This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Looking For Answers In Looking For Richard

1865 words - 7 pages

Looking for Answers in Looking for Richard  

    Al Pacino's "Looking for Richard" is an unusual film. It is a documentary about the complexities of Shakespeare, the performing of the play Richard III, and the ignorance of the average American regarding Shakespeare. The unusual nature of the film - it's similar to a filmed Cliff-notes version of the text - provokes wildly different reactions from film buffs, critics, and Shakespeare purists. A perusal of five different reviews of the film show such variant descriptors that range from Mary Brennan's comment that the documentary is "decidedly narcissistic" to Edwin Jahiel's comment that the film is an "original, mesmerizing exploration." The rather wide incongruity between the reviews leads to an interesting juxtaposition of its critiques, as we examine the reasons "Looking for Richard" incites such strong responses from its proponents and detractors.

A summarized look at each of the reviews reveals the wide range among the criticisms. The first review, by Mary Brennan and posted on the Film.Com web site, is generally positive, despite the aforementioned quotation that the documentary is "decidedly narcissistic." Brennan found herself enjoying the film despite herself, enjoying the "extraordinarily riveting" way the film dissected Shakespeare. However, every endorsement of the film is subsequently balanced by a disparaging remark about it. Brennan calls some of the rehearsals "thoroughly entertaining," then says that the endless scenes of Pacino "mugging into the camera... rapidly lose their charm." Still, she seems to enjoy the film despite its perceived weaknesses. Al Pacino's posturing is "exasperating but likable," and the whole package is enjoyable. Brennan seems to take the not-uncommon view that Pacino revealed his ego prominently throughout "Looking for Richard," but that along with it he revealed Shakespeare's text with exceptional clarity.

Part of the issue when perusing these reviews is to determine what the critic perceived the purpose of Pacino's film to be. Brennan's hypothesis is that Pacino's primary objective is to find meaning in Richard III, and the secondary objectives include creating an accessible version of the play the Mr. Joe Average can understand, while portraying the acting process when faced with such a formidable text. How a critic views the goals of the film directly relates to how well he or she believes Pacino achieved these goals, so it is important to discuss them.

Dre, a Girls on Film critic, offers another similar conjecture as to what Pacino's goals for the film were. According to the first-name only Dre, the purpose of the film was to present a tribute to Shakespeare, to explore the acting process, and to explain and portray a version of Richard III. Giving the film the page's highest rating, it is obvious that Dre feels the film delivers on its goals.

In fact, much of Dre's words match quite closely with the reasons Pacino stated...

Find Another Essay On Looking for Answers in Looking for Richard

Comparative study of texts and contexts (King Richard III and Looking for Richard)

963 words - 4 pages Context influences the representation of values in a text and can shape the meaning to become more relevant. This is shown through the texts 'Richard III' by William Shakespeare and 'Looking for Richard' by Al Pacino. The different values held in society in the times these texts were created have a strong impact on the way they were written. The idea of divine order and justice was prominent in the time Shakespeare wrote the play, while the

Looking For Alaskla Essay

646 words - 3 pages forgotten to visit the grave. They never find out whether or not she committed suicide. At the end of the novel, Pudge turns in an essay for school that answers one of Alaska's questions: "How will we ever get out of this labyrinth of suffering?" He concludes that to forgive is the way out of the labyrinth of suffering, and Alaska's spirit must still exist somewhere, because it was too full of life to stop existing. What are the central

Looking for Alibrandi Essay

956 words - 4 pages Melina Marchetta In what ways does Melina Marchetta comment on racial and cultural differences, and how effectively does her novel reflect reality? Looking for Alibrandi is a novel that discusses many racial and cultural differences and portrays the issues with a perspective very similar to reality. Marchetta addresses these issues with a true understanding as she grew up in the same conditions as Josephine Alibrandi. The main issue is how

Looking For Alibrandi

771 words - 3 pages Growing up is complex, especially in a society with different cultural background. This is the major issue the novel "Looking for Alibrandi" discusses. A realistic view through the eyes of a seventeen-year old Italian girl, Josephine is presented. Josephine’s like many teenagers that have learned from their mistakes. This is the long road that everybody meets while growing up. Learning to become an adult has many different

Looking for Alibrandi

804 words - 3 pages It can be argued that Looking for Alibrandi is very much a novel about change. After all, at its end Josie Alibrandi consents to becoming Josie Andretti. But there are many other things that change in her life. She loses a friend, John Barton, in tragic circumstances, but she also discovers her father. Mysteries about the actual identity of her mother's father are solved, and she develops a greater understanding and love for her grandmother. She

Looking for a Roommate

1330 words - 6 pages with me to let him find us two more roommates, but my answer was still no- Oh Gosh he’s doing the puppy eyes, I can’t say no to the puppy eyes. I mean how bad could it be, my room is pretty big I could fit another roommate in there, but the boys on the other hand would be pretty cramped with three in a room. For some odd reason even though there were two of them in their room and only one of me they insisted that I take the small room. And that

Looking For Love...Online

1329 words - 5 pages Today, we have the ability to do a multitude of tasks online; a computer is used in almost every school, home, and business in America. It’s not so futuristic to think that people would also find ways to enhance their personal lives online. Dating online began in the 1970’s and carried with it the stigma that only desperate people used the web to search for a love; however, today this stigma is gone, and dating online is a widely excepted

Looking For Happiness

1459 words - 6 pages personal anecdote to give reader a basic idea of what is happiness to some people. Second, he cites some experts’ sayings of what is happiness in order to give reader a professional answer. Third, he also cites some experts’ sayings to inform readers how people control or pursue happiness. Buettner’s last two parts of the essay are written in division. He divided these into eight questions. For example, the questions are “What is happiness?”(6

when looking for humor

734 words - 3 pages with his sense of humor is suitable through a variety of mediums. Despite the circumstances, he is known to invite himself directly/indirectly in a way approach the listeners subject to their situation. “Humour is therapeutic, providing a mechanism for coping with daily stressors and having positive effects on the immune and central nervous systems” (Shammi and Stuss, 1999). If Bernie Mac could openly discuss delicate phases of his early life

Looking for Relationships Between Variables in Malaysia

1072 words - 5 pages Methods Design This research is a correlation design because it is a study that employed surveying method and also the variables measured in this study are used to look for relationship between the variables. There are four variables in this study. They are perceived mother acceptance. The second predictive variable is perceived father acceptance or rejection. The third predictive variable is the gender of respondent which consists of male or

Looking for Alaska Book Report

1016 words - 5 pages Looking for Alaska starts off with Miles Halter leaving his home town in Florida in search for the Great Perhaps (the last words of Francois Rabelais) at Culver Creek Preparatory High School in Alabama; the same boarding school his father had attended when he was younger. At the beginning of the book Miles is seen as a bit of an outcast with little friends and a weird habit of memorizing people’s last words. Miles arrives at Culver Creek and

Similar Essays

Richard Iii And Looking For Richard Connections

962 words - 4 pages To explore connections between texts is to heighten understanding of humanity’s progressing values and the underlying relevant themes that continue to engage societies regardless of context. William Shakespeare’s King Richard III (1592) (RIII) and Al Pacino’s docudrama Looking for Richard (1996) (LFR) demonstrate how opinion is created through comparative study, both explore the struggle for power within differing contexts to determine the

Comparison Of King Richard Iii And Looking For Richard

911 words - 4 pages Connection between texts shapes your understanding of context and valuesExaminations of Shakespeare's play 'King Richard III' and Pacino's docu-drama 'Looking for Richard' reveals relationships between the texts and their respective audience. The fifteenth century and twentieth century contexts demonstrates the values of each text and enables understanding of how the film enriches the ideas presented in the play. 'King Richard III' portrays a

Connections Between Richard The Third And Looking For Richard

1311 words - 5 pages Richard the 3rd and Looking for Richard"Transcript"Good Morning and my fellow scholars, I am Doctor Keenan Singh and welcome to my keynote presentation.William Shakespeare's 'History tragedy' Richard the III, is an incredibly informative and entertaining play from the Elizabethan Era, though for much of the general population of the 20th century, itself and Shakespeare's work in general are seen as out-dated and irrelevant to the contemporary

Comparison Of King Richard Iii And Looking For Richard

1603 words - 6 pages hunchback’d toad’, reflects the play’s propagandist nature, and in conjunction with divine imagery, with Richard being the foul devil, juxtaposed against the God-fearing Lady Anne. The perpetuation of the Tudor myth, through Shakespeare’s iniquitous characterization of Richard, reflects the often-biased nature of historical representation, through the particular contextual agenda of the Elizabethan reign. Pacino’s film Looking for Richard reflects