Linda Zagzebski: A Virtue Based Definition Of Knowledge

1211 words - 5 pages

The philosopher, Linda Zagzebski, offers a virtue based definition of knowledge. She arrives at this definition by presenting numerous accounts of knowledge definitions that fail, explore why they fail, then shows how her theory satisfies knowledge criteria.
Zagzebski defines knowledge by expressing the relationship between the subject and the truth proposition. A truth claim becomes knowledge when your state of belief makes cognitive contact with reality. What it is to know that you understand something is different from having a relationship with something. Propositional knowledge, that can be known or believed, is her focus due to simplicity. The criteria required for belief is to have a thought, followed by augmentation with experience. The minimal criteria for a definition of knowledge must incorporate two types of “good”; a moral and an ethical. These truths are implemented to develop the foundation on which Zagzebski later builds her definition.
How we approach the question of knowledge is pivotal. If the definition of knowledge is a necessary truth, then we should aim for a real definition for theoretical and practical knowledge. Methodology examines the purpose for the definition and how we arrived to it. The reader is now aware of the various ways to dissect what knowledge is. This entails the possibility of knowledge being a set of truths; from which it follows that one cannot possibly give a single definition. The definition given must therefore satisfy certain desiderata , while being strong enough to demonstrate clarity without losing the reader. If we base our definition on every counter-example that disproves our original definition then it becomes ad hoc. This is the case for our current definition of knowledge; therefore the method for attaining the definition must be addressed.
The contextual and logical problem of knowledge being a justified true belief (JTB) is unpackaged. It shows the gap between truth and the component of knowledge. This is demonstrated with the Gettier example. Despite Howard-Synders’ attempt to correct the accidental knowledge by offering the non-accidental clause, we still arrive to a false belief being true. The definition must satisfy the condition of being achieved noncontingent on counter-examples for future Gettier defeaters, but must intrinsically be tied to the cognitive faculties used to obtain the definition. The JTB method that the Gettier case attacked should be altered to do so. For a definition of knowledge to be good, it must satisfy two conditions; it must lead to the truth, and it must do so not accidently.
The definition of knowledge proposed is contingent upon who is asking. This prioritizes the essential characteristics offered in the definition. The presupposition is that the definition of must be true for it to be good. It follows that the property of a belief and/or the justification of it cannot make it true. Properties are determinants of the truth...

Find Another Essay On Linda Zagzebski: A Virtue Based Definition of Knowledge

Definition of a Profession Essay

646 words - 3 pages profession. The characteristics, previously listed, refine the definition of a profession as: a group of people that live and work by a code of ethics and a higher standard of functioning. People that are accepted by the public as having special knowledge and skills and are prepared to use this knowledge and skill to protect public health and welfare.Heightened public awareness and the demand for an educated, expertly skilled, and ethical

A Definition of Genius Essay

1938 words - 8 pages Subjective EnvyMost of us, at one time or another, have called someone a 'genius.' The connotation is usually quite positive. It brings to mind images of Plato, Maria Curie, and Blaise Pascal. All of these people seemed to possess genius according to the dictionary definition: someone with extraordinary intellectual ability, originality and creative power, someone excelling in a strong natural talent (Dictionary.com, pars. 1). However, the

Definition of a Stock

1145 words - 5 pages Definition of stock. A stock (also referred to as share or equity) is a security issued by a company that represents a stake of the ownership rights in the assets of the company and a share of its profits after payments of corporate liabilities and obligations. Stocks are sold and bought on an exchange. Corporations issue stock in order to raise capital to finance their operations. A stockholder is an owner of a company. A stockholder is an

Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

598 words - 2 pages Linda Loman in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman       Linda Loman is the heart and soul of the Loman household.  She loves her family, even though she is all too aware of husband's faults and her sons' characters. She provides a sharp contrast to the seamy underbelly of the world of sex, symbolized by the Woman and the prostitutes.  They operate in the "real world" as part of the impersonal forces that corrupt.  Happy equates his

A Baseline Definition of Culture

523 words - 3 pages concept of a shaping template and body of learned behaviors might be further broken down into the following categories, each of which is an important element of cultural systems:systems of meaning, of which language is primaryways of organizing society, from kinship groups to states and multi-national corporationsthe distinctive techniques of a group and their characteristic productsSeveral important principles follow from this definition of culture:If

Shakespeares Definition Of A Ghost

1082 words - 4 pages Shakespeare's Definition of a Ghost      The American Heritage Dictionary, published in 1973, defines a ghost as, "the spirit or shade of a dead person, supposed to haunt living persons or former habitats." Unfortunately, this simple definition does not explain where a ghost comes from or why it haunts. When used in the context of Shakespeare's Hamlet, this definition seems to suggest that the ghost who

Shakespeare's Definition Of A Ghost

1165 words - 5 pages Shakespeare's Definition of a GhostThe American Heritage Dictionary, published in 1973, defines a ghost as, 'the spirit or shade of a dead person, supposed to haunt living persons or former habitats.' Unfortunately, this simple definition does not explain where a ghost comes from or why it haunts. When used in the context of Shakespeare's Hamlet, this definition seems to suggest that the ghost who visits Hamlet truly is his dead father seeking

Definition of a business plan

892 words - 4 pages leasing it rather than buying it.There is also asset based financing which is financing an enterprise by using its hard assets forcollateral to acquire a loan of sufficient size with which to finance operations. Another is royaltybased funding. This usually refers to financing for small companies that is secured and repaidwith royalties. Venture capital is another option. Money from investment pools or firms thatspecialize in financing young

Science fiction is the search for a definition of man and his status in the universe which will stand on our advanced but confused state of knowledge

4990 words - 20 pages Science fiction is the search for a definition of man and his status in the universe which will stand on our advanced but confused state of knowledge .At first glance this topic could seem rather irrelevant having in mind that the two works are separated by more than a century. During this lapse of time, humanity has witnessed profound changes at a breath-taking speed. The partly Gothic and partly Romantic world of Mary Shelley is quite

A Knowledge -based Approach to Innovation An Application for Project- based Firms

1055 words - 4 pages knowledge depend on networks of relationships in a PBO. Knowledge-based perspective concentrates on building up capabilities during the implementation of projects. Networks are formed by knowledge flows through collaboration, sub contract and strategic alliances.#Knowledge, Networks and InnovationAccording to the Knowledge-based View (KBV), knowledge is of strategic importance and firm's competitive advantage lies in its ability to integrate the

“A skeptic is one willing to question any knowledge claim, asking for clarity in definition, consistency in logic, and adequacy of evidence” (Adapted

1570 words - 7 pages Knowledge comprises of how an individual thinks, which can be influenced by his/her experience, observation, or what has been taught to him/her. A skeptic is said to be someone who questions knowledge, by asking for clear definition, consistency, or evidence. When I am studying for my exam, when I don’t understand something, I question the definition, consistency, and evidences in order to fully understand what I’m learning, does this make me a

Similar Essays

Death Of A Salesman Linda Loman

624 words - 2 pages Death of a Salesman - Linda Loman In the play Death of a Salesman, Linda Loman serves as the family's destroyer. Linda realizes, throughout the play, that her family is caught up in a bunch of lies. Linda is the only person that can fix the problem and she doesn't. The first instance where Linda Loman serves as the family destroyer is in Act when Willy Loman comes home and tells her, "I suddenly couldn't drive any more. The car kept

Linda Hutcheon’s A Theory Of Adaptation

1481 words - 6 pages , when the same story – or an element of the story - is used in various different media, it will inevitably spark debates on which one is superior. Adaptations often get frowned upon for appropriating and exploiting their adapted texts. There are many questions and doubts surrounding adaptation, such as what can be adapted and why are certain works easier to adapt. Linda Hutcheon’s book, A Theory of Adaptation examines these issues and attempts to

Perspectives On The Definition Of Knowledge

1483 words - 6 pages sciences, we must first know the meaning and types of knowledge. One may simply ask in a deeper sense “what is knowledge?” There have long been several controversies in regard to the definitions of knowledge however, although there may not be a completely correct definition, there are some conditions that a definition must meet in order to be accepted. The conditions are as follows: there must be a firm belief towards something in order to be considered

Knowledge: Attitudes About Aging And Aging Anxiety By By Linda J. Allan And James A. Johnson

1926 words - 8 pages Knowledge UNDERGRADUATE ATTITUDES TOWARD THE ELDERLY: THE ROLE OF KNOWLEDGE, CONTACT AND AGING ANXIETY. By Linda J. Allan and James A. Johnson The aim of the study was to examine the relationship between attitudes about aging and aging anxiety. The focus of the study was to determine the role that aging anxiety plays a mediator between experiences. The experiences focused on were in the form of factual knowledge and contact with the elderly