This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Limitations Of Theories Of Sociology Of Deviance

2514 words - 10 pages

Theories of Deviance are limited in their ability to explain deviant acts if one adopts the view that these theories are universal. There is no universal, right or wrong theory, rather each theory provides a different perspective which only "fully makes sense when set within an appropriate societal context and values framework" .The functionalist theories share a common structural explanation of causes of deviance . They assume that conformity in society is achieved through the existence of norms and values shared by the general consensus and that a high level of social integration is required for society to function successfully .Merton's Anomie of Strain theory hypothesises that deviant behaviour is the result of a "disjunction between culturally defined goals to which most members of society aspire, and.....legitimate means for achieving the goals" . Thus socially induced strain causes deviant behaviour.Merton argues that many people in the USA strive to achieve the "American dream" which recognises that all members of society have equal opportunities to achieve success and that deviance occurs when the goals take precedence over the means to achieve them as people resort to deviant behaviour as a result .The theories main premise is that because lower-class people are under greater strain than people of upper classes, they are more likely to engage in deviant behaviour . However one cannot reduce deviance into a simple equation of poverty and alienation . Strain theory is limited in providing explanations for why every person living in poverty does not engage in deviant acts, and why individuals from upper classes of society do engage in crimes .The anomie of strain theory is also limited in that it adopts the assumption that everyone in society shares the same goals of achieving wealth . Most studies of individual's priorities in life indicate marriage, friendships and health are of greater importance than material concerns such as success , which is at odds with the theories identification of material success as peoples main motivation. Another example of this is groups such as "hippies" who make a conscious decision to reject goals of financial success as opposed to the failure to achieve those same goals .This highlights the need for a further explanation of why people engage in deviant acts, as clearly the failure to achieve goals of financial success is the only goal in society people strive to achieve.The strain theory could also be viewed as being limited in explaining deviance in a universal and equal manner, in so far as that it relies exclusively on official crime statistics, which generally tend to be both unreliable and invalid as they fail to take the "dark figure" of crime into account and structural inequalities .It is argued that the disproportionate number of lower-class members of society are imprisoned because they lack the money, power and connections of the upper-class individual , the result is the lower-class become a...

Find Another Essay On Limitations of theories of sociology of deviance

Sociology:Outline and assess Structuralist theories of crime and deviance

589 words - 2 pages All Structuralist theories of crime and deviance seem to suggest that crime is socially constructed rather than focused on the individual.Albert Cohen, combining Structuralist and sub cultural theories drew on Merton's idea of strain but criticized Merton's ideas of crime being an individual response and believed that he ignored non-utilitarian crimes such as vandalism and joy-riding. Cohen was particularly interested in deviance which was not

Sociological Viewpoint of Deviance Essay

2968 words - 12 pages class values, not a distinctive set of alternative values. Unlike previous theorists, there is no assumption made that all people within a society share a consensus as to what their life goals should be, that is there is a rejection of the functionalist view that society is founded on consensus. (Moore (1996), p.16) According to Interactionist theories of deviance, they make radical conception of deviance in terms of there

Labeling Theory of Deviance

2539 words - 11 pages beyond the original work. Today, the labeling theory is used to explain various types of deviance and to reaffirm existing theories. The theory has spread into topics outside of deviance and is steadily improving with more research and studies. There are many flaws when considering the labeling theory, however, if labeling theorists consider the theory Confounds in the Labeling Theory Although the labeling theory was very popular when it was

The Statute of Limitations

810 words - 3 pages liabilities, with injuries may take time to manifest, many courts adapted different rules such as postponing the running of the statute until the injury has been reasonably discovered. The length of time differs among states and branches of law (Danzon, 1985). The long and deferred statutes of limitations lead to long tail of claims and contributed majority of medical malpractice and product liability (Danzon, 1985). In this section, statutes of

Sociology: Outline and assess left and right realist explanations of crime deviance

711 words - 3 pages copewith the statusfrustration and marginalization.Hughes notes that left realists should be valued for the challenge they posed to radical criminology's thinking on the issues of intra-class and intra-ethnic crimes.Left realism has drawn attention to the brutalising effects of street crimes in the inner-city and the fact that some theories of crime have romanticised offenders, it has highlighted the effects of crime for victims, a group neglected by

Comparison of Limitations

1433 words - 6 pages Comparison of Limitations Article One Wright and Panley’s (2010) research weaknesses could be the participants’ age range because the majority of the persons who responded to the survey were 50 years old more or less. Another research weakness could be that the persons who participated in the survey were mostly White people and other races were not well represented in the survey. Wright and Panley (2010) other research weakness could be that

Limitations of the Paparazzi

1424 words - 6 pages Paparazzi). In my opinion, I think that the paparazzi should have some limitations. I think it is a little ridiculous how they can just take pictures of people who are just trying to lead normal lives, aside from being celebrities. No one’s life should ever be cut short just because the paparazzi were following him or her all for a few pictures. Then if they were to get hurt they would ask for a settlement fee that is an outrageous amount of

Limitations of the Gods

833 words - 4 pages In many myth’s the gods seem to be able to everything, and nothing can stop them. As figures who are personifications of things humans cannot understand, they are powerful beings, but even they may have times of struggle. As some stories tell, the gods themselves had weaknesses, and things that they could not achieve. The gods do have human traits or tendencies that often lead to them being unable to do things. Sometimes it was the fact that

Deviance of Spousal Cheating

1507 words - 6 pages more then likely to have been friends with one who has cheated, whether it is known to them or not. These numbers are staggering for a culture that sees this type of deviance as the third most despicable act, following rape and murder (Cooper). Discovered cheaters are looked upon as lowly members of society. A thief, alcoholic, and drug abuser are seen upon better light then one who betrays the trust of a relationship. Presidents have faced

Labelling Theories' Contribution to the Sociological Understanding of Crime and Deviance

1575 words - 6 pages of the labelling theorists to the sociology of deviance can be made. Firstly it has to be questioned about the success of the labelling theories in answering questions such as why a given act is considered deviant and/or criminal in some but not all societies or why a certain kind of reaction may identify behaviour as deviant. However, Becker goes some way to explain the underlying problems of labelling theory in his

The Three Main Theories of Deviance and Their Strengths and Weaknesses

2887 words - 12 pages The Three Main Theories of Deviance and Their Strengths and Weaknesses A functionalist analysis of deviance looks for the source of deviance in the nature of society rather than in the biological or psychological nature of the individual. Although functionalists agree that social control mechanisms such as the police and the courts are necessary to keep deviance in check, many argue that a certain amount of deviance

Similar Essays

Deviance In Society The Sociology Of Deviance

2215 words - 9 pages limitations of the sociology of deviance, these theories still remain an extremely useful tool in analysing deviance and social control.A dominant finding in almost all sociological theories on deviance is that society will always contain rule breakers, regardless of the social setting. These theories believe that for societies to run with some semblance of order, deviance is essential and intrinsic, even when problematic and disruptive. Deviance is

Sociological Theories Of Deviance Essay

929 words - 4 pages . Three main sociological theories of deviance include the cultural transmission theory (also known as the differential association theory), the labeling theory, and the control theory. If we take a look certain agents of socialization, for example, a school system, it becomes very easy to pinpoint and understand the facets of the cultural transmission theory. This theory considers deviance to be a behavior that is learned through interactions with

Assess Marxist Theories Of Crime And Deviance

626 words - 3 pages , as they make healthy workers to earn them profit. Neo-marxism or critical criminology is a newer philosophy, having arisen from marxist theories and social action theories. A Fully Social Theory of Deviance was a book written by criminologists Taylor, Walton and Young that combines traditional marxism with Neo-marxism. Karl Marx claims that crime is inevitable in capitalists society, as capitalism is a criminogenic system. In a capitalist

The Sociology Of Deviance Disputing It Is Dead

2379 words - 10 pages history, the sociology of deviance did generate or highlight a host of interesting ideas, concepts, and theories that Appeared to of seeped out into and influenced allied fields, eventually becoming part of their practitioners’ thinking about how the social world works. Goode feels clearly, the deviance concept is still relevant, but it’s a lot less likely to be called deviance. He goes onto clarify that we understand the difference between the