Life Or Death Who Has The Right To Make The Choice

1039 words - 4 pages

The physician is informed of her decision and assists the mother in signing the appropriate paperwork. The patient soon confronts the physician and makes him promise to stick to the DNR order no matter what his condition, the physician agrees. Shortly after the DNR is completed and all other appropriate paperwork are in order, the patient goes into respiratory arrest. All the parties involved in this situation are present when the respiratory arrest occurs. The physician stands by will all intentions of honoring the DNR but within 30 seconds of the arrest, the mother orders the physician to intubate. The physician looks to the patient as he shakes his head indicating that he does not want to be intubated, the physician also is aware that the patient will be 18 years old in three weeks.Ethical Dilemma Initially it appears as if the dilemma revolves around what the physicians next move should be.When actually the real dilemma is who owns the rights to make this life or death decision. It is clear what the patient wants for his course of treatment. It is equally clear what his mother will allow his treatment to be. Each have equally selfish reasons for wanting their decision to be upheld. The mother does not want to lose her son and will at all costs keep him alive. She feels he is romanticizing death and has no real concept of what dying means. Her son lived with cystic fibrosis since age four and has seen many of his friends placed on ventilators only to later die. He does not want that quality of life in his final days. The physician is supportive of the patients request but is placed in an awkward legal position if he abides by the patients request. The nurse who has acted as an intermediary throughout this entire process continues to acts as a patient advocate an ensur! e the patients rights are observed and that his wishes are acknowledged.Ethical Analysis of Dilemma Contemporary Utilitarianism is divided in to four basic principles, each principle will be used to analyze this dilemma. The first principle considers which action will provide the greatest happiness for the greatest number. As we look at the action in this case the patient should not be allowed to discontinue treatment because his mother and girlfriend do not wish fort him dye. This action does not provide the greatest good and it appears that the patient looses by a vote of two to one.The second principle is based on what the consequences of this action are, not what or how its done but how the chosen action effects the majority. Again we find that the patients requested action of no medical treatment and death is not the consequence that the majority wants. So the chosen action in a bottom line analysis would not be considered good.The third and fourth principles appear to get more egoistic in nature by definition, but remember the basis of this theory is the greatest good for the greatest number. The final principles are centered around human happiness and minimizing...

Find Another Essay On Life or Death Who has the Right to Make the Choice

Defining Education, and who has the Right Answer’s

973 words - 4 pages Although both authors have noted the issues with public education, primarily teaching methods and accountability (facts of the material or lack thereof) they both have overlooked the importance of the “how” is their goal accomplished? The need for specific examples to remedy the issues they present are unaccounted for. Lowen’s rhetorical effect is strong from the uncommonly beginning. He has made it abundantly clear that there is a severe

The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms

1464 words - 6 pages Untitled The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use

Whether or not Taiwan has the right to be autonomous

1535 words - 7 pages gradually shifts to the indisposition to being governed by Mainland China. This is the main historical factor behind Taiwan’s attitude towards different regimes, and it clearly states that Taiwan has the right to be autonomous, but the actualization of becoming autonomous may not be their best choice. From a historical perspective, Taiwan has no official belonging, and it has shifted from one government to another but wasn’t very satisfied with any

Whether or not Taiwan has the right to be autonomous

1310 words - 6 pages be independent, and they back Taiwan up by selling them weapons and trying to evoke tension between the two lands. This lures both countries to give up peaceful settlement and pick up weapons to fight against each other. Many people are agitated and misled, which is understandable considering the reputation that China has, but any propaganda is biased and is written to make people make moves the way they want. Blindly believing in only one of the

The Right Decision or No Choice

1124 words - 5 pages and urban areas. It also tells the struggles and the choices that poor people have to make at the same time. However, as many different considerations are being taken into account, the decision is not always as simple as choosing whether it is a right or a wrong choice. If I am the parents who have to take care of my family, under those circumstances, perhaps I would do the same as well.

Euthanasia - The Right to Death

755 words - 3 pages ' protests. These current laws are set in place stating that a patient or next of kin has the right to end life support, and nothing more. Pushing these limits and removing these bans are dangerous to the American people. By removing said bans, and legalizing assisted-suicide and active euthanasia in the United States would potentially lead to illegal use and euthanization of unwilling demographics. Limitations to be implemented and upheld include

The Death Penalty, Right or Wrong?

2338 words - 9 pages rights and retain the death penalty at the same time.      I uphold the following: A Declaration of Life I, the undersigned, being of sound and disposing mind and memory, do hereby in the presence of witnesses make this Declaration of Life; I believe that the killing of one human being by another is morally wrong. I believe it is morally wrong for any state or other governmental entity to take the life of a human being

The Death Penalty: Right or Wrong?

2252 words - 9 pages retributivist’s standpoint, a person who is capable of taking the life of another human being possesses neither moral standards or any type of self-consciousness and for that reason forfeits their right to live (Bedau, Cassell, 2004) From a retributivist’s view, there are three propositions; the first being that anyone proven guilty deserves to be punished, secondly, only the guilty deserve to be punished, and finally, the guilty deserve a punishment equal

Is the Death Penalty right or wrong?

2692 words - 11 pages The death penalty is a major issue that brings up a lot of controversy in our society. The most important question concerning the death penalty is whether it should be abolished or not. Many people think that the death penalty is the ultimate denial of human rights and that it also violates the right to life. Some say it is cruel, inhumane, and a degrading type of punishment. Other people are for it and believe that we need to weed out the bad

Abortion: Choice or Life. Asks the question of whether abortion should be a choice or if life outweighs the choice for a woman to have an abortion

675 words - 3 pages cell at conception that certainly couldn't have lived outside the womb. (Emmens 5)The largest politically argued abortion issue is whether or not the woman should have the right to choose to have an abortion. There are the pro-choice group who think the woman should make the decision and the pro-life group that thinks all abortion is wrong except in extreme circumstances. (Emmens 1) Abortion is currently legal as a result of two Supreme Court

Euthanasia: The Right Choice

2430 words - 10 pages that no one who is in any pain or suffering, has the right to end their life because “they don’t know what they’re saying,” but is that always the case? According to Somerville, “Western societies have rejected euthanasia as a solution for over two thousand years. Why, then, are we considering legalizing it now, especially when we can do so much more than in the past to relieve suffering?” (438). Most can understand the argument Somerville is

Similar Essays

Who Has The Right To Take A Life?

1189 words - 5 pages Who Has the Right to Take a Life? Conforming to the correct rules of conduct, or moral values, reflect an individual’s views about life. Morality draws the dividing line between what is right and wrong. When developing an opinion toward the death penalty, one immediately drifts toward a certain side. Introduced to world justice systems early on, the death penalty became a means of punishment for those who committed crimes deemed as morally

Who Has The Choice ? Essay

810 words - 4 pages Abortion is the practice of terminating a pregnancy, which results in the death of the human fetus. People are debating about whether or not abortion is right or wrong and there are two main sides: those who think that abortion should be illegal, also known as pro-life and those who think abortion should be legal, also known as pro-choice. Both sides feel so strongly about the issue that it is regularly debated in politics, states and citizens

Teen Pregnancy: Make The Right Choice

2724 words - 11 pages it. However, there are other alternatives than aborting the precious life inside. Be a responsible parent-to-be, think clearly on the possibilities that can be taken and make the right choice. References Abortion Facts, Retrieved on January 15, 2011 from http://www.abortionno.org/Resources/fastfacts.html Abortion Health Risks and Side Affects, Retrieved n January 17, 2011 from http://www.contracept.org/abortion-health-risks.php

Left Or Right Who Has More Brain Power To Learn

1249 words - 5 pages brain is a very complex part of the body that has everything to do with daily life and the ability to learn. As many people do not understand there are two parts of the brain and each works completely different in how one will learn and retain information. Why is the brain such a complex system and has the ability to adapt to every situation. We are going to be looking at the Left and Right side of the Brain and how each hemisphere works from