Making Decisions Today For Health Care Tomorow

2737 words - 11 pages

Making Decisions Today For Health Care Tomorow

Today, 80-85% of Americans die in medical institutions. Of those, 70% require decisions about whether to apply, withhold, or withdraw medical treatment (Makar 58). Due to this ever increasing number, the right to die is one of the most popular and controversial topics in medicine today. The issue comes down to personal beliefs and ethics and the fact that there is so little clear-cut legislation on this topic confuses it even more. Advance Directives provide, in theory, for self-determination and put the patients mind at ease with the knowledge that they have decided for themselves the extent of health care that they wish to receive. Also, for the family, the process of watching their loved one suffer through unwanted medical treatment is eliminated. In practice, however, there are a lot of inconsistencies and legal barriers that place limits on their usefulness.

Some would argue that there is a limit to the amount of self-determination a patient retains even with an advance directive. They would say that a part of self-determination is that the patient makes an active, mental decision about his/her health care, and that advance directives dont fulfill this requirement. Regardless, it is clear that it is better than having no voice whatsoever in the decision. Also, in regard to attitudes toward self-determination today, many people waive this right either because they dont know that they have a choice or because they feel that they dont have a right to question a doctor or make medical decisions themselves (report Abram et al. 49-50).

Alan Lieberson, author of the Living Will Handbook, describes a progression that our society has taken that has led to the necessity of advance directives. This is that since our society places a very high value on human life, it is becoming more and more important to preserve life, even when the quality of life is decreasing. Prolongation of a patients life started to reflect on the physicians ability. The relationship between this and huge advances in medical technology in the 1960s that introduced new machines that could be used to temporarily restore health led to several problems. One is that these machines began to be put to use even in cases where there was no hope of recovering with the previous quality of life. Second, even physicians who didnt want to use these machines sort of got trapped into using them in emergencies, when it was unclear what the outlook for the patient was. Once the machines are hooked up, it is difficult for legal reasons to get them turned off (Lieberson 27). In this way advance directives are economically wise because they eliminate a lot of unwanted, but previously unavoidable expensive health care (report, Abram et al. 56-57).


In 1976, California passed the first living will act. The legislators felt that for terminally ill patients, the loss of dignity and the amount of pain and suffering that they...

Find Another Essay On Making Decisions Today For Health Care Tomorow

Health Care: Not For Sale Essay

988 words - 4 pages HEALTH CARE: NOT FOR SALE A number of polls conducted in Canada show that adequate healthcare is the number one concern of the vast majority of Canadians. The transformation of Canada's healthcare system is inevitable, Canada?s health care system is in crisis. There are two main possible routes which can taken to solve this dilemma. The first route, the easier, consists of letting our healthcare system evolve in a direction similar to that of

Using Biblical Principles For Making Wise Business Decisions

2384 words - 10 pages considering whether to increase operations by adding capital projects to existing assets that will help produce either more of its existing products or entirely new products, expansion decisions are made.” CEG Consultants will review all options to best benefit ABC Company for their decision. We realize that the owners of ABC Company are leaning toward a building expansion, but we are hired to bring other options to the table. Rumelt (2011) writes

Lack of Health Care for Senior Citizens

987 words - 4 pages Canada has always been known as a great country to live in for a number of reasons and one being, having free heath care. Although this is a bonus for Canadian citizens, people forget to see the numerous flaws in our system. One great example of an important issue in our Canadian health care system is the lack of care to our seniors. Canada’s baby boomers are reaching the age of retirement, some even older, and are occupying nearly half of the

Need for a New Health Care System

1411 words - 6 pages Need for a New Health Care System      One of the major problems nagging America is the need for a new health care system. The number of uninsured Americans needing medical treatment is rising. Medicare, a major part of the American health care system, is projected to go broke in 2019 according to USA Today?s article, 'Congress refuses to swallow cures for ailing Medicare.' I have seen this ruin people?s pursuit of happiness. I worked in a

Affordable Health Care for America Act

2573 words - 10 pages For the first time in U.S. history, every American will have access to quality, affordable health care under the updated health insurance reform legislation passed by the House. "The Affordable Health Care for America Act or H.R. 3962, blends and updates the three versions of previous bills passed by the House committees. "(Kruger, M. 2010) This bill is expected to ease the out-of-control costs of health insurance, introduce

Health Care for All in South Africa

627 words - 3 pages Topic: Health Care for All 1.1 Constraints to the expansion of Economy and Business. The ANC-led government introduced various systems to improve access to health care for all South African citizens. As a result of this system, pregnant women and children under the age of six are able to access free health care and every South African citizen is able to access free primary care. Senior citizens who qualify for social grant are also receiving

Health Care Inequities for Aboriginal Women

1815 words - 7 pages Health care inequities for Aboriginal women There are 1.1 million Aboriginal peoples living in Canada as of 1996 and 408,100 of them are women (Statistics Canada, 2000; Dion Stout et al, 2001). More than half live in urban centres and two thirds of those reside in Western Canada (Hanselmann, 2001). Vancouver is comprised of 28,000 Aboriginal people representing 7% of the population (Joseph, 1999). Of this total population, 70% live in

American Health-care Plans for the Uninsured

1311 words - 6 pages into the employment of terribly inefficient hospitals (Morici 1). Unfit hospitals do not provide the best care for the injured and sick. Moreover, Implementing Obamacare is not the best thing for our country’s people because many things can happen to their health-care. Obamacare does not just mess with people’s health-care plans, it also puts the country and its citizens into more debt. Many doctors may reconfigure into concierge practices that

Florida Agency For Health Care Administration

1188 words - 5 pages The Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) is a regulatory agency in Florida which was created under the Health Care Reform Acts of 1992. The purpose of the Health Reform Acts of 1992 was to ensure efficient quality and affordable health care services were available to all Floridians by the end of 1994. Florida, in the 1980’s, had a very large population of uninsured residents and a large population of senior citizen, practically all of

The Need For Universal Health Care

1701 words - 7 pages The Need For Universal Health Care Like many college students I have to pinch pennies to make it through school. Every last penny counts when budgeting my monetary supply. As a result of this I have found that I do not have enough to spare to pay for health insurance. Unlike most college students I am over the age of 23 and thus not covered by my parents insurance. Since I am only employed part time I am also not able to obtain it from

The Need for Health Care Reform

1140 words - 5 pages Abstract It is time for our government to take a step away from war and look to meeting the needs of their own citizens. The need for health care reform is more evident than ever. The recession of America has caused many people hardship due to many lay-offs and the fact that insurance premiums have risen drastically. Many families are not receiving the health care that they require due to these circumstances. It affects not only the young

Similar Essays

Health Care Profession Education Today Essay

1385 words - 6 pages work in teams (Thibault 1929). Until recent changes in social norms, this seemed to work. However, it has been found that a new form of educating aspiring doctors creates better outcomes in patient satisfaction. Inter-professional Education calls for the intermixing of health care professionals throughout their training, creating “well functioning multi-professional teams” (Thibault 1929). This way of educating leads to students building

Care Planning: Making Decisions That Involve Everyday Participation And Communication

2146 words - 9 pages Dementia Care: Research into Practice. Berkshire: Open University Press, pp. 168-186. BUCKMAN, R. (1992) How to Break Bad News: A Guide for Health-Care Professionals. London: Macmillan. CHANDLER, D. (1994) The Transmission Model of Communication. Available from [accessed on 5th June 2011]. CHESTON, R., BENDER, M. and BYATT, S.(2000) Involving People who have dementia in the evaluation of

Decision Making Case Study Health Care Management

1386 words - 6 pages create a total budgeted savings of $40,700.00.ReferencesLiebler, J., & McConnell, C. (2008). Management Principles for Health Professional (5th ed.). Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.Stoddard Conty. (2008). Stoddard County Public Health Center. Retrieved November 30, 2008, from Of Phoenix. (2008). The informed decisions toolbox: Tools for knowledge transfer and performance improvement. Retrieved November 30, 2008, from University of Phoenix, Week Two, Resource HCS 514 - Managing in Today's Health Care Organizations Web site.

Picking The Health Care Industry And Making It Efficient

2343 words - 9 pages improving the public health care is to pick up the quality of health care by making it efficient and affordable for all the people. Apart from this, they work with dedication for introducing various safety measures in order to protect the people from any severe natural calamity. 2. Plan Maintenance There are various special task forces who work with enthusiasm towards providing health care services to public in case of any natural disaster or lethal