This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mahfouz's Akhenaten, Dweller In Truth Essay

4118 words - 16 pages

Mahfouz's Akhenaten, Dweller in Truth

In the history of literature, perhaps the most explored genre is the historical novel. From the Epic of Gilgamesh to the present day, authors have taken historical facts and interpreted them novelistically. When no facts are available, the author may extrapolate missing parts of the story from two sources -- either through the interpretation of the existing scholarly data or through the author's imagination. These two approaches to 'filling in the gaps' of a historical novel can either appease the historian and displease the literary critic or please the literary critic and upset the historian. Very few novelists can produce a historically accurate novel that is also pleasing to a literary critic; to do so would be very difficult because the novelistic plot structure hardly ever follows the structure of truthful historic events. A novelistic writing about a battle in World War Two would be bound to either an accurate portrayal of the events around the main character or a convincing depiction of the people involved. If the author chose to write about turrets, casualty statistics, and troop movements, he would surely sacrifice much of the artistic content of the novel. If the author chose to focus on character and plot, then the writer couldn't portray the event with the specificity it requires. However, the exception to these guidelines appears when a novelist chooses to write a historical novel about a time or a person when large portions of the historical picture is still either unknown or up for scholarly debate. This condition presents itself infrequently to the historical novelist, in circumstances where few people witnessed or spoke about the event, or through an event so ancient that the vast majority of the historical facts surrounding it are either lost or interpreted and reinterpreted. The common element between these conditions is that the intended audience, largely uneducated in scholarly theories of the period, would be accepting of facts presented to them.

Thus, Naguib Mahfouz, in choosing to write about the aftermath of the pharaoh Akhenaten, becomes a historical novelist not necessarily bound to the conventions of factual portrayals. The author joins a long line of historical novelists who have, with varying results, examined the Amarna period. Since Herbertson's first fictional account of the period in 1890, novels set in the ancient Egyptian Amarna period have shifted thematic focus according to society's need for commentary. If a feminist needed to write about a strong female model, the author would adapt Nefertiti to her goals. If an imperialist wanted to portray the glories of empire, then Akhenaten became a bold, defiant leader. If a theologist wanted to examine alternatives to Western religions, then Atenism became his model for Oriental monotheism.

Naguib Mahfouz's Akhenaten, Dweller in Truth, as a historical novel, provides the reader with a rather balanced model between...

Find Another Essay On Mahfouz's Akhenaten, Dweller in Truth

Walking The Line Essay

1085 words - 5 pages The reality in which we exist, also known as the realm of opinion is revealed in Plato’s “Republic” to essentially be a cheap imitation of the ultimate realm of form and knowledge. Plato uses the “Allegory of the Cave” to demonstrate the various stages of life that we are faced with. We are born into the realm of reality and opinions. Here the truth is relative and constantly changing, however in the realm of the forms the truth remains

Understanding of Discoveries: Myth of the Cave by Plato

886 words - 4 pages his ignorance the cave dweller would have never discovered such amenities as food and its varieties that we take for granted today. Yet, they were comfortable in believing that the images on the wall were the actual reality. The truth-seeker chooses to move beyond images on the wall to the bona fide things themselves. He therefore makes the journey from ignorance to knowledge because of his curiosity. As mentioned in the text, "last of all he will

Finding Jesus in The Wanderer

1871 words - 7 pages will never obtain the wisdom which the wanderer possesses in order to understand the idea of existence. Life is never a constant factor; it can change at any given moment and the earth-dweller will now be fully prepared for whatever lay ahead. He knows to look to the "high-earth" for guidance and that the "middle-earth" is a mere fantasy of the inhabitants. Existence is decorated with pretty colors by people who are afraid to search for the truth

Allegory of the Cave

676 words - 3 pages light. He steps out and this new world is illuminated by the sun, which makes it very hard for him to see. The man is in disbelief and is not able to see the truth right away. He slowly progresses not to see just shadows, but reflections of real things in water that is somewhat what he is used to seeing, but more defined and colored. The images are closer representations of something more real than shadows. Then at night the cave dweller looks to

My notes from class over Beowulf

798 words - 3 pages attests to the ingenuity of intellectual achievements of people *Creates a stable community *He relies on the different talents and abilities of his people *There is no discrimination in Hrothgar's kingdom *Know name of mead hall in line 71 *Genre-epic poem *1.(Three parts of an Epic Poem) epic villain- pure evil; no goodness in them and stronger than ordinary person *Spite-full of anger-malicious vengeance *Evil dweller is upset because he

Researching Socratic Pedagogy and Education in Plato's Republic

4911 words - 20 pages their whole life in the cave would believe that the projected shadows of people walking outside the cave were not merely images of real things but the real things themselves: "'...such men would hold that the truth is nothing other than the shadows of artificial things'" (Republic, 515c). Since this existence is all they have known, the cave dwellers do not believe they are prisoners. But what if someone on the outside, a non-cave dweller, released a


4027 words - 16 pages of gold from the land of Kush. There is some evidence remaining of the splendor of his Malkata palace with its walls painted and plastered with lively scenes of nature. At Karnak he embellished the already large temple to Amun and at Luxor he built a new one to the same god. He also built the statues known as the Collossi of Memnon on the West Bank. Akhenaten is the new name Amenhotep IV took early in his reign and he is credited with a

Plato's Republic

1034 words - 4 pages Socrates’ begins talking about the allegory at 515c, Glaucon describes Socrates’ image as being “strange”, where Socrates’ interjects to tell him that the people he is describing are “like us”. This seems to spark Glaucon’s interest even more. Glaucon shows his feelings at another point in Socrates’ story, when he speaks of how the cave dweller who had left the cave would rather suffer in the sun than be back in the cave, sharing the opinions of

Beauty is More Than Skin Deep: Depictions of Aging Women in Ancient Egyptian Art

2068 words - 8 pages perspective and focus on the male elite. This is especially true in terms of aging. Overall in Egyptian culture and artwork aging was often stigmatized and associated with outsiders and subordinates. For women, it was difficult for aging to provide a positive counterpoint to youth and beauty. Although we are able to make some generalizations about aged women during this time, the truth is that this stage of life was different for each individual

Kath Walker's Aboriginal Character of Rights

1009 words - 4 pages longing for "help" in times of assistance, to be "welcome(d)" and to have a "choice" in life. A need for an end to stereotyping and racial prejudice is expressed in the use of wording chosen by Walker. She articulates her anger towards defamation directed at the Aboriginal community. Walker feels the strong need for white society to stop "libelling" and defaming Aborigines as "fringe-dweller" that reside within "missions

Most People Live In Ignorance Most Of The Time

844 words - 4 pages Hypothesis: Most people live in ignorance most of the time.Definitions:1)Ignorance - Destitute of knowledge; uninstructed or uninformed2)Allegory - A figurative discourse, in which the principal subject is described by another subject resembling it in its properties and circumstances3)Plato's "Republic" - a dialogue in which Plato explores what an ideal society would be like4)Reality - The state or quality of being real; truth; fact; that which

Similar Essays

Amenhotep Iv And Art And Religion

2337 words - 9 pages . It paid homage to the sun, its central idea was ‘living on ma’at,’ that is, variously translated as "righteousness", "justice", and "truth." The doctrine of this religion failed to win the approval or support of any but Akhenaten’s followers. It is said that cult of Aten did not have an ethical code. It centered around gratitude towards life the sun for life and warmth. Ankh was life the force that the sun-disk (Aten’s ) rays bestowed on man in

Boundary Stelae Essay

2029 words - 9 pages his plans. Perhaps it is just his prayer to the Aten even spiritualists love positive affirmations as they are empowering. Why then could it not also be what he was doing? Akhenaten refers to how he speaks the truth in affirmations, is that not what one does, says something until they believe it in order to make it so? Akhenaten felt that the Sun was life and the Sun brings life to all who want it if the just ask and then reach out and accept

The Boundary Stele: Religious Beliefs Influence Town Planning In New Kingdom Egypt

1473 words - 6 pages imperial couple might sail in on the royal barge named “Aten Gleams” (Wilson 1951:202-203). Not only did Tiye outlive her husband Amenhotep III, her son Akhenaten gave her a Sunshade temple in addition to numerous other privileges once he established the new City of Akhetaten. We know of this in modern times because the tomb officials at “Akhetaten, recorded her presence in the new capital” (Arnold 1997:8). She was still a source of wise council for

Amenhotep Iv Essay

5074 words - 20 pages began to portray different types of scenes. It showed more domestic pictures. Pictures of Akhenaten kissing his wife, in ceremony, or at the dinner table with his family. One mural of Akhenaten’s daughters shows them in playful poses, studied defiance of all rules of Pharoanic dignity. Scenes of busy markets and soldier’s guardrooms were depicted. These are scenes of everyday life, instead dealing with ertenal things. There is seen a truth in art