This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Lying Up On The Job: Does Deceptive Impression Management Work?

1076 words - 4 pages

John Carlson’s article Lying Up On The Job: Does Deceptive Impression Management Work? is published in the Ivey Business Journal: a reputable journal on improving the practice of management. Rankings from BusinessWeek and Financial Times acknowledge Ivey among the top business schools in the world (“Business Schools,” n.d). This incisive and practical publication of 2012 is considered a credible source. Additionally, the prolific author of this article John Carlson, is currently the Assistant Professor of Information Systems at Baylor University. In 1995, Carlson attended Florida State University where he achieved a PhD in Information and Operations Management. Carlson who has conducted several studies (“Business Directory,” n.d) on this topic, having published articles titled: Deceptive Impression Management: Does Deception Pay in Established Workplace Relationships? (2011) and Upward Influence and Deceptive Impression Management: The Power of Subordinates Who Lie (2010) is no stranger to presenting organised materials by designates of exhaustive depth and logic. According to Carlson (2012, p.3) the purport of this article is to apprise associates within business and commercial institutions of a research study examining the efficacy of different forms of Deceptive Impression Management, and determinately, the implicative insinuations for managers. These topics are well communicated with balanced arguments and detailed research to strengthen any claims. Carlson’s accolades, and breadth of knowledge regarding management, further contributes to this articles credibility.
Outline of Carlson’s Argument (2012)
Overall Argument:
Subordinates attempt to manipulate supervisors through active distortion, destruction, or omission of information. However, in real-world circumstances this isn’t viable.
Supporting Arguments:
• Lying in the workplace is so commonplace as to be both expected and ineffectual.
• A host of concerns unravel if a business culture accepts dishonesty. If your subordinates are inclined to lie to you, who else are they inclined to lie to? And what else are they willing to lie about?
• An unethical employee can cause damage that could cost a business more than an unproductive employee.
• A supervisor has the right to truthfully receive information, genuine opinions and honest feedback from the subordinate.
Credibility Evaluation of Assessing the role of aggression, empathy, and self-serving cognitive distortions in trait emotional manipulation – Rachel Grieve and Laura Panebianco
Rachel Grieve and Laura Panebianco’s article Assessing the role of aggression, empathy, and self-serving cognitive distortions in trait emotional manipulation was first published online in 2013 by the Australian Journal of Psychology. Grieve, current lecturer in the Division of Psychology at the University of Tasmania with accreditations including an honours degrees and a PhD in Psychology (2011), thus increases this articles credibility...

Find Another Essay On Lying Up on the Job: Does Deceptive Impression Management Work?

The Effects of Supervisor Impression on Motives of Feedback

1356 words - 5 pages motive of feedback seeking is plays the vital role in leader-member exchange and work performance. As said, there are two accountable motives. First, it could be work performance enhancement. The other motive would be image enhancement towards management. Subordinates can seek feedback to improve their work performance, while some do so only to make a good impression. When the supervisors perceive that the feedback seeking behavior is based on the

On-The-Job Training Essay

1074 words - 4 pages the capacity to concentrate on a task for reasonable period of time, to show up for work regularly and be punctual, to read, to perform simple mathematical manipulations, and to follow in- structions all constitute general training. Similarly, gaining word processing, carpentry, or accounting skills would be considered general training. Alter- natively, the ability to perform an assembly procedure unique to a firm’s products exemplified

Learning on the Job

1140 words - 5 pages control over the one thing that I perceive as most important…the ability to learn on the job. Works Cited Brown, J.S. & Gray, E. S. (2004). Introduction. In M.L. Connor & J.G. Clawson (Eds.), Creating a learning culture: Strategy, technology, and practice (pp.1-16). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2008). Number of jobs held, labor market activity, and earnings growth among the youngest baby boomers

Does the Honor System Work

1629 words - 7 pages Does the Honor System Work Almost everyone has cheated on something at least once, whether it was on a test or in a football game, everyone has cheated at least once. For the majority of us, it was only once and we felt guilty enough afterwards to quit, but there are some that continue to cheat at every opportunity. While most colleges and universities would like to think that this does not happen on their campuses, the fact is that it

How Does the Brain Work?

3068 words - 12 pages different intellectual composition. We can improve education by addressing the multiple intelligences of our students. These intelligences are located in different areas of the brain and can either work independently or together (Concept to Classroom, 2004). I found this theory very interesting and was exited to find out about my specific areas of intelligence but ended up disappointed by the outcome. My highest result was Spatial on par with

What impression does the audience have of Hamlet by the end of act one?

1124 words - 4 pages Hamlet is introduced to the play in act one. Amongst the eerie atmosphere of tension and unease the fact that he does not actually speak until scene two stimulates intrigue about his character in the audience. Hamlet's first soliloquy gives us a first glimpse of his inner thoughts, and helps us to understand his character better. The speech is particularly important to the audience because Hamlet conceals his true feelings from the other

Does Nonviolence Work on a Large Scale?

2139 words - 9 pages . The leadership in a violent campaign is likely to rely on someone who can pick up a weapon and use violence no matter the circumstance and no matter who.11 In nonviolent campaigns the leadership can fall upon many people, due to the lack of having to face a moral barrier, and typically these people have sympathy and compassion for whatever they are resisting and fighting.11 This also makes for an effective strategy for nonviolent campaigns, when

Deceptive Intentions - Analysis on "The Merchant of Venice" by William Shakespeare

876 words - 4 pages this scene, Morocco pleads Portia to "mislike [him] not for [his] complexion"(II, i, 1). Portia tells Morocco that she does not mind the complexion of his skin and that he is "then stood as fair as any corner [she] ha[s] look'd on yet for [her] affection"(II, i, 20). Once he leaves, however, Portia says, "Let all of his complexion choose me so"(II, vii, 78-79). Portia sets an innocent and admirable face when Morocco or any other suitor is

Does the Modern Prison System Work?

834 words - 4 pages arguments about shifting control of prisons from government to private businesses. These facts are bringing some questions to our attention, one of which is the purpose of this research as well: ‘Does the modern prison system work?’ 2. Methods This research was conducted by a questionnaire and considered the students of University of Westminster’s thoughts on the prisons efficiency. Seven students were surveyed by the questionnaire that

How Does the Public Sector Work?

1733 words - 7 pages If you don't understand how the public sector is supposed to work, how can you ensure that it is working? An easy definition of public administration is, “the implementation of government policies” (Encyclopedia Britannica, 2010), or, “the implementation of public policy” (, 1997). While policies and procedures seem to be continuously up for debate, it should be noted that, an informed public are the only sure-fire way to ensure

Does the Placebo Effect Really Work?

2931 words - 12 pages “Does the placebo effect really work?” We’ve all been there, sitting in the waiting room surrounded by people coughing a spluttering all over you, surely making you worse rather than better. Then, half an hour after your appointment time, your name is called and you reach the safe (sanitary) haven of the doctor’s office. After a poke and a prod, and a rather uncomfortable “Aaaaahh!” with an ice-lolly stick half way down your throat and a light

Similar Essays

Lying On The Roots Essay

1218 words - 5 pages This poem’s structure is composed by two stanzas with ten lines each and free verses. It is very similar to narrative in its structure. The rhyme schema is composed by off-rhymes, such as: “horizontal/soil” (lines 1, 2); “love/leaf”(lines 3, 4); “unpetal/immortal”(lines lines 7, 8); and so on. There are also some other elements which are able to sustain rhythm in this poem as line 19th, for example: “And I shall be useful when I lie down

Lying On The Couch By Irvin Yalom

1143 words - 5 pages In this paper we will be look at the book called “Lying on the Couch”. I will be going over what I saw as the biggest ethical issues that I read about in this book, I will also go over my thoughts on this book and the ethical problems that I saw for Dr. Lash, Carol and Marshal Streider. I will explain my personal opinion regarding self-care and my reasoning as to why it is so important to maintaining clear boundaries. BODY In this book, Dr

How Does Steinbeck Shape The Reader's Impression Of Curley's Wife?

1379 words - 6 pages How does Steinbeck shape the reader's impression of Curley's Wife?Monday 24th February 2014Curley's wife is a complicated, main character in Steinbeck's novel "Of Mice and Men". She is first introduced in chapter two and ultimately causes the end of the whole novel, her naivity and flirtatiousness lead to her inexorable death at the hands of Lennie, bewildered and scared by her forwardness and eventual panic.Steinbeck first introduces her

The Influence Of Paternalistic Leadership On Work Related Employee Attitudes: Job Satisfaction And Organizational Commitment

8446 words - 34 pages . 185) defined job satisfaction as "the extent to which employees like their work".Although research to date has focused specifically on the impact of job satisfaction on commitment, absenteeism and turnover (Agho & Price, 1992), results of several studies have indicated that employees are more likely to experience job satisfaction when they are able to use their skills and knowledge on the job,perform enriched tasks, the organisation adopts a