Macbeth Was Sane Essay

1144 words - 5 pages

Macbeth was Sane

 
     Although Macbeth may have suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, his suffering does not constitute insanity.  Macbeth was in a healthy mindset when he embarked on his murderous spree and treacherous rule of Scotland.  His actions and reactions prior to and throughout his tenure as King of Scotland were normal considering the circumstances.  The following evidence will prove that Macbeth was indeed sane.  

 

The first thing I would like to point out is Macbeth's clear understanding of his motives and their consequences.  After he heard the prophecies of the weird sisters, his ambition got the best of him.  He immediately considered murdering Duncan and the morality of the murder.  Macbeth knew his thoughts were wrong and said to the stars, "hide your fears, let not see my black and deep desires (I.4.50-51)."  This acknowledgment of the sinfulness of his desires shows that Macbeth's mind was functioning properly.  Macbeth also acknowledges that there would be consequences if he murdered Duncan.  He thought to himself, " if the assassination could trammel up the consequence, and catch with his surcease, success (I.7.2-4)," the decision to murder Duncan would be easier.  These examples prove that Macbeth was not impulsive with his thoughts.  Instead, like anyone else, he realized the gravity of his desires.  If Macbeth was insane, he would not have thought twice about the murder and its consequences.

 

Macbeth also demonstrates guilty feelings when he considers murdering Duncan.  These guilty feelings came about when he analyzed the relationship between himself and Duncan.  Not only was he Duncan's subject and soldier, he was Duncan's host.  He realized that entertaining thoughts of murder while Duncan was a guest at Inverness was completely wrong.  Duncan was there, "in double trust (I.7.12)," and to violate that trust would be a corrupt action. It is obvious that Macbeth was thinking clearly because he understood the significance of his thoughts and felt guilt over them.  This guilt would not be present in a crazy man because a crazy man kills without remorse.

 

Another important matter to discuss in determining Macbeth's mental state is Macbeth's hallucinations.  In my professional opinion, these hallucinations were not the result of insanity.  I feel that they were manifestations of the stress Macbeth was feeling.  In no way do they suggest that Macbeth was insane.  Rather, they prove that Macbeth was reacting the way any other person would to extremely stressful and gruesome situations.  

 

Macbeth's first hallucination of the bloody dagger leading him to Duncan's room was a way for Macbeth's mind to release some of its anxieties concerning the act of murder.  Although Macbeth had killed before, he had never killed for the purpose of improving his position.  His previous killings were in battle where he was killing his enemy, not a man...

Find Another Essay On Macbeth was Sane

Imagery of Illness Essay

714 words - 3 pages Even though, in Macbeth, Shakespeare’s repetition and use of imagery for illness may not seem notable or significant for the story, it helps the reader understand the affliction guilt has on the characters. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth ponder the idea of murdering Duncan and ultimately go through with it. As they deal with the events that they caused, they struggle to stay sane. By examining the imagery of illness, one can determine that it is

Macbeth Independence and Failure Essay

1735 words - 7 pages execution of the crime separates them...In fact, after the murder theycan only speak in short sentences, not communicating or even answeringquestions. (Jorgensen 67)Although he blames his rage on the grooms for killing Duncan, he was actuallymad at himself for committing the murder. Not until he kills the grooms with his regretdoes Macbeth become totally independent from the thanes and slide from the bundle oflimbs (II, iii, 108-19). The action of

Macbeth Insanity

966 words - 4 pages that originates as sane, but then is driven towards madness through the tragic flaw of ambition; this is the result of (1) Macbeth’s likelihood to commit atrocities, (2) willful construction of figments, and (3) external pressures for pursuance of ill-advised intentions. Ambition plagues Macbeth over the course of the epic tragedy, conveying his sanity progresses to a state of mental illness through his murderous measures. At first, Macbeth

guilt in macbeth

1679 words - 7 pages , and grieving woman. Unlike Macbeth, Lady Macbeth is not affected by her actions immediately. Rather, she stays calm under pressure and at times, must keep Macbeth sane while he deals with his own guilt. In her clear thinking she remembers to return to the castle and cover up all evidence that was left behind by Macbeth. Eventually, however, the guilt does catch up with her and she begins to sleep walk and talk in her sleep about washing blood

Guilt and Conscience in Shakespeare’s Macbeth

1301 words - 5 pages Macbeth tells us that he is jealous of Duncan because the King, being dead can sleep forever, whereas he can’t sleep at all. Likewise Lady Macbeth begins sleep walking, recalling the night on which Duncan was murdered. While sleepwalking she writes confessions down and puts them in a box. Suggesting that Lady Macbeth is just as guilty as Macbeth himself because she can’t sleep and her mind is agitated just as Macbeth’s is. The Kings guard who

Analysis of Macbeth's Soliloquies

2527 words - 10 pages brilliant man- to become king himself or not to kill the king and live the rest of his life wandering 'what if'. Macbeth has reason not to kill the king. One of the reasons is that he thinks heaven will avenge the murder if it was to happen. Macbeth is very troubled at this point in the play and starts to show it in "line 16-22" but then at the end, his ambition to be king overrides any guilt/cowardice he's feeling. Between

William Shakespeare's Macbeth

2511 words - 10 pages quenched when he visited the witches on the mortal world for the last time. This was the point where their marriage broke down. At the end of the banquet scene we, the audience, see the last of the 'sane' Lady Macbeth. The assassination of Banquo made Macbeth seem very much like "Butchery". Killing Banquo was much harder overcome than the grief when he killed Duncan as Banquo was his best friend as well as his loyal assistant

Importance of Sleep in Shakespeare's Macbeth

964 words - 4 pages thought the same way as he did and who, even in the end, would defend him and his actions.    Yet another effect of his self-inflicted insomnia is Macbeth's naiveté when it comes to the witches.  He seems to believe everything that the three witches tell him.  These prophecies, to most, would seem very unlikely and yet, Macbeth questions none of them.  Any sane person would question the source when someone tells

Failure in Macbeth Essay

1952 words - 8 pages they discover how the execution of the crime separates them...In fact, after the murder they can only speak in short sentences, not communicating or even answering questions. (Jorgensen 67)Although he blames his rage on the grooms for killing Duncan, he was actually mad at himself for committing the murder. Not until he kills the grooms with his regret does Macbeth become totally independent from the thanes and slide from the bundle of limbs (II

Response to Shakespeare's Macbeth

5781 words - 23 pages possibilities to be explored that could be found to be the impetus bringing Lady Macbeth to sleepwalk. The first being that in Shakespeare's time a person found to be sleepwalking meant that evil spirits and demons possessed them. Lady Macbeth played a forceful role in the scheming, leading up to the murder of Duncan and was heavily involved in the event itself. In act two, scene two; exasperated with Macbeth, Lady Macbeth takes the

The Evils of Macbeth in William Shakespeare's Macbeth

6019 words - 24 pages effective nowadays as belief in the supernatural is small, unlike when Shakespeare was writing this when more people believed in devil worshipping etc. But the idea that Lady Macbeth will stop at nothing, even give herself up to Demons, is still running strong and carries with it the idea that Lady Macbeth is so ambitious to the point of not caring how she gets what she wants, as long as it becomes hers. This once again

Similar Essays

The Defence Speech For Macbeth As A Murderer

1242 words - 5 pages the hands two assassins. Macbeth?s personal ambition consumed him as he then planned the execution of Mac Duffs entire family to thwart any potential heirs claiming the throne. Innocent women and children were massacred during in their sleep while their father was away planning the resistance against Macbeth.Today the defence has come to you with a plea of insanity. A plea that begs that Macbeth wasn?t in a sane state of mind at the time of him

Macbeth Ruthlessness Essay

866 words - 3 pages Macbeth was more ruthless than her husband, and it was her ruthlessness that fueled Duncan's murder. From the start of the play, Macbeth desires to become king after he hears what the witches said about his fate. "Present fears are less than horrible imaginings. My thought, whose murder is yet but fantastical, shakes so that my single state of man that function is smoldered. I surmise and nothing is but what is not."(Shakespeare 1:3

Images And Imagery In Macbeth Essay

1028 words - 4 pages hide his deepest desires. When Macbeth and Lady Macbeth discuss the murder of Duncan, Lady Macbeth calls on evil to wrap itself around her in a blanket of darkness so that she would not be suspected in the lines, "Come, thick night, /And pall thee in the dunnest smoke of hell," (I.V.53-54). The morning after Duncan was murdered; Scotland remained in darkness and obscurity. The events that involve immoral acts by characters are continuously

Macbeth's Tragic Insanity Essay

1158 words - 5 pages as nothing but a “dead butcher” (V.ix.35). Macbeth was unarguably sane in the beginning of the play, however, at the end of the play its unclear whether or not Macbeth truly was a “deranged blood hound” (V.ii.32), or if he was still acting on his own accord. Critics may say that this “Bloody sceptered tyrant” (IV.iii.95), who murdered innocent people indiscriminately through the novel befell the holds of insanity, but in truth, Macbeth, whether