Love And Psychotherapy Essay

2212 words - 9 pages

“Love and Psychotherapy are fundamentally incompatible. A good therapist fights darkness and seeks illumination, while romantic love is sustained by mystery and crumbles upon inspection” (use citation) This is the overall theme that is prevalent throughout the first story of Yalom’s book that is also titled, “Loves Executioner”
In this story Yalom decides to treat a 70-year-old woman named, “Thelma” that had a love affair with her former therapist, Mathew, eight years ago. Although Yalom believed no one was beyond his skills that he could break Thelma’s obsession with her former therapist, he soon realized that he was overcome by excessive hubris and the problem was more intricate and complex than it had appeared to be.
In the beginning of the story, because of a research grant on geriatric therapy he decides to treat Thelma and give her “good therapy”, as compared to the interns she has been used to seeing. Yalom felt she had not been given adequate therapy in the twenty some years she had been seeing inexperienced therapist as Yalom felt could treat any patient and Thelma was no different. I personally thought this was one of Yalom’s first mistakes as to assume that a person can treat virtually treat anyone is not admitting to possible limitations they have not explored in themselves as not ever situation is the same.
Yalom was intrigued with her love obsession and couldn’t understand why her former therapist that was considerably younger would even want to have sexual relations with Thelma which he describes her as, “a shabby old woman.” (citation) All of these aspects of Thelma’s crisis, the love affair with her former therapist, her obsession and the power he gave Matthew, made her the ideal candidate for the geriatric study on therapy.
In the first session Thelma explains to Yalom that he is her last hope and that she cant seem to move on from being obsessed over her former therapist and wants to give therapy one last try as she might succeed in committing suicide unlike last time she attempted it. (ciation) Thelma explains about her and Mathew’s first meeting outside therapy happened a year later in union square San Francisco near a cafe. Thelma and Matthew end up spending the day having coffee and talking about everything as if they had been old friends reunited, as the next 27 days they becoming very close as we as having sex on one occasion. She describes Mathew being caring and attractive and how she had suspicion’s that he was gay because he lived in one of the San Francisco gay enclaves. (ciation )
Thelma informs Yalom that she had not spoke to Mathew in over eight years that she couldn’t see herself without him, as she would just be happy with a phone call to let her know he still thinks about her as he made her feel alive and that Thelma could care less if he loved he or not. (Citation) I found idea of her needing to speak to Matthew interesting because even though Thelma says she doesn’t care if Mathew loves her,...

Find Another Essay On Love and Psychotherapy

Carl Rogers Essay

1060 words - 4 pages psychotherapeutic method: "unconditional positive regard"……?"(Psychotherapy Networker Magazine, 2007)Carl Rogers was a prominent psychotherapist and consultant, and one of the top respected psychologists in the country. In 1982, a copy of Psychology Networker was published and in the same year, American Psychologist had surveyed members of the American Psychological Association to find out which orientations they followed and which

Personality Disorders Affect Social Repuration Essay

931 words - 4 pages an altered self-image. As a matter of fact, it is characterized by an abnormal love of self, an exaggerated sense of superiority and importance, and a concentration on pride, power, and success (MayoClinic). Other common traits of Narcissism include preoccupation of intelligence, beauty, or love, expectation that others will follow what he or she desires, inability to recognize another person’s feelings, and envy of others. A narcissist may mask


1710 words - 7 pages of that, I always have the answer if people ask me why I did something. Based on that, I discover myself quite critical over something. I might not say it out loud, but the thinking seems restless. It affects my relationship with significant others. For example, when someone says he/she loves me, I would wonder why, what make him/her love me. These thought some time make me feel bitter. Hence, all these time I try to balance between thinking and

couples therapy for Shrek and Fiona

1037 words - 4 pages fire-breathing dragon. Much to Shrek's dismay, he is accompanied on his journey by a talking donkey that is extremely hyperactive, inattentive and annoying. For Shrek, who's main goal is to be alone, this is a challenging proposition.Fiona is the princess whom Shrek rescues and ultimately falls in love with. Princess Fiona, however, has been bewitched. She is a princess by day, and an ogre by night. She was hidden away in the tower by her father to

Depression in Adolescents

1809 words - 7 pages depression among adolescents. Being socially connected is one of the main contributors to having positive emotional health. Even though the National Longitudinal Study suggest being connected to family is the greatest preventive factor, connectedness within the school and the community are also important components in the prevention of depression. These relationships reflect love, communication, trust, and active roles between the teen and the groups


1750 words - 7 pages without treatment, most often will last longer. There are different methods of treating depression, which include antidepressant medication, psychotherapy and magnetic stimulation, but essentially, it is up to the individual to help themselves. One must believe in them self and have confidence in whom they are and what they want to do with their lives. There are numerous antidepressant medications and each works in their own way and has different

Anna Nicole Smith

1378 words - 6 pages Vickie Lynn Hogan grew up in a small, Texas town. She was a product of a difficult childhood due to poverty, her father leaving, and her mother having little to do with her. Feeling the pressures of poverty and the lack of love shown by her mother, Vickie eventually dropped out of school and married Billy Smith at the age of 17. A year after the nuptials she gave birth to a baby boy for which she claims she devoted her life to. The marriage to

Humanistic Psychology

2255 words - 10 pages are innately good, and that they have intrinsic value. It also assumes that people have the innate need to make themselves and the world better. Much like a plant has the instinctive tendency to grow under the proper environmental conditions, humanistic therapy argues that humans follow the same inborn tendencies. Given the correct amount of positive regard (unconditional love, acceptance, warmth), a healthy sense of congruence (the balance

The Contributions of Sigmund Freud

1589 words - 6 pages difficult to get into. In addition, Freud may have been discriminated against due to his Jewish decent. He settled for becoming a doctor. During this time, Freud began courting Martha Bernays, who was a friend of his sister. Freud was very prude and apprehensive when it came to romantic relationships. There were numerous accounts of love letters that Freud sent to Martha. One of his letters consisted of an inkblot, a psychotherapy

"Tis better to have loved and lost/Than never to have loved at all" (Tennyson). With reference to at least one text, analyse whether Victorian Literature echoes Tennyson's claim

1552 words - 6 pages member of the London Centre for Psychotherapy. He sums up Freud's different and opposing views on "Eros" are that "Eros clamours, holds together, unites, binds, preserves, lives, loves, is a parent, complicates and creates mischief." (Mann, 17). It is the idea that Eros "complicates and creates mischief" which will be discussed in reference to Wuthering Heights. It is the love between Heathcliff and Cathy, which "creates mischief" and is the

What is Energy Psychology?

1204 words - 5 pages Benefits Energy Psychology is astoundingly effective with fear, anxiety, and the emotional difficulties of everyday life, from unnecessary anger to intolerable feelings of guilt, shame, anger, jealousy, rejection, isolation, and grief. It helps change unwanted habits and behaviours and enhances the ability to love, succeed, and enjoy life. Average life coaches also incorporate energy psychology into their repertoire. They teach it to their

Similar Essays

Life Coaching And Therapy Essay

1804 words - 8 pages assistance. This review is considered according to a Christian worldview. Commonalities and Contrasts of Life Coaching and Therapy Experts in the therapy field and life coaching have been surveying the similarities and differences of life coaching and therapy over the past several decades. The chief focus in psychotherapy is on the client’s internal experiences or condition, whereas life coaching deals with well- balanced individuals who

Comparing Psychodynamic Psychotherapy And Person Centered Psychology

1612 words - 6 pages ability to get along with others is compromised. The final stage is the genital stage that lasts from puberty until death, in which the individual begins to explore their sexuality and pursue sexual behavior with a partner. Fixation at this stage provides the individual with difficulty having mature relationships because they can only experience extreme feelings of either love or hate. Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: Assessment, Testing

Approaches To Clinical Psychology Essay

686 words - 3 pages Emotive Behavioral Therapy (REBT). REBT is used in family and individual therapy to try to re-train the clients to learn to discover the root of their problems and find ways in which to alter their behaviors and attitudes to improve their outlook on life. "REBT is an action-oriented psychotherapy that teaches individuals to examine their own thoughts, beliefs and actions and replace those that are self-defeating with more life-enhancing alternatives

Albert Ellis Essay

1810 words - 8 pages a fiction author. He wrote many fictional works, but at the age of 28 with no published manuscripts he decided his talents lay elsewhere. Ellis (1977) chose to switch to nonfiction on sex, love, and marriage which he states “I was interested in and I thought would sell” (para. 25). He researched, read and became somewhat of an expert on the topics to where friends and family started asking for his advice. He soon discovered that he had an