This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Linda Hutcheon’s A Theory Of Adaptation

1481 words - 6 pages

The art of storytelling is not a modern invention, neither is adaptation. In spite of their century-old traditions, they both are relevant and evolving. Reading the same stories over and over again would get boring pretty quickly, but transcoding them to different media such as film or video games gives them new meanings, thus keeps them interesting. Adaptation opens up new dimensions for creators and consumers of adaptations alike. However, when the same story – or an element of the story - is used in various different media, it will inevitably spark debates on which one is superior. Adaptations often get frowned upon for appropriating and exploiting their adapted texts. There are many questions and doubts surrounding adaptation, such as what can be adapted and why are certain works easier to adapt.
Linda Hutcheon’s book, A Theory of Adaptation examines these issues and attempts to theorize the process of adaptation. Using an impressive array of sources, the author aims to explore the topic of adaptation without excluding overlooked areas or more recent developments. Her methodology for this involves ”[identifying] a text-based issue that extends across a variety of media, [finding] ways to study it comparatively, and then [teasing] out the theoretical implications from multiple textual examples”.

According to the preface, the book’s aim is to challenge the notion that adaptations are merely secondary, derivative works compared to their adapted texts. Hutcheon also puts emphasis on analyzing intertextuality and confronting the negative perception of adaptations that is so common in our society. The author states that the examples provided in this book aid to help readers get more familiar with the topic and relate to the issues discussed in these chapters. Hutcheon also claims that this volume doesn’t contain extended case studies of any of the examples. Moreover, it is not supposed to be focused on a specific genre or medium. This introduction does not suggest more than the title does, but it sets high expectations towards the content.
In Chapter 1, the author discusses the relevance and role of adaptation. Nowadays, adaptation come in many different forms and genres, ranging from literature to video games, and everything in between. In spite of the increasing demand for adaptations, they still get a bad reputation for disrespecting and appropriating their adapted texts in a blasphemous manner. Out of all the genres, cinematic adaptations are criticised the most, due to a perceived hierarchy between genres. Therefore, an opera or ballet adaptation is somehow more accepted, than a film version of the same story. Hutcheon also argues that adaptation’s appeal is that it combines comforting familiarity with surprise.
By calling a work an adaptation, we acknowledge its relation to its prior text. Although adaptations can have many different intentions behind them, they certainly don’t intend to copy or remake the original. According to...

Find Another Essay On Linda Hutcheon’s A Theory of Adaptation

Death of a Salesman - Linda Loman

624 words - 2 pages Death of a Salesman - Linda Loman In the play Death of a Salesman, Linda Loman serves as the family's destroyer. Linda realizes, throughout the play, that her family is caught up in a bunch of lies. Linda is the only person that can fix the problem and she doesn't. The first instance where Linda Loman serves as the family destroyer is in Act when Willy Loman comes home and tells her, "I suddenly couldn't drive any more. The car kept

Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

598 words - 2 pages Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman       Linda Loman is the heart and soul of the Loman household.  She loves her family, even though she is all too aware of husband's faults and her sons' characters. She provides a sharp contrast to the seamy underbelly of the world of sex, symbolized by the Woman and the prostitutes.  They operate in the "real world" as part of the impersonal forces that corrupt.  Happy equates his

Linda Zagzebski: A Virtue Based Definition of Knowledge

1211 words - 5 pages The philosopher, Linda Zagzebski, offers a virtue based definition of knowledge. She arrives at this definition by presenting numerous accounts of knowledge definitions that fail, explore why they fail, then shows how her theory satisfies knowledge criteria. Zagzebski defines knowledge by expressing the relationship between the subject and the truth proposition. A truth claim becomes knowledge when your state of belief makes

Two Nursing Theories: Theory on Human Caring and Theory of Adaptation

1051 words - 4 pages huge impact on nurses around the world, and her Theory on Human Caring has been adopted by many healthcare organizations. (slide 8) Impact of Roys’s Adaptation Theory on Nursing Roy’s adaptation theory has had a significant impact on nursing and the way we view and approach patient care. It is a systemic approach to understanding and addressing the physiological, self-concept, role function and interdependence needs of a patient and helping them

The Character of Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

530 words - 2 pages The Character of Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman Linda is the heart of the Loman family in Arthur Miller's play, Death of a Salesman.  She is wise, warm, and sympathetic.  She knows her husband's faults and her son's characters.  For all her frank appraisals, she loves them.  She is contrasted with the promiscuous sex symbolized by the Woman and the prostitutes.  They operate in the world outside as part of the impersonal

The Conflicted Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

759 words - 3 pages The Conflicted Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman   Watching a solitary blade of grass will never tell you the direction of hurricane, just as one characteristic can never describe Linda Loman. In Death of a Salesman, Linda Loman is a woman torn between guilt, retaliation, and pity. Her guilt stems from the fact that she prevented Willy from pursuing his true American Dream; she retaliates in response to Willy's failure

Linda as an Anabler in Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller

1346 words - 5 pages There are many examples throughout the play: Death of a Salesman, by Arthur Miller that reveals that Linda is the classic enabler who indirectly causes the dysfunction in the Loman household. Willy has problems with his memory, but Linda is always making excuses for Willy’s many mistakes. Making those kinds of excuses for someone’s mistakes is just as bad as the mistake itself. She could have tried and helped Willy get better, but instead she

Legitimacy of Happiness to Evaluate Societies’ Performances: Hedonic Treadmill/ Adaptation Theory

1412 words - 6 pages In addition to Diener and his colleagues, Sheldon and Lyubomirsky recommend the use of variety and appreciation to resolve the limits of the hedonic adaptation theory. In testing the hedonic adaptation prevention model, Sheldon and Lyubomirsky address two main reasons why happiness cannot last. First, as individuals get used to all the positive events that occurred as result of the initial positive change, they just don’t notice them anymore and

Legitimacy of Happiness to Evaluate Societies’ Performances: Hedonic Treadmill/ Adaptation Theory

2054 words - 8 pages was not until Brickman and Campbell that the adaptation theory was first coined the term “hedonic treadmill.” To explain this idea of the hedonic treadmill, Brickman, Coates, and Janoff-Bulman (1978) further conducted a two-part study on lottery winners and paraplegics and compared their past, present, and predicted future happiness levels. They showed that people readily adapt to their misfortunes or fortunes. For instance, lottery winners

DaimlerChrysler Financial Services Australia - A market analyis by Linda Schmid (extraction of an internship report)

5020 words - 20 pages Daimler Chrysler Financial Services in Australia - A market analysis by Linda SchmidExecutive SummaryThe purpose of this report is to apply theoretical approaches learned at University to a practical environment. The company which was evaluated is DaimlerChrysler, in specific, DaimlerChrysler Financial Services in Australia. A market analysis of Australia was undertaken to assess if this market would be beneficial for the company. The approach

Miller and Friesen: A Model of Organizational Adaptation

1044 words - 4 pages tend to have momentum associated with it. A Model of Organizational Adaptation The model has three related tenets 1. Momentum is expected to be a dominant factor in organizational evolution.Reversals in the direction of change in variables of strategy and structure are expected to be rare. 2. Momentum is likely to coexist among a great many variables of strategy and structure at the same time. Changes(or stability)in the variables will tend to

Similar Essays

Review Of Hutcheon's A Theory Of Adaptation

695 words - 3 pages reason of the popularity of adaptations nowadays might be explained with financial facts. It is simply because if something made profit and was popular once, there is a high possibility of it will do the same once more, and even more sequels can be made, the risks would be minimal, the profits maximized. If we dwell deeper into the theory of adaptation, we might realize, that they have a “double nature”. Adapters do not only want to repeat or

Roy's Theory Of Adaptation Essay

1670 words - 7 pages While completing a master’s degree at the University of California- Los Angeles, Sister Callista Roy theorized that the ultimate goal of nursing was to promote adaptation (Clarke, Barone, Hanna, & Senesac, 2011). Applying scientific knowledge to nursing practice, her framework aimed to improve nursing care by providing a holistic perspective to the adaptive behaviours of individuals and groups. Since publication in 1970, Sister Callista Roy

Analyse Two Texts On The Module In The Light Of The Linda Hutcheon’s And Siobhan O’flynn’s Assertion That ‘Part Of Th[E] Pleasure [Of Consuming Ad

2151 words - 9 pages ) Groenendyk, Kathi, Modernizing Mansfield Park: Patricia Rozema’s Spin on Jane Austen, Jane Austen Society of North America, V.25, NO.1 (Winter 2004) Hutcheon, Linda, and O’Flynn, Siobhan, A Theory of Adaptation, (Routledge, 2006) Johnston, Andrew, Time Out New York, (November 18–25, 1999), p. 121 Kantrowitz, Barbara, Making an Austen Heroine More Like Austen, (The New York Times, 31 Oct. 1999), Pg. 17, 26 Parrill, Sue, Jane Austen on Film and

A Journey Of Adaptation Essay

1125 words - 5 pages of the books as vixens or heathens to their male counterparts. The most important technique of adaptation, however, revolves around the author’s ability to properly adapt the theme of a story to better to relate to the time in which the author is writing in, and more importantly the author’s ability to retain the central motives that the theme of the story is motivated by. Throughout all three stories there is a central theme of perseverance