This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Liberalism Vs The Hobbesian Theory Of Human Nature

6765 words - 27 pages

 
The attempt to fuse the public and the private lies behind both Plato's attempt to answer the question "Why is it in one's interest to be just?" and Christianity's claim that perfect self-realization can be attained through service to others.  Such metaphysical or theological attempts to unite a striving for perfection with a sense of community require us to acknowledge a common human nature.  They ask us to believe that what is most important to each of us is what we have in common with others - that the springs of private fulfillment and of human solidarity are the same.
CIS, xiii
This passage represents the Plato-Kant tradition to which Richard Rorty's book Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity is opposed.  In his book Rorty presents a historicist philosophy in which he separates the public sphere of human life from the private sphere.  In the private sphere of our lives we should create ourselves, or more accurately, poetically redescribe ourselves.  But, as it is with all theories of self-creation, Rorty inherits the problem of developing a moral guideline that will prevent one individual's project of self-creation from harming an other's.  In an attempt to provide such a guideline Rorty introduces "liberalism."  He believes that an individual should conduct himself as a "liberal" in the public sphere.  Rorty defines a liberal as one "who believes that cruelty is the worst thing we do" (CIS, 146). A true liberal will feel an obligation not to be cruel to others and will try to increase his sphere of solidarity to encompass as many people as possible.  Rorty believes that a moral guideline will arise from his ironist interpretation of liberalism.  I contend that Rorty's ironist liberalism is incompatible with, and inhibits, his more important project of self-creation.  I intend to show that Rorty's liberalism is incoherent.  In light of this failure of ironist liberalism I will provide a new basis for a moral guideline for self-creation that arises from the philosophy of Thomas Hobbes.  Before I present an alternate "moral guideline" I will lay out Rorty's concept of self-creation and liberalism.
Rorty rejects traditional moral theory because of its reliance on a common human nature or essence.  He defines human essence as being that "something within each of us . . . which resonates to the presence of this same thing in other human beings" (CIS, 189).  Rorty rejects the concept of a common essence shared by all human beings regardless of historical or social context.  Because of his rejection of human nature Rorty argues against "attempts to unite a striving for perfection with a sense of community" because such a synthesis necessarily requires presupposing a common human nature.  That is to say, there is no single response that adequately answers both "How should I live my life?", and "How should I treat others?" that does not depend on metaphysical presuppositions.  In order to avoid such presuppositions, Rorty abandons all attempts to...

Find Another Essay On Liberalism vs the Hobbesian Theory of Human Nature

The Human Nature of Medea Essay

2040 words - 8 pages Euripides' contemporaries and classical scholars alike point out the non-Aristotelean elements in Medea, this might intimidate today's reader. Euripides, instead of following the guidelines established by Aristotle in his Poetics, has a stirring psychological truth of human nature. This is clear when we examine the monologues given by Medea during the play. Each speech develops the character and creates a certain audience empathy. Medea is not a

Nature vs. Nurture: Leaning Towards the Nurture Theory

2205 words - 9 pages (Morton). Overall, the nature theory may have some research to back up its argument, but much of it is based on inconclusive genetics research. While the nurture theory has over a century’s worth of research to substantiate its claims, the study of human genetics is a relatively new subject with only a few decades of research. One of the major studies done on human genetics is the Human Genome Project. This project began over two decades ago with

Nature vs Nurture Theory: Alcoholism

845 words - 4 pages The Nature vs Nurture Theory is one the most controversial debate topics in Psychology. This debate has been going on for years now. The Nature argument is supported by genetics and what is hereditary to a person. Psychologists who support the “nature” theory concentrate on what an individual is born with. For example, they focus on genes, DNA, personality traits and other qualities they just can’t change about themselves. Researches focusing

The Transformation of Liberalism

2879 words - 12 pages been lost in the conversion into modern liberalism. In order to answer this, the areas of freedom, the role of government, human nature, and the function of law should be addressed. While this may not be a complete register of change in liberalism, research into these subjects can provide strong indications toward the nature of this transition. Objectively, the evidence suggests that many of the ideas of classical liberalism were either abandoned

Similarities And Differences Of Books About Human Vs. Nature

609 words - 2 pages The stories I am going to discuss about are: "Wine on the Desert," by Max Brand, "To Build a Fire," by Jack London, and "The Birds," by Daphne Du Maurier. These stories deal with the conflict of human versus nature. This paper focuses more on what the stories are and how I interpreted them. Other things that are included in this paper are the summaries, comparing, and contrasting. What I'm trying to show with these is the

Human Development: Nature vs. Nurture

1643 words - 7 pages affect human development. Naturally, the nature versus nurture debate relates to many controversies such as intelligence, gender identities, violent behaviors, and sexual orientation. There are countless studies on whether intelligence is an inherited trait or if it is influenced by environmental factors. A study was conducted with adopted children and non-adopted children to see if a conclusion can be made based on the influence of hereditary and

Nature vs. Nurture and the Impacts on Human Intelligence

2276 words - 9 pages education. A higher emphasis is placed on that individual's educational future. This act in itself alters the environmental influence on the individual's intelligence. From the examples used in this paper we can see an argument for environmental influences taking shape as the majority defining factor of an individual's intelligence level. I conclude that while both nature and nurture have varying influences on human development, it is the

The Enlightenment View of Human Nature

1643 words - 7 pages new species has organised to meet its needs. About the human nature, In rival beliefs it is often embodied in different individual ways of life and in potential and economic systems. whereas, Marxist theory takes over the general public of humans in the society due to the fact that he dominated with his communist rules of the twentieth century that any kinds of questioning could have consequences and it can be quite

Lord of the flies human nature

906 words - 4 pages The Revolt of Human Nature Human nature can find its way through people as young as school age. In The Lord Of the Flies byWilliam Golding, a group of school age boys are stranded on an island and have to fend for themselves. After time each child shows his feelings in very severe ways. Ralph, Jack and Piggy all have very different characteristics and ideas and try to express them constantly. Some, although, take much more extreme actions

Lord of the flies-human nature

858 words - 3 pages The Revolt of Human NatureHuman nature can find its way through people as young as school age. In The Lord Of the Flies by William Golding, a group of school age boys are stranded on an island and have to fend for themselves. After time each child shows his feelings in very severe ways. Ralph, Jack and Piggy all have very different characteristics and ideas and try to express them constantly. Some, although, take much more extreme actions to

Human Nature in Lord of the Flies

659 words - 3 pages appreciate the island's beauty as opposed to being their graveyard. These are examples of how Golding counters his own belief in the book Lord of the Flies.Lastly, there is the rational belief in human nature. In real life, what is evil? Why kill? What is the difference between Hitler and Gandhi? The fact is, the nature of people is not evil, but that of an animal. The clownfish and sea anemone do not fight, but coexist for mutual beneficence. But

Similar Essays

Human Nature In Realism And Liberalism

2441 words - 10 pages 2009, XI 2). With the inevitable and constant struggle for power, Hobbes contributed to conceptualize human nature, which became fundamental in realism. Hobbes characterized human nature as egoistic within the state of nature, and introduces the social contract theory in order for man to survive in anarchy. Singh furthermore explains how one of the most significant political philosophers, Thomas Hobbes viewed the principle of the universe, as made

Liberalism Vs Conservatism And The Blurring Of Lines

1443 words - 6 pages People can often be heard spewing nonsensical political jargon such as belonging to either the “Right” or “Left”, but what exactly does belonging to and holding such positions mean? There are a countless many political parties to which one can belong and although there are those who believe that they can be broken into the two categories and schools of thought; namely that of Liberalism and Conservatism, they are, without a doubt, completely

The Roots Of Human Nature Essay

690 words - 3 pages The Roots of Human Nature The roots of human nature are sunk deep into our history and experiences. When in our own lives we are to find the basis of our human nature, we must look to our early years, the formative years. Now take for example if we placed a newborn in the wild or in a high-class, well-mannered, wealthy family. The human nature of the newborn in the wild will be exactly that, wild and chaotic. While on the other hand the

The Duality Of Human Nature Essay

1038 words - 5 pages In The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Robert Louis Stevenson expresses the concept of the duality of man. Using gothic literature, he depicts the idea of man’s doubled nature. Stevenson demonstrates through the character Henry Jekyll the duality of human nature and the constant battle of good and evil inside all individuals. In Victorian society, maintaining a good reputation is of utmost importance (Perkins 207). For instance, Dr