This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Making Sense Of Quebec And Canada’s Ocean Of Confusion: The Clarity Act

1425 words - 6 pages

Making Sense of Quebec and Canada’s Ocean of Confusion: the Clarity Act
In 2000, the federal government made an attempt to respond to the matter of confusion in referendums dealing with the secession of a province from Canada through the Clarity Act, in response to previous events in Quebec. The aim of this paper is to further explore the Clarity Act and examine its influence over potential upcoming referendums in Quebec over the matter of secession. In order to do so, this essay will first draw attention on the origins of the Clarity Act; next, it will consider the purpose and goal of the act; furthermore, this paper will deliberate on the reactions obtained in response to the Clarity Act of 2000.
Origins
The accumulation of prior events in Quebec dealing with the sovereignty movement and the responses from the federal eventually led to the creation of the Clarity Act in 2000. The outcome of the 1995 referendum in Quebec concerning the issue of sovereignty demonstrated a split in view from Quebec’s population. Indeed, the margin of difference between the two options was slim to nearly none by just over one percent (Toope, 1999, p.520). For years, the idea of Quebec’s sovereignty was left at that, simply an idea; the two referendums of 1980 and 1995 would transform the notion of sovereignty into an increasingly conceivable possibility. Thus, the federal government had to address the sovereignty matter in Quebec.
In result of this situation, Prime Minister Jean Chrétien raised hypothetical questions to the Supreme Court of Canada in 1997 concerning the constitutional legitimacy of a unilateral declaration of independence in Quebec (Malcolmson & Myers, 2009, p.32). The first one questioned the legality of a unilateral secession of Quebec from Canada under the Canadian constitution; the next addressed whether international law accorded Quebec the right to self-determine its secession; finally, the third would ask whether Canadian constitutional law or international law would have priority in the case of a unilateral secession of Quebec from Canada (Toope, 1999, p.521).
The Supreme Court of Canada ruled its decision on the matter in the following year, in 1998. The judgement on the hypothetical case stated that Quebec could not unilaterally secede under Canadian constitution and that international law would not recognize Quebec’s unilateral secession because its population was not considered to be oppressed by the rest of Canada (Philippas, 2012). In addition, the ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada would maintain that, in the case of a “clear” majority in favour of a “clear” question concerning a referendum on sovereignty, the political actors concerned would have the obligation to begin negotiations with Quebec (Dion, et al., 2000, p.22). Ironically, the question of clarity in the ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada is what remained puzzling and subject of debate. With the former ruling of the Supreme Court of Canada, the determination of...

Find Another Essay On Making Sense of Quebec and Canada’s Ocean of Confusion: the Clarity Act

The Influence of Vision, Understanding, Clarity, and Agility

931 words - 4 pages In today’s day and age the term VUCA, short for volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity, is often an all-encompassing excuse to explain away the hard work put into a particular position or course of action that goes astray. However, Johansen’s leadership opportunities of vision, understanding, clarity, and agility provide a roadmap to success by flipping the danger, like an aikido move in martial arts, absorbing the attach, and

Discomfort, Irritation, and Confusion of The Bath

1103 words - 4 pages   Discomfort, Irritation, and Confusion of The Bath          People are living robots. They follow the norm. They go with the latest trend. They walk the latest walk and talk the latest talk. Even the "brilliant ideas" that sprout from people's minds are a combination of other people's thoughts and ideas; friends, family and the media are the greatest influences. When a situation that is out

The Plight of Canada’s Fitness

1135 words - 5 pages problem, however, it is facing several issues considering the class size and the limited funding. Nonetheless, it is the attitude and experience of the instructor is what makes a sport activity an enjoyable one, is what makes the difference. And before 2010 winter Olympics becomes the last time we win gold medals, we need to act now. Thus, we need to activate the physical education programs in the country and make them mandatory nationwide. Canada, please act now before it is too late to do so.

Canada’s Shame: The Oppression of Aboriginal Women in the Indian Act

1652 words - 7 pages decision making processes within the family. Furthermore, the Indian Act planted the seed for lateral oppression. As the aboriginal men accepted their role as leaders of women, lateral oppression in the form of domestic violence against women was born and today aboriginal women have “about four times the odds of experiencing violence compared to non-Aboriginal women” (Gosine, 2000, p.8). The Indian Act took away the biological

The History of Quebec Separatism

1679 words - 7 pages people of Quebec feel that they should be united as one rather than with the rest of Canada. They think that they have been marginalized and treated as a minority in Canada. Their primary belief is that since the majority of them are French, the language itself should be separate from English, as it was pre-Confederation. ; Even though they are the largest province in Canada by area, Quebec is extremely different from the rest of Canada. From its

The Importance of Clarity in Writing

1122 words - 4 pages is clarity, you may be asking? It is simply the process of making your paper clear to the intended audience of your text. This may sound too easy and most of us probably think our papers are always clear, after all we know what we are saying in them. The question is, does everyone else? Both Williams and Strunk and White mention clarity and the importance it plays in the text we read. Williams point out that when we come across a sentence that is

Making Sense of Graffity in the Modern World

1746 words - 7 pages feelings to the public. The essential argument, is whether graffiti has a place in the grand context of society. One end of the spectrum paints it as a nuisance to property owners and city officials allow for a criminal perspective of the practice. While at another end you can view it as the artist in a sense blessing others with the fruits of their inner consciousness. An artistic expression no matter what the viewpoint of society, in an

Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms

1294 words - 5 pages is the document the truly separates Canada from all the other powerful nations and is really something that Canadian take a pride in. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms brings up many questions, but the biggest and most common question is How effectively does Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protect your individual rights? . To exactly know how effectively it protects your rights you can look at situations where it has protected

The Aging Effects of Canada’s Population

3981 words - 16 pages in knowledge, technology and information. As a result, the risks that labour shortages will deepen is expanding. Shifts in population size within various age groups have far-reaching social, economic and policy impacts (Dowd, 1980). This evolution has shaped Canada’s demographic past, present and future as the number of pre-schoolers, students, workers at the beginning, middle or end of their careers, retirees and

The Needs of Canada’s Youthful Population

975 words - 4 pages Did you know that in 2006, the number of aboriginal people in Canada surpassed one million? This means that the aboriginals represented 3.8% of the total population in Canada. Even though this number is much smaller than the non-aboriginal population, they have an impact on Canada, in the north and south. Unfortunately, some of the aboriginal groups do not have a stable way of living and the Canadian government is very selective when helping

Aliens of the Ocean

2064 words - 8 pages Many people view jellyfish as small monstrosities, due to their uncommon feature in this common world. Despite the perceptions people have of jellyfish, they are extremely important in marine life. Jellyfish are also food for many marine animals making life in the ocean a continuous cycle. Jellyfish play an important part globally and in order to make sense of jellyfish, it is important to know what jellyfish are, how they live, how to treat

Similar Essays

Making Sense Of The Sounds Essay

615 words - 2 pages In ¡§ How We Listen to Music,¡¨ composer Peter Chu tells us how we listen to musical sounds will deepen our appreciation of the music that we hear. But, by using a three-prong analysis to make his point, Copland appears to be arguing against the very concepts that seem to be driving today¡¦s music industry, things like repetition and easily understood meanings behind the pieces. Copland is writing from the

Common Sense And The Constitutionality Of The Texas Privacy Act

1277 words - 6 pages part of their hobby. Recently, there has been new legislation enacted called the Texas Privacy Act; commonly referred to as the "drone bill." Debated under the premise of privacy, the drone bill is aimed primarily at the civilian hobbyist. Moreover, this legislation has no effect on the numerous types of governmental drones that "We the People" actually fear. Simply stated, the Texas Privacy Act is unjust, virtually unenforceable, and limits First

The Development Of Canada’s Rights And Freedoms

665 words - 3 pages French because his mother was both of French and Scottish decent. Pierre attended the Collège Jean-de-Brébeuf, where he began supporting Quebec nationalism. He became the leader of the Liberal party in 1968 and became prime minister on April 20 1968. Through many hardships and successes (mentioned in question 2) he resigned from politics on June 30, 1984. In between all the politics, Pierre Trudeau married Margaret Trudeau in 1971 but divorced in 1984

The Battle Of Quebec Essay

1057 words - 5 pages The battle of Quebec was also known to be the seven year war. It was the French and Indian war. The battle started in 1757 and it finished in 1762. The place where the battle took place in was Quebec Canada. The war started on the date of September 13. The British and Americans were against the French and Canadians. Major General James Wolfe was one of the generals. He was against the Marquis de Montcalm. The British Army had almost around