Macpherson Report (1999).

2264 words - 9 pages

On Thursday 22 April 1993, Stephen Lawrence an 18 year old A-Level student, and his friend Duwayne Brooks were making their way home after spending the day together. As the pair rushed to catch a bus in Eltham, a Southeast London suburb, they were confronted by a gang of white youths. These white youths subsequently set upon Stephen and stabbed him. He collapsed just 200 yards away in a pool of blood and died. His death was formally recorded the next morning by Dr Richard Shepard as "haemorrhage resulting from stab wounds."The police investigation that followed, or rather the lack of it has since been exposed as the most serious of threats to cohesive society today. This rather inept police investigation led to a public inquiry. The Lawrence Public Inquiry chaired by Sir William Macpherson has raised allegations of systematic corruption and institutionalised racism within the British Police. It placed both the police and the Criminal Justice System as a whole on public trial.The Macpherson Report was published in February 1999. It is the most damning indictment of policing ever published. Within it is contained a complete catalogue of professional incompetence, which highlights with hindsight how Lawrence's murderers went free. With its 70 wide-ranging recommendations it is hailed as a watershed for race issues in Britain. This essay will analyse the main recommendations of The Report, which were designed to ensure that the criminal justice system responded more adequately to the needs of ethnic minority communities.One of the main recommendations of the Macpherson report called for a Freedom of Information Act. Recommendation 9 proposed "that a Freedom of Information Act should apply to all areas of policing, both operational and administrative, subject only to the 'substantial harm' test for withholding disclosure." This would cover all information about policing, with "no class of police information excluded wholesale." Macpherson proposed that any such information should only be withheld where its disclosure would cause "substantial harm." However, the government has rejected elements of this issue, they propose to exclude two classes of police information from the Act. They wish to exclude information regarding investigations or prosecutions, also information regarding police informers. This they said was to be required because of:"the need to avoid prejudicing effective law enforcement, the need to protect witnesses and informers, the need to maintain the independence of the judicial and prosecution processes, and the need to preserve the role of the criminal court as the sole forum for determining guilt."Other information will be accessible to the public, but this is to be based on a test of harm. The governments response here simply states that this will be "an appropriate" harm test.This Freedom of Information Act was initially propose by the government in their white paper of December 1997 to cover the public sector as a whole at all...

Find Another Essay On Macpherson Report (1999).

The Public's Confidence in the Police and their Pledges

2566 words - 10 pages Macpherson Report to find the extent of the corruption and conscious and unconscious racism by the police when investigation Stephen Lawrence’s murder. The inquiry into the handling of the murder found the police blamed the victim for his own murder (Guardian 1999). As this murder case was reported on the T.V news, newspapers and radio stations the public became outraged on the way police handle racist attacks and the public began to see the police

Ideological Bias Reflected in American Crime Statistics

2719 words - 11 pages are known to greatly represent a particular ideological bias: Institutional racism. As defined by Macpherson (1999) Institutional Racism consists of the collective failure of an organisation to provide an appropriate and professional service to people because of their colour, culture or ethnic origin. Though his accounts have been criticized, there has been evidence in studies that ideologies about particular groups has influenced policing to a


1598 words - 6 pages investigation five white youths were arrested, however, there were no convictions as a direct result of the investigations. In 1999, as a result of the killing, a report was published by Sir William Macpherson which examined the original Metropolitan police investigation. The report concluded that the force was institutionally racist and has been called one the most important moments in the modern history of criminal justice in Britain (British

The Use of Ritalin Should be Limited

5773 words - 23 pages to have substance abuse problems or have attempted suicide (Simon, 2002). As for the report of side effects, most young people report mild side effects, most often loss of appetite.Despite these promising results, there is a growing group of psychologists and physicians who are speaking out against the use of Ritalin to solve what they say are social problems. Instead of solving behavioral problems through therapy, society is quicker to drug the

Poverty in Our Society

3218 words - 13 pages has risen since 1979/80 especially child poverty. [Social Justice Report 2000] I will now look social work services, regarding what it does and can do to support and empower the 90% of people on means-tested benefits. [Becker & MacPherson p310] Social work is seen to be reactive rather than proactive, dealing with individuals and families in distress in relation to income management, maximising benefits, only

Racism within football/Soccer in europe and great Britain

3337 words - 13 pages public eye especially in light of the Stephen Lawrence enquiry about his murder and the subsequent investigation that followed which was dogged by institutional racism (MacPherson,1999).Football and the structure of the game would also appear to being affected by institutional racism.There are very few Black coaches and managers being employed. Indeed what are the sociological effects this is having and how are these theories affecting the game


2691 words - 11 pages Press of New England [for] Middlebury College Press. Sen, A. (1999). Democracy as a Universal Value. Journal of Democracy, 10. Sen, A. (2011). Development as Freedom. New York: Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. Transparency International-TI (2012), Corruption Perception Index-2012. Transparency International, London. United Nations Development Programme-UNDP (2013), Human Development Report 2013. United Nations Development Program, New York

Discussing the Credit Card Debt Crisis

3403 words - 14 pages treacherous social and economic currents of contemporary U.S. society” (44) he adds. Manning also talks about the “Cross Roads of Debt: Citicorp and the ascension of the consumer credit card” Manning brings up an event from April 30, 1998 when a share holder of Travelers Group spoke at a merger meeting with Citicorp. He stated to Sandy Weill (Travelers Group CEO) that “She must have felt like she asked supermodel Elle Macpherson on a date and instead

Sociology - Social Inequality and Poverty within contemporary UK today.

4554 words - 18 pages minorities. The MacPherson Report (1999) into the investigation of the Stephen Lawrence murder said that the police force was institutionally racist, and said that the recommendations of the Scarman Report have been ignored. Health - In April 2001, Pakistani and Bangladeshi men and Women in Britain, were reported to have the most recordings of poor health and long-term illness. While Chinese women and men were reported to have the lowest rates

Write a short piece about your own social identity. Drawing on this, answer the following question: 'Critically evaluate the claim that 'collective social identities are both inclusive and exclusive'.

4321 words - 17 pages discrimination'.(Dodd, The Guardian Dec 15 2004)This report comes five years after it was found to be institutionally racist by the Macpherson report into the tragic death of Stephen Lawrence. It is noteworthy to point out that what the aforementioned examples illustrate is agency on the part of the individual to sue the NHS after facing discrimination and the courageous battle of the family of Stephen Lawrence to fight for an investigation.But

Analysis of Provisions Related to Police Powers

6186 words - 25 pages stop and search ones reasonable suspicion can also be used excessively. Consequential to this more people of a particular age group, sex, colour, might be targeted to be stopped and searched. In particular young black males driving a vehicle, and wearing hats. Stone (2004) recognized this in the “MacPherson report on the Stephen Lawrence inquiry (1999) Cm 4262, this as one example of ‘institutional racism’” (81

Similar Essays

Police Relations With Minority Ethnic Communities

3570 words - 14 pages Police Relations with Minority Ethnic Communities The Macpherson report was published in 1999 amidst problems of racial inequality and a lack of faith in the police amongst minority ethnic communities. There is an ongoing debate on whether Macpherson’s report was a help or a hindrance with regards to minority ethnic relations and the police; it is this dispute that the essay shall examine. To begin with the paper will

Lord Scarman On Crime In Britain.

649 words - 3 pages of there being racism in this country, but it is fair to say not all people are racist and not all people within organisations could possibly on purpose be racist.BIBLIOGRAPHYQuote by MacPherson taken from Hall, Stuart. History Workshop Journal, Vol 48, 1999. Oxford University PressClass Handout: The riots: Issues of crime and of race relationsStephen Lawrence enquiry, Chapter 6.8 and 6.9, Racism

To What Extent Has Social Policy Tackled One Of The Following Social Divisions? Ethnicity

1002 words - 5 pages Lawrence has brought about a lot of controversy for the past 20 years as it’s considered to be ‘’…one of the highest profile racial killings in UK history’’ (The Telegraph, 2013). Stephen Lawrence was a black teenager who was murdered in South-East London in 1993 his murder investigation appeared to consist of many faults. The Macpherson Report has examined the procedures the Metropolitan Police took during the investigation. As a result the Report

Ethnic And Racial Inequalities In The Justice System

543 words - 2 pages use of stop and search against members of minority ethnic groups. Firstly Police Racism; the Macpherson Report (1999), on the investigation of the murder of the black teenager Stephen Lawrence, concluded that there was institutional racism within the Met.Police. Other people have also found there to be excessive racist attitudes among officers. Also Phillips and Bowling suggested that officers hold negative stereotypes about ethnic minorities. Such