This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Machiavelli: The Misunderstood Humanist Essay

2176 words - 9 pages

Machiavelli was a Florentine diplomat, statesman, and political philosopher in the early sixteenth century. He authored The Prince, a set of rules for new princes to follow in order to maintain control of their domains, emphasizing the use of power without regard to morality. Machiavelli published The Prince in 1513 and dedicated it to the Medicis with the goal of convincing them to unite Italy and end the Italian Wars, which took place from 1494 to 1559. Machiavelli’s philosophies have been criticized as contradictory to traditional humanist views, but this conclusion fails to consider the ideas set forth in The Prince in the context of other political philosophies and humanism at the time. Machiavelli’s political ethics meet the four characteristics of humanism: Classicism, realism, individualism, and active virtue. These factors combine to depict civic humanism in line with the humanist philosophies of Coluccio Salutati and Leonardo Bruno, two of Machiavelli’s predecessors.
Classicism is a defining characteristic of humanism displayed by Machiavelli. Humanist Classicism is characterized by the reference of classical sources and history (mainly Greek and Roman) not with nostalgia, but as a basis for argument. Machiavelli derives several of the arguments in The Prince from classical history and philosophy. For example, he first defines a type of state known as mixed principalities. These have two characteristics: first, they are ruled dynastically by a prince; second, they conquer new territories that differ in language, laws, and customs from themselves. Machiavelli explains that these states tend to come into difficulties while expanding because of the natural difficulty of ruling over peoples of different language, laws, and customs. He advises that, to avoid the pitfalls of expansion, princes follow the example of the Romans, who “always followed these procedures in the countries they seized: they sent in colonies, provided for the less powerful without increasing their strength, put down the powerful, and did not allow powerful foreigners to gain prestige there.” Machiavelli repeatedly supports his arguments with classical history, a characteristic of a Classicist.
Machiavelli, in his criticism of pope Alexander VI and the Papal States, demonstrates a realistic view of the world that is predicated on his own honest view of politics rather than the traditional literature at the time, in which authors traditionally praised the Church so as not to be declared heretics. First, Machiavelli criticizes the rule of the Papal States in general, stating that its rulers “do not defend subjects and do not govern them; and their states, though not defended, are not taken from them.” He then rebukes the Papal States for neither governing nor defending its subjects, and points out with bewilderment that despite this negligence, these states remain intact. This seems to contradict the power politics that Machiavelli has focused on in the rest of the...

Find Another Essay On Machiavelli: The Misunderstood Humanist

Niccolo Machiavelli Essay

856 words - 3 pages faces in staying in power. Machiavelli is really important because he introduced the concept of realism, practical down-to-earth considerations, into a previously exalted or "transcendental" subject. Furthermore, The Prince was one of the first humanist works of the Renaissance and was very secular. In it, Machiavelli proposes that religion and politics should be separate, which was a very new idea for the people to accept easily. The main themes

The prince Essay

1505 words - 6 pages historical events (Donno 9). Machiavelli kept his writing simple and concise, making only the points which he intended and leaving no room for arguments to his themes.Rarely in The Prince does Machiavelli hold back on his own opinions for fear of criticism. He explains every point, no matter how controversial or misunderstood he knew it would be, without deviating from his own thoughts. For example, he surely knew that his references to the ruthless

The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli

1074 words - 5 pages Niccolo di Bernardo dei Machiavelli also referred to as Niccolo Machiavelli born May 3, 1469 is an Italian Renaissance many of talents and qualities. He was a historian, politician, diplomat, philosopher, humanist, and writer. Machiavelli’s most notorious masterpiece was a novel called The Prince, which consider the most untraditional novel of the Italians renaissance period. Although, Machiavelli knew the consequences of his masterpiece

Political Action and Morality in Machiavellian Times

1453 words - 6 pages as the freedom of his country from its barbarian oppressors as his ultimate goal, it becomes clear that Machiavelli is not advocating for the complete divorce of morality and politics. Taken as a whole, Niccolò Machiavelli is perhaps one of the most misunderstood philosophers of his time. While his focus on necessary evils and mastering the art of war seem to indicate a man concerned only with maintaining power at the expense of all others

The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli, Chapter 18

1138 words - 5 pages classical culture of Ancient Greece and Rome. The Prince, published in 1513 at the decline of the Renaissance and written by Italian statesman and humanist thinker Niccolo Machiavelli, discusses how to successfully, some may say amorally, use power politics to rule successfully. In chapter eighteen of this piece of influential renaissance literature, Machiavelli gives practical and realistic advice on how to rule successfully and unify a group of people

Discuss Machiavelli's view on morals and politics in the Prince

2480 words - 10 pages traditional politics.Having determined the republican idea of politics in the quattrocento, it is important to look at the humanist ideals of princely government and how far Machiavelli agreed with them, before the Prince can be fully understood. To humanists in the late fourteenth century the ideal ruler was the vir virtutis, the virtuous man. For them virtuosity was having the combined qualities of honour, glory and fame obtained through one's own deeds

ETHICS AND POLITICS: COMPARE TWO MACHIAVELLIAN THINKERS (Machiavelli And Han Fei Tzu)

1286 words - 5 pages their thoughts and interests.Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527) was an Italian humanist who lived under the rule of the Medici family. His publication of the "The Prince" was a dedication to the Medicis in attempt to regain his post as secretary of war after being exiled. He rejoined humanist circles in failure of this attempt.Han Fei Tzu (c.280 B.C.-233 B.C.) was a Chinese philosopher who wrote political advice for the emperor. His publication

Political Ideology in The Prince by Niccolò Machiavelli

745 words - 3 pages State. This revolutionized political theory and moved away from earlier politicians following the same guidelines. With Machiavelli’s humanist background, he was part of an anti-Savonarolan government (Skinner 6). Girolamo Savonarola was an important Church leader, and Machiavelli did not approve of the Church being so involved in the State. This led to the eventual ban on his works when the Church published the list of forbidden books, a counter

Different Times â€" Different Views

782 words - 3 pages Who should have the power in a political state? Does the sovereignty belong to a single monarch or should the people themselves be sovereign? Well, as Americans in today's society this question seems to have an obvious answer. This question didn't seem so simple prior to the American Revolution though. Niccolo Machiavelli and Thomas Paine have distinctively different views concerning sovereignty and people's rights. These views are expressed in

Niccolò Machiavelli and Desiderius Erasmus: Two Styles of Humanism

534 words - 2 pages Machiavelli and Erasmus were both humanists, but had very different points of view. Machiavelli whose writing was from the Italian humanist's view, when Erasmus wrote from the points of view of Christian humanist in Europe may be one of reasons for huge differences in Machiavelli's and Erasmus' thoughts. However, these two styles of humanism provided us means to "generalize about the meaning of the Renaissance."(303).According to Lawrence in his

Machiavelli

1578 words - 6 pages The Italian Renaissance is known for its birth of many notable philosophers, including the famous Niccolo Machiavelli. He is, without a doubt, one of the greatest political thinkers to have ever existed, and his ideas and beliefs have been an inspiration and motivation for many famous leaders. Although he has known to have been a positive influence on mankind, Machiavelli has also distinguished a bad reputation that has been unfairly given to

Similar Essays

Comparing The Secular Humanist, Machiavelli And The Religious Humanist, Erasmus

3216 words - 13 pages Comparing the Secular Humanist, Machiavelli and the Religious Humanist, Erasmus One can often identify a person's political, religious or cultural orientation by his or her reaction to certain words. A case in point is the expression "secular humanism." For religious conservatives those words sum up much of what is wrong with contemporary society. Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary gives several definitions for humanism, a word

Cruel To Be Kind Essay

1850 words - 8 pages actually treated very unfairly there, especially with the possibility that he did not commit the crime. Another huge misconception about Machiavelli is that his “motto” was “the end justifies the means,” which basically means that if you want something enough, it doesn’t matter what you did to get it. However, Machiavelli never said anything of the sort (Humanist, Diplomat and Political Theorist). The reason why Machiavelli is considered to be such

Machiavelli Essay

1091 words - 4 pages . Machiavelli was indeed a persuasive writer worthy of the praise of his Humanist peers and of leaders who read his works. One can now draw another connection between the political situation in Italy and the ideas Machiavelli incorporated into The Prince. The money from influential Italians supported the boom in cultural activities, which allowed those such as Machiavelli to be immersed in Civic Humanism and one can see why The Prince was written

Virtu And Fortune In Machiavelli's The Prince

2406 words - 10 pages regional influence and control but were instead joined by power-hungry political forces from France, Switzerland, the Holy Roman Empire and Spain. Machiavelli received an excellent humanist education, studying grammar, rhetoric and Latin at the University of Florence and made his entrance into public view after his appointment as a civil servant of the Florentine Republic, as the Second Chancery of the Republic of Florence in 1498 at the age of 29