Machiavelli And Castiglione Essay

837 words - 3 pages

Machiavelli and Castiglione both present the epitome of perfection in their topics of leadership and the way a women should be, respectively. In the case of Castiglione's work, it is stated by signor Gaspare that " the way people sometimes hanker after things that are impossible and miraculous, rather then explain them you (Magnifico) have wished them into existence." This quote is true of both excerpts. Both have created idealisms that are of perfection; however, both do also allow for imperfection. Again in the excerpt from Castiglione's work where Magnifico states "...because man is more robust, more quickly agile and more able to endure toil..." shows the obvious imperfections of the female gender. Machiavelli, on the topic of leadership, also talks of imperfections: "The new prince - above all other princes - cannot escape being called cruel, since new governments about in dangers." Leaders therefore are left to the mercy of their own imperfections and the imperfections of the human spirit. Perfection, even mixed in with a few imperfections, is very hard to meet. One would have to be of the offspring of God to meet some of the qualities mentioned. However, far from the offspring of God, there is another that comes close to many of the generalizations stated. She is a leader behind a leader and is probably one of the strongest women of her time. First, Mrs. Clinton as a leader possesses many of the qualities mentioned by Machiavelli; such as her toughness and appearance of good morals. In Castiglione's realm, she matches the qualities of dignity and strong virtues. Hillary Clinton clearly shows qualities mentioned in both excerpts regarding her position as a leader and as a woman.First, Hillary Clinton as a leader possesses a great number of qualities mentioned by Machiavelli, one of which is represented in her handling of the Whitewater scandal. Machiavelli gives and example of how it is important to, "in order to keep his position, act contrary to the truth." Mrs. Clinton most likely lied about her involvement in the scandal in order to "keep her position" as a leader. Mrs. Clinton also fits true to what Machiavelli says about appearance: " is not necessary actually to have all the above-mentioned qualities, but it is very necessary to appear to have them"; the qualities being: merciful, trustworthy, humane, blameless, and religious. The first lady appears to be trustworthy, in that she holds true to her contract of...

Find Another Essay On Machiavelli and Castiglione

Don Quixote Essay about created reality

539 words - 2 pages and that people should adhere to an ideal and try to emulate it, even if it is impossible to become. However Machiavelli is more concerned with describing a real model for princes and what they have to do to survive as actual rulers rather than a happy ideal they can try to be, but never will obtain. Both Machiavelli and Castiglione spend a lot of time explaining how important it is for one to appear virtuous, even if one is not. More precisely, they are both more concerned with appearance than reality.

How did artists and writers reflect Renaissance ideals?

743 words - 3 pages philosophy and scholarship, as well as “guidebooks” to help people of the Renaissance achieve success. Baldassare Castiglione wrote the most widely known of these handbooks, which was called The Book of the Courtier. It detailed the manners, skills, learning, and virtues that a member of the court should reflect. Castiglione wrote specific guidelines for the ideal men and women in society, which people of the time could relate to. Another

The Renaissance: The Dawning of a New Age

1953 words - 8 pages mind which ennoble men” (Wiesner 219). This quotation displays the importance of education for the Renaissance men. Their education is important because he must use it to serve and know God, and to serve the city/state (Wiesner 213). Most Renaissance men are courtiers, those who attend the royal court as a companion or adviser to the king or queen. Castiglione, a 16th century Italian aristocrat and author of The Courtier explain that a courtier

Renaissance - A unique development in the European History

823 words - 3 pages , protection of land, maintance of power, social order, religion, afterlife and fear of unknown. The Renaissance individual was more concerned with materialism, wealth, secular world where religion and state were separated and social mobility.There were a lot of social changes. Education was one of the most important Renaissance values. According to Castiglione, the Renaissance man had to be educated, have a broad background in many academic

Cultural Achievements of the Italian Renaissance

804 words - 3 pages long period of time by a member of the clergy. Mass production of books was a very important development during the Renaissance as it meant that all the new ideas were obtainable to many more people than would have been the case, had printing not been invented. Authors of the time include Dante (poetry) and Machiavelli (prose). The famous "Book of the Courtier" by Castiglione, goes into great detail about the attributes of the ideal courtier. Some

Defend or Refute - "The Renaissance was a new development, strikingly different from the preceding Middle Ages." - This essay agrees with this quote, and gives many reason as to why

1323 words - 5 pages literature, such as The Prince by Machiavelli, in which he tells the ways a ruler should gain and hold power, The Courtier, by Castiglione in which he described what a perfect Renaissance man would be, and many others. It was also during the 16th century that the influence of this literature began to be seen in the rest of Europe.The new ideas of liberal arts, individualism and humanism gave power to the middle class, since now they were educated


1245 words - 5 pages because it focuses of virtue and rhetoric because it teaches eloquence.  Castiglione wrote The Courtier to train, discipline and fashion young men into ideal gentlemen.  In The Courtier, he said that the educated man of the upper class should be well educated in many subjects, his spiritual and physical capabilities should be trained and he should be familiar with dance, music and art.  The Courtier was widely read in the sixteenth and seventeenth

Ties of the Renaissance and Reformation

1445 words - 6 pages . Machiavelli wrote “The Prince” which told how to get and hold political power. Castiglione wrote the “Book of Courtiers” which describes the perfect Renaissance noble. In Renaissance society marriages were arranged to strengthen political ties. The woman’s family paid the dowry and the men controlled the business and family. Children were only adults when their father went to the court and freed them. Renaissance education, they believed would

The Time Machine

2352 words - 9 pages Petrarchan love sonnets, Castiglione and he famous book The Courtier that continues to influence Europe's upper class in civilized behavior, some of the times most influential painters; Raphael, Parmigianino, Titian, Giorgione, di Vinci and of course the sculpturer/painter Michelangelo. I came across a man who I had yet to read about named Niccolo Machiavelli. I'm not quite sure what it was that caught my eye, but I think it is the name of a T-Pac

Noble, a summary

8644 words - 35 pages hun ogen statisch en onveranderbaar. Hun ideeën werden in de war gegooid door de Franse inval in Italië in 1494. Men ging zich afvragen of geschiedenis nou - The Marketplace to Buy and Sell your Study Material echt wel zoveel te leren had aan het heden. De belangrijkste kritiek kwam van Niccolò Machiavelli. Hij ontwikkelde een nieuwe wetenschap van politiek. Zijn belangrijkste werk was Il Principe. Machiavelli vond

How Valid Is Burckhardt’s Assessment Of The Role Of Humanism In Renaissance Culture?

2910 words - 12 pages increase of courtly behaviour. This, however, was not entirely true. The formalised customs Burckhardt speaks of - and Castiglione describes in the Courtier - really applied only to the upper crust of society, not the common people of the masses. Burckhardt also tells of the availability of cultural accomplishment, which for many did not exist. Most, in fact, did not have the opportunities that the aristocracy and the wealthy merchant class had. If

Similar Essays

Castiglione And Machiavelli Essay

997 words - 4 pages War, Politics, Castiglione, and Machiavelli During the Renaissance period, many great minds expressed their ideas and talents to their fullest potential. Neither Baldesar Castiglione nor Niccoló Machiavelli were exceptions. In Castiglione?s greatest work, The Book of the Courtier, he describes the qualities that should be possessed by the perfect courtier in a compilation of made-up conversations between the members of the court of Urbino

Two Sides Of The Same Coin

724 words - 3 pages The Renascence was based on the idea of humanism, the human essence of men. The common ground that this definition had was based on the idea that the population is human and religion falls in the background. The idea that “simple” humans could be heroes comes to light and both Castiglione and Machiavelli describe the characteristic of this person. These two, based on the same subject they implement a different integrity on how to succeed

Discuss Machiavelli's View On Morals And Politics In The Prince

2480 words - 10 pages brought him only power and not glory.Another topic on which Machiavelli agreed with the humanists was their view of the role of fortuna in politics. Many of the humanists wrote about fortune, for example, Pontano in his treatise On Fortune and Castiglione in his work The Book of the Courtier. They both describe the fickleness of fortune. Machiavelli fully agrees with the importance of fortune in politics. He cites the example of Cesare Borgia who

Cassirer, Nietzsche And Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince

1154 words - 5 pages Cassirer, Nietzsche and Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince When the word "Renaissance" is mentioned, an image of love for antiquity learning and fine arts usually springs to one's mind. Yet this perception, however legitimate it may be in many areas of Renaissance human achievements, shatters in the face of Niccolò Machiavelli's masterpiece The Prince. Unlike his contemporary Baldassare Castiglione who exemplified subtlety, Machiavelli was