Macbeth By William Shakespear Essay

1238 words - 5 pages

Macbeth by William Shakespeare Year 10 GCSE English Coursework: Media Compare the two films of Macbeth. How do they differ and in what ways are they similar? Which film do you prefer and why? William Shakespeare wrote Macbeth the play. Many directors in their own style have interpreted this play. I will be comparing two films played by different directors. Different directors make the two films. The two films are based on the same story but the differences occur in the way each director has interpreted the text. The traditional style of Macbeth was done by Roman Polanski and the modern version was done by Penny Woolcock. The traditional version was made in 1979 and the modern BBC vision was made in 1997. The traditional version was made in Scotland and the modern version was set in Ladywood in Birmingham. The actors used in the traditional version were pretty famous and known but in the modern version ordinary people who have little knowledge of acting play the characters. The traditional version was made for a worldwide audience and to be put on cinema. The modern version was made for the BBC to be put directly on TV for England.Both films tell a story of Macbeth. Three witches prophecy that he will be King and this leads him to kill Duncan the King of Scotland. He becomes more and more involved in murder and terrible deeds. He arranges for his friend Banquo to be murdered because he is afraid that Banquo's after sons will become Kings. Macbeth goes back to the witches who tell him that "no man of woman born will harm him"and until Birnam Wood comes to Dunsinane (his castle) he will not be harmed. Macbeth gets so obsessed with this prophecy that he has Macduff's wife and children murder. Lady Macbeth who encourages Macbeth to kill the King goes mad and dies. Then Macduff comes back to seek revenge for his family and kills Macbeth because Macduff was "from his mother's womb untimely ripped".The two films were set in very different settings. Polanski's Macbeth was set in the open countryside in Scotland and his castle was more like the setting of the play, which made it more traditional, and there were the mountains and woodlands where the whether created an atmosphere. By putting the music on in the background the weather was cloudy and made it look eirie. The witches where more traditional and lived in the moors. Whereas the BBC version is set in the Ladywood flats and local facilities we used as film sets such as the playgrounds and parks. Then made a very good use of outdoors and indoors. In the BBC version there is not much use of dark because most of it is going on in the light unlike the traditional version where they use light and dark wisely to reflect shadows of the wall. The music in the BBC Macbeth was more modern and the women sing the song "I will survive". This is ironic because both of them die. In the traditional vision the witches music was out of tune and discordant, this is to make it sound more atmospheric and build up...

Find Another Essay On Macbeth by william shakespear

Macbeth by William Shakespeare Essay

1248 words - 5 pages Macbeth by William Shakespeare Many children are constantly trying to find new ways to entertain themselves. One might suggest that rollerblading as fast as possible and jumping off a deck would be a great possibility for pleasure. Well, this has happened in the past, and the results have mostly been broken bones. Ultimately it’s the choice of the youngster whether to jump or not: the will of the being is the decisive factor. “Every action

Macbeth by William Shakespeare Essay

1629 words - 7 pages Macbeth by William Shakespeare Macbeth, one of William Shakespeare’s famous tragedies, is set in Scotland. Returning from battle with his companion Banquo, the nobleman, Macbeth meets with three witches. They predict that Macbeth will initially become the Thane of Cawdor and then king of Scotland. Macbeth privately has ambitions of being king and enjoys the ideas of becoming the head of the country. After the first part of the witches

"Macbeth" by William Shakespeare

635 words - 3 pages MACBETH ESSAYThroughout Macbeth William Shakespeare uses many symbols to highlight major themes in the play. One of these symbols is blood, and the theme that it reinforces is murder and the fear associated with killing. Many scenes in the play involving murder also have blood mentioned, although not necessarily during the act itself. The use of blood as a symbol is very important when connected to the theme of murder, and is used as a

Macbeth by William Shakespeare

1403 words - 6 pages In human society there are different rank and class systems that distinguish groups of people. Ambition -- the quest for power – is an internal drive that is embedded in every one of us. It motivates us to improve ourselves. Ambition can lead to corruption as in the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, where the main character Macbeth is driven by his ambition and eventually becomes corrupt. Macbeth chooses to let ambition override his humanity

Macbeth by William Shakespeare - 2284 words

2284 words - 9 pages Macbeth by William Shakespeare William Shakespeare wrote Macbeth. It was written at the time of King James, and it is relevant as you read on. King James was attracted to witches, and the play includes many matters that interest him. Macbeth as a character is very expendable, thinking and mostly unpredictable. The way Shakespeare uses Macbeth and Lady Macbeth I unique. The play is very powerful in terms of evil and lessons in life. The moral

Macbeth by William Shakespeare - 814 words

814 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare’s Macbeth it is believed that the universe and king were connected. Therefore, if the two were connected, when the king was killed the universe would respond with unnatural events. In this play, the unnatural events foreshadow evil. The unnatural occurrences in Macbeth predict the downfall of the kingdom and death of Macbeth; since the universe is connected with the king. The people of the Elizabethan time period believed

Macbeth, by William Shakespeare

1300 words - 5 pages The famous playwright William Shakespeare used symbolism throughout all of his thirty-seven plays. Light and dark are used as powerful symbols of good and evil in his tragedy Macbeth. Shakespeare uses these themes of light and dark or day and night to form an actual image of the play's ongoing conflict for the reader or viewer. The meaning behind this specific symbol essentially creates the story of Macbeth. William

Macbeth by William Shakespeare - 2648 words

2648 words - 11 pages Macbeth by William Shakespeare The supernatural is vital to the plot and the actions of the characters in Macbeth. As a director of a film version, how would you put across this influence to your chosen audience? In this essay I am going to explain how I would go about directing the first two witches' scenes in Macbeth. I will sum up why I am doing a certain action, for example the symbolism it has and what relevance

Macbeth by William Shakespeare - 848 words

848 words - 3 pages Macbeth by William Shakespeare 'Macbeth,' one of William Shakespeare's shortest and bloodiest tragedies was written in 1606. Macbeth is also possibly the most memorable. It is a mysterious and somewhat powerful play. It has also attracted various film directors such as Polanski. Roman Polanski is famous for his horror and thriller - like films. He decided to express his interpretation on it and filmed an unexpected

Lady Macbeth by William Shakespeare

1177 words - 5 pages “It will have blood: they say blood will have blood” (Mac. 3.4.149). These famous words are the words Macbeth speaks as he realizes that he is turning into a tyrant and murderer. William Shakespeare's play, Macbeth, shows an honorable, powerful general, thoroughly loyal to the king, as he metamorphoses into a merciless, paranoid king that kills anyone who might not respect him. His regicide slowly drives him insane. Shakespeare uses blood and

Play: Macbeth, by William Shakespeare

1163 words - 5 pages As one of the shortest plays William Shakespeare has written, Macbeth represents Shakespeare most popular play. Throughout the play, many characters transpire, however the main character remains Macbeth, a laudable man who develops into a man engrossed by his ambition of power. In addition, Banquo, as another important character who develops as a dramatic foil to Macbeth and represents a brave and ambitious individual while he retains his morals

Similar Essays

Macbeth's Destiny, An Issue Of Fate Or Freewill??? William Shakespear Macbeth

727 words - 3 pages spirit living within him that will be stopped by nothing and noone. Were the witches just stating the inevitable? That a man with such a demeanor will inevitably one day take the throne? If this was the witches only prediction one could ponder this topic for days and weeks on end. It is the other predictions of the witches that bring the theme of fate into a brighter light. On Macbeth's second visit to the witches they predict that Macbeth

How Did Shakespeare Create Sympathy For 'the Dead Butcher' Macbeth? "Macbeth" By William Shakespear

686 words - 3 pages man. In the play this is shown by the way some of the other characters portray Macbeth. E.g. Ross says:'The King hath happily received Macbeth'I think this mediates how much respect people had for Macbeth at the beginning and how slowly over the course of the play peoples opinions of him change.Macbeth is responsible for Duncan's murder because at the time Duncan was staying at Macbeth's castle. Lady Macbeth convinces a wayward Macbeth to kill

Macbeth, By William Shakespeare Essay

941 words - 4 pages William Shakespeare’s Macbeth is the play which tells the story of a soldier and the disastrous path which he took in pursuit of the throne. Macbeth was a victim of forces beyond his control; they are the witches and Lady Macbeth. The witches create a stimulus for Macbeth to become destructive in his pursuit for the throne. However Macbeth was only persuaded and ready to kill after being influenced by Lady Macbeth. Therefore we can assume that

Macbeth, By William Shakespeare Essay

1356 words - 5 pages death of Duncan. He becomes a conduit for evil, a means for evil to wreak its destruction upon all those closest to him. Macbeth becomes “a wolf to man,” (48) as Lance Morrow writes. “Evil is a disease,” (Morrow 51) William James once said. As Shakespeare demonstrates in Macbeth, madness evolves from evil, and evil can grow unchecked within madness. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are tempted and charmed by the driving forces of evil. Their own