Little Red Riding Hood: A Comparative Analysis Of Two Cross Cultural Retellings

807 words - 3 pages

Different versions of “Little Red Riding Hood” have been retold throughout written history. Each retelling was written in a culture of its own, which holds its own philosophies on each of the continuing main ideas in each version. One integral philosophy is their principles of femininity. Because so much time had past from the original work to the time of the newer retelling, the newer version had to be rewritten to tell a different tale, distinguishing the principles of femininity that the two cultures contrasted. Two versions that contrast very well are Brother Grimm’s “Little Red Cap” and Tanith Lee’s “Wolfland”. They offer different positions of femininity, one representing the innocence of the earlier 19th century, the other representing the dominance of the late 20th century.In Grimm’s traditional version, the femininity of Little Red Cap and her grandmother is a rather fragile one. Little Red Cap is an innocent character. She sees no danger in giving detailed information about the location of her grandmother’s house, her destination, to a complete stranger: “Her house is right under three large oaks. You must know the place from the hazel hedges near it” (Grimm 620). She is also a naïve character, following the advice of the wolf to gaze upon the flowers and birds in the woods, without ever thinking about his intentions, as she should not have listened to anyone: “Little Red Cap, have you seen the beautiful flowers all about? Why don‘t you look around for a while? I don‘t think you‘ve even noticed how sweetly the birds are singing“ (Grimm 621). Little Red Cap and her grandmother are submissive to masculinity. In this particular version, the grandmother is eaten by the wolf, and later Little Red Cap. Furthermore, both women in this story are rescued by a man. A protective huntsman checking up on the grandmother cuts open the wolf and rescues both women from the wolf’s belly “ (Grimm 620). A huntsman happened to be passing by the house just then and thought to himself: ‘How the old woman is snoring! You’d better check to see what’s wrong” (Grimm 621).This story is appropriate for its culture, as it depicts the time period in which it was written. During this time, men were very dominant figures over women. The wolf dominated Little Red Cap by tricking her by distracting her, and both Little Red Cap and her...

Find Another Essay On Little Red Riding Hood: A Comparative Analysis of Two Cross-Cultural Retellings

Fairy Tales Paper: A Retelling of Little Red Riding Hood

1052 words - 4 pages depiction of the lead character: Little Red Riding Hood (LRRH). Different versions of this classic tale portray her as a cunning and mature little girl capable of turning the tables on the wolf (Norton 11) or as a woefully ignorant and immature little girl whose victimization is her just reward (Norton 5). These accounts give us dull, one dimensional character that merely exists as a means to an end for the storyteller. Although these stories were

Retelling of Little Red Riding Hood

704 words - 3 pages That particular day, I left my den to go on a nice hike through the woods. Then I met her. Little Red Riding Hood came wandering up the path. She told me she wanted to go to her grandmother’s house, which was just down the path, but she was lost, so I, being the kind wolf I am, gave her directions. She thanked me and skipped off happily. Later on, I began to worry if she reached the house safely. After all, she had seemed apt to getting lost

Appropration of "Little Red Riding Hood"

1451 words - 6 pages , which took her to the same dark place where Grey Robe was lurking, and the same fate as her elder sister befell her.Now, the mother was becoming suspicious at her two girls not delivering their parcels to the grandmother. She took out the last bits of the enchanted foodstuff, put it into a basket, and bade Red Hood carry it to the grandmother.Red Hood set out happily, walking on the shiny golden path, and started picking the glowing mushrooms on

A Comparison of Little Red Riding Hood and Little Red Cap

1022 words - 4 pages innocence, her move from childhood or adolescence into adulthood. The way women are treated within each story is different. Little Red in the French version was eaten; whereas in the German version, she is rescued by the woodsman, and this further emphasizes the cultural differences.      The common elements in the two stories are the wolf, Little Red (Riding Hood/Cap), her grandmother, and her mother. The beginnings of the stories are also similar

Fairytale Analysis: "Aladdin's Lamp" and "Little Red Riding Hood"

1031 words - 4 pages significance is especially apparent in the appropriations of ‘Aladdin’s Lamp’ and ‘Little Red Riding Hood’. Aladdin’s Lamp, 1704, was included in Antoine Galland’s translation of Arabian Nights., however, it has a status as a disputed orphan tale, bearing its origins vaguely from an 1115 manuscript and a tale recited to Galland by a scholar, Youhenna Diab . The tale was designed specifically to appeal to both the aristocratic and the plebeian

A Psychoanalytical Look at Broumas' Little Red Riding Hood

607 words - 2 pages A Psychoanalytical Look at Broumas' Little Red Riding Hood     Sigmund Freud, the key developer of the psychoanalytical approach to the human mind, created a theory that can explain the driving force behind all forms of human life. In his theories he uses the desire for sexual pleasure as one of those driving forces, but very often, according to Freud, those desires are not met, weather they are through the actual event

The Variations in Little Red Riding Hood

3615 words - 14 pages remains, of course, as to if and when students should read "Little Red Riding Hood." Although E.D. Hirsch, Jr.'s Cultural Literacy is a debatable book, it has been very influential, and Hirsch, for good reason, lists the tale in his "Appendix: What Literate Americans Know." (184) The story pervades our culture, and thus Hirsch is probably right. Depriving students of "Little Red" is to deprive them of an important focal point on our culture

Psychological Approach to Little Red Riding Hood

760 words - 3 pages Psychological Approach to “Little Red Riding Hood”       By looking at Broumas’ Little Red Riding Hood you can apply the three Freudian zones of the psychological approach to the poem, which are the id, superego, and ego. The three Freudian zones allow the reader to look at different aspects that is believed to rule our lives.  Each zone has a different meaning that interrelates with the other.  Broumas’ Little Red Riding Hood has lots of

"Little Red Riding Hood": Write a descriptive story and show the building of tension and climax.

1558 words - 6 pages beautiful crescent blue musketeer clothing, was on duty in the inner areas of the forest, in patrol duty to protect innocent citizens from dangers of wolves and other sly creatures. Noticing little red riding hood, a young maiden, walking through the forest, the hunter followed her.Little red riding hood walks towards the forest, as a cunning wolf slowly follows the foolish girl, secretly, and intercepts his prey right at the cross road of the

An essay examining gender roles in the child's fairy tale Red Riding Hood, or "Little Red Cap".

1016 words - 4 pages Cap leaves his company, "[t]he wolf thought to himself, this is a good juicy morsel" (748). Two things are evident in this statement. First, the carnal appetite of the wolf (juicy morsel) is shown again in another suggestive remark. Secondly it shows the girl is an unthinking puppet at the direction of first her mother, then the wolf, who is capable of rational thought and devious logic. "Little Red Cap," he said, "just look at the beautiful

Cultural Values and Communication Norms: A Comparative Analysis of Two Cultures

2192 words - 9 pages Malaysian Management. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: Malaysian Institute of Management. 2. Avruch, K., Cross-Cultural Conflict. Conflict Resolution: Vol.1. Institute for Conflict Analysis & Resolution (4D3), George Mason University. 3. Culture Briefings: Malaysia (2003, November), Retrieved from 4. Dattner, B., A Framework for Understanding Cross-Cultural Misunderstandings. New York University. 5

Similar Essays

Comparative Essay Of Little Red Riding Hood

1584 words - 6 pages significant role in many versions of Little Red Riding Hood. There are three types of versions that will be analyzed: an oral story, a written interpretation, and lastly a film adaptation. The first to be analyzed is an oral story. "Oral tradition is the transmission of cultural items from one member of a culture to another, or others. Those items are heard, stored in memory, and when appropriate, recalled at the moment of subsequent transmission

Little Red Riding Hood Essay

3762 words - 15 pages analysis, investigating the theme of aggression and cruelty in Little Red Riding Hood, which is a well-known bedtime story.The fairy tale of Little Red Riding Hood is now incorporated into the literature of all civilized peoples, and is read as enthusiastically by the children around German and French firesides as it is in England and America. (Aldin, 238-239) It also has a lot of fans in Iran, in a way that there is not anyone who does not know

Little Red Riding Hood Essay

767 words - 3 pages Little Red Cap: A Reflection of the Past All cultures have their folktales. These folktales often reflect the culture's attitudes and beliefs towards important issues. "Little Red Cap" reveals a time when the modern idea of the family unit was being established. The primary place of a woman was at home. A man was responsible for earning a living outside of his household. Society valued purity and innocence. The gender roles in this world

Little Red Riding Hood Essay

1141 words - 5 pages There was a young boy called Red. It was a good name, because everything he wore was red – his K-Swiss Trainers were red, his New York cap was Dark red, his t-shirt was a deep crimson and even his hair had bright red tips. He was a cheeky orphan, who didn’t obey the rules; he was rather mature but still quite arrogant. He lived in the middle of a city a big city - the busiest place in the world, it was called New London and it was in