Locked In Syndrome And Pvs Essay

1621 words - 6 pages

Locked-In Syndrome and PVS: Implications for Brain = Behavior

During our first few class sessions, I became very intrigued by the brain = behavior idea and the I-function. I kept searching for what I thought to be an easy way to approach these complicated issues. We discussed extensively the example of Christopher Reeve, as someone with an intact I-function, but who has lost a certain element of connectedness between total I-function control and his actual body. I became very interested in how the I-function and brain = behavior interrelate. I thought that looking into some information about the persistent vegetative state and the locked-in syndrome would yield a satisfying and definitive answer once and for all. Is a brain still a brain without the I-function? I found no definitive answer, but I was able to convince myself of the "less-wrongness" of the brain = behavior idea.

I first looked into the persistent vegetative state. Below I have reproduced a somewhat technical explanation of how PVS patients are believed not to have an I-function:

Three lines of evidence suggest that PVS patients are "noncognitive, nonsentient, and incapable of conscious experience [12]." First, motor and eye movement, and facial expressions in response to stimuli occur in stereotyped patterns rather than learned reactions. Second, positron emission tomography reveals cerebral glucose metabolism at a level far below those who are aware or in locked in states. PVS levels are comparable to those in deep general anesthesia and as such are totally unaware and insensate. Third, neuropathological examinations of PVS patients show "lesions so severe and diffuse [12]" that it would be almost impossible, giving our current understanding of neural anatomy and function, to have any sort of awareness. (1) [see site for references within]

As the above passage clearly indicates, patients in PVS lack an I-function. They are totally removed from the world of perceptive experience – they are simply not there. A PVS patient goes through normal periods of sleep and wakefulness, can "grind their teeth, swallow, smile, shed tears, grunt, moan, or scream" (2). When I discovered this, I was quite puzzled. I didn’t understand how someone who is ostensibly not in control of such actions, could exhibit behavior that in my everyday life I observe to be a clear indication of emotion and feeling. These are things that seemed to me should to be absent from the lives of people with this syndrome.

What troubled me I later found out, was simply the fact that these things are remarkably similar to things we might normally think are clear evidence of the I-function. So, my problem with the I-function then became the following: if a human being has no I-function then does brain still equal behavior? It seemed very interesting to me that that the things a PVS patient can do don’t require a functioning mind to do them. That is, the brain, even when seriously injured, can control a range...

Find Another Essay On Locked-In Syndrome and PVS

Ethical Issues in End-of-Life Decisions Essay

1814 words - 7 pages have cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) if your heart stops or if you stop breathing” (Family Doctor.org, 2010). Dr Cranford, an advocate for the “right-to-die” movement was one of the neurologists who testified in the Terri Schiavo’s case in favor of removing the feeding tube. Ronald Cranford who calls himself, “Dr Humane Death, states "Just a few decades ago cases of brain death, vegetative state, and locked-in syndrome were rare," he wrote

Case study:The Portman Hotel

2291 words - 9 pages ' personalities and their professionalities.Although the Portman Hotel has unique philosophy, its strategies do not coordinate with it. Here are some strategies that I think have some faults in the hotel after I read this case.RecruitingThere are several faults in how the Portman Hotel recruited their PVs (personal valets). First, they thought the most important measure of PVs' personality is "friendliness". Mene, vice president and managing director of

Portman Hotel and the management of change

1289 words - 5 pages employees don't get promotions.Whereas employees in other hotels had a very specific task to perform, PVs are asked to be skillful in cleaning, serving, bar tending etc. Their pay isn't adapted to their polyvalence as they earn as much as maids in other hotels.Salary at Portman's is mainly based on tips, the base pay being low (7.5$ an hour) and the expected weekly tip estimated at 200$.The "broad" content of the PV's position is a good way to easily


1501 words - 6 pages murder. Euthanasia may stop the pain and suffering of watching a loved one die but it also adds the extra burden on relatives who may have to live with, perhaps, a lifetime of guilt. Should euthanasia be legalised or not? The medical profession, like society in general, is split on this issue. Some doctors say that withholding the treatment of a patient in a deep coma-like state called Persistent Vegetative State (PVS

Family Members Should NOT Decide When Life Support is Needed

1621 words - 6 pages not the same. When an individual is brain dead there is no activity anywhere in the brain, in PVS there is some activity in the brain steam and some other primitive regions. Persistent vegetative state or PVS often follows a coma and refers to a state where an individual loses their higher cerebral functions of their brain, but their breathing and circulation (functions of the brainstem) remain comparatively normal. The individual may cry, laugh

Prader-Willi Syndrome Discovered by by Endocrinologists Andrea Prader and Heinrich Willi

1623 words - 6 pages Syndrome Association).” Children will have normally acted no differently than other children. They will though want to continually eat. Children with this syndrome will often be shorter, and have lesser muscle tone, even in some cases having mental retardation; as well as being unable to control their eating, which usually results in obesity, if all food at home and school is not locked up. “Fewer calories are needed to maintain normal growth and

Down Syndrome

660 words - 3 pages Down Syndrome, a chromosome abnormality is present in all ethnicity, social economic classes, and gender. In Britannica.com, Down Syndrome is defined as a "congenital disorder by an extra chromosome on the chromosome 21 pair." Although there are many theories that have been forwarded for the cause of chromosome abnormalities, there is no known research for the cause of Down Syndrome. There are three main types of chromosome abnormalities in Down

The Cause and Effects of Down Syndrome

1274 words - 5 pages The Cause and Effects of Down Syndrome Some people wonder what Down syndrome is. How it is caused, and how it is treated. The causes and effects of Down syndrome is when there is an extra 21St chromosome. The effects include some birth defects and health problems. The physical features are different from someone without Down syndrome. What is Down syndrome? It is a chromosomal disorder caused by an error in cell division that results in an


971 words - 4 pages Down Syndrome is a disease in which there is an extra 21st chromosome in the body. This is caused during cell division. When the baby is in the mother womb, down syndrome can be detected. It can also be detected after the baby is born as well. This disease causes the baby to not develop properly. Researchers have been studying the causes of down syndrome and one of the highest risks, is having the baby when you are over 44 years old. Once you

Genetic Disorders and Down Syndrome

1177 words - 5 pages and cause mild to severe mental retardation. Fragile X syndrome, Down syndrome, Turners syndrome and many other syndromes result from a mutation of a chromosome, an extra chromosome, or too few chromosomes. Discovered in 1991, Fragile X syndrome is considered a fairly new genetic disorder. According to The Fragile X Association, Fragile X Syndrome (FXS) is caused by the expansion or lengthening of the FMR1 gene on the X chromosome, known as a

Down Syndrome Chromosome Twenty One

1214 words - 5 pages Down Syndrome Chromosome Twenty One Down syndrome affects one out of 700 children born in the United States. A chromosomal disorder associated with the twenty first chromosome pair, brings a lifetime of challenges to the affected person. Down syndrome is associated with intellectual disability, a characteristic facial appearance and reduced muscle tone during infancy as stated by Genetics Home Reference (2013). There are three different

Similar Essays

Savant Autism And Asperger’s Syndrome In Children And Adults

1765 words - 7 pages autism, can sometimes have symptoms that are not so severe, causing the person to appear almost normal. Savant syndrome is people who have more severe symptoms, but have extraordinary talents. In popular culture, the end of the spectrum is shown, such as in the novel The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time written by Mark Haddon, and the movie Rain Man. The characters Christopher and Raymond help to paint a picture of Savant autism and

Distinguishing The Differences Between Asperger’s Syndrome And Depression Symptoms In Adolescents

1876 words - 8 pages This paper will focus on the distinctions between the symptoms of Asperger’s syndrome and depression symptoms in adolescents. Misdiagnosed children suffer silently, facing academic difficulties. A strategy for early detection, treatment and prevention of depression within the school setting is an effective approach for success. The Differences Between the Two Disorders Asperger’s syndrome is an autism spectrum disorder. The most notable

This Is An Essay On Prader Willi Syndrome. It Is In Depth And Fills A Solid Three Pages. 820 Words

888 words - 4 pages Prader-Willi Syndrome Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is a genetic disorder that causes low muscle tone (floppiness), short stature, cognitive disabilities (mental retardation), behavioral problems, and chronic hunger that can lead to over-eating and life threatening obesity. The disorder is usually caused by an error during sperm and egg formation, not passed on from parent to child like most genetic diseases. This makes the disease nearly

A Report On Down Syndrome. This Report Tells About How People Are Born With The Disorder And What They Can Do Later In Life.

611 words - 2 pages Down syndrome is a disorder that is caused by an extra number 21 chromosome. This affects one in every 800 births worldwide, and causes birth defects. Also, there is no cure for Down syndrome. Most research says that there have always been people suffering from Down syndrome. Dr Jon Langdon Down was the first person to recognize this. Down syndrome was also known as "mongolism" because the people who had it seemed to resemble Mongolian Asians