Local Successes And National Failures Of The Ezln Today

1242 words - 5 pages

Local Successes and National Failures of the EZLN Today

On January 1, 2004, over one thousand people in the mountain hamlet of Oventic, Chiapas, celebrated the 10th anniversary of the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) rebellion with song and dance. It seems a fitting time to take stock of the successes and failures of the Zapatista movement in the context of its original goals. The success of the establishment of thirty eight autonomous indigenous communities in Chiapas is overshadowed by government’s refusal to permit similar autonomous regions outside Chiapas. Moreover, the Zapatistas have failed to have a tangible effect on national economic policies. In the following pages, we will explore those factors which made the isolated successes of the Zapatistas possible, and extrapolate from Linda Hamilton’s analysis of the “limits to state autonomy” (CITE) to explain the failure of the Zapatistas to implement their broader vision of social justice.

In a letter to President Zedillo in 1994, Subcomandante Marcos demanded for all Mexicans three conditions for a “dignified peace: democracy, liberty and justice.” The Zapatistas’ nationalist ideals were supplemented by practical demands to meet the needs of the impoverished and exploited indigenous peoples of Mexico. In 1993, EZLN promoted an indigenous struggle

“for work, land, housing, food, health care, education, independence, freedom, democracy, justice and peace. We declare that we will not stop fighting until the basic demands of our people have been met by forming a government of our country that is free and democratic.”

By the late nineties, the struggle for indigenous autonomy had become “the central basis of the Zapatista movement.”

Since 1994, the Zapatistas have made significant gains towards autonomy, health, and education within Chiapas. As of December, 2003, the EZLN had established 38 autonomous municipalities which “have constructed a series of schools, clinics and co-ops that fill the openings created by the rebels’ refusal to take money from the mal gobierno (bad government).” In addition, the Zapatistas have created five organizational centers (caracoles) and established Juntas of Good Government in each of them in order to “resolve conflicts and disequilibrium between the centers and the outlying autonomies.” The caracoles mark the EZLN’s first success with regional, as opposed to municipal, autonomy. These Zapatista achievements can be attributed to the local terrain of Chiapas, the legal restraints of legislation, as well as local and national scrutiny.

The Mexican government faced legal and practical restraints from launching an all-out war on the Zapatistas. After a government counter-attack in 1995, the federal congress passed a “law for dialogue.” This foreclosed the option of a unilateral show of force by the Mexican army in areas under Zapatista control. Moreover, this legislation catalyzed the signing of the San Andrés...

Find Another Essay On Local Successes and National Failures of the EZLN Today

Successes and Failures Essay

781 words - 4 pages In my opinion, success and failure depend on whether you have given your best shot. Even though trying does not guarantee a good outcome, it is always worth the try. If a person does not take the first step to get out of his comfort zone, how can he ever improve himself from where he began with? However, I am a very shy and really lazy with reading news or books. Moreover, in my living area, there are more people to speak Chinese rather than

The Successes and Failures leading to the collapse of The Wiemar Republic

2132 words - 9 pages once Hohenzollern Monarchy and a rise in the practical ideology of Democracy. Historians discuss that the Weimar Republic as a Democracy proved a significant rather valuable subject of the Weimer Republic; its many successes however, mirrored the failures leading to its collapse to the Extreme-Right wing party Leader - Hitler - after the great depression. The many attempts to overthrow the Weimer Government where agreed to be a result of the much

The Successes and Failures of Mussolini's Domestic Policies in Italy Between 1922 and 1939

1606 words - 6 pages The Successes and Failures of Mussolini's Domestic Policies in Italy Between 1922 and 1939 Similar to those of Hitler, Mussolini’s main goals were to create an Italian state with a strong identity and role within Europe with a powerful military force. From the day he became Prime Minister on October 29th, 1922 of a coalition government, he lacked a certain skill in organization. It was not quite clear what exactly

Discuss the successes and failures of the Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929

2051 words - 8 pages The Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929 had many successes and failures, starting in chaos and ending in relative stability. However, due to individual perspective these successes and failures were often viewed as both successes and failures- not either. Class, political leanings and other moralistic beliefs, primarily influenced the individual's perspectives. Overall, due to the relative stability, (the aim of any government) primarily achieved

Evaluate the Successes and Failures of One Single Party State.(Stalin's USSR)

1353 words - 5 pages Having reached the pinnacle of power in 1929, Stalin attacked the primary problems facing Russia, which broadly fell under the economic, political and social, and the foreign respective categories. Success can be defined as the positive externalities brought about to the people and country. Where as failure being the lack of such. In my essay I will be using this definition to determine the successes and failures in the respective categories

Successes and Failures of Sexual Offences Act 2003

1419 words - 6 pages Successes and Failures of Sexual Offences Act 2003 The Sexual Offences Act 2003 was heralded as a response to shifting social attitudes, encompassing the broad libertarian approach towards sexual behaviour that has become increasingly dominant since the Act that preceded it whilst attempting to account for the myriad of more widespread sexual deviancies and abusive practices that were otherwise poorly regulated by

Successes and Failures in Biotechnology Innovation

2297 words - 9 pages Successes and Failures in Biotechnology Innovation      When I first started this paper I would have to admit that I was pretty green in the field of Biotechnology, I had a brief understanding but nothing near an in depth understanding of the field. So when I first started looking for a success story, I tied my views on successful innovation in the areas that I am familiar with to the biotech field. The major theme that emerged was that

Local and National Provision of Football

1348 words - 5 pages Local and National Provision of Football I have chosen the sport of Football to study in my local and national provision; the assignment consists of 6 sub-headings; · Grassroots development. · Provision for pathways/for elite performance. · Additional agencies and bodies. · Provision for male/female competitors. · Provision for disabled participant’s local/elite. · Critical analysis/evaluation

Detail the factors that brought about the Cuban revolution of 1958/59 and evaluate the successes and failures of the subsequent communist government.

1890 words - 8 pages Detail the factors that brought about the Cuban revolution of 1958/59 and evaluate the successes and failures of the subsequent communist government.The first part of this essay will explore and analyze the many factors that brought about the Cuban revolution of 1958/59.These factors stretch back to when Colon first landed in Cuba in 1942.Cuba's location in the Carribean has always been the key aspect which foreign powers have most wanted the

Critically analyze some of the successes and failures of the mission (What led to the interventions and how successful were they?

1922 words - 8 pages . The military intervention into Libya is said to use “ all necessary measures" to stop bloodthirsty attacks of Gaddafi and protect civilians. They had limited successes in terms of putting an end to Gaddafi’s government. However, the UN intervention in Libya has raised an amount of controversy . This essay tends to examine main reasons of the interference of the U.S and its allies into Libya and explicate the main successes and failures of this

The Façade of Heroism -- Discusses the Presidency of John F. Kennedy; his successes and failures, and that his success resulted more from inspirational demeanor than true talent.

1204 words - 5 pages national security, but more importantly of issues of personal shame. He lied about his background, claiming he attended the London School of Economics, when in fact he did no such thing (Reeves 96). He lied to his wife and essentially to the nation, regularly and unashamedly committing adultery (Reeves 93). He even stooped so low as to lie to the nation about his words-read-per-minute count (Reeves 99). Of course, dishonesty was not nearly his only

Similar Essays

The Successes And Failures Of The Zapatista Movement

1991 words - 8 pages The Successes and Failures of the Zapatista Movement On January 1, 2004, over one thousand people in the mountain hamlet of Oventic, Chiapas, celebrated the 10th anniversary of the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) rebellion with song and dance. Thus, it seems a fitting time to take stock of the successes and failures of the Zapatista movement in the context of its original goals. While the EZLN has been able to establish

The Successes And Failures Of The League Of Nations

1562 words - 6 pages In the 1920s, the League of Nations achieved some significant successes involving the international community. One of the main achievements was making agreements that were designed to solve international conflict and sustain global peace. The League managed to solve disputes over the Upper Silesia, Aaland Islands, Bulgaria, and other small nations. It also addressed the issues of health, transport, refugees, working conditions and other social

The Successes And Failures Of The New Deal

1446 words - 6 pages certain necessities, without providing the politicians with the opportunity of corruption, Roosevelt watched over these proceedings carefully. The plans that were implemented at this time included huge public buildings, dams, irrigation and other flood- control projects. Another relief plan that helped businesses in particular was the National Recovery Administration, along with the National Industrial Recovery Act. These were designed to help

Successes And Failures Of Patriarchy In Colonialism

3256 words - 13 pages through his dialogue with Owen, when he says that ‘we must learn those new names’ . His ignorance is amplified when he takes the post in ‘the new national school’ , only thinking about the money. Gaelic, once the spoken language of the entire island, declined in use sharply in the nineteenth century, as a result of the 1845-1849 great famine and the transformation of the nationalisation education system. Hedge schools were supplanted by the national