Majority Verdicts In Australia Essay

1420 words - 6 pages

The role of the jury is to determine innocence or guilt of defendant based on the evidence given in court. The requirement 12 people must find the defendant guilty beyond reasonable doubt has existed in law since the 14th century. In the past 12 jurors had to reach a unanimous verdict which was often difficult to achieve because of rogue jurors. It was inefficient in terms of time and tax payer money. Majority verdicts have been debated extensively since the mid 1990s and there have been three private members bills introduced on the subjectOne of the problems induced by unanimity is that of hung trials. 8% of trials by jury end up hung and this inability to reach a verdict frustrates the administration of justice. Such trials cause emotional, financial and time costs and can end with no sense of closure for the victim.Another problem with unanimous verdicts is that of rogue jurors. Director of Public Prosecutions Nicholas Cowdrey demonstrates the basic principles behind this issue, as one can see from this quote. Rogue jurors are those that may irrationally and tenaciously refuse to agree with the majority and can debase an entire trial, resulting in time and monetary cost for the entire justice system and ultimately the communityYet another issue is compromised verdicts which are the result of undesirable compromises, for example under Black directions where minority jurors may be coerced to take majority views even if they don’t completely agree. Some may be harassed and bullied into agreement, especially if only one disagrees.Finally, juror corruption is another issue that needed to be addressed. It encourages interference with jurors in order to secure desired verdict. If one juror can be corrupted with bribery or intimidation the rest of the jury is rendered powerless. Using unanimous verdicts, there is more opportunity for corruption – under majority, more than one would need to be approached, which would increase risk of detection.In 1998, local councillor Phuong Ngo was charged with the 1994 murder of John Newman, a political rival who held the seat of Cabramatta. The first trial was aborted by the prosector on a legal technicality, the second ended in a 10:1 hung jury after 13 weeks in May 2000, and the third in 2001 resulted in Ngo’s conviction for joint enterprise, however no other joint enterprisers were convicted. In the final trial, the jurors deliberated for three days after the four month trial.This case illustrated many flaws in unanimous verdicts. Firstly, after three trials only one person was found guilty, that was enough – the jury couldn’t convict co-conspirators which could mean that they hadn’t put complete thought and effort into the conviction. After the second trial, the lone jury who voted for acquittal accused other members of the jury of racism and intimidation, which is an unfortunate problem that sometimes occurs in the jury room. Finally, supporters of Ngo say he was convicted on...

Find Another Essay On Majority verdicts in Australia

Australian Migrants and their experiences in the 20th century- "Australia has not always been the lucky country for all its inhabitants in the twentieth century." Discuss

1033 words - 4 pages twentieth century, but at times, has in fact been the a fairly lucky country for them all. Majority of the twentieth century was considered unlucky for the migrants in Australia, but as time progressed and things happened, life for migrants developed into a more enjoyable experience. In the last few years of the twentieth century, the migrants of Australia were regarded as Australian, and the cultural difference between the country's inhabitants

International Relations of Australia during the 20th Century

507 words - 2 pages maintain its ties with the British Empire. At this point in time, parliament was able to make laws concerning internal nation wide issues but had no control over its foreign relations and polices. The English government would decide these. Because over 50% of the Australian population were British born, and the majority of the population considered themselves 'Britains living in Australia', there was a large amount of pro-British sentiment

Southeast Asia Prehistoric Settlers: James Cook

1461 words - 6 pages Australia. The second language spoken in households in Australia is Italian, and the majority are from overseas, this is 2.3% of Australian population. Greek, Cantonese, Arabic and Vietnamese are ranked next. 11% of Australia's population speaks a language other than English. This does not mean they don't know English, most households would practice their native language and English. System of education In Australia 52% of Australian's aged 15

Australia: 1700 to Present

3119 words - 13 pages of Australia went through hard times, they made it through. The current unemployment rate in Australia is a low 5.1%, meaning that a large majority of Australians are employed. Australia still is a large figure in global economic trade, even after their rise from a non-economic continent, to a country in depression, and finally to a functioning country with critical imports and exports worldwide. In conclusion, since the 1700’s, Australia has

Comparing the Maldives to Australia. size, government, culture, food, etc

543 words - 2 pages the Maldives is made up of South Indians, Arabs and Singhalese.The climates of the two countries are also quite different. The Maldives has a tropical climate of wet and dry seasons. The temperature stays humid all year round, at 21 to 32 degrees. The majority of Australia experiences 4 seasons, with warm summers around 30 degrees and mild winters at about 23 degrees. However, the northern third of Australia lies in the tropics, experiencing the

Socrates' Last Error

3144 words - 13 pages of Athens, but only to judges, court executives, prison wardens and other representatives of the legal and executive power. Since the majority of citizens cannot or do not have to participate in law enforcement, the obligation to carry out verdicts cannot refer to them. In modern legal systems this point is quite clear, but the legal system of Socrates’ time was not that sophisticated and specialized. Since Socrates, as an ordinary citizen, had

Australia and Japan's Relationship since World War II

1035 words - 4 pages agreement in 1974, which allowed the two countries to conduct various cultural exchanges. The mutual respect between Australia and Japan is at an all time high (Tom.W 2001:30). Knowledge of and interest in each country’s culture is strong, although it is often misunderstood. For example, a majority of Australians tend to have difficulty recognising the sophistication and uniqueness of the traditional Japanese art forms. Similarly, Japanese people do


539 words - 3 pages classes owns the majority of Australia's wealth (Dilnot 1990, p14). Although this upper class may own the majority of the wealth in Australia, this does not necessarily make them the ruling class.Karl Marx is known as the founding father of the term "˜ruling class'. The Marxist theory speaks of class as being determined by a person's position in mass production (Bulbeck 1998, p316). This means that to be in a "˜ruling class' a person would


2560 words - 10 pages draft federal Constitution. Queensland with drew from the conferences in their final stages of drafting the federal Constitution. Western Australia did not send representatives to the conferences, where as New South Wales demanded many concessions to the Constitution as well as a referendum passed by a special majority. Towards the closing years of the nineteenth century colonies agreed to federate. The committee decided they wanted to establish

Australia Day, January 26th. Do we need to reconsider?

1261 words - 6 pages Australia Day is annually celebrated on the 26th of January; the date recognises the initiation of British sovereignty over Australia in 1788. The nation’s achievements since then are nothing short of outstanding. As regarded as a considerably young nation, we have realized extraordinary growth, expansion, development, stature and respect across the globe; and deemed our greatest achievement, our multiculturalism. Yet despite these momentous

All You Would Like to Know About Australia

905 words - 4 pages Australia is a continent located between the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean with the land area of 2,941,283 sq. mi. The population of Australia was estimated 1,015,576 people, as of 2012. The climate in Australia can tropical, mild, or dry depending on the location. Canberra is the capital of Australia which is at the bottom of the continent, southeast of the biggest city in Australia, Sydney. Sydney is the largest city with a

Similar Essays

Unanimous Verdict Vs. Majority Rules Verdicts

901 words - 4 pages Wales must be unanimous. The rule that a verdict in a criminal trial must be the unanimous verdict of the members of the jury also exists in Victoria, Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory, but in other parts of Australia unanimity is not usually required.The weight of evidence would therefore suggest that the implementation of majority verdicts within Australia would not necessitate solution nor eliminate the already small number of

'consider What You Think Are The Key Aims Of A Criminal Trial And Explain, With Reasons, The Extent To Which You Think The Crown Court Or Magistrates’

1689 words - 7 pages within the magistrate’s verdicts; a shoplifter’s sentence would simply depend on which magistrates heard their case. Fortune is not justice, but the Lawrence’s study would have us believe that this is the case with regards to the magistracy. However, the study is perhaps unreliable because it only examined seven magistrates across two courts. A much wider range of data would be required to prove that this was the case for the majority of

Should Judges Reflect The Society In Which They Live?

1239 words - 5 pages Justice that is absolutely impartial is a cornerstone of democracy. Judges are the highest officials of the judiciary, as independent arbitrators they are relied upon to perform their judicial duties according to the law and Constitutional principles, autonomously of social, political and ideological concerns.In democratic nations, as that of Australia, it is not appropriate for judges to reflect their society in the performance of their

The Power Of The Situation Rodney King

1585 words - 6 pages all these people criminals who used the verdicts as an excuse to commit crimes, or was the nature of the social situation the primary determinant of this nefarious behavior? In the course of this paper, I plan to explore this question from a psychological perspective with an emphasize on conformity and social norms, bystander intervention, social perception and reality, and finally, prejudice. Generally looking at the Los Angeles riots, and