Madison Vs. Jefferson: On The Issue Of Constitutional Conflict In The Federalist Papers

1398 words - 6 pages

In the Federalist Papers, James Madison and Thomas Jefferson discuss the issue of constitutional conflict, specifically the encroachment by any one branch of the government on another. Jefferson proposes a method for resolving such a conflict between the Judicial, the Legislative, and/or the Executive branch of government. His proposal states that ``whenever any two of the three branches of government shall concur in opinion, each by the voices of two thirds of their whole number, that a convention is necessary for altering the constitution, or correcting breaches of it, a convention shall be called for the purpose" (Madison, No. 49 310).Jefferson has two reasons for making such a proposal. First, no one department can ever be a judge in such a constitutional conflict, because none of them "can pretend to [have] an exclusive or superior right of settling the boundaries between their respective powers" (Madison, No. 49 311). Secondly, appealing to the people to resolve constitutional conflicts is a reasonable course of action, since our republican form of government derives its power and legitimacy from the people. Who better to be the judge the central government, than the highest power in the land, the people? Therefore, without resorting to a convention made-up of the people, such encroachments could never be deterred nor redressed. Only they have right or ability to pass judgment and enforce their ruling.Madison strongly objects to Jefferson's proposal. One such objection concerns the effects repeated appeals would have on public's overall opinion of the government. The concern is that by frequently displaying the faults, conflicts, corruption, helplessness, and ineffectiveness in government, the people would no longer trust and respect their government. An opinion held in private and isolated from society is powerless and poses little or no danger to the established authority. However, such an opinion has the propensity to gain momentum and grow at an exponential rate. The fear is that this opinion could lead to instability, as more and more people adopt this viewpoint. Further, instability is likely to result, simply because the general populace is ruled by their passions, rather than "the voice of an enlightened reason" (Madison, No. 49 312). Thus, Madison reasons there is little to be gained and much to be lost by "disturbing the public tranquility by interesting too strongly the public passions" (Madison, No. 49 312).Another important objection of Madison, to Jefferson's proposal, is that the "decisions which would probably result from such appeals would not answer the purpose of maintaining the constitutional equilibrium of the government" (Madison, No. 49 312). That is, by trying to resolve constitutional questions by appealing to the people, the executive and judiciary branches of government, being relatively small and disconnected from the people, would be at a distinct disadvantage to the legislature.To substantiate the previous...

Find Another Essay On Madison vs. Jefferson: On the Issue of Constitutional Conflict in the Federalist Papers

How the federalist and anti-federalist papers led to the ratification of the articles of confederation

1358 words - 5 pages September 1787, an article was published in a New York paper. The article was an anti-federalist article written by an author who went under the pen name Cato. Cato was suspected to be George Clinton who served as vice president under James Madison and Thomas Jefferson. This was the first articled published trying to convince the people of the United States that there was no need to ratify the constitution. This began a long feud between

An Essay Concerning The Creation of Government Using the early American texts (e.g., The Federalist Papers)

3451 words - 14 pages abilities.This issue of equality in relation to all manors of policy and government warrants some further discussion. At the forefront of this argument is the understanding that humans, regardless of nationality, ethnicity or gender, are by nature competitive beings. Madison freely admits "If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary

Constitutional Conflict of the Dealth Penalty

776 words - 3 pages Constitutional Conflict of the Dealth Penalty The courts positions of the death penalty has changed over the years. For centuries societies have used death as the ultimate penalty for crime. In the 1960's, the court ruled against the death penalty as a "cruel and unusual punishment", which was forbidden by the eighth amendment of the Constitution. By the 1990's the death penalty was again in wide use supported by the court and

James Madison and the Slavery Issue

3379 words - 14 pages Federalist who wanted to appeal to northern antislavery sentiments in order to divide and conquer the Republicans. Madison and Jefferson both warned the ultimate price of injecting slavery into national politics would be the eventual disruption of the union, (Meyers, p.319-320). Though numerous visitors came to Montpelier for advice about the slavery issue and the Missouri Compromise, Madison refused to be drawn into the issue. Before Madison's

The Federalist

1235 words - 5 pages In order to ascertain the cultural and literary significance of the “The Federalist”, an understanding of some small but significant United States history is in order. In 1787 the Constitutional Convention was to meet and determine the next pivotal step for the United States of America. What will be the governing body of this new republic and how should it strike forward on this great adventure. A team of framers set out to write what would

The Federalist/Anti Federalist Debate

1951 words - 8 pages Hamilton and John Jay. They wrote The Federalist Papers between October 1787 and May 1788 in which they stand up for the Constitution with body and soul. On the other hand, the Anti-Federalists did not agree with most of the principles established in the Constitution. They were composed of a lot of important farmers and politicians like Robert Yates, Luther Martin, Melancton Smith and even Thomas Jefferson. What opinions did the Federalists and Anti

A Play Script Based on Federalist and Antifederalist Papers

4849 words - 19 pages The men featured in this conversation will be:Alexander Hamilton James MadisonJohn Jay George ClintonRobert YatesSamuel BryanPatrick HenryMelancton SmithRichard Henry(Several men enter a room. The room is dimly lit, with only candles to provide it with light. Several tables are scattered across the rooms, with papers and inkwells on each of them. The walls are a beige color, yet look as if they need to be repainted. It is well kept however, and

This essay concentrates on the central issue of "siblings in conflict." It is an analysis of Tobias Wolff's "The Richer Brother." It has parenthentical documentation and is solid.

1205 words - 5 pages The Measure of a ManAnd in this way, smiling, nodding to the music, he went another mile or so and pretended that he was not already slowing down, that he was not going to turn back, that he would be able to drive on like this alone, and have the right answer when his wife stood before him in the doorway of his home and asked, Where is he? Where is your brother?(Wolff 269)What is the measure of a rich man? Is it his material possessions, the

I have lived in the ritzy part of the Madison

692 words - 3 pages I have lived in the ritzy part of the Madison area my entire life. We didn't cross the race line to often. I was always told to be civil and that everyone is different, but they still are nice people. Coming to college opened up a new world to me, a world where I confronted people of different ethnic and racial backgrounds on an everyday basis. I never thought that there would be an issue dealing with race within this community; I thought people

Custom Written Term Papers: The Role of Women in Othello

2711 words - 11 pages are unprepared for the forthright, brave young woman we see in the senate scene. Desdemona is not afraid to assert her rights as a married woman and openly insists that she is ready for a sexual relationship. The question of whether she is still a virgin when she dies is left open by Shakespeare. Despite this, it is clear that Desdemona is sexually very inexperienced, and this is portrayed in her conversation with Emilia in her bedroom, later on

Foreign Policy in the Federalist Era

586 words - 3 pages . On the other hand, France felt being betrayed by the so called “Neutrality” and its agreement with England, for France had helped America substantially during the American Revolution, and the confederated government had signed an alliance in 1778 promising aid if France were ever under attack. In the election of 1796, Federalist obtained majority in the congress and John Adams became the president. Adam’s continued Hamilton’s pro-British foreign

Similar Essays

Summary Of The "Federalist Papers".

934 words - 4 pages This document (the Federalist) will provide all the reasons to support the new plan of government described in the U.S. Constitution, and responses to each of the criticisms of the plan.Opponents to the new plan criticize it most on it creating a strong central government that will be abusive to individual liberty. However, an energetic government is crucial to the protection of individual liberty. The plan of government under the Articles of

This Essay Is On Strict Vs. Loose Construction During The Presidencies Of Madison And Jefferson

1167 words - 5 pages Constitution. After the constitutional convention had taken place, Thomas Jefferson petitioned against the ratification of the newly written document, the Constitution. Jefferson also argued for a Bill of Rights in the Constitution. In a letter to James Madison Jefferson called for a Bill of Rights because it provided "freedom of religion, freedom of the press, protection against standing armies, ... and trials by jury in all matters triable by

Aristotle's Legacy In The Federalist Papers

2047 words - 8 pages ? If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” As to the question of what influence Aristotle may have had on the architects of the Federalist Papers, it seems clear that at the very least, his writings contain ideas that are in no small way shared by Hamilton, Madison, and Jay. While it is always debatable as to the extent of

The Federalist Papers And The Birth Of A Nation

1268 words - 5 pages “the few versus the many”. The question of how a democracy lead by a few people would fail to materialize into an aristocracy was firmly addressed within the Federalist papers, notably number 57. Madison argues that limited terms as well as the heavy involvement by the population would keep the few elected from trampling the rights and interests of the many. While a distinct class system fails to materialize in the Constitution, a layered system