This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Louisiana’s Public Policy Regarding Same Sex Marriage And Legitimacy Of Children

3095 words - 12 pages

The Current State of the Law in Louisiana
Louisiana’s Public Policy Regarding Same-Sex Marriage and Legitimacy of Children
Whenever matters of same-sex marriage arise, politicians and conservatives in Louisiana quickly reference Louisiana’s Constitution and the Civil Code, which ban and make it against public policy to enter into or acknowledge same-sex marriage. Louisiana’s public policy argument against same-sex marriage is primarily to protect their civil law tradition of marriage. The consensus from the senate floor was the civil law tradition had to be protected by more than just the Civil Code to continue the historic tradition of marriage existing only between a man and woman, and the way to accomplish this was to have the language added to the state constitution. Furthermore, supporters of the amendment argue it protects traditional marriage from all future threats. More so, supporters argue that the language in the amendment falls in line with the language of other civil code articles relating to marriage. For example, La. C.C. Art. 86 defines marriage as a civil contract entered by a man and woman, La. C.C. Art. 89 makes same-sex marriage an impediment, and La. C.C. Art. 94 states that a marriage with an impediment is an absolute nullity. Outside of the traditional and legal arguments, many anti-marriage equality supporters have religious, biological, and parenting arguments against same-sex marriage. A number of cases have relied on these arguments against same-sex marriage.
Legitimacy of Children
Louisiana also has a historically rooted public policy regarding legitimacy of children, reasoning that it is for protection and promotion of the family unit. Under Louisiana law, unmarried couples are not required to be listed on a child’s birth certificate. Furthermore, an unmarried couple is not permitted to receive a reissued birth certificate bearing both parties names as parents, regardless of an in-state or out-of-state adoption. Louisiana law provides a legal remedy for unmarried biological heterosexual parents who desire to be listed on their child’s birth certificate, if both parents voluntarily sign an agreement of paternity or by judicial decision. Unfortunately, this option is not extended to same-sex parents.
Louisiana has a presumption if a couple is married then the child born during the marriage is the husbands child. However, Louisiana allows dual paternity of a child meaning the child can have two fathers, biological and legitimate, the biological father provides support for the child while the legitimate father maintains his relationship with the child. The Supreme Court of Louisiana addressed this issue in Smith v. Cole, the Court affirmed the appellate courts ruling, and under dual paternity, the biological father had an obligation to provide support for his child while the legitimate father remained in his role. The Court reasons, a biological parent is not availed of a support obligation because...

Find Another Essay On Louisiana’s Public Policy Regarding Same-Sex Marriage and Legitimacy of Children

Legalization of Same Sex Marriage Essay

2510 words - 10 pages the debates over marriage, influenced outcome in voting nationwide against same sex marriage. These same religious groups are also very public and publish information easily available to the public about their financial contributions in support of bills such as Proposition 8 in order to keep same sex marriage illegal. With the separation of Church and State, how is one particular religious view allowed to prevent any individual from having the

Same Sex Parenting and Children Essay

1812 words - 7 pages limited amount of research in this area to corroborate this concern. Should same-sex marriage be an issue when raising children? Some states such as Massachusetts, Vermont, and Connecticut have legalized the holy union between two people; other states offer civil unions, and several offer partner-benefit programs. Whether you are on the right or left side, you still have to consider how this union might affect the children under the care of what

Same-Sex Marriage and Immigration: The Role of Federalism

1936 words - 8 pages Throughout recent years, two major issues have become prevalent in the United States, followed by increasing debate of whether they should be regulated by the federal government or state governments: same-sex marriage and immigration. Although the federal government has attempted to deal with same-sex marriage in the past, it has become evident that the public is not in agreement over this issue, rendering the efforts of the federal government

Same Sex Marriage

2189 words - 9 pages ideologies re-evaluate the meaning of love and marriage in modern society. Besides the social movements, several scientific research was made regarding children who grow up in same sex marriages. Children raised in a same sex marriage share the same core values with the society, maybe even higher because they never learned about sexual discrimination in their home, and the only reason why they are restrained is because of the public opinion on

The Issues of Gay and Same-Sex Marriage

1187 words - 5 pages socially conservative commentator, regarding the same sex marriage, Gallagher states, "Same sex marriage is founded in a lie about human nature:' there is no difference between same sex and opposite sex unions and you are a bigot if you disagree (Corvino 7).'" Gallagher uses the word “bigot” to describe her counterparts with conflicting opinions right away without any clarification of acts of intolerance by the opposing sides. The appropriate and

Same sex marriage

600 words - 2 pages causing problems in their society growing up.Legal endorsement of same-sex marriage would be confusing to the institution ofmarriage. Marriage is a social institution of a long term relationship between man and woman.Marriage is fundamentally about children, love between man and woman, and the civilization ofsociety. Marriage is an institution that much of the culture revolves around in the environment,The history of our nation has demonstrated

Same sex Marriage

1048 words - 5 pages modern society. Besides the social movements. Several scientific researches was made regarding children who grow up in same sex marriages. Children raised in a same sex marriage share the same core values with the society, maybe even higher because they never learned about sexual discrimination in their home, and the only reason they are restrained is because of the public opinion on these situations. People often think homosexuality is a disorder; it

Same Sex Marriage

1246 words - 5 pages that homosexual marriage is not as bad as some may see it. According to the Gallup poll that was taken in 2011, the public support for gays and lesbians has continued to rise throughout time. 64 percent of the respondents agreed that same-sex marriage should be legal. “Support for same sex marriage, which was endorsed by 27 percent of Americans in 1996, has risen ever since” (Stranz 117). Debates on homosexual marriage will take a toll on

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage

1238 words - 5 pages responsibilities, it cannot be replaced by civil unions or other social contracts. Thus, homosexuals should have the rights to be entitled the legitimacy and sanctity of marriage. Gay marriage is a major global issue regarding religious conflicts, psychopathology, and the protection of children of same-sex parents. Throughout history, the legal definition of marriage is constantly changing and progressing. Arranged marriages and polygamy were once considered

same sex marriage

3364 words - 13 pages of LGBTs and same-sex marriage must end in order for society to grow and accept the change around them. Politics has once corrupted the idea, but in recent years, same-sex marriage has favor in politics. Based on statistical data, a slight majority of politicians are now supportive of same-sex marriage, and campaign to provide LGBTs with equality. Public opinion states that more citizens wish to legalize the practice. Same-sex marriage should be

Against Same Sex Marriage

1290 words - 5 pages of life depends. It is the primary reason why marriage is so important to society. In same sex marriages procreation would be eliminated entirely.First, when the state sanctions homosexual relationships and gives them its blessing, the younger generation becomes confused about sexual identity and quickly loses its understanding of lifelong commitments, emotional bonding, sexual purity, the role of children in a family, and from spiritual

Similar Essays

Same Sex Marriage And Public Opinion Essay

3087 words - 12 pages “[Same-sex marriage legalization] would be a foolish and tragic choice,” the statement made by Peter Sprigg in 2012, still does echo some Americans feelings about same-sex marriage. Although there is some truth to his statement, the tide is turning in favor of legalization of same-sex marriage. As public opinion polls show, Americans are beginning to accept the idea of same-sex marriage more and more than they have been in the past. Their

Recognition And Legalization Of Same Sex Marriage

2979 words - 12 pages Louisiana Legislature amended the constitution to state that marriage in Louisiana only exists between one man and one woman. The Louisiana Civil Code article governing marriage expressly states, marriage between people of the same sex is strongly against the public policy of the state. Furthermore, Louisiana will not recognize a same-sex marriage legally entered in another state. Although Louisiana has such conservative views regarding

Pros And Cons Of Same Sex Marriage

1679 words - 7 pages , unconstitutional under both DueProcesseandaEqualuProtectioniClauses.”s.” Cons of Same-Sex Marriage Traditionally, the institution of marriage has been defined as between a man and a woman. On October 15, 1971, the Supreme Court of Minnesota found that the institution of marriage as a union of man and woman, uniquely involving the procreation and rearing of children within a family, is as old as the book of Genesis. The allowance of gay couples to be wedded

Legalization Of Same Sex Marriage Essay

1376 words - 6 pages Lesbian Couples Raising Children. Social Science Quarterly, 93 (4), 1007-1029. Daley, A. (2006). Lesbian and gay health issues: OUTside of Canada’s health policy. Critical Social Policy, 26(4), 794-816. Fein, B., & Stoddard, T. (1990). Gay marriage. ABA Journal, 76(1), 42-43. Hansen, T. (2009). Love Isn’t Enough: 5 Reasons Why Same-Sex Marriage Will Harm Children. Retrieved from http