Library Selection Policy Essay

956 words - 4 pages

In order for a school to have an effective Selection Policy, there must be basic components to it. This author will attempt to compare the Selection Policy from Canutillo ISD to the components presented by the American Library Association. The ALA article states “a good policy on the selection of instructional materials will be relevant to your particular system and include basic sections on objectives, responsibility, criteria, procedures for selection, reconsideration of materials, and policies on controversial materials.” (Workbook for Selection Policy Writing, Revised 1999)
The Selection Policy from Canutillo ISD contains an objectives component. It summarizes the District’s directives in allowing “District professional staff to select and acquire instructional resources.” (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002) The objectives section includes the definition of “instructional resources”, which this author feels could use further explanation of what “supplemental materials, electronic resources, and any other materials” comprise. (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002)
The primary statement of policy includes the following: “Although trained professional staff is afforded the freedom to select instructional resources for their use in accordance with this policy and the state mandated curriculum, the ultimate authority for determining and approving the curriculum and instructional program of the District lies with the Board.” (CISD Board Policy EFA, 2002) There is no clarification of whom the trained professional staff is. This statement would be more effective in the objectives component so that the public is aware of where the final selection decision resides.
The CISD Selection Policy does not contain a procedure for acquiring resources. This component is imperative because the public will be aware of the extensive process that goes into acquiring resources. Those responsible for the selection of resources should be able to view and evaluate all sources that can provide all types of resources and curriculum needs. Some of the more common sources are “bibliographies (latest edition available including supplements), such as Children’s Catalog, Middle and Junior High Core Collection, Senior High Core Collection, and Non book Materials Core Collection.” (Workbook for Selection Policy Writing, Revised 1999)
Not only should the responsible parties evaluate bibliographies, but they should also consult current reviewing media. Because of the vastness of information on the internet, there are myriads of reviews available. However, those responsible for the selection of resources should be careful in their choice of reviewing media. The responsible parties should carefully examine the media and determine what are the criteria and policies of the reviewer. They should also ensure that the review provides information not only about the content of the book but also of the quality of the material. Therefore, as a rule, the responsible parties tend to...

Find Another Essay On Library Selection Policy

Managing Library Education Essay

4527 words - 18 pages theoretical thinking behind both the technology and the profession.Swigger (2000) asked if there had to be one way.He points out that “. . . choice is in fact the essence of human condition:more options than any individual can pursue.”In the information age “review and selection are essential.”The same could be applied to library schools. Trying to design a library and information science school with a one-size-fits-all mentality just will not

Freedom of speech

5194 words - 21 pages telecomms, that information intermediaries, let alone traditional libraries, may be obsolescent (see Figure 5).Yet another model for us to consider is the pre-selection and post-selection approach. Censorship has always thrown up the question of whether good materials in a library simply "select themselves", and that selection is only a more socially acceptable word for censorship. Librarians are looking for value for money and quality

Staffing and Selection

1108 words - 4 pages talent. When attempting to acquire new talent, Bank of America encompasses a wide range of staffing practices and selection tools. In response to diversity and technology trends, Bank of America’s staffing practices are effective in meeting current and future employment needs of the organization.      Bank of America’s multicultural supplier and development program began in 1990. The program increased the amount of quality

Analysis the admission policy of primary and secondary schools in the UK

2122 words - 8 pages that, the status of current selection process will be discussed. Thirdly, the advantage and the problems will be evaluated. The last part of this report will show some suggestion for solving the problems, like improving the quality of local schools and punishing “address cheats”. 2. History Admission policy has undergone a series of changes and developments since Butler’s 1944 Education Act set up compulsory primary (5-11 years) and secondary

Filtering Software is Unnecessary

1804 words - 7 pages cannot ensure that material which does not fit it's selection policy will not get through. The Internet is constantly growing with new websites emerging daily. It is impossible for any filtering company to know every potentially harmful website. As Kranlin (2003) notes, “Only about 1.5 percent of Internet sites are considered pornographic; and of those, the best filters block about 75 percent when set at the highest levels (p. 14). A study

Methods to Strengthen the Chains of Inference

1740 words - 7 pages ’ (using past analysis as foundation for further assessments) and ‘satisficing’ (analysis from an intuitive selection of the most likely hypothesis that is satisfactory and suffice) . These techniques are generally acceptable for less complex and lower impact analyses, however, when the judgement may have significant consequences, these methods are highly vulnerable to bias as well as denial and deception . Often the analyst will use the

My Future in The Intelligence Community of the U.S. Navy

1703 words - 7 pages the latest technology and techniques to collect, analyze and disseminate information vital to military planning.” ("Intelligence: Information & technology,"). Each personnel part of the intelligence community is “armed with top-secret, up-to-the second data related to international policy and military strategy that help Commanders make decisions.” ("Intelligence: Information & technology,"). The responsibilities of enlisted sailors and officers

Foreign Aid and Growth

2173 words - 9 pages I. Aid has no Effect on Growth One of the earliest papers that examined the impact of foreign aid on economic growth was Boone (1995). Boon used a neoclassical model, and his time frame was 4 samples of 5-year average from 1971-1990. He focused on the effect of policy on the effectiveness of aid by comparing three political regime scenarios in developing countries. The first scenario, was egalitarian regime where the government maximize

Design a Diversity Management Plan for Wal-Mart's CEO

1721 words - 7 pages skills of participating members of management, and increase management knowledge of diversity best practices and inclusion in the workplace.Wal-Mart's world class personnel practices ensure nondiscriminatory treatment of Associates in hiring and selection. The company utilizes state-of-the-art hiring and promotional systems (Selection Systems) to make sure that all applicants, both internal to Wal-Mart and external to their company, have an

Recruiting in China

7690 words - 31 pages the laws regarding foreign invested ventures permits employment of Chinese citizens without residency restrictions, practices vary according to localities. A number of foreign firms adopt the policy of conforming to residency requirements for some of the positions in order to demonstrate their contribution and cooperation to the locality, though they need not do so legally. A discussion of findings of the various selection tools responsible for

The Essential Causes of Problems in Scholarly Communication

1742 words - 7 pages publishing (Palmer, 2009). Electronic publishing will require new skill sets which will, ultimately, alter the current responsibilities of librarians. In “Rethinking Research Library Collections: A Policy Framework for Straitened Times, and Beyond,” Dan Hazen describes electronic publishing as the future of libraries and encourages its acceptance. The future of scholarly communication is currently unknown, but cooperative efforts between

Similar Essays

Problem Patrons: The Needs Of Homeless And Public Libraries

1727 words - 7 pages updated version of McGrath’s 1995 survey on library patron aggression. This survey contained 70 questionnaires that were sent by both regular mail and e-mail to a random selection of public libraries with a response rate of 59%. The findings were that there were no recorded change for verbal abuse between the two surveys, but physical abuse and sexual harassment had declined. The main prevention and responding techniques that she brings up is

What Is Policy Analysis

661 words - 3 pages rational or political reasons? ™ Describe the tradeoffs policy makers must accept based on your selection - what tradeoffs do policy makers see as inherent in the selected policy? Step 4: Implementing a Policy ™ What agency or organization implemented the policy? Was the policy implemented according to original design? ™ Has the agency changed or skewed the policy to reflect its own interests and goals? ™ Which changes were

Medina City Library Collection Evaluation Essay

2571 words - 11 pages higher. The number of individuals with a bachelor’s degree or higher is almost 10 percent higher than the state average (U.S. Census Bureau, 2013). The Selection Selection Choice Upon arriving at the library, I spent close to fifteen minutes browsing the shelves, trying to get an idea of what area within this library I would be interested in evaluating. I determined that it would be best to confer with the library staff, not only to let them

Fieldnote Assignment: Research And Writing

2344 words - 9 pages ; people are everywhere but I find it difficult to account for their chaos. Finally overwhelmed by the sheer profusion of idiosyncrasies I have already witnessed I go to the library to assess the few notes I have assembled thus far.Once in the library I realise that this is what I have been missing out on so far. For my first time in the field I get the idea that I will be able to do this, that I have something I can work with. Firstly the library