Maggie: Dead On The Streets Essay

2372 words - 9 pages

Since its publication in 1896, Stephen Crane’s Maggie: A Girl of the Streets has generated speculation and debate over issues like censorship (Dowling 37) and class consciousness (Lawson), but what is possibly the most heated debate concerning Maggie is less about social or literary criticism and more about a plot point—the cause of death of Maggie Johnson; some critics claim that she is murdered, while others claim that she commits suicide (Dowling 36), and, while both arguments have strong cases, they seem to have neglected the most probable cause of the death of a Stephen Crane character—death by natural causes.
Robert M. Dowling and Donald Pizer present opposing cases in their article “A Cold Case File Reopened: Was Crane’s Maggie Murdered or a Suicide?” in which Dowling presents the death by murder while Pizer claims death by suicide (Dowling 37).
Donald Pizer bases his argument on textual, historical, and critical evidence. In a textual context Pizer claims that the debate over the cause of death only began after the release of the second, edited version of the story. The key factor leading to the debate is the omission of a section of the original text that includes a “huge fat man” (Dowling 37) who is depicted menacingly in the scene just prior to the revelation of Maggie’s death. Pizer contends that the reason many claim Maggie is murdered by the fat man is not because of his inclusion in the story, but because of the attention drawn to him because of his omission. Pizer supports this assertion saying:
The possibility that Maggie is murdered did not enter criticism of the novel
until the mid-1960s, following R. W. Stallman’s and Joseph Katz’s discussions
(in 1955 and 1966 respectively) of the significant difference between the
close of chapter XVII in the 1893 and 1896 editions of Maggie. (Dowling 37)
Pizer insists that the only reason the cause of death issue has come up is because of this otherwise unwarranted attention on the “huge fat man.” Pizer feels that since the fat man has become a significant source of conflict in the debate, his part should be addressed, but, since he only appears in the 1893 version, his significance should be addressed “entirely by reference to that text rather than to Crane’s motive in cutting the passage” (Dowling 38). If the reader takes the scene in which the “huge fat man” appears without considering its later omission, the man is clearly disgusting and indicative of the extreme fall of Maggie’s circumstances, but there is no evidence to show that the man was anything more than a revolting client. The man, if taken at face value, is only a repulsive man, and any evidence that could be used to charge him with murder would be circumstantial at best; certainly he was in the wrong place at the wrong time, but no legal court could convict him with so little hard evidence. One may hypothesize about Crane’s motives for cutting the scene, but that too would be conjecture and, therefore, invalid for...

Find Another Essay On Maggie: Dead on the Streets

Hypocrisy in Steven Crane’s Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets

728 words - 3 pages Hypocrisy in Steven Crane’s Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets One of the many themes shown in Maggie: a Girl of the Streets is that of hypocrisy. Hypocrisy occurs when one pretends to be something that he or she is not. Most people associate hypocrisy with a person that speaks poorly of something, yet commits that something him or her self. In Maggie, many of the main characters in the novel display the trait of hypocrisy. The trait is

Stephen Crane’s “Maggie: A Girl of the Streets”

1434 words - 6 pages less than ideal. Because choices do exist for characters, free will is still there, which indicates that naturalism is a derivative form of realism. In Stephen Crane’s “Maggie: A Girl of the Streets,” the characters may have little chance to escape the world they inhabit, like Maggie, Jimmie, and Pete, but choices are there, even if these choices aren’t very good. Maggie, herself, is a prime example. In the end of Crane’s tale, Maggie is

Hypocrisy in Steven Crane’s Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets

3608 words - 14 pages the contrary she was never taught that there was another means to her lifestyle. The Johnson’s public damnation of Maggie’s behavior provides some evidence that “they are keen on respectability as the primary moral goal,” stated Nazmi Al-Shalabi author of “Authenticity and Role-Playing in S. Crane’s Maggie: A girl of the streets” (200). Everyone who had any power of influence over her life, such as her mother, brother, Pete, and the

Q 1 Naturalism in "Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets"

584 words - 2 pages Stephen Crane in his book Maggie: A girl of the Streets, used Maggie to convey devastating consequences that befall those violating the social and economic boundaries set upon them at birth. Crane's supposed norms of the world often impart naturalistic qualities to his work. Naturalism is synonymous with characters being pitted against forces that are beyond their control. The naturalists of Crane's day believed that social circumstances were

Power And Control In Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets

1324 words - 5 pages The world of Stephen Crane’s novel, Maggie: A Girl of the Streets, is a dark, violent place. People curse one another openly and instigate fights over petty issues. The intense poverty of the populace leads to a feeling of general despair and creates a lack of self-confidence in each individual. People want to feel that they mean something. They want to know that their life does not go unnoticed. They desire power over others

Maggie: A Girl of the Streets by Setephen Crane

1577 words - 6 pages Stephen Crane’s novella, “Maggie: A Girl of the Streets” deals with many difficult concepts and situations. However, the most prevalent seems to be the people that find themselves caught in a vicious cycle of violence. Although some claim that a literary label cannot possibly contain Crane’s work, his ideas certainly have much in common with other naturalistic writers of his time. He portrays poor Irish immigrants, the dregs of humanity

Maggie: A girl of the Streets as an Exemplar of Literary Naturalism Author: Stephen Crane Title: Maggie: A girl of the Streets

835 words - 3 pages Stephen Crane's interpretations of life are spawned from his own opinions of the world. These opinions correspond with naturalistic train of thought. He makes use of an observation technique to show the natural law of the universe: One can either accept the laws determining social order or become their victim. In the Novella Maggie: A girl of the Streets, Maggie is used as a medium to paint the picture of the devastating consequences that befall

Maggie: A Girl of the Streets: She Never Had a Chance

1258 words - 5 pages Maggie Never Had a Chance “She imagined a future rose-tinted because of its distance from all she had experienced before,” (53). The distance from the broken furniture and drunken bawls was not far. Maggie’s new wonderful cultural experience was a short glimpse at New York’s museums with time spent at cheap theatres and dance halls. Instead of a fairy tale story, Crane told of reality in Maggie: A Girl of the Streets – the reality that would

"The River Flows on" by Maggie Craig

728 words - 3 pages has give, life isn't as great as they expect it to be. Kate's life is described as many youngsters in this time.Through this novel we go through the life of Kate Cameron, a typical teenager who lives in the time of World War I. Maggie Craig gives us an understanding of the central issues of war-time for young people, the effect created on her life and develops the main points in her life giving us the full view on war life.At the age of sixteen

Runaway Girl Escaping Life on the Streets

1504 words - 6 pages , and health issues to get to where she is in life now. You have to go through things to find out how strong you are and what you’re able to put yourself. Mrs. W got her to love math again and she ended up going to law school because she wanted to help people like her. She was most successful when she actually was able to tell her story and made it into a documentary. Bibliography Phelps, C., & Warren, L. (2012). Runaway Girl Escaping Life on the Streets, One Helping Hand At a Time. New York: Penguin Group. Vito F. Gennaro, K. C. (2012). Juvenile Justice Today. New Jersey : Pearson Prentice Hall.

Reflecting on the Dead

1425 words - 6 pages Reflecting on the Dead In Katherine Mansfield’s “The Garden Party” and in D.H. Lawrence’s “Odour of Chrysanthemums,” two women were in a situation where death was literally at their feet. In “The Garden Party,” Laura finds herself contemplating the dead body of Mr. Scott, a man of lower class who lived at the bottom of the hill from her house. In “Odour of Chrysanthemums,” Elizabeth finds herself contemplating the dead body of her husband

Similar Essays

Research Essay On Crane's Maggie A Girl Of The Streets

1911 words - 8 pages By Lee A. ZitoA person's identity is a mixture of many characteristics. These characteristics make up who we are, how we act, and decisions we make in life. These decisions can include where we hang out, who we hang out with, and what type of behavior we emit. What creates these characteristics? How do we develop these traits that determine who we are in society?When Stephen Crane wrote Maggie A Girl of the Streets, he created two characters in

A Brief Analysis On Maggie From Stephen Crane's Maggie,Girl Of The Streets

805 words - 3 pages The cruel reality of poverty is examined in Stephen Crane's Maggie: A Girl on the Streets. In it, Maggie Johnson, born in the rough streets of New York, dreams of having a better life, one with culture, money, and meaning- the opposite of the one she was born with. Though she believed that her dreams were becoming tangible, with the aid of Pete, she ultimately returns to the streets and is destroyed by them. Throughout the novel, the birth and

"Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets" By Stephen Crane

1301 words - 5 pages goin’ to the lik dat Riley kid and dey all pitched on me” (pg. 4). Although fights are breaking out on the streets, Maggie’s home life appears to be just as bad. Typically, Jimmie is the one to get punished. Considering their mother is an alcoholic, and a devil-like figure, and their father is a brutal alcoholic, their home is not a place of safety, and the children have no means of escaping any brutality. The reader can clearly see

Analysis Of Stephen Crane's, Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets

2550 words - 10 pages Analysis of Stephen Crane's, Maggie: A Girl of the Streets Today in modern America, it has become almost impossible to avoid the tales of horror that surround us almost anywhere we go. Scandals, murders, theft, corruption, extortion, abuse, prostitution, all common occurrences in this day in age. A hundred years ago however, people did not see the world in quite such an open manner despite the fact that in many ways, similarities were