Louis Riel: A Hero Or A Traitor?

685 words - 3 pages

Was Louis Riel a hero or a traitor? Well, some individuals say that he was a hero, and others say that he was a traitor. Individually I believe that Louis Riel was a hero because he was the forefather of Manitoba, which is a province of Canada. The fact that he was a persuasive politician and spiritual leader made him a hero as well. Lastly, he stood up for Native rights. Others like the British had thought of him mostly as a traitor, because they were not able to understand that Louis Riel had just needed the Canadian government to treat his people fairly, and that he was willing to do everything for his people. Instead the government had thought that he was violent and evil, so a threat to them. Most people who had seen him as a traitor had realized that he did everything for his people…after his hanging.

My first reason for saying that Louis Riel was a hero is that he was the founder of Manitoba which is why he said things like "I know that through the grace of God I am the founder of Manitoba" or “And the province of Manitoba? Without our provisional government it would still be nothing more than a colony tied to the apron strings of Canada. I deserve to be called the Father of Manitoba.” I think that the second quote, is kind of exactly what I think as well, because if there was no Louis Riel, there would be no Métis provisional government, meaning that Manitoba would be nothing more than a colony tied to the apron strings of Canada. That is why he should be called the father of Manitoba. Some people see him as the father of Manitoba, like the Métis, and that shows that they too show loyalty and consider Louis Riel a great hero.

Secondly, my second thought is that he was an influential politician and a spiritual leader. If you are a noble leader and a swaying politician, most...

Find Another Essay On Louis Riel: A Hero or a Traitor?

Edward Snowden: Hero or Traitor? Essay

1537 words - 6 pages truth whether we like it or not. The question still remains what to classify Snowden as. Is he the folk hero, the rebel, the traitor, or the man with who caused a million problems with one small leak? The truth is that Edward Snowden’s actions cannot be defined as simply good or evil. It had good effects on the American public. We deserve to know the inner workings of our government and we deserve to know if our rights are being invaded. The whole

Louis Pasteur: A National Hero Essay

1025 words - 4 pages Louis Pasteur, one of the greatest benefactors of humanity was the first person to see that bacteria cause diseases. He was a scientist who associated an animal disease with a microorganism. Pasteur solved the mysteries of rabies, anthrax, chicken cholera, and silkworm diseases. He is also contributed to the development of the first vaccine. He described the basis of fermentation, wine-making using pasteurization and brewing of beer. Pasteur’s

Benedict Arnold: A Traitor

995 words - 4 pages Arnold was in the hospital, recovering from the shot, Major-General Horatio Gates took all the credit for the monumental British surrender (Creighton). While all of this was happening, Arnold went broke and his wife, Margaret Shippen, passed away. Some say that Margaret is the real traitor. She came from a loyalist family and the legend has it that she wore him down so that he adopted their philosophies. Legend has it, Shippen the contacted her

Louis Riel Should not have been Hung: Agree or Disagree?

624 words - 2 pages Justice is fairness. Justice is equality. Justice is necessary. In today's society, justice isn't always served. Over a hundred years ago, justice wasn't always served. Louis Riel was just one of the many back in the days of John A Macdonald who was discriminated against and treated without respect. He was a Canadian politician, a devoted Métis leader, and most of all, a martyr for his people. Throughout his 41 year life, from 1844 - 1885

Edward Snowden is a traitor

884 words - 4 pages involving the stock market. Some people may be thinking at this point, “If Snowden stole secret for the greater good, doesn’t that make him a hero, not a traitor?” Not necessarily. A traitor is a person who betrays either a friend, a country or a principle. Snowden did exactly this and sold out his government. This was a violation against the United States government and a violation against the U.S.A. Someone who runs away from their own country to

Was Benedict Arnold a Real Traitor?

1153 words - 5 pages The argument over Arnold’s place in American history has carried into this century. All the Americans relate George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, and Thomas Jefferson as their heroes, but there is a debate whether Benedict Arnold was a victim or a traitor. Arnold was a general during the American Revolutinary War, and he fought for the Continental Army. His name became synonymous with the word traitor. Benedict Arnold was a Revolutionary Hero

Benedict Arnold: Marked as a Traitor

1184 words - 5 pages Benedict Arnold was an American hero. He might have even been the best general the United States had. But during a bleak moment of envy, hurt and distrust, an admirable leader turned into a monster that could not be turned back. When he was at his lowest, he decided to surrender West Point, a fort that was essential to the Americans during the Revolution, over to the British. He did not succeed, but he still managed to get away before he was

Was Napoleon a hero or a tyrant?

1337 words - 5 pages Was Napoleon a hero or a tyrant? The great Napoleon Bonaparte once said, "The art of government is not to let me grow stale." Napoleon meant that his leadership could protect France's advancements of eliminating the "old regime" but only if the French could keep him in power. Bonaparte grew up in a noble Italian family and attended some of the most prestigious military academies throughout France. His military education proved beneficial

Gregorio Cortez: A Hero or A Rebel?

956 words - 4 pages ) Many question if he’s a hero for defending his brother the way he defended him. Many think he is just a rebel for killing a sheriff for no good reason, but Cortez had a reason. Cortez is a hero for the reason that he was brave enough to confront injustices from defending his brother, never giving up, and persisted as long as he could, demonstrating that he had the courage most individuals do not. One of the many characteristics that a hero needs to

Ned Kelly a hero or a villain?

1009 words - 4 pages How does a man hanged for murder, become an Australian national hero? Ned was just 16 when he was convicted of receiving a stolen horse and served three years in gaol before being released in 1874. Whether or not he was set for a life of crime is hard to say, but one event had a dramatic effect on determining his future and that was in April 1878. A police officer called Fitzpatrick accused Ned's mother of attacking him and Ned of shooting him

Robin Hood: A Thief or a Hero?

1460 words - 6 pages innocent, poor people of the country, (Lindahl 1), it would be wrong not to betray the country. They were also involved in charging ridiculous taxes and oppressing the common people of the land. (“Robin Hood: The Folk Hero” 2). This is yet another reason that Robin Hood had to betray his country. Fighting against the evil is always the right thing to do whether you have pledged allegiance to them or not. Robin Hood was not a thief. He was simply

Similar Essays

Louis Riel: Victim Or Criminal? Essay

1826 words - 8 pages Louis Riel a Hero or a Traitor? Retrieved on June 5, 2014 from https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090615212104AAZjjpH Yahoo! Answers. (n.d.). Do You Think Louis Riel was Innocent or Guilty? Retrieved on June 5, 2014 from https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20101126200443AAiKtrD

Benedict Arnold: Traitor Or Hero? Essay

946 words - 4 pages People often talk about how “evil” Benedict Arnold was, how his name was often associated with the word “Traitor”. Then we hear how he was: brilliant, victorious leader, very successful, credited battle hero, and the list goes on. But do we really know if Benedict Arnold was as bad as his reputation proceed? Was Benedict Arnold a Traitor or a Hero? There has been six Benedict Arnolds including the traitor of the United States of America. The

Benedic Arnold: Hero Or Traitor? Essay

706 words - 3 pages villainous hero (or heroic villain) is the Revolutionary War general, Benedict Arnold. Whilst betraying his country, he lead America to victory in several pivotal battles. While Benedict Arnold did many bad and traitorous things, overall he was a Revolutionary War hero. Benedict Arnold is a good man who fought proudly for his country. His love and dedication to America towards the beginning of the war is hard to beat as well. Arnold himself

Edward Snowden Hero Or Traitor Essay

952 words - 4 pages of the people would be that they are protecting them from possible terrorists, but some may still ask the question of: Is the government violating my privacy? After gathering all the information, it is up to you to decide: Is Edward Snowden an American hero for exposing to the people of the U.S. the government’s dirty spying secrets or is he an American traitor guilty of espionage and treason?