Lies My Teacher Told Me By James W. Loewen

2035 words - 8 pages

Lies My Teacher Told Me by James W. Loewen

High school history textbooks are seen, by students, as presenting the last word on American History. Rarely, if ever, do they question what their text tells them about our collective past. According to James W. Loewen's Lies My Teacher Told Me, they should be. Loewen has spent considerable time and effort reviewing history texts that were written for high school students. In Lies, he has reviewed twenty texts and has compared them to the actual history. Sadly, not one text measures up to the author's expectation of teaching students to think. What is worse, though, is that students come away from their classes without "having developed the ability to think coherently about social life"(Lies p.4). Loewen blames this on the way that today's texts are written. This paper will compare one text, The American Pageant, to Lies.

One of the biggest problems with today's texts is the process of heroification. This process turns real people, from our past, into "pious, perfect creatures without conflicts, pain, creditability, or human interest"(Lies p.9). Several examples, including the lions from our history, in Pageant include Christopher Columbus, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Woodrow Wilson. Others are defamed, like Stephen A. Douglas, and John Brown.

In Pageant Christopher Columbus is one of the first people named as relevant to our history. He is built up as a hero, with words such as "a man of vision, energy, resourcefulness, and courage" used to describe him (Pageant p.4). We are told that he knows the world is round, but that nobody will believe him. Finally he convinces Spain's monarchs to fund him, and is given "three tiny but seaworthy ships manned by a motley crew"(Pageant p.4). With these, and not much else, he makes a "sensational achievement," but one that turns out to be one of the "most successful failures of history," because he was convinced until his death that he had found the Indies, not a new continent(Pageant p.4). According to Loewen they got his name right, and not much else. Lies points out that there were many groups of explorers that had "discovered" America before Columbus. He probably used some of their information as a basis for his plans to sail west. A full eight pages are devoted to other possible explorers. These groups include ancient groups from Indonesia, Japan, China, and Phoenicia. More recent groups include the Vikings, British Islanders, West Africans, and Portuguese fishermen. There are varying levels of evidence connecting these groups to pre-Columbian America, but still enough to throw doubt into the mix. Columbus got the credit because of the way in which Europe responded to his "discovery."

Other false ideas taught about Columbus deal with what is left out. His original motivation may have been to find another trade route to the Orient, but his real motivation, in subsequent expeditions to America, was money. By...

Find Another Essay On Lies My Teacher Told Me by James W. Loewen

The Lies My Teacher Told Me and People’s History of the United States

1465 words - 6 pages one passage. Works Cited Loewen, James W. Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong. Second. New York, New York: Touchstone, 1997. Print. Zinn, Howard. A People's History of the United State. Fifth. New York, New York: Harper Collins, 2010. Print.

oppinions on writing. this is a funny essay about lies my teacher told me about writing I got an A- on it

542 words - 2 pages Lies my teacher told meAt some point during the lengthy, drug-induced coma that I sometimes refer to as "my high school years," I briefly regained consciousness and found myself eye-to-eye with what appeared to be a three-headed, English teaching dwarf. Before I could fall back into my customary stupor I realized that this evil shrieking dwarf would say anything to trick me into wasting what was left of my mind with books and reading and other

Prescription and Mama Told Me by Wale

1254 words - 5 pages inspired by. He wants to make real hip hop. Hip-Hop that talks about the everyday life and struggle. He is willing to forsake the profits that he could gain for the potential of his art and music. Even though Wale didn’t graduate college but he left college to pursue his dreams. Even though I won’t drop out of college but I know I will pursue my dreams to the end. My mother also told me that if I work hard, all of my dreams could come true and

This essay was written about my grandfather, for the "Stories my Grandparents told me" essay contest

716 words - 3 pages My grandfather is a schmuck. Yet to him, that insult is doubly offensive, because he is also anti-Semitic. He tried to stop my father, who was raised Catholic, from marrying my mother, who was raised Jewish. He recently divorced my grandmother, after 58 years of marriage. My grandfather has told me many stories, most of which were either exaggerations for the more boring ones or altogether facetious, but always mind-numbingly dull. In fact, I

"Catch Me if You Can" by Frank W

558 words - 2 pages Catch Me if You Can by Frank W. Abagnale is the true story of Frank Abagnale himself, as a real fake. Throughout the book, Abagnale uses several different rhetorical devices, such as foreshadowing, irony, point of view, and importance of title; and raises certain social issues.The title Catch Me if You Can is very important because it is a perfect example of foreshadowing. Frank's first taste of the criminal life occurs at age sixteen. He cons

Me and My Life by Shelly Kagan

1247 words - 5 pages that is the sole thing welfare must be altered by. Hence, genuine connections to reality that are lacking in the Experience Machine are not intrinsic desires affecting an individual’s welfare and objections to Experientialism have been effectively addressed and rebuked. Works Cited Kagan, Shelly. "Me and My Life." Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 94. (1994): 309-324. Web. 7 Feb. 2014. . Nozick, Robert. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. Basis Books, 1974. 118-119. Print.

Comparative Essay on "To Earn My Living" & A "Man Told Me the Story of His Life", The similarities and differences between those two stories

812 words - 3 pages the protagonist, the way the writers convey their stories differs greatly. 'To Earn My Living' has a much more feminine tone, whereas the other story has a much more masculine tone within the story. Therefore, the protagonists having different sex alter the entire tone of the story.The second difference the method used on conveying the story. In 'A man told me the story of his life', it doesn't mention much about the setting of the story such as

Deaf Like Me by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley

2236 words - 9 pages Have you ever felt like there was nothing that you can do for your child? In this book, Deaf Like Me, by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley, I can see the journey that Lynn’s parents took to get her help. (Spradley & Spradley, 1978). This book was an excellent read. I really liked the way that they described the ways they tried to help Lynn to understand the world around her. The book, is a great asset for any family that might be

"The Day It Happened" by Rosario Morales . The teacher told us to write a short summary about the story and compare it to the world or our lives in some way

1098 words - 4 pages have Josie call him. He's shocked by what he sees and says her name in a small voice. She says I told you if you hit me again I was leaving you, my life and the life of our baby is unsafe with you the way you are. She says she left rice and chicken for him along with the electric bill waiting for him on the table upstairs. Josie hugs everyone and then Ramon lunges at her and grabs her by the ankles and starts begging her to stay. He tells her I

Me and You in the Poem Choosing My Name by Puamani Burgress

887 words - 4 pages my family since my twin brother beat me at birth by 15 minutes. Probably he was tired of sharing that little space with me for nine months. Anyway, I got this name from my grandfather. My father was the youngest among his sibling so my grandfather would call him “Kancho”. Thus my grandfather decided to name me kancho and my father agreed. My mother told me she wanted to call me with a different name but our society is very matriarchal, thus

The Ignorance of Man. It's a Persuasive essay. My teacher gave me a 5, (which is a 90% on her scale). Comment was "Excellent Work! Very articulate with strong opinions!"

1402 words - 6 pages ourselves beyond repair. How can we expect others to respect and honor us if we don't respect and honor our own class? We brought discrimination upon ourselves by hating ourselves. I want to leave you with a thought. No one is "pure blood." No one is purely Black, White, Spanish, Irish, etc. Somewhere down our lines, we are mixed with another race. No matter how much you may choose to argue, it's true. Think about it.I know I could have done a better job, but she gave us a short time limit, 46 minutes to be exact. This is actually one of my worst essays, but my teacher is a VERY harsh grader, so if I got a 5, it must be acceptable. Enjoy!

Similar Essays

Overview: Lies My Teacher Told Me By James W. Loewen

2090 words - 8 pages There are certain criteria that must be fulfilled in order for a nonfiction book to be successful. The two criteria that we should judge all argumentative nonfiction by are well written anecdotes that capture the reader’s attention and well explained factual data that proves the author’s point. The book Lies My Teacher Told Me by James W. Loewen contains both of these criteria and as such is a successful nonfiction book. Loewen’s purpose in

Lies My Teacher Told Me By James Loewen

1429 words - 6 pages James Loewen wrote the book ?Lies My Teacher Told ME? to help the students of the United States become aware of their true history. This book attempts to show how and why American history has been taught the way it has without regard for the truth. Mr. Loewen had compared twelve different history textbooks they are: The Great Republic, The American Way, Land of Promise, Rise of the American Nation, Challenge of Freedom, American Adventures

Lies My Teacher Told Me Essay

1175 words - 5 pages how you take in what Loewen is telling you. If I would have had just my history classes that taught me about slavery and racism, my mind would have been blown at all the information he shares. Since I was able to really see some of the events that happened as a repercussion to what he discussed, I was able to rationalize the chapter as I was reading it. I also think my high school experience helped view both sides of the story as well. Works Cited Loewen, James W. Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2007. Print.

A Critical Analysis Of Lies My Teacher Told Me

1202 words - 5 pages of proposing great ideas without any follow through, or if there is follow through, it is too boring and misleading to appreciate. While this book had the potential of being a great in consideration to the teachings of American history due to its ability to identify little known facts about the United States, it is too flawed to even be thought of as anything impactful. Work Cited Loewen, James W. Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1996.