothels and

It's Time to Reconsider America's Right to Bear Arms

1297 words - 5 pages , remember that the Bill of Rights was written during the British occupancy of America during the Revolutionary War. In this time, America lacked an organized army, and relied on a militia of armed citizens to protect the country. In fact, most pro-gun control lobbyists argue that the right granted in the Second Amendment is only the right of a militia, a right satisfied by the American Armed Forces. Second, remember that the “arms” in the

Amusing Ourselves to Death: It's Time to Stop Laughing

2283 words - 9 pages Amusing Ourselves to Death: It's Time to Stop Laughing       The form of communication created by the television is not only a part of how our modern society communicates, but is has changed public discourse to the point that it has completely redefined it, argued Neil Postman in his convincing book Amusing Ourselves to Death. He viewed this as very harmful, and additionally so because our society is ignorant of it as they quickly becomes

Similar Essays

It's Time To Legalize Drugs Essay

3019 words - 12 pages guaranteed by our Constitution.” In “Legalize Drugs Now!: An Analysis of the Benefits of Legalized Drugs” authors Meaghan Cussen and Walter Block, explain that due to drug prohibition. We no longer have the basic civil liberty to pursue our own happiness. Current drug laws have in a way taken away our liberties we are no longer free to choose whether or not we consume drugs. The only way to restore our rights as granted by the Constitution and the

It's Time To Limit Animal Rights

1091 words - 4 pages definition doesn't take sides in the debate by stating which rights are inherent to a being. That debate is left to the writer's argument. The writer first argues that it's at least theoretically possible for animals to have rights. He argues that, since society has no philosophical reasoning which proves that humans are entitled to any rights, and because we simply accept that we have certain rights, animals can potentially have rights under the

Marriage Inequality In America Spotlighting Equal Rights For The Lgbt Community

2475 words - 10 pages the various stances on marriage, civil unions, and equal rights in regards to the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) community it is fundamentally important to follow Jefferson’s cue and approach the varied perspectives with an open mind. With the average person’s opinion on marriage equality having been shaped by their upbringing it is important to review not only the arguments of the Democrat and Republican parties, but also the

It Is Time To Legalize Marijuana

3074 words - 12 pages attitude toward marijuana and whether or not it should be legalized. During the time of illegalization of marijuana, the drug had a vastly negative feeling associated with it, which many people now believe to be inaccurate and unfair. Now that people are more informed, more connected and more vocal, the United States government should allow and even encourage more research of the dangers and addictive nature of the drug which will assuredly legalize