Lycurgus And Spartan Government With Reference To Ancient Sources You Have Researched, Explain The Spartan System Of Government

1608 words - 6 pages

There is no doubt of the Spartan existence; however there is the legend of Spartan constitution, a mixture of all pre-existing schemes that holds uncertainty.The Spartan laws and constitution were supposedly the creation of a man named Lycurgus. There is much controversy and doubt concerning Lycurgus. The origin of Lycurgus’ legal reforms and the man himself is wrapped in legend. Is he a man or a myth and how did he embark on the laws for the city-state? The Historians; Plutarch, Xenophon, Plato, Aristotle and Herodotus explore the uncertainties of Lycurgus using historiography.Plutarch (c. 45-126 AD) was a Greek historian who wrote a series of biographies comparing Greek life to Roman life- illuminating their common moral virtues and failings. In his Life of Lycurgus he brought forth the issue that surrounded Lycurgus- the travels he embarked on, the laws that he supposedly made and the city-state which he founded.Plutarch detailed the arguments of the period in which Lycurgus lived “in general nothing can be said which is not disputed.” (Plutarch) Plutarch informs us that Aristotle- (c. 4th century BC) a Historian devoted to the constitution; had the opinion that Lycurgus thrived in the time of Iphitus and jointly “contrived the order for the cessation of arms during the Olympic Games” (Plutarch). However, Apollodorus (c.180BC) a Greek grammarian and Eratosthenes (c.276-194BC) a mathematician, geographer, and astronomer; declared he was more ancient than the Olympic Games by calculating the succession of the Spartan kings. Plutarch also examined Timaeus (c.345-250 BC), an ancient Greek Historian, who devoted much attention to chronology. He had the theory of more then one Lycurgus’- “…there were two Lycuguses at Sparta at different times and that to one of them the achievements of both were ascribed.” (Plutarch) There was speculation to say Lycurgus lived long after Homer; and some people say they had seen him “some assert that he actually met Homer face to face.” (Plutarch)These different reports demonstrate the uncertainty of the Spartan lawgiver Lycurgus and how there are many speculations and disagreements to the very age he descended from, “There is least agreement among historians as to his life dates.” (Plutarch)Just like the controversy over Lycurgus’ actual existence there is also the debate of the foundations of his laws and how they came to exist. Plutarch, Xenophon, Plato, Aristotle and Herodotus produced arguments in respect to whether Lycurgus received the Spartan law from the Delphic Oracle, Crete or if he simply asked the Oracle to affirm the laws he wrote independently.Xenophon (c.4th century BC) was a Greek Historian who provided insights for social customs, laws and the military of Sparta. In his’ Constitution of the Lacedaemonians he stated that Lycurgus, before he delivered his laws to the public, asked the Delphic Oracle to approve the laws that he...

Find Another Essay On Lycurgus and Spartan Government- With reference to Ancient sources you have researched, explain the Spartan System of Government

In reference to Land Rights and Criminal Justice System, how have Aborigines been disadvantaged by past government policies?

1104 words - 4 pages Past government policies which have disadvantaged ATSI in terms of land rights can be traced as early as settlement times in the late 18th century with the concept of Terra Nullius, to the still limited status of ATSI in owning traditional lands with the 1970s-present policy of self determination. These government policies have not only brought problems concerning land rights, but also other issues which continue to impact contemporary Australia

The Ancient Greek Government Essay

539 words - 2 pages gives everyone a voice in their government, meaning that everyone has a say and is treated fairly. In a democracy, anyone can be involved in running a country, but in a monarchy, a bad leader could very likely influence the country into making incorrect decisions and taking wrong actions. Instead of one person's opinion, the Greeks had begun a way of government that involved many voices.What is most significant about the ancient Greek government? It is important to remember that of all the things invented by the Greeks, the system of democracy was Greece's best idea of all. Thanks to the Greeks, democracy is still used in many countries throughout the modern world.

Globalization and the State System of Government

2554 words - 10 pages When answering the question “Who am I?” or “Who are we?,” more thought needs to be put into the response then ever before. The past 350 years have been characterized by the state system, which has provided the only answer one could possibly need to respond to the ‘identity question’. Everyone has identified themselves as a member of a state; a state being defined as a stable population with a government, a monopoly over the legitimate

Explain what you understand by the concept of 'globalisation' and, with reference to relevant examples, assess the role and impact of the mass media in this process.

2471 words - 10 pages capitalist world system spreading across the actual globe, and the expansion of a network of relations between countries. This is often for wealth and trading purposes, and can at times come at the expense of culture. Francois Bourricaud said, 'Modern societies are characterised less by what they have in common, or by their structure with regard to well-defined universal exigencies, than by the fact of their involvement in the issue of

"DEMOCRACY: Democratic government and democratic ideals" A general overview of democracy, the contemporary understanding of democracy with reference to governmental issues and democratic ideals.

2265 words - 9 pages not be separated with clear lines. First, it is a practice or method of government, a set of forms and procedures. Second, it relates to ends rather than means, to an ideal or set of ideals.DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENTFirstly, democracy is a form of government in which the people, either directly or indirectly, take part in governing. In practice it means following the view of majority. (Raphael, 1990) It is a system involving effective competition

America Must Explore Alternate Energy Sources and Cease Dealing with the Corrupt Saudi Government

2017 words - 8 pages America Must Explore Alternate Energy Sources and Cease Dealing with the Corrupt Saudi Government When Mohammed al-Khilewi, a high-ranking official at the Saudi mission to the United Nations, defected to the United States in 1994, he reportedly brought with him fourteen thousand internal government documents. He claimed that these documents proved the Saudi royal family's corruption, human rights abuses, and financial and technical

The Human Government System

980 words - 4 pages The Human Government System As the Human Race enters the new millenium we have created a somewhat organized and affective society. This society consists of many states that govern their people by allowing them to go about their daily activities and providing them services without a large amount of chaos interfering in their lives “Human beings usually do not venture out of their caves (or the modern counterpart) unless there is a reasonable

Area of study: Diversity - The Great Gatsby - 'Variety is the spice of life.' Discuss with reference to your prescribed text and other material you have studied.

2095 words - 8 pages morality plays an important part in the text. In society it is immoral to have an affair and kill someone. Daisy went against both these principles. She had an affair with Gatsby and killed her husband's mistress Myrtle. It is against society to commit these things and these should effect how she feels. Diversity of financial position can be shown through the characters Daisy and Nick for example. Daisy is rich and lives in a mansion while Nick lives

Aread of study : Journey - My Place by: Sally Morgan - 'Variety is the spice of life.' Discuss with reference to your prescribed text and other material you have studied.

2109 words - 8 pages shows people working so hard, day and night, with the inability to slow down, just to reach their life-long goals, but in actual fact are working to their death, which may be seen as their ultimate goal which they are yet to realise.There is also and added sense of conformity. It shows people doing what the rest of society does which suggests that people in mainstream society live like everybody else, have the same goals which concludes to the same

Comparison of the Government of Japan and Australia Legislative System

856 words - 3 pages party (or coalition) with a majority of members in the House of Representatives is invited by the (by Governor General (Queen's representative in Australia) or in Japan by the Emperor) to form the Government. The Leader becomes the Prime Minister and the other elected members of the ruling party in both the Upper and Lower House become responsible for the administration of Government departments. Figure 1 Semi-Proportional System used in Japan

The Tsarist System of Government of Russia

1392 words - 6 pages out wars slowly demoralised the Russian people and resulted in discontent. Aside from destroying any pride they had in the "system", they were subjected to witnessing the death of their comrades and the draining of their country. However, war when carried out swiftly and with success can have positive benefits for the popularity of a ruler. Bismarck's foreign policy showed this. But the wars in which Russia was involved

Similar Essays

Spartan Government Essay

1236 words - 5 pages importance was not very significant as Bury and Meiggs emphasise "If the elders and magistrates did not approve of the decision of the majority of the assembly, they could annul the proceedings by refusing to proclaim it. Therefore the Apella's importance within the Spartan Government is over ruled by the power of the Ephors.It is evident that all forms of Spartan government within the system play an important role in the running of Spartan society. However, from the evidence provided, it can be gathered that the Ephors are the most dominant and superior form, as they have the most power.

The Spartan Caste System Essay

1675 words - 7 pages The Spartan Caste System setup are the Helots who are slaves and laborers. The Perioeci who were neither slaves nor full citizens. The Spartriates were citizens and warriors. They are the cause of Sparta's fall because they didn't change the government and always being outnumbered. The government didn't change like the rest of the Greek city- states( McArver). The Spartriates were very arrogant because helots still has the ability to fight

Explain The Main Features Of The Spartan Economy. This Essay Explains The Features Of The Spartan Economy In Ancient Sparta That Contributes To Their Austere Lifestyle

1181 words - 5 pages , sometimes made to fight in war for Sparta) were rich enough to maintain a high level of professional training and equipment. Each Spartiate, therefore had to have a minimum income to pay for his mess dues and the state had to have income to pay for armour and equipment. This was achieved through the exploitation of Helots who produced foodstuff that : paid the mess dues, and was used to trade with Perioikoi that provided the armour and

The Role Of The Spartan Education System, The Agoge

1889 words - 8 pages range of sources may have made it more reliable.•Spartan Society, P.MedcarfThis was very useful as it contains extensive information on the details of the agoge, syssitia, krypteia, and laconic phrases, with strong references to Plutarch and Xenophon. The table "The life and training of Spartan boys" was very useful as it gave a brief overview of the education system in a clear manner.•Wikipedia:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki